14 ms·
Should a dog's sniff be enough to convict a person for murder?
- NHQ 5y agoA dog cannot take the stand and be questioned, so how can it provide witness?
- renewiltord 5y agoDogs are cuddly AI. The first time we make a Convolutional Neural Network warm, cute, and fuzzy we will have created the perfect tool of the police state. Which naturally means that we already have created the perfect tool. It’s a dog. Nothing wrong with police in general. They’re just like dogs in their own way. Dogs get treats when they say there’s a drug, irrespective of the actual presence. Cops get treats when they a guy gets arrested or convicted, irrespective of guilt.
- grae_QED 5y agoFun fact: The Stasi had a scent library[0]. They would regularly use dogs to identify and arrest people. [0] https://theresagameinthat.blogspot.com/2011/06/stasi-scent-library.html?m=1 https://theresagameinthat.blogspot.com/2011/06/stasi-scent-l...
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoTLDR: No Usually it's not a dogs sniff but the dog handlers evidence about the behaviour of the sniffer dog. And dogs are far too good at behaving to please their handler/owner sometimes and acting out of instinct or boredom in others - how many dogs that have gone on a murderous rampage have been said to be sweet, loving creatures all their lives. It's hard to see how a dogs sniff evidence can be treated with the same level of accuracy as fingerprints/DNA evidence unless tests had proved that it (perhaps even the individual dog) was accurate to 1 in 1000 or 1 in 10,000 or more cases.
- Jon_Lowtek 5y ago>> Corcoran had trained Molly to sit when the dog detected the odor of human remains ... the team went to Redwine’s cabin, which was unoccupied. Molly sat down in a nearby stream and indicated at five other locations outside the home, according to Corcoran. Then she saw her dog looking up at a window. An investigator climbed into the house and opened the door for Corcoran and Molly. Inside, the dog made its indication—a sit—near a wood stove, in a bedroom, on a brown sofa, by a washing machine, and elsewhere. insert "this is worthless" spongebob meme template here. Convicting someone of murder because a dog sat in their house is worse then fake science, it is worse than superstition, that dog handler is blatantly creating fake evidence. Has that dog ever cleared someone of an accusation their handler believes in by refusing to sit near their stuff? Edit: to clarify, a cadaver dog is useful, if one searches for a cadaver: when the dog indicates a specific place one should dig there. But that is not how the dog is used here.
- h2odragon 5y agoIMO, this discussion goes wrong when we involve the dog in the first place. The testimony is that of the handler; they are the party saying that they have reason to believe X, based on their interpretation of their dog's behavior... which might as well be a dowsing rod or any other scrying method for the repeatability it has. If a dog/handler leads them to evidence, then the evidence can stand (or not) on its own just as if they were led to it by a psychic or a "hunch".
- annoyingnoob 5y agoI had a security dog in an airport come and sit next to me while I was standing in line. Thought for sure my day was over, really freaked me out because of stories like this. Nothing happened, I think the dog just figured me for the dog person that I am. You are not supposed to pet working dogs while they are working but that didn't stop me.
- michaelcampbell 5y agoMaking no opinion one way or the other, convictions are (I suspect) routinely made on eyewitness testimony which has been show many, MANY times to be horribly unreliable.
- encryptluks2 5y agoI was going to say the same. Not to mention how people are conditioned to trust cops and how prosecutors only need to get a person to say that they saw someone do something or heard them talk about it and a cop to say, yes this person is bad based on my interactions, in order to get conviction.. regardless if there is any real evidence, or evidence to the contrary in that matter.
- ChrisKnott 5y agoTechniques like this should only ever be used to direct investigations, and not be presented at court as evidence in their own right. It seems they work to an extent, but we clearly don't understand when and why they don't work.
- andi999 5y agoCan we just get back the polygraph?
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt's sad that a bullshit system that the accused and the accuser can easily game is one of the "successes" of forensics. At least there the accused can do something.
