4 ms·
> politics: that rare area where there are no real experts, and it's every man for himself There are experts, but things are so politicized that everyone disli
by wolverine876 5y ago
> politics: that rare area where there are no real experts, and it's every man for himself
There are experts, but things are so politicized that everyone dislikes them (the acts don't agree with anyone's partisan position) and reads what is appealing. I think that was the OP's point, but it's a dangerous notion to think we all know politics roughly equally well.
Political science can be highly informative and predictive, as can research in adjacent fields such as international relations. It transforms my understanding of what others are saying (with partisans being reliably absurd).
- strulovich 5y agoWho are some of those experts in your opinion? Sounds like an interesting read perhaps.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe Monkey Cage column at the Washington Post is written by political scientists (generally, afaik), and will reference others. https://www.washingtonpost.com/monkey-cage/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/monkey-cage/ The Duck of Minerva is a good blog, with contributors who are at the level of full professors at leading universities https://www.duckofminerva.com/ https://www.duckofminerva.com/ Political Science Quarterly can be fantastic, though being a quarterly, won't be tackling news from the last 24 hours (but I think we have enough of that). For a different perspective, the Lowy Interpreter blog at Australian think tank The Lowy Institute, has excellent, expert analysis from a often strikingly different geopolitical point of view: https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter Other non-partisan think tanks can be a great source. U of Pennsylvania has a ranking of them which, while I wouldn't take verbatim, can provide a good starting point.
- mpalczewski 5y agoWhat makes these people experts? It looks like some of this is that they are professors, or they cite each other, which is rather circular. Are there testable predictions, or some utility to those who aren't political scientists?
- mistermann 5y agoI would think it would be a relative scale, whoever are the top x% (by some measure) would by The Experts, by definition. As a terrible analogy, the top 10% of a fruit crop (or whatever) for a given season are "the best", by definition. It would be lovely if we had a kind of absolute scale to measure by (as is often done in sports and other less complex domains), but that is not possible. However, what is possible (or should be, to some degree) is that (more) people could think from an absolute perspective, which I believe can substantially change how some things appear. How you would go about doing this though is not obvious, to me.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIf that's the argument it's the same with any department in any uni. All those math professors are just citing each other. That Erdos is the worst circle in math!!
- barry-cotter 5y agoNo. Maths makes testable predictions, which can be checked with computers in completely deterministic ways using extremely little human judgemnt. The same reality principle applies to the exact sciences and to a lesser extent the social sciences. At some point we leave the social sciences for the humanities where taste is disguised as fact. Not always, and the boundary is unclear but at some point knowledge ends and bullshit begins. If you believe there is no god theology is clearly bullshit. If you don't think white people are indelibly and irredeemably racist then Ibram Kendi is full of shit. Finance, politics, international relations are more complicated because humans play against humans. As an insight becomes known it becomes useless because humans incorporate it into their models to beat other humans. But Math clearly has real experise. Ramanujan was recognised on the basis of correspondence. Soros has real expertise in finace. Dominic Cummings managed to run two referendum campaigns that beat UK elite opinion. Kissinger and Bismarck are and were real experts in politics. But they can't demonstrate crushing qualitative superiority like experts in exact sciences can.
- wolverine876 5y agoI don't understand the question: You don't understand what qualifies them as experts? Look at their bios.
- lliamander 5y agoThe point is not that we all know politics equally well. Thr point is that, in politics, a credentialed expert doesn't really have any advantage in predictive power over a reasonably well-informed layman. Statistician and market researcher Jim Manzi made this point roughly ten years ago. It's not a knock against the social sciences either. The point is that you can't generalize in the social sciences the way you can with harder sciences because the causal factors are so complex.
- pmyteh 5y agoFor prediction? No. For understanding (some of) the dynamics of what is going on? Hopefully. That's what much of our discipline is actually aimed at. (Source: am political scientist)
- wolverine876 5y ago> (Source: am political scientist) Cool! Any recommendations (beyond what I listed below)? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29031783 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29031783 > For prediction? No. For understanding (some of) the dynamics of what is going on? Hopefully. For some reason, it seems to me that social scientists undersell themselves (why is that? it seems like they almost go along with anti-intellectualism rather than have to deal with the conflict). Understanding the dynamics leads to better predictions and thus better outcomes; it's hard to overlook that mechanism.
