4 ms·
>If an employer has decided to fire you, then you've not only failed at your job, you've failed as a human being I mean I would take that as a pretty good iron
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
>If an employer has decided to fire you, then you've not only failed at your job, you've failed as a human being
I mean I would take that as a pretty good ironic comment - I would definitely need a lot more context for me to decide that the person who said it meant it for real.
That is to say there are some viewpoints that can be held by real people, for example that the earth is flat, but if someone says in a passing comment "I've decided to cancel that vacation to Indonesia because I don't want to fall off the edge of the world where the sea monsters dwell" it is more reasonable to suppose it facetious until we get enough data to figure no, they're just nuts!
- cushychicken 5y agoI've spent enough time in counseling over the past year to tell you that there are people out there who tie their identity so strongly to their jobs that this statement would definitely be true. There's at least one of them - that's me! Part of why I'm in counseling is that I recognized this, and I want to change it.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoyou might feel that about yourself, but would you have expressed it to another person about them? Lots of people can feel that they have failed as a human being when they get fired, but it takes a real nut to say that about someone they don't know as a piece of objective fact!
- cushychicken 5y agoYeah, I agree - that's a harsh verging on psychotic thing to tell someone who's just taken a blow like that. I hate to say it, though, but I think the sort of person that would say something like that is the sort of person I have been for the better part of the last decade. I defined myself so strongly by my job, and what I did, that I probably would have seen it as a huge personal and moral failing to be fired. I pity the person who said that. (Not nearly as much as I pity the person who heard that. What a shite thing to say to a friend, or even an acquaintance!) That's no excuse for that level of unkindness, but I think I see the worst parts of my personal history in what would drive someone to say something like that. I hope they see that, and I hope they are inspired to change when they recognize it.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoOk well I'm glad to hear you're better, but as I started out with I think that is the less likely situation than just being ironic and the irony not being apparent (because it was said online). But maybe I just think that is the more likely because I can totally see myself saying that ironically. on edit: I probably don't sound caring enough but I have a hard time doing that, so believe me I am glad you do not have this problem anymore since it sounds pretty bad.
- cushychicken 5y agoPro tip: irony, or ironic humor, is not a great reaction to someone who just told you they got fired.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIs it from people talking about themselves? If so, I'd default to believing it's honest. When people get a setback like that a huge amount of them believe they failed as human beings. Not doing so requires a large amount of introspection and wisdom. If it's people talking about other people, without the emotional baggage, then I agree, it must be either irony or some evil one trying to control people.
- barrenko 5y agoTrust me, people are really religious about jobs.
- jt2190 5y agoTo quote Homer Simpson: “It’s funny because it’s true.” Whether the original commenter quoted by the author of this article (that quote should be proceeded by >> above, to make that clear) meant it in jest or not doesn’t change the fact that employers actually judge candidates with this exact criteria every day. (Edit: clarity)
- crispyambulance 5y ago> ...need a lot more context for me to decide that the person who said it meant it for real. Yes, of course. But the thing that ends up hurting a lot of people in a really deep way is the psychological hangs-ups caused when they conflate THEIR OWN self-worth to their employment status (not just employed or not, but also level and salary). Any adult who has a solid self-image can tolerate hearing "you've failed as a human being" from derps all day long, what ends up causing damage is if they take it seriously, or much worse, tell it to themselves.
- Igelau 5y agoYeah, that's some "coffee is for closers!" phony business machismo.
- bodge5000 5y agoThe same kind of people who brag about never taking a sick day or always working unpaid overtime. If you do either of those things, absolutely fine, you have your reasons, but theres a certain kind of person who wears it like a badge of honour and will jump at the chance to tell you about it. Not that I think they're bad people for it, just very odd, and not really someone I'd like to be.
- austincheney 5y agoI remember when Travelocity went through layoffs in 2009. A thousand people out the door, about a third of all employees. No me, and I had just received a critically negative annual review for the prior year.
- jaggederest 5y agoIt's extra funny, because the same movie has this wonderful scene I refer to often when I'm working as a consultant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTjhHrcyiQI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTjhHrcyiQI TL;DW: "We're professionals, treat me like a professional. If it's not working out, say so, and I'll make it right or we'll shake hands and part ways on good terms". I used to provide clients with a "how to fire me" document because it made them feel comfortable hiring me in the first place. (Tell me, I return materials, pay me outstanding balances, here's the keys you change, here's how we wrap up the contract terms, etc etc) I've been "fired" a bunch of times, and at times have had those same clients that "fired" me refer me to new clients. It's the same as with most technical work, I find: if you're not failing at least sometimes, you're not pushing the limits of what is possible.