5 ms·
Surely building codes mandate a comprehensive evacuation design. There are clearly aesthetic complaints many people will have here, but realistically safety sh
by ajross 5y ago
Surely building codes mandate a comprehensive evacuation design. There are clearly aesthetic complaints many people will have here, but realistically safety shouldn't be a problem. This is simply not a "large" building by skyscraper standards, and those can be built safely.
Honestly... I think this is very much a taste thing. Is it so weird that I don't think this looks so bad at all? Yeah, yeah, no windows. But dense housing means lots of local goodies in the same building. These 4500 kids in their sardine rooms will have multiple food options, probably several gyms, rec rooms, libraries, etc... all "down the hall".
I spent a lot of time in college trudging to stuff through the snow (though to be fair not a lot of snow at UCSB). Physical access to amenities means more than I think suburban detached garage owners tend to remember.
- rglullis 5y ago> These 4500 kids in their sardine rooms will have multiple food options, probably several gyms, rec rooms, libraries, etc... all "down the hall". No better way to get kids prepared for what comes ahead in their adulthood, huh?
- ryandrake 5y agoPreparing/conditioning today's young adults for the dystopian future, where all our jobs are being done by robots, and the elite class needs to warehouse the rest of us safely away in 2mx2m cells in gigantic concrete honeycomb dormitories, where we're given a TV and one Soma per day.
- rglullis 5y agoYou won't have any possessions, and you will like it.
- superkuh 5y agoIf anyone is interested, this is basically the first half of the speculative fiction story, "Mana" (https://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1) which has been posted here on HN a few times.
- ryandrake 5y agoYea, it seems every year we are moving closer and closer to some dark mixture of Manna, Fifteen Million Merits [1] and Elysium [2], where regular people no longer serve any purpose, and are simply warehoused somewhere to keep them out of the hair of the few rich elite. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifteen_Million_Merits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifteen_Million_Merits 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elysium_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elysium_(film)
- r00fus 5y agoI don't see automated everything becoming possible in our lifetimes, instead I see dystopian societal collapse due to climate shifts being much more likely.
- InitialLastName 5y agoTo be fair, that sounds like any of the cookie cutter "luxury" apartment complexes I see coming up all over the place, right down to the inability to see anything other than your neighbors out the window.
- canaus 5y agoHow many "cookie cutter 'luxury' apartment complexes" do you know that house 4500 people? Let's forgo the absolute number, what about the population density? 94% of the residents won't have windows. Can you list any of these apartments that have that characteristic?
- CydeWeys 5y ago"Cookie cutter" apartment complexes are waaaaay nicer than this, including literally about 10X the square footage per inhabitant, and way more windows. Dunno what you're talking about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joachim4 5y agoNot having natural light is one of the best way to attack your mental health. This building is just a bad design, and human are not made to live without natural lights.
- JoeAltmaier 5y ago...and I am working in a warehouse-style building at a Silicon Valley startup. All the windows have been blacked out, to keep the IP safe. It's a little like being inside a Borg Cube.
- ethbr0 5y agoAnd just like this building (Munger Hall), your startup is presumably funded by investor money. ;) Correlation!
- cwkoss 5y agoBuild a replica Borg recharging alcove around the coffee machine
- BoorishBears 5y agoThey couldn't cover them in something translucent?
- p_j_w 5y agoI wish architects showed the same level of concern for office workers! Kidding aside... given the size of the bedrooms, I get the impression that the students aren't meant to spend much time there aside from whatever amount of sleep college students are getting these days. The rest of their time would probably be spent in common areas that actually do have sunlight. Recalling my personal experience in college, where most of my time was already spent in common areas anyways, I don't see the lack of bedroom windows as that huge a problem. This particular dorm design also seems to allow for more privacy than a traditional dorm does.
- mattmcknight 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoFalse dilemma. They could make the first floor have food courts and gyms, while having windows or simply not having a 97 year old billionaire donor dictate taste with zero input just because money. You are assuming a lot about whether the safety designs exist, or are adequate.
- yaacov 5y ago> just because money Money is really important, probably the single most important constraint for state universities.
- vmception 5y agoyes, I understand the perverse incentives that led to greenlighting this. its also not an excuse. they should reject the $200 million donation and hope Munger sends another with no restrictions. that's where we are at.
- indymike 5y agoMaybe build the $200M dorm instead of the $2B dorm?
- falcolas 5y agoHis money represents less than 10% of the final cost of the dorm, while retaining 100% of the design rights. Something's happening here that's more than just the money.
- throwaway75787 5y agoNo, it's just the money. It's just the perverse disconnect between the wealthy, and those just trying to get by. It's Mr. Burns hanging a "you're here forever" sign, or Kanye West ranting about his napkin design for the iPlane in the Oval Office while dropping a few "motherfucker"s.
- ajross 5y ago
- nescioquid 5y agoFormer firefighter cautions we should be skeptical of the safety of this plan, and your rebuttal is "surely building codes mandate..."? A zero-evidence rebuttal concerning the safety of 4500 students.
- jl6 5y agoI don’t find it unreasonable to assume that the building will comply with government fire safety regulations and that those regulations are at least somewhat adequate.
- fdr 5y agoThe regulations may have been written with architectural rules of thumb in mind, as in, "surely no one would..."
- LegitShady 5y agoBuilding code isn't really written as rules of thumb but as rules.