- dash2 5y agoAnthony Downs just died. His Median Voter Theorem organises a lot of understanding about political competition. Short version: elections get won in the centre.
- pmyteh 5y agoA major difficulty is that understanding one part of a complex system does not necessarily lead to testable predictions about the system as a whole. Take elections, for example: we have really good models for voter behaviour under different conditions, so can make good estimates for how, say, a sitting President's votes will vary as a function of employment, or the differential effect of various changes on results in states with different demographics. But what is the electoral consequence (say) of Bill Clinton being impeached? There's no real way to know in advance: individual political scientists will have intuition, but it's too novel a situation with too little existing data for solid model building or prediction. And it turns out that politics is rammed full of new situations, unexpected events, or changes in the environment. How will voting patterns in the South change as a result of GOP realignment after civil rights? What will happen to the British government's popularity when the Queen dies? A case in point: a couple of years ago I made an HN comment about parliamentary manoeuvring over Brexit and the likely outcomes [0]. I am skilled and knowledgeable about British parliamentary culture and history, many of the subtleties of the Standing Orders (which were suddenly relevant), and had been closely following the proceedings and thinking hard about the implications. I missed the actual outcome completely, by factoring in the possibility of no deal, or of different kinds of compromise, or of the rebels winning a second referendum. But I didn't consider that Johnson could knife Theresa May, supplant her as PM and then successfully sell a clearly defective alternative (and 'harder') deal as a triumph. Even though I knew lots about Conservative politics, and the strengths of populist rhetoric in changing public perceptions. I assumed that if May was deposed her successor would be in the same bind. But Johnson changed the terms of debate unexpectedly successfully and escaped it. My mostly-rationalist colleagues basically missed calling it too. FWIW I'm big on intellect, but I'm also big on epistemic modesty. There are lots of things we can show are basically true or false (the 'filter bubble' hypothesis for online political information has been basically debunked, for example) but too many unknowns for our mere opinions to be provably correct. The same is equally or more true of basically everyone else, of course, which is why I find the false certainties of the newspaper opinion pages so depressing. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19372349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19372349
- lordnacho 5y agoMaybe a better way to put it is politics is an arena where every person can have an opinion that's contrary to what is common, and still have good reasons (even after we look closely) for it being so. We can both believe that the world works in a certain way but have differing views on what to do, simply from having different values. For example, we can both think that higher taxes harm business, or that higher taxes can be used to equalize opportunities, but have differing views on what is good to do.
- wolverine876 5y agoI agree, and I think the reason that works, and is necessary, is that only we know our very localized situation (often too intuitively to articulate or to recognize as not applying to everyone else).
- hogFeast 5y agoI studied politics and history. In my experience, there is also a bias towards writing exceptionally partisan things. I used to write things that were hedging, and which were summaries of the argument. Invariably, these papers scored significantly lower than papers which took a position (whether that was accurate or not). Of course, university isn't reality. But my point is that people do not find realistic opinions that interesting. Saying "I don't know" or "both sides have merit" is sometimes accurate but never interesting. Society selects for this. I also worked in finance which exposes you to a reasonably fast feedback loop between opinion and reality. I met people who had multi-decade records of crushing it, and they usually had very anodyne takes. You come in expecting they have access to some higher form of truth...in reality, they are just better at seeing what is already there. You see this, particularly, when a famed investor says the market is over-valued. Inevitably, they will get lambasted publicly. But you realise that their view is usually one that works long-term, that is quantifiable, that uses reason...everyone else just wants emotion. The difference isn't knowledge. You can have huge knowledge, you can be rewarded heavily for being right, you can be a media "expert"...but if you aren't interested in reality, it doesn't matter. I don't think it is about avoiding having strong views either but it has to be strong views, weakly held. With time I think a minority of the population realises that some people will have the same opinion regardless of what facts are presented to them. What is frustrating is that society reproduces so much of this nonsense.
