5 ms·
I’m so confused, why can’t you have a private network? It’s the best way to run it. You get a pool of public addresses to use from your ISP that you can use for
by Spivak 5y ago
I’m so confused, why can’t you have a private network? It’s the best way to run it. You get a pool of public addresses to use from your ISP that you can use for anything! and then you give yourself the entirety of IPv6 private address space for your internal network.
- ok123456 5y agoBut now you're relying on your ISP to do your network addressing for you. What happens when you have multiple sites? Now you have to do more ipv6 epicycles.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 5y agoSorry, guess I wasn’t clear. I’m talking about using NAT with IPv6 being the best way to set it up. Your ISP gives you a whole pool of public addresses you can use for hosting stuff publicly or forwarding or high availability. None of your devices will have public addresses. Then you use all of the private address space for your internal stuff.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, why don't you just do that? I mean, there's a huge set of local IPv6 addresses for you to use, and odds are all of your computers are already using some (maybe more than 1). You don't need a NAT box at the network edge to set a private network. And iptables support what you described without a problem. But most people prefer to allocate the public addresses to the actual computers, not route them by demand. So the edge machine acts only as a firewall. It's easier, and there are enough addresses.
- slownews45 5y agoI tried this. It doesn't work. First, which ISPs give you the static IPv6 blocks? Its pretty easy (for $10/month) to get a block of IPv4, but I had a hard time getting anyone to find any free IPv6 addresses (oddly).