9 ms·
I do agree that housing as an asset is a bad idea. I regularly think that if you gave everybody a rent free room, society would be wildly different. People are
by agumonkey 5y ago
I do agree that housing as an asset is a bad idea. I regularly think that if you gave everybody a rent free room, society would be wildly different. People are running around to pay rent doing insane stuff just to get by. It's humanly painful.
- ricksunny 5y agoIt's like Squid Game, except debt is replaced with, oh wait, still debt. Just of the housing variety (we call it 'mortgage').
- ricksunny 5y agoAnd this is where it gets fun - Joe/Jill tech-worker wants to live in Menlo Park. So she works at Facebook. To pay his/her mortgage (or mortgage market-correlated rent), (s)he has to build selective sharing algorithms that emphasize anger but maximize 'engagement' and make lots of revenue for the company. Even though friends & family tell him/her (s)he's being detrimental to the world - it's paying his/her salary, and so the mortgage/rent. In-group vs. out-group baiting, mayhem, & loss-of-life ensue. (h/t Frances Haugen)
- realce 5y agoTHEN this person has to hide/digest the guilt of their actions, knowing that they are immoral but still required by society. By hiding that guilt, this person becomes disgusted by people who don't commit immoral acts to pay their mortgages, since every good action reminds them of what they're doing wrong.
- VRay 5y agoHaha, dude. I hate Facebook too, but you’re kidding yourself if anyone there thinks they’re evil. The employees just focus on how easy it is for non tech savvy people to share vacation and kid photos across the globe with each other through their service, and go to bed in their $1.2M condos with a smile every night
- baremetal 5y agoyeah thats why there isn't a string of leaks and whistleblowers, and even former upper management decrying what is going on at fb. oh wait..
- eevilspock 5y agoIt's not about being "evil". People are very adept at making convenient self-serving justifications on-the-fly. For example the very same liberal parents who chastise conservatives for promoting racial inequality will cry murder when there are attempts to racially desegregate the school their child attends by changing admissions, and they'll come up with the perfect rational for this contradiction after the fact. They will put their child first, regardless of the fact that their child is already far ahead because of socio-economic advantages, and that the disadvantaged kid even with the better education is still going to be disadvantaged compared to their kid. It's even worse in a culture and economic system where selfishness is deemed a virtue. Here on HN, you can see such heavily self-serving bias in discussions like this, where the emphasis is entirely on the positive aspects and negative concerns are shot down: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28924751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28924751.
- VRay 5y agoAmen I'd say it's fair to call the process by which people justify doing bad things as "evil". I just wanted to correct the notion that Facebook employees think of themselves as villains. Facebook is connecting people with each other. Amazon/Microsoft/Google are collecting usage data to improve their products. Amazon and Microsoft think it's such a benign thing to do that there's no need at all to allow people to see or opt out of this collection. Google thinks that providing visibility into what they're doing is more than enough to make up for it. Apple thinks that making it explicitly opt-in is enough to justify it. Defense contractors are keeping Americans safe and making the world a safer place. High-frequency trading firms are providing liquidity. Landlords are "housing providers" Etc etc
- eevilspock 5y agoBut whether or not you call it "evil", it is a moral failure, and deep down most people, including Facebook employees, know what they're doing is wrong. They look the other way, or shrug and say Everyone else is doing it, why should I lose out?, etc. Likewise most Google employees aren't proud that their high salaries are paid by advertising and the personal data collection for it -- deep down they know its a deal with the devil.
- kcatskcolbdi 5y agoIt is not Facebook's fault human nature engages with outrage. Facebook didn't change anyone. Facebook doesn't make a good person into a bad person. "In-group vs. out-group baiting, mayhem, & loss-of-life " existed throughout all of human history (and in much larger quantities!) before the age of Facebook. They will continue to exist long after Facebook displays its last newsfeed item. The longer we try to blame a technology for humanities issues, the longer it will take to address the issues.
