4 ms·
Does anyone else have feelings about “there’s too many tiers of Pi” yet? I’m not sure if I feel that but it’s on my mind.
by Waterluvian 5y ago
Does anyone else have feelings about “there’s too many tiers of Pi” yet?
I’m not sure if I feel that but it’s on my mind.
- xor99 5y agoNot really: the pico is in the mcu space, compute module for industrial projects, pi4 as large sbc, and pi zero as small sbc. Seems like a good range. I think the least differentiated are the pi4 and pi zero but there's still a big difference when you think about applications (e.g. trying to stick a pi4 in a diy smart speaker or multiple VMs).
- michaelt 5y agoI don't know about too many tiers, but they've certainly run out of sensible naming ideas. Who the hell signs off naming a product 'Zero 2' let alone the 'Zero 2 W' ?
- exporectomy 5y agoIt's becoming like USB version names. If you're familiar with them from working with them all regularly, you can just remember what name means what. But for newcomers, it's a massive struggle. I feel that naming things in general imposes a lot of cognitive burden on people. Chrome version numbers are beautiful. Just incrementing integers, the way we numbered things as kids. I wonder if the naming mess is intentional for marketing or an accident of not predicting the future well enough? They certainly seem to be trying to keep it simple and it's nowhere near the impossible muddle of, say, Intel and AMD CPUs or Nvidia GPUs yet.
- martin_a 5y agoWhat baffles me is the rather bad availability of older versions. I'd have guessed that there's somewhere a warehouse full of Pi Zero Ws, but I can't buy one right now in Germany. There's a shop in Switzerland, but I'd have to pay import taxes and whatnot to get hold of that. So, let's try a Model 3 B+ then... Same as before: Official vendors are almost all sold out, one has some but it's 15 to 20 Euro above the recommended price... Something's broken in the reselling system if you ask me.
- justincormack 5y agoIn case you didn’t hear, there is a global supply chain crisis and a chip shortage.
- micheljansen 5y agoIt says on the official Raspberry Pi website: Are you discontinuing Zero and Zero W? No. We seldom discontinue products, even where they have been superseded by more modern product at the same price point. Zero 2 W is $5 more expensive than Zero W, and joins the Zero family as a third member. Note that Zero and Zero W are currently experiencing supply constraints in the context of the global semiconductor shortage. We hope that this will be resolved in 2022.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> So, let's try a Model 3 B+ then... Same as before: Official vendors are almost all sold out, one has some but it's 15 to 20 Euro above the recommended price... An econ student would probably tell you that this is the market adjusting (or trying to) against the official price not matching the supply/demand intersection, so they're only available at the "real" price that unofficial vendors provide. (Of course, it may be more complex than that simplistic reading, hence econ student :])
- madisp 5y agoif you don't mind a soldered-on header then berrybase seems to have plenty of Pi Zero WHs
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoI prefer the WH, unless you have serious space constraints, soldering your own is a little fiddly.
- marcosdumay 5y agoThe PI is almost always sold off, since the first version. Availability has always been low. What you are seeing is probably because the 3B+ is the most sold version, and replenishing anything is slightly harder right now.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe different options are definitely appreciated. The default choice should be the base model Raspberry Pi 4. The other options (compute module, Zero, higher RAM versions) are for specialized needs. Even if you’re using the Zero or Compute Module you probably want the normal Raspberry Pi 4 around for development.
- spicybright 5y agoSame. If you're shopping for a ras-pi, I think you're already in the market of people that are ok researching many models to find one that matches your use case best. It's different from, say, apple having 10 different types of mac books each for slightly different use cases.