- eftychis 5y agoOr even better uniformly at random imprison some possible suspect -- you avoid the cost of the trial and you are fairly certain that an honest person is in jail -- that seems to be the goal of the system: let the jurors, judge and cops sleep at night. Who cares about justice anyways...
- andi999 5y agoNo smoke without fire they say.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThere is a huge difference between a dog finding a body (material evidence independent of the dog's behavioral characteristics) and a dog handler "reading" his dog's behavior and making various predictions out of it. The latter should absolutely not have any value in court. And to think that we laugh at the Romans for predicting future from the flight of birds (augury) and animal liver (haruspexy)...
- agys 5y agoThank you for “augury”! I looked up the etymology in Italian for auguri and it derives from the flight of birds. “Tanti auguri“ means “best wishes“, on the contrary “sciagura” (same root as “auguri”) means “misfortune“.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> predicting future from the flight of birds Well, to be fair, we can - to the extent that when I see birds fly-off from my back-garden I know it's about to rain...
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd to be fair, if you’re a subsistance farmer the ability to predict rain and other weather events is a huge percentage of the future you care about. Augury would be able to predict a decent bit of the important future for those people.
- jjluoma 5y agoThe same dog was used in all occasions: 1) sniffing of the clothes 2) around the house 3) inside the house 4) sniffing the truck. I would question if the dog was essentially trained to recognize the smell of the suspect, and if so, did the dog really indicate it was smelling odors from a dead body or the odors from the suspect. Also, only clothes of the suspect from an evidence room? Only one truck?
- kolanos 5y ago> I would question if the dog was essentially trained to recognize the smell of the suspect, and if so, did the dog really indicate it was smelling odors from a dead body or the odors from the suspect. And upon questioning, how would you possibly be able to verify?
- eftychis 5y agoYou mean accept as evidence a dog's reaction which has been criticized and known to be directed by officers/handlers for illegal searches (by providing fake probable causes). A dog that you can not ask what they detected or even statistically test as we have seen in the article like you could do an ML model. A whole field has been sprung on if and how ML inference could be used to make decisions, with lots of issues of racial profiling. And the judge and jury decided to accept a dog's reaction whose handler's new career was on the line. I am not sure why one should trust the justice system these days. P.S. A bunch of posts about Donziger and how UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention has stated to the U.S. he detention and imprisonment is against international law. I just find the sequence of articles ironic.
- tqi 5y agoAgreed. If Ring doorbell cameras were giving bogus probable cause at the rate these dogs were, the NYT would be all over it. But because it's not novel no reporters can be bothered to write about it...
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"They asked 554 mock jurors to read a story about a dog detecting the odor of drugs on a suspect’s car even though a later search turned up cash but no evidence of illegal activity. Lit says the scenario was meant to sound preposterous. Nonetheless, two-thirds of jurors surveyed said they would have found the suspect guilty." There is a real problem right there. Looks like you could get a conviction based on a fortune teller.
- biofox 5y agoTo me, it just highlights that there really ought to be some basic comprehension and reasoning test for jurors.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoI disagree with the jury system but as I understand it American jurors are supposed to reflect society. If you only want smart people you leave it to the judge.
- dls2016 5y agoAbout those judges…
- dTal 5y agoIn fact jury selection is notorious for discarding potential jurors with intelligence, critical thinking, legal awareness, or domain expertise. Jurors reflect the part of society least qualified to be making these decisions. Attorneys do not want thinkers, they want predictable cogs in the court machine.
- parineum 5y ago> In fact jury selection is notorious for discarding potential jurors with intelligence, critical thinking, legal awareness, or domain expertise. Jurors reflect the part of society least qualified to be making these decisions. Jurors get dismissed based on whether or not one side feels they decide in their favor or not. That's it.
- amelius 5y agoSimilar question: Should Machine Learning be allowed to drive a car?