- mindcrime 5y agoYou might be surprised. Fire regulations are very much a local issue and there can be a lot of variance (although many local municipalities base their codes on standards put out by bodies like the NFPA, etc.). There are quite frequently things that one might intuitively expect to be in the regs, that aren't. Requirements for sprinklers, for example. As surprising as it may seem, there are still lots of places where sprinklers are not required in many buildings. I don't know the situation in Santa Barbara, but I did email their fire department earlier with an inquiry about this topic. Hoping to hear something back.
- docfort 5y agoFire sprinklers appear to be required. https://www.santabarbaraca.gov/civicax/filebank/blobdload.aspx?BlobID=12040 https://www.santabarbaraca.gov/civicax/filebank/blobdload.as...
- tw04 5y ago>Surely building codes mandate a comprehensive evacuation design. Surely building codes should mandate structural flaws and sinking foundations be fixed immediately. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/collapsed-miami-condo-had-been-sinking-into-earth-as-early-as-the-1990s-researchers-say/ar-AALoUP0 https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/collapsed-miami-condo-had-...
- LegitShady 5y agothis only betrays a deep misunderstanding on your part of the challenges in construction and issues with Sub grade stability in coastal zones and how different those things are to having enough fire exits. Your comment is not making any point but your of lack of understanding.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"deep misunderstanding on your part of the challenge" A citizen doesn't care about challenges in construction or software or food contamination, it is our professional responsibility not to be negligent in our work.
- LegitShady 5y agothe standard for negligence for an engineer isnt that "something bad happened", and talking about a building with foundation issues due to unstable local soil is far different than "didn't meet fire code" from the perspective of anyone who knows anything about the issues at hand. Just an FYI it's unlikely an architect designed those foundations - there were probably engineers who tested the soil and gave its properties to a designing engineer who designed the foundation and both of those things are going to be tempered by what was common engineering practice at the time, and if the unstable soil situation was known about. My understanding is this situation is common in the area due to building practice at the time.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoAll a layman knows if that he should not die in his sleep because the building caved in, you can't expect a homeowner to debate you on the exact details of structural engineering. However I can comment on the culture of negligence - and I think it's getting worse. Of course in every job, there is constant pressure from management to cut corners, junior colleagues or peers that mess up, deadlines to meet. It is very easy to say to avoid inspecting troubled areas, to say 'I've done my job' and avoid headache. Often it is not in anyone's job description to police this. The 'client' is typically none the wiser, and when problems arise 10 years down the line, often they can't be traced to anyone personally. The fact that we've replaced entire careers with gig economy, and people stay in one job less and companies now invest less in training that ever in the past 40 years means that there is even less accountability and more opportunity for mistakes. Cases of unpredictable 'something bad happened' are extremely rare. Soviet government was warned that reactors used in Chernobyl were dangerous, Tepco was warned that sea wall protecting Fukushima was inadequate, Robert Lund warned that Nasa should not launch Space Shuttle Challenger, residents of Grenfell Tower warned about fire safety before they burned alive, same goes goes for Bhopal disaster, subprime loans and 2008, 737 Max and every other major event. It is also extremely rare that the consequences of these decision ever catch up with the top brass. Hence we have culture of negligence.
- bastardoperator 5y agoThe design looked like rooms inside a pod inside a building. Seems like a fire in front of a single door could in theory kill everyone in the pod based on the image in the article. Honestly, this looks like a low security prison to me. Small cells and a day room for activities and socializing.
- wombatpm 5y agoIf they lofted the bed, the desk could be moved under the bed. And if they had everyone just wear house uniforms, they could reduce the need for storage space and reduce the size of the rooms by 1/3
- tsimionescu 5y ago"This is an announcement from Genetic Control It is my sad duty to inform you of a four foot Restriction on humanoid height I hear the directors of Genetic Control have been buying all the Properties that have recently been sold, taking risks oh so bold It's said now that people will be shorter in height They can fit twice as many in the same building site (They say it's alright)" (From "Get'em off my property", Genesis, Foxtrot, 1972)
- hn_user82179 5y agoIt's clear the donor purposefully designed the rooms to be unpleasant to get people up into common rooms. It's just... weird. It doesn't matter if it looks good or bad but uncomfortable design like this is bizarrely aggressive to students, who are already living away from home and at-risk for depression and suicide. Not to mention that housing like this makes breeding grounds for the flu and other contagious illnesses. It's poorly timed given we're still battling Covid-19 worldwide.
- throwaway09223 5y agoAs you note, students are at-risk for depression and suicide in today's existing student living quarters. We don't know whether or not a community focused living design would help or hurt in this regard. The covid/contagion question is interesting, because we DO know that designing for contagion safety is seemly inherently at odds with designing for social/emotional safety. I think there's no clearly superior solution here, which tells me that building both types of systems would at least help further our understanding of the issues.
- spookthesunset 5y ago> Not to mention that housing like this makes breeding grounds for the flu and other contagious illnesses. It's poorly timed given we're still battling Covid-19 worldwide. Designing 100 year buildings around our current hysterical reaction to covid is just silly. Covid is over, time to move on. History will harshly judge our reaction to covid and we will hopefully never repeat this awful public health policy again. The idea that we should be designing building with covid in mind is just a symptom of how much parts of society has lost the plot.
- hn_user82179 5y ago"Covid is over" is inaccurate and is at best very US/EU-centric. There is a reason though that I specifically called out all contagious illnesses. I can tell you that I got colds and the flu much more often in college than I do even in an open office. What's more, is students don't get sick days or time to catch up after an illness except in the most serious cases. I don't think it's illogical to think students (and their parents) don't want a dorm hotbed for contagions.
- itronitron 5y agoYeah, but there is nothing guaranteeing that the common area amenities (rec room, multiple food options, libraries, etc.) won't be reallocated to additional dorm rooms or storage.