- wolverine876 5y agoOne of the better posts I've read on HN, thank you. > Saying "I don't know" or "both sides have merit" is sometimes accurate but never interesting. That's fine but IMHO the real work is to go beyond that, to the next step. Find a solution, make a contribution, under that condition.
- hogFeast 5y agoYep, I have been there. Example (sorry to use another finance story): the market today is overvalued by any logic. Valuation, 0% returns for next ten years. Equity risk premium, max 2% real. Contributions that are valued most heavily are complex and surprising. If you say the market is overvalued when it has gone up 15%/year for a decade then people are expecting something very big...not some nerd talking about equity risk premia. I think this is the difference between how humans reason emotionally and how humans reason logically. Finance is a bad example because most people lose it when money is involved. But you see this in other areas where it is very hard to make a contribution if that contribution isn't surprising, controversial, or shocking in some way. It has to have emotional valence. This isn't universal. Some areas of study don't have that culture, some organizations have clear decision-making processes that try to stop this...but everyone is prone to emotional reasoning.
- AmericanChopper 5y agoPolitical “science” can help you understand politics, but it can’t endow you with an expert opinion on which policies to implement. Prioritising or selecting policy agendas is largely an exercise in choosing what to value, and there is no scientifically correct perspective on human values. Also, if you want to implement a democratic process, then the goals of your policies should be to align with what people want, even if you think people want stupid things. All other forms of government are authoritarian, including technocracies run by “experts”.
- mpalczewski 5y agoI don't get it. In what sense does it help you understand? Is it just that you can tell a story(non-predictive) about what has happened?
- AmericanChopper 5y agoUnderstanding how political systems operate and how they’re structured is firmly within the capabilities of political science. Understanding broad political philosophies can help you better understand any individual policy, and political science can help you understand the types of outcomes a policy is _likely_ to achieve or fail to achieve. But as a science, it’s not robust enough to make especially reliable predictions, and while understanding mainstream or even fringe political philosophies can be valuable, it is beyond the remit of science to tell you what the “correct” expectations are to have of government and society in general. Because that entirely depends on personal values.
- mpalczewski 5y agoHow does it validate that the understanding is correct?
- AmericanChopper 5y agoUnderstanding the structure of government is largely a matter of understanding law and formal procedure. This understanding can be validated by decisions that courts make when resolving controversies relating to that structure. Validating an understanding of political philosophy cannot be done scientifically, which is the same for all areas of philosophy. Validating an understanding of the outcomes produced by certain kinds of policy can be approached somewhat scientifically, but you’re never going to derive reliable predictions, or conclusions that are widely agreed upon. Which is the same issue that all scientific research of human behavior encounters, in this case further complicated by the fact that the domain is the entirety of human civilization.
- mcshicks 5y agoSpecifically in terms of being predictive you might be interested in reading Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know? by Philip E. Tetlock if you are not familiar with it already. He tried to empirically test experts political judgement and the main conclusion was pretty much everybody was bad. He now runs the good judgement project which trying to measure good forecasting skills to figure out who really is good at it. It was very eye opening to me at the time. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691178288/expert-political-judgment https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691178288/ex...
- civilized 5y agoIIRC the broad conclusion was that "experts" are really specialized, whereas predicting political developments requires a broader awareness. Hedgehogs and foxes.
- dillondoyle 5y agoThere are also different 'politics' careers or sets of knowledge. I own a digital agency that does digital marketing/fundraising for Democrats. so my view is there is a ton of knowledge and experiences that are unique to how political campaigns are run. For sure a lot of knowledge is transferable like if you know how to buy FB ads. (sidenote imho political consultants are way too insular and lag behind what the rest of the digital marketing world does) But I believe there is unique expertise that one builds up learning through years of working on campaigns. It's a weird blend of science, marketing, and some unquantifiable 'experience.' Which is BS sometimes for sure. But an example of experiential expertise is that say you want to make decisions based on data. So you do polling and surveys. But one can write a poll question in a bunch of ways to get pretty different response. Framing and background knowledge is important. though lol now that I wrote this out polling might not be the best example, it's a big can of worms. Pollsters after each election say they learned what was wrong with their weighting/models ex post facto lol.