- swilliamsio 5y agoThat similar question and this entire thread reminds me of xkcd 2173. [0] We obviously already let neural networks detect drugs and drive cars, though the former gets to wear a nice fluffy fur coat. [0] https://xkcd.com/2173/ https://xkcd.com/2173/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iso1210 5y agoNot at all a similar question, the outcome of machine learning of driving a car can be judged on objective results (incidents, accidents, injuries, deaths, etc)
- ootsootsoots 5y agoSo can the judicial system. Given the number of imprisoned found innocent over time, some models suggest up to 25% of the incarcerated population are innocent. Layer on those in prison for minor drug crimes and it goes up dramatically. Everything is quantifiable. The dimwitted elders in charge prefer you don’t think like that. Just abide the story; senile elders raised in a era of worse education standards, social standards, toxic leaded gas clouds, paranoia inducing world wars and cold wars are clearly the most capable leadership
- amelius 5y agoSorry, can't agree. You can validate the performance of dogs in a test setup, just like you can validate machine learning in a sandbox environment.
- sebow 5y agoYou're right there but that's not why these are not similar questions. A ML agent driving a car is about being able to do something out of "it's own agency"(We'll pass the free will observations for now, they're really irrelevant unless that's the point one makes between a ML agent and a dog, where the latter arguably has it compared to the former), the focus here being on "doing". A dog's sniff being considered as enough evidence to put someone in jail is not really the equivalent to "the dog has put X in jail".There's a case to resolve, and obviously the person/agent who has the evidence does not put the criminal in jail.Here the focus would be on the fact that the dog is not only observing something, but also the subjective interpretation of it's senses (assuming we would have such a thing as an "objective interpretation of one's senses at a given time", which is problematic imo)
- ootsootsoots 5y agoGiven the credibility of American governance, no. Frankly I would not trust most Americans to host a bbq without lighting someone on fire these days. There’s no way I’d sincerely trust their dogs. Those in policing are barely better educated than the dog.
- sebow 5y agoNo. It should be taken into account, but it shouldn't be considered "definitive" evidence (compared to something like a video footage).
- kolanos 5y agoA drug sniffing dog is a violation of the confrontation clause in the sixth amendment. It provides that " in all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right…to be confronted with the witnesses against him." You can't cross-examine a dog.
- AlbertCory 5y agoNo, but you can run your own test, where a neutral "handler" whom the dog has never seen runs his/her own scent tests on the dog's ability. Which should be the defendant's right if dog evidence is presented against him.
- MertsA 5y agoDogs being able to identify the scent of illicit substances is not the question at hand. The issue is that it's all too easy to manipulate the dog into signalling whatever the handler wants. A neutral handler would probably show that the dog can identify presence or absence of some drug with much better than a coin flip odds. In practice there's a terrible accuracy problem with drug sniffing dogs. In theory there's a somewhat reasonable accuracy of drug sniffing dogs. The judicial system likes to plug their ears and pretend that drug dogs are accurate and ignore the obvious fact that dogs are fallible social creatures that first and foremost are trying to do what their handlers want them to do. If the handler wants them to check for drugs, great, but when the handler doesn't care about accuracy and just wants them to "find" drugs, it should not be shocking that the dogs behavior reflects the handler's wishes. https://reason.com/2021/05/13/the-police-dog-who-cried-drugs-at-every-traffic-stop/ https://reason.com/2021/05/13/the-police-dog-who-cried-drugs... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_v._Harris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_v._Harris
- AlbertCory 5y agoRight, the question is not "dogs" but "this dog." Just like a good defendant in a speeding case doesn't stop when the cop says "I used my radar gun" - he asks what kind of radar gun and when was it calibrated, and how?