- dahart 5y ago> The longer we try to blame a technology for humanity’s issues, the longer it will take to address the issues. I think it is the people at Facebook are being blamed in the comment above, and not the technology, no? > Facebook didn’t change anyone. You’re right that human nature is not Facebook’s fault, however, you cannot logically use that to conclude that Facebook bears no responsibility. Facebook is changing people, and there’s evidence of it. You don’t get to claim human nature when feeding drugs or alcohol to an addict, or when being a bookie for illegal fights, or when pimping. Advertisers don’t get to claim human nature when advertising cigarettes to teenagers. There are plenty of laws on the books to prevent companies from trying to leverage the negative sides of human nature, and there are plenty of companies that are currently using our worst impulses to goad us into spending our time and money with them. Facebook intends to normalize incredulity at all times, in order to maximize their own profit, and because of the scale of Facebook, it’s causing a net negative in human behavior. Fewer people would be choosing outrage, and less often, if Facebook wasn’t pimping it. Allowing people to form companies with this intention should be illegal, no? Or if you see this as purely human nature and think Facebook is not complicit, how are you suggesting we address the issues?
- ricksunny 5y agoI should have genericized the company name - I wanted to highlight the housing motivation for tech-workers to do ill. the company-formerly-known-as-fb just provides one very familiar example of this. We're all constantly tempted to engage in sociopathic but well-remunerating work. (No doubt there is plenty of pro-social well-remunerating work - i.e. I'm not painting that as a zero-sum choice) The question becomes, 1 - what choice does each of us individually make when faced with such a role, and 2 - more importantly, how easily can a company identify & recruit a sufficiently-qualified-yet-sufficiently-desperate individual for the same role who will go ahead and make such a moral compromise.
- DrJones1098 5y agoThink about inflation increasing at 3% annually on average, with no accompanying deflation, and with no accompanying increases in wages for most of the population. A dollar is presently worth half as much as in 1990. A 100,000 a year job in 1990 is equivalent to a 50,000 a year nowdays. Every year the noose gets slightly tighter, the slack is slightly reduced, the competition is slightly increased, society become slightly more cutthroat, people are forced to do slightly crazier and crazier things to make ends meet and sacrifice their morals just a little bit more, work just a few more hours to make the same money. Then new generations are born into a world that's much more competitive than their parents world 20 years previous, and start out thinking this level of competitiveness and craziness is normal. And the water in the frog pot inter-generationally continues to get hotter. We're literally on a slow unstoppable pathway to a third world country and no one even realizes it. Or possibly creating the conditions for war.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI came to the same conclusion after going back to a middle class country with my parents in early high school. On the salary of two public school teachers which is middle class though above average, life was not so different from in Canada on the salary from the same profession. Better in some ways, worse in others, overall only slightly worse. That would have been insane a few decades earlier, and it's not just because of improving third world countries, but also because as you said the noose tightened - everything became more expensive, especially rent, working hours increased, two salaries became necessary, etc..
- lottin 5y ago> with no accompanying increases in wages for most of the population Take a look at the median US household income over the last 40 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_States#/media/File:Median_US_household_income_through_2018.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United...
- nickthemagicman 5y agoMedian wage and median household income are two separate things. Median household income can mean two parents are working... Take a look at inflation adjusted wage growth for a singular person over time. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/%3famp=1 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2...
- Emma_Goldman 5y agoA great thought experiment, though not necessarily an entirely fictional one. Social housing schemes, and proposals for 'universal basic services', are common enough and ought to be the positive side to the deflation of the housing market. Mortgages currently dominate the average person's life.
- an9n 5y ago> Mortgages currently dominate the average person's life. Indeed, it's sickening, and there's a very well developed structure to stop the average person stepping outside of the system via a tiny house, van life etc.
- mlac 5y agoThe average person does not want a tiny house or van life. So it’s not a well developed structure built for “the average person”. Tiny homes are the mobile home of this generation, except less widely adopted. But they will depreciate, widening the gap between those who chose to purchase a traditional house and those who chose a simpler approach. Van life and tiny homes are not suitable for 99.99% of families with children.
- Spivak 5y agoYou're dis-agreeing with the parent. The problem is that for almost everyone houses are unaffordable without mortgages and the only alternatives to it -- smaller homes, mobile homes, vandwelling are bad. But they're bad not because of something fundamental but because we make it artificially harder for them.
