3 ms·
> - Tax capital gains >1m a year as regular income. It sounds fair, but aren't lower capital gains taxes used to encourage investment? And if we get rid of tha
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
> - Tax capital gains >1m a year as regular income.
It sounds fair, but aren't lower capital gains taxes used to encourage investment? And if we get rid of that incentive on income > $1 million (at least, can they still offset losses?), then would that lead to some adverse consequence (like much lower investment overall as direct income generation becomes preferred at that point)?
- adam_arthur 5y agoI would guess not much reduction in investment. If you have 100m dollars, there's only a limited number of places you can put it. What are you proposing re: direct income generation? It will lead to reduced liquidity though. E.g. holders of assets are likely to sell less frequently to avoid the higher tax burden.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> If you have 100m dollars, there's only a limited number of places you can put it. Stock market is a risky place to put it for sure, especially if the upside is taxed more aggressively. > What are you proposing re: direct income generation? They will invest more in private businesses and just take a salary, which is also taxed as income.
- adam_arthur 5y agoMost wealthy people are likely to own dividend paying stocks, so valuations don't matter as much for risk re the market. They get paid every quarter by the company, and can just live off of passive distributions. If they follow what you're proposing, they pay the higher tax rate anyway. But also don't think that's really feasible at very high net worth.
- pas 5y agoIf you move money from one stock market position to an other do you realize your gains? If not, then said investors can simply dump their gains into small new companies that are on the stock market. (Plus see SPACs.)