- kortex 5y agoThis should be really easy to settle, like basic undergrad experimental design, double blind study. Hardly a thorough literature search, but I found this reference. > On average, hidden drug samples were indicated by dogs after 64 s searching time, with 87.7% indications being correct and 5.3% being false. In 7.0% of trials dogs failed to find the drug sample within 10 min. ... > Dogs were equally efficient at searching in well-known vs. unknown rooms with strange (i.e., non-target novelty) odors (83.2% correct indications), but they were less accurate when searching outside or inside cars (63.5% and 57.9% correct indications respectively). So that tells me two rough indicators: - There's a ~5% chance a sniffer dog/handler could put away an innocent person. This is a lower bound, the risk is higher with cues/confirmation bias - There's only about ~60-80% sensitivity in unfamiliar situations, of what I presume are pretty fresh samples. You don't have to bust out Bayes' theorem to realize that a cadaver dog accurately hitting scents in the woods months later, stretches credibility. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0379073814000371 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03790...
- Zigurd 5y agoDogs are amazingly good at detecting things like cancer in double blind experiments. There are good reasons to think dogs can detect lots of things. That's not the problem: 1. No MD would order cancer treatment on the basis of a dog's sniff. 2. Analysis of all kinds of evidence, including the use of sniffer dogs, should not be managed by police departments, or even prosecutors. There have been many scandals of police evidence handling, even by supposedly professional evidence labs, have mishandled evidence and innocent people have been imprisoned. There needs to be independent analysis of evidence, incentivised to find the truth even if unfavorable to police and prosecutors. 3. Cops lie.
- flatline 5y agoUnfortunately there is more than statistics at play: http://www.wayne-county-forfeiture.com/content/drug-dogs-and-false-alerts-police-lie-and-dogs-wont-sniff-out-perjury http://www.wayne-county-forfeiture.com/content/drug-dogs-and...
- jakelazaroff 5y ago
- nikkinana 5y agoAbsolutely. Or do you hate dogs too?
- elmolino89 5y agoImagine a drug detecting dog going through 100 apartments. No drugs were found in any of them but say in 5 of them the dog sat on his bottom /barked/did whatever constitutes something resembling "drug odor detected". I hope no judge will put the people who did live in these apartments up to half a year before in jail.
- alphabettsy 5y agoNot just that, but the dog’s indication is used to do incredibly invasive searches that the government does not have to incur the costs of the damage done. They will essentially toss a home or vehicle like a burglar, even going as far as cutting open things like seats and removing parts.
- MertsA 5y agoNot only will police occasionally destroy vehicles in a search without being liable for the damages, often any insurance policies also do not cover it. You can do absolutely nothing wrong and obey the law and buy comprehensive coverage and gap insurance and still have your vehicle destroyed by the cops because they managed to convince a dog to scratch your paint, and you're the one that's stuck with a totalled vehicle and a huge loan to pay off. https://reason.com/2021/04/23/the-cops-trashed-her-house-she-says-she-was-targeted-for-retaliation/ https://reason.com/2021/04/23/the-cops-trashed-her-house-she... https://jalopnik.com/new-jersey-cops-destroy-bmw-searching-for-weed-that-was-5871909 https://jalopnik.com/new-jersey-cops-destroy-bmw-searching-f...
- FpUser 5y agoWhatever the fuck happened to "beyond the reasonable doubts". Any reasonable person should have such in this case.
- vkou 5y agoYou'd be surprised by what reasonable jurists believe is damning evidence.
- FpUser 5y agoWell, not really. After reading about some cases I've long lost any trust I may have had in the system. It might be ok in general (do not have enough real stats) but when it comes to fucking up particular person's life without any consequences the government / their institutions shine.
- pitay 5y agoYeah the lack of consequences for those that administer justice is (I believe) the strongest reason an innocent person is convicted or punished far too harshly for the given crime. The only time I have heard of judges ever getting punished for their judgments is either when it is revealed that they have been taking bribes or their nation lost a war.
- dzink 5y agoThere was a news mention months ago of a dog at a police department that “detected” drugs 100% of the time ot was deployed - the running joke was that the dog was brought in whenever they wanted to detain anybody. A dog is only as good as it’s training and there is plenty of room for abuse in the system.
- Buttons840 5y agoMine as well just let the officer sniff. Yeah, human smell isn't up to the task and will be wildly inaccurate, but that's not a problems for dogs, so why should it be a problem for humans?
- adam-p 5y agoThis seems analogous to using an AI. We trained it, it seems to mostly do what we want it to do, but we don't entirely understand how (or what cues and confounding factors might be in play that wouldn't like if we did know about). Do jurors respond the same way to a black-box "expert" if it's not furry?
- deepsun 5y agoUnlike AI, sniff dogs are trained to bark at a sign from it's owner. So whenever police wants to search you, they make a sign to the dog, and it barks.
- betwixthewires 5y agoThis is patently false, you get your information from movies and not real life. Sniff dogs sit when they detect what they're looking for, they do not bark.
- deepsun 5y agoSure, they sit at the command of their officer. That's not my point. My point is that it's easy to make a case for a search with a dog.
- betwixthewires 5y agoAnd my point is, if you don't even know the first thing about their training you're just making shit up because you want to believe it. Read a little about sniffing dogs.
- Nevermark 5y agoExcept the point that dogs respond to their owners wishes, even subtlety or unintentionally displayed, was valid. You don't need to know about special sniffing dogs to know dogs want to please their owners. The burden is on those interpreting the behavior of specific sniffing dogs in a way that demonstrates their is actual reliability in general, and in the specifics. No the other way around.
- harha 5y agoThis shows a greater dilemma: we don’t want a caste of legal experts making fundamental decisions for an individuals life, but the alternative of getting a jury consisting of the average population who lack sufficient education also doesn’t lead to an outcome one would want when on trial. I wonder if there is a middle ground solution where the jury decides on parts of a trial independently without knowledge of other parts, e.g. only on admitting a piece of evidence.
- LightG 5y agoNo. I've not read tfa but being stopped under suspicion of carrying drugs at an aiport because a sniffer-dog got a bit too excited about a humous sandwich I'd just bought tells me answer to this question. Also raising the question of whether a sniffer-dog can be manipulated by its handler. Questons, questions ...
- marsdepinski 5y agoIt's science!
- chmod600 5y agoWe celebrate "science", but we skip the scientific method. Observational studies, unreprodcible experiments, and non-falsifiable models have taken over. Not just taken over in pop science, but actual scientific fields. So can we really blame judges and juries for taking a few intellectual short cuts? Yes, I suppose we can, because an individual is at risk and we should expect better. But the scientific community should take some blame for compromising on the core of science while continuing to fly the banner of science.
- chmod600 5y agoWhere can I find I good test for scientific and statistical reasoning? Something a layperson could easily take, like a bunch of word problems that aren't numbers-heavy?
- AlbertCory 5y agoI dismiss anything Corcoran says after I read this: There’s so many missing people that need to be found. You know, it’s just sad. And that’s really what it’s all about: If we can recover somebody, so their family can know the ending. That’s really what it should be about. So this is totally about the problem, and not the "solution." If you're attacking her, you're against families finding out what they need to know. BS. Maybe if she said something about the reliability of the method, and not the need for ANY method, I'd pay more attention.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoSeems like the appropriate defense strategy should be to arrange their own cadaver dog analysis which shows completely contradictory evidence to that of the the prosecution dog.
- AlbertCory 5y agoAfter reading all the comments (a dirty job, but someone has to do it), I reach this conclusion, which doesn't require any massive changes to our justice system: The constitutional right to "confront" a witness against you should be interpreted as the right to run your own unbiased tests on any dog whose results are used. This would mean a neutral handler whom the dog doesn't know conducts double-blind tests on the dog. If the dog is found to be unreliable by the judge, then the evidence is discarded, the same as if a warrantless search had been conducted.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoDogs learn to please their handlers and react to their cues. Any reliable use of dogs (or any animal for that matter) must have the paranoid kind of quality control known from machine learning. Worse, actually, because an animal is a learning agent, shifting its model.