- mlac 5y agoThank you! That’s not how I interpreted that original post, but It’s not that small houses are bad. Small houses (as I’d define it 1000-1750 sq ft for a 3 bedroom) are great. But I still see it written as “if those structures were removed” that those alternatives are a suitable alternative to a stick-built house for the majority of people. I think they are all sub-optimal solutions that people should not be forced into unless they want to.
- mrfusion 5y agoOr just fix zoning. No fancy giveaways needed.
- Emma_Goldman 5y agoI don't understand why this would just be a supply-side issue, rather than a huge demand-side issue given asset price inflation consequent from QE, the expansion of private credit and the financialization of housing over recent times. Or indeed a distributional issue given that we are now living in a new Gilded Age, of poverty amidst plenty. A lot of housing problems result from the uneven and combined development inherent in capitalism. Physical and human capital floods to major sites of economic activity, leading to a positive feedback loop benefitting a small number of major cities. The rest of the country becomes a hinterland, sucked dry of business and anyone who has the option of leaving. In the UK, where I live, this is the major underlying cause of Scottish independence, and now the increasing calls for Welsh independence, and even Northern independence. The economy is asymmetrically built around London. That in turn makes it increasingly difficult for normal people to live in London (e.g. nurses and teachers). Zoning isn't going to fix that.
- throw0101a 5y ago> I don't understand why this would just be a supply-side issue Rates are low everywhere, but housing costs are not exploding everywhere (in the West). Even with-in a single country like Canada, in the Toronto/SW-Ontario area prices are way up, but the Prairies are flat/down in most places. > rather than a huge demand-side issue given asset price inflation consequent from QE, the expansion of private credit and the financialization of housing over recent times. Some of the Commonwealth countries (CA, AU, NZ) have the higher rates compared to other countries (DE, CH, JP, FR), and yet have higher housing price rises: * https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt/status/1446515836504743956 https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt/status/1446515836504743956 You'd think the cheaper-debt countries would have the bigger rises in prices. In Toronto/GTA, prices have been going rising especially since 2015, when there was no QE going on. But there was a whole bunch more immigration without corresponding construction.
- VRay 5y ago
- Frost1x 5y agoThat's sort of the point though, isn't it? We're at a point where large capital holders pretend they want competitive forces to keep them in check, yet employ anti-competitive practices and cry regulatory overreach at every opportunity. Current businesses don't want a competitive labor market in the sense they have to compete for your time, they want drones to do whatever they want and want to pay bottom dollar for it. Just look at the massive outcry right now claiming labor shortages. Maybe there is some shortage but it's a well justified shortage in my opinion. If you had a labor force with a real basic sense of security, people not worried they may get sick and their entire life's accumulation of assets from work will be washed away in an instant or they may be out on the streets looking for a warm bed, then you have a strong labor force that can negotiate reasonable working conditions. We don't have that. We largely have a growing precariate class of people that seem to be sweeping in low to lower middle income that seems to be growing into the middle income brackets. A large bit of middle and upper middle are fine but even there, pressure seems to be growing.
- throwaway6734 5y agoIt's not mainly large capital holders pushing for policy that leads to less housing availability, it's your average middle class American
- agumonkey 5y agoI think nobody really know what's going on. Every subgroup/subclass has its own view and interests and try whatever that might work. To me it's mostly a sign of dislocated/fractured society with no coherent purpose. No calling for communism :) Change education, add more pragmatic knowledge of everything to people's lives so they don't chase shiney and don't rely on money exchanges for things to happen in their day. Maybe internet will help a bit here. Lots of people are learning about stuff through videos, we need to make it more tangible day to day I guess.
- novok 5y agoTBH even if you have socialized health care, you still have most of these problems. Canada is a great example of this, and it's had a housing problem for a decade+ at this point for a far greater percentage of it's population. The average canadian does not worry about their savings going in a poof if they have a health issue.
- Valakas_ 5y agoWe've gone full circle again. History tends to repeat itself. But now we don't have pitchforks. I wonder how the next revolution is going to happen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism