7 ms·
Lumina Desktop Environment
- dgan 5y agoI settled down with vanilla xfce a long time ago. I don't customize almost anything (except keyboard layout), because i think having a simple standard setup is valuable on its own. There is too many things to do, beyond how window decorations look and what wallpaper i am using...
- djbusby 5y agoAnd it's easy to script up all your settings/tweaks to move to new machines or survive re-installs
- xrayarx 5y agoNew desktop from the bsd universe. Available for Linux. No dependencies. Qt5 Based. Customisable. X11. Free of systemd. Multimonitor. Plaintext Config. Can reproduce the look of other desktop systems. Plug-ins. Widgets. Nothing about multi desktop.
- peakaboo 5y agoScreenshots?
- gigglesupstairs 5y agoFound hidden inside hamburger menu: https://lumina-desktop.org/screenshots/ https://lumina-desktop.org/screenshots/
- programmarchy 5y agoNice wallpapers but would be way more helpful if they actually opened some windows for the screenshots.
- gigglesupstairs 5y agoYeah. Found more application level screenshots at this page: https://lumina-desktop.org/features/ https://lumina-desktop.org/features/
- pugworthy 5y agoEven then there's not much there to get me interested.
- mysterydip 5y agoIronic since one of the desktop features listed is "Create/Edit Screenshots"
- beebeepka 5y agoUse the desktop site if you don't see the left menu: https://lumina-desktop.org/screenshots/ https://lumina-desktop.org/screenshots/
- stncls 5y agoThank you. Also, - BSD 3-Clause license - mostly C++ (Qt has other bindings too) - no dependency on DBUS, policykit or consolekit - no Wayland on the roadmap for now (but they are open to porting in the future) - screenshots here: https://lumina-desktop.org/screenshots/ https://lumina-desktop.org/screenshots/ - github here: https://github.com/lumina-desktop/lumina https://github.com/lumina-desktop/lumina
- pengaru 5y ago> No dependencies. > Qt5 Based. We have very different definitions of "dependencies".
- jcelerier 5y agoif you're going to write a desktop environment with widgets, buttons, list views, GL abstraction, file system explorers, image viewers, etc... you're going to reimplement pretty much the whole of Qt Core / Gui / Widgets anyways
- pengaru 5y ago> if you're going to write a desktop environment with widgets, buttons, list views, GL abstraction, file system explorers, image viewers, etc... you're going to reimplement pretty much the whole of Qt Core / Gui / Widgets anyways Is this not the same basic rationalization process anyone goes through when introducing third-party dependencies to a project? You either: 1. don't include the functionality 2. implement it yourself 3. depend on something else to do it for you
- jcelerier 5y agobut when we are talking about open-source the only practical difference between 2. and 3. is the git repo in which the files are. There's no difference between depending on myself from yesterday writing pushbutton.cpp and depending someone else writing the same code 15 years ago, those are different persons than myself writing image_editor_ui.cpp today in both cases.
- pengaru 5y agoI don't see what this has to do with whether Lumina has dependencies or not, it obviously does. The rationalization process is completely orthogonal. I'm not here to debate the value of dependencies which you seem to be interested in defending.
- deleted 5y ago
- bacchusracine 5y agoThank you. This is the kind of information that should have been upfront and immediately findable when accessing the link or as a submission statement. Very appreciated.
- netizen-936824 5y agoI don't understand why anyone would want widgets. They have NEVER been a good experience, from system load standpoint or UX. They bring nothing interesting to the table. Just use i3 or DWM if you want minimal and lightweight with minimal putzing around with window placement
- godDLL 5y agoAs a recent convert to minimal dynamic partitioning window managers I do miss the Z axis to multiple desktops that widgets provided. As well as my home-grown widgets, lovingly coded.
- gigglesupstairs 5y agoA suggestion, please do not hide important stuff inside hamburger menu.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoA suggestion, as a mobile user, maybe you are not the target audience for this site.
- dkdbejwi383 5y agoWhat a silly thing to say. Just because I am looking at this on my phone right now doesn’t mean that I don’t also have desktop computers.
- gigglesupstairs 5y agoHaha, what are you even trying to say here? That mobile users don’t or can’t use Linux as their desktop environment?
- squarefoot 5y agoSeems rather essential, which is a good thing. Also good that it is ported to Alpine Linux. But although they say it is packaged for Debian, I couldn't find its .deb anywhere.
- hulitu 5y agoUgly in the spirit of win 10. No windows decorations (title bar, borders) . No consistent decoration on windows that they show. Buttons too small. I mean even TWM does it better.
