6 ms·
NASA just announced that they want to spend $1B per launch for SLS once a year until 2050. For a capability less than what SpaceX might provide for $10M. Tha
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
NASA just announced that they want to spend $1B per launch for SLS once a year until 2050. For a capability less than what SpaceX might provide for $10M.
That's not sensible risk management, that's head in the sand denialism.
https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/10/nasa-wants-to-buy-sls-rockets-at-half-price-fly-them-into-the-2050s/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/10/nasa-wants-to-buy-sl...
- api 5y agoIt's a jobs program for Alabama.
- handrous 5y agoThe space museum (also home of the famous Space Camp) in Huntsville, AL sure is pimping it, still. That's the one and only future rocket for USA space flight, one might think if one's only knowledge came from a visit to that museum, rather than a sad zombie project that everyone knows will be badly obsolete by the time it flies. Plus a huge amount of square footage dedicated to advertising for various MIC contractors for stuff that has little or nothing to do with space, and a lot to do with killing people. Super lame. Half of the museum feels like a government contractor trade show, not a museum, which makes sense given where it's located, but doesn't explain why it seems to have a good reputation, as far as space & rocketry museums go.
- panick21_ 5y agoThis is beyond insane and wont happen. Once Starhip flies even the last politicans can be cornered to admit to kill this ridiculous rocket.
- yokem55 5y agoNo, there will be one excuse after another. Starship isn't human rated and only Orion is rated for human deep space flight. So something else will still be needed to launch Orion to that lunar trajectory. That something else is SLS. Now the obvious solution is to rate Dragon for deep space and launch humans in that on a falcon and have it meet up with a starship in LEO. But getting that will probably take more years and billions paid to to the Orion and SLS POR before it will actually come to pass. Never underestimate the power of a self-licking ice cream cone.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt's not like they're paying the 2050 launch costs up front. If Starship succeeds, expect SLS to get quietly relegated after a few token launches.
- dangerbird2 5y agoThe problem is that for Starship to hit that $10M price point, SpaceX will have to demonstrate several as of yet unproven capabilities: In-space refueling (required for any missions outside LEO), safe and reliable re-entry from orbit, and fast turnaround for Starship to be launch-ready after landing. The last thing NASA needs is a glorified Space Shuttle 2.0 that takes months to be rebuilt after each re-entry, and has the constant risk of the crew burning up on re-entry. Fortunately, it's looking increasingly less likely that this will be the case, but NASA is right to not put all of its eggs in the Starship basket. For what its worth, if Starship does succeed in being a cheap and re-usable super-heavy launcher, NASA can always just stop making SLS (presumably after giving the senators for Alabama sufficiently large bribes) and switch to Starship for super-heavy launches.
- kiba 5y agoIt doesn't matter if Starship can't do all of these. It will still be likely cheaper and more capable than NASA's SLS, even if it's capable of only launching one time. Remember, SpaceX is engineering a production line to make Starship, not just prototyping Starshipp.
- dangerbird2 5y ago> That is still a 200-ton to Orbit launcher for the cost of a Falcon 9 or cheaper. [citation needed]
- panick21_ 5y agoLook at how fast they can build an upper stage with basic materials and standard welders from the oil industry. The engine cost is reportedly already under 1M and they are building a huge factory t produce more. Even under the worst assumption, where I take conservative assumptions and then double them you still end up with cost comparable to Falcon Heavy.
- panick21_ 5y agoEven if you assume only basic first stage re-usability (that is well proven). That is still a 200-ton to Orbit launcher for the cost of a Falcon 9 or cheaper. And for what it is worth, SLS should be canceled no matter if Starship exists or not. Its a program that embodies everything bad about the modern space industry and space policy.
- ren_engineer 5y ago>denialism more like corruption
- onepointsixC 5y agoWhile I have much dislike for SLS, there is just no way in hell SpaceX will charge $10M for a launch. SpaceX have their own goals which they need funds for and they're not going to under cut their Falcon 9 that intensely like that. That's not to say that Starship won't be the best price per ton of payload to orbit. But let's stay reasonable here. As for NASA remaining with SLS, for now at least, is due to a mix of congressional support, and the remaining unproven nature of starship. SLS allows members of congress say that they're supporting jobs. While SpaceX is pushing the limits of space engineering, Boeing and many other contractors have pushing the limits of political engineering. Hence the result that the same company that took us to the moon can't get into orbit, but is still maintaining contracts in spite of screwing up everything.
- panick21_ 5y agoEven with Starship not existing SLS is a mistake. It doesn't do anything that you can't do in other ways. We already have distrusted rocket launch. SLS is holding the moon architecture hostage. There is simply no need for it.
- JulianMorrison 5y ago> they're not going to under cut their Falcon 9 that intensely Once Starship is tried and tested, I strongly suspect they will flat out deprecate Falcon. Fly the missions that have been paid and scheduled, and then bin them.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoI am sure that absent interference from the US House and Senate NASA would say something different but if NASA says too much their stand to have their funding cut.