- foxfluff 5y agoNot really, but that's because I largely dismiss the early Pis altogether. They sit in the awkward space where they're larger and faster than a microcontroller but practically speaking require an OS that wastes a lot of the available resources; for running Linux applications, they feel way underpowered. Pi 3 seemed powerful enough to be interesting and I did a small project with it, but Pi 4 pushes it to where I'm actually starting to like the platform (though I'm still anxious for a Pi 5). Now with the Zero 2 W, there are three tiers: the Pi 4 for SBCs, Zero 2 W for providing connectivity for things that don't really look like computers as such (but still need Linux for whatever reason?), and then the Pico for microcontroller projects. The difference in capabilities between each tier is large; they cover a wide spectrum of use cases. You can't complain that there are too many tiers. It's good to know that you can fall back to the older Pis if you have very specific/niche needs that they fulfill better than the new ones, but you'll know it when you need them, and having these extra choices doesn't hurt. If you don't have very specific requirements, just pick the most appropriate of the three new ones. Easy. I guess I'm also disregarding the compute module, because I haven't seen particularly compelling reason to look at it. Again I guess if you have very specific needs and can design a carrier board for it, have a go at it. Otherwise, ignore.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoI think the later Pi 3 models are still fine; they're a little slower (CPU and IO), but they're cheaper than the 4 while still running 64-bit ARM and being reasonable capable. I would agree that unless you have existing stuff to replace in place the Pi 1 and 2 are irrelevant today:)
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> They sit in the awkward space where they're larger and faster than a microcontroller but practically speaking require an OS that wastes a lot of the available resources; for running Linux applications, they feel way underpowered. The Raspberry Pi isn't competing with a microcontroller. They're on opposite ends of the computing spectrum. If an application can be quickly developed and run on a microcontroller, using a full embedded Linux system would be overkill. As for Linux work: The Raspberry Pi 4 is plenty fast for most embedded applications. If you're trying to use it as a desktop replacement it's going to feel sluggish relative to an actual desktop, especially if you're only using an SD card instead of a USB3 SSD. However, it's generally not a problem for most non-desktop use cases. Compiling large projects is the only place where a Pi 4 starts to feel limited, but cross-compilation is available with plenty of guides online. If you have a situation that requires more power than a Pi 4, you should probably be using a real desktop or VM anyway. These are embedded systems that start at $35, not something competing with a $500 NUC or a $2000 laptop.
- blippage 5y agoYes, I think there are too many. Everyone tends to go for the latest and greatest. The Pi is heading towards becoming a PC replacement, but I'm not sure what advantage that is. Instead of have faster computers, I want a faster OS. Or preferably very little in the way of an OS. Something like a DOS, perhaps. Something where you could write blazingly-fast software because the kernel is straightforward. And I want a real-time kernel. I'm vaguely aware that there's some stuff out there, like RTEMS and a real-time Linux, but I suspect it's all a pain to set up. I've played around with writing my own "kernel" - but it's more in the style of a "unikernel" - which is a pretty good approach. The real problem occurs when you want to use the USB. A USB stack is not easy to implement. I also had the SD card working, but I haven't been able to get it working lately. I would like to see Pis flourish as a way of implementing Operating Systems, but the hardware is too complex. Maybe some kind of Pico/Pi hybrid might be feasible. That might sound an insane suggestion, but Ebon has mentioned in the past that a combo of a Pi with a microcontroller is a good one. Why not take this idea to its logical conclusion and put both on the same board?
- bri3d 5y agoSTM32MP1 is a good example of your hybrid idea - it combines a Cortex A7 Linux application-side stack with an STM32 Cortex-M4 based microcontroller on the same SoC. This is very useful for running hard realtime tasks on the microcontroller and "control" / GUI / application-stack intensive tasks on the Linux side, as you suggest. With that said, all this does for toy OS development is makes it more complicated. I think what you are looking for for your use cases might really be just an RTOS on a microcontroller with some provided driver blocks. Take a look at ESP32 as well :)
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoThanks for posting that! On the table next to me I have a system that's comprised of a SOM running Linux for a UI and an STM32 for real-time control. They talk over a serial port. I didn't realize that ST had combined the two. That's definitely useful information!
- spicybright 5y ago
- marcosdumay 5y agoIMHO, the relevant ones are 3B+, 4B+ and zero. The zero comes on many forms, but if you are using it, their difference should be clear enough. For random stuff you do once, if you need a powerful computer (weak-desktop-like) with great IO, you go with 4. If you need great IO on a weak normal computer, you go with the 3. If you need a powerful-desktop-like computer, you go with AMD64, and if you only need great IO and not much of a computer, an Arduino. The zero goes on things that you will do many times or that have very specific constraints.
- occamrazor 5y agoI wouldn't say so. RPi doesn't discontinue products, but it doesn't really make sense to buy most older models. In practice there are 4 RPi's: the Zero (5$ is hard to beat), the Zero 2 W (small, cheap, with WiFi) and the 4 Model B. Then there is the Pico, but it is a microcontroller, a completely different product, and the CM4, for large scale deployments.
- ThatPlayer 5y agoI also like the 3 A+ for an inbetween Zero 2 W and 3/4. Don't need a USB OTG adapter you'd need for a Zero, and not as big as the 4.