3 ms·
> If inflation is 2%, then your house rising at 1.5% is a terrible investment, compared to a stock market rising at 5%. I don't care if it's much worse than th
by Dylan16807 5y ago
> If inflation is 2%, then your house rising at 1.5% is a terrible investment, compared to a stock market rising at 5%.
I don't care if it's much worse than the stock market. All a house has to do is hold your money pretty steady against inflation and it will be an acceptable investment.
If the intent is "houses can't beat the stock market and remain affordable" then that's what people should say, because that's very different from just being "an investment".
And for what it's worth my intent was a number slightly below inflation, because it doesn't really matter if it's half a percent over or half a percent under.
> Remember, inflation is basically measuring how much purchasing power we have... So if the price of something is rising faster than inflation, by definition that thing is becoming more expensive, which means less people will be able to afford it.
That's only true if you assume wages stay steady with inflation, and they don't have to do that.
If house prices would grow faster than inflation but slower than wage growth then everyone could be pretty happy with the result.
- SkittyDog 5y agoYou seem to be working some very personal, non-standard definitions, so there's really not much more for us to talk about. I hope you find a good financial advisor, and that you start listening to them.
- Dylan16807 5y agoNonstandard definition of what, "investment"? The thing you said about inflation is objectively false either way, so I wish you the same.