- masswerk 5y agoI guess, this can be easily changed and they were deliberately aiming at a minimalistic appearance for these screenshots: > "Appearance profiles can easily be used to reproduce the look and feel of other common desktop systems." https://lumina-desktop.org/features/ https://lumina-desktop.org/features/
- KarlKemp 5y agoYeah, right… What was that Linux Distel trying to copy maxOS again? „Elementary“? All rounded rectangles and the same 50 shades of gray, but not a single label had the same margins to its button. Design takes more than a „skin“. Besides proportions and font rendering, it’s also about behaviour.
- b215826 5y agoDoes it support HiDPI displays? Lack of good HiDPI support was the reason why I switched from Xfce to i3 + custom Qt/GTK+ configs.
- account-5 5y agoI like lightweight DE's. I would like to see a side by side with other lightweight DE's for look and feel and resource consumption. This looks good though.
- wruza 5y agoAs a user who tried a few of sub-popular DEs in recent decades, I see zero information on why would/should one choose it. ¿Does it have: snap/zones/keybindings for windows, mount features, configurable menu, hw acceleration, exposé, notifications, language menu, etc, etc? It’s not that it must support these (other programs/settings may do that), but their landing sells on completely irrelevant points, if you plan to install and use some software instead of playing with wallpapers all day. I don’t mean to sound harsh or too negative, but it just doesn’t add up to something meaningful or specific. You can only try and find out by yourself, after reading docs on its config files/utils. What problems does it solve?
- otabdeveloper4 5y ago> I see zero information on why would/should one choose it It says right from the start that it doesn't use any of the Linux desktop stack software. It's for the BSD operating systems. Is there anything else competing in this space?
- webmobdev 5y agoYes and No ... they specifically say that while it was originally planned for PC-BSD, it was ultimately made OS agnostic: ... He started working on it in his free time. He wanted to design a small lightweight desktop for PC-BSD that didn’t come with the challenge of dealing with Linux-isms. However instead of designing a desktop that had BSD-isms, he decided to design the desktop to be as OS agnostic as possible with as few dependecies as possible ...
- jonathankoren 5y agoThat doesn’t really answer the question. What are these linuxisms, and why are they problems? Are they actually technical problems, or is this mere license purity?
- DeathArrow 5y ago>What problems does it solve? It was designed as a DE for PcBSD. Unlike Linux distros, some OS design teams do believe that having only one tool do a job and that tool should be perfectly integrated with the rest of the OS has some value.
- sjellis 5y agoThese days, I am really impressed by the MATE desktop environment: https://mate-desktop.org/ https://mate-desktop.org/ It does the stuff that you need without excess weight, the look and feel is flexible enough that you can make it look like other systems if you prefer, and the small development team consistently put out new releases to fix and refine it without any drama. AWS use it for their Linux cloud-based desktop service, probably for these reasons. Ubuntu MATE is a great showcase for what can be done with MATE. It's arguably more user-friendly than the main Ubuntu, with the MATE desktop and quick-start features like a well-curated software selector. https://ubuntu-mate.org/ https://ubuntu-mate.org/
- daniel-thompson 5y agoMATE is fantastic, I've been running it for the last few years. The central feature is that it gives you a desktop with familiar features and idioms; it doesn't try to "reimagine the experience" or reorganize all the functionality or any of the other stuff that drives me crazy about e.g. Gnome 3. It's the DE for people who want to spend as little time as possible thinking about a DE.
- netizen-936824 5y agoI found tiling was better for "not thinking about my DE" In which I never think about Tue size or placement of my windows. Its mostly automatic and I can swap them between spots with one click. Where with gnome and mate, if I want two windows next to each other I have to putz around d with dragging them to the right snap points
- daniel-thompson 5y agoYou can run i3 with MATE, see https://mattgreer.dev/blog/mate-and-i3/ https://mattgreer.dev/blog/mate-and-i3/
- netizen-936824 5y agoInteresting, thank you!
- DominikD 5y agoI wonder what the future holds now that Project Trident (Void-based Linux distro that came with Lumina as a default DE) has reached its end.
- leephillips 5y agoThe first claim on the page: “Lumina is designed to have a small footprint, giving your system the best performance possible.” I suspect that the setup I’ve been using for a decade, with no desktop environment and dwm, leads to better performance. As well as being less annoying: the first screenshot shows a pop-up, hierarchical menu, an interface element that I detest. That’s not the way I want to change settings.
- FunnyLookinHat 5y agoI kept trying lightweight DEs like this over and over again (XFCE, LXDE, MATE, etc.) - I wanted them to work because I'd rather not give the desktop any more CPU resources than necessary. Time and time again there were a handful of things that I realized I'd taken for granted with the more heavy desktops (Gnome, KDE, etc.) that brought me back. In the end I realized what I wanted was something that got out of my way and let me drive with a keyboard (and yes, was full of all the features I'd expect without needing to tweak and script). I've landed with PopOS using their tiling WM system, and I haven't looked back.