5 ms·
>- Remove step up in cost basis on inheriting assets. my impression is that the step-up cost basis is there because you've already paid the estate tax when the
by gruez 5y ago
>- Remove step up in cost basis on inheriting assets.
my impression is that the step-up cost basis is there because you've already paid the estate tax when the assets were transferred to you? otherwise you'd end up getting double-taxed.
- adam_arthur 5y agoI need to read more into that. If true, the cost basis should only be stepped up such that it accounts for the estate tax. I'd prefer some simpler overall approach though. Removing step up in cost basis alone obviates the need for an estate tax, as eventually assets would be sold and tax revenue generated. But important to do some research into how often inherited assets are kept permanently and gains never realized (thus tax never paid). Just on gut instinct, I would guess most who inherit wealth eventually sell off any assets. I recall it tends to be that most accumulated wealth is lost by the third generation.
- WalterBright 5y ago> thus tax never paid The estate tax is still due. The federal estate tax is 40%.
- adam_arthur 5y agoI was saying, in a world without an estate tax. If you could remove estate tax and cover by removing step up in cost basis, is probably preferable (but contingent on assets eventually getting sold, requires some research)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoFor almost every US person, it IS a world without an estate tax. Nobody pays that in 2021 without an estate worth more than US$11.7M
- WalterBright 5y agoThe figure is $2,193,000 for Washington State. Considering that even starter houses are over a million bucks here, I bet that sweeps in quite a bit more than "nobody".
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThe median house price in Washington State is $450K. If you have another $1.7M in assets when you die, you died rich.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago... with rates at most half the 40% being cited here for federal estate tax. State policies differ, indeed. Almost all discussion of estate taxes in this thread has focused on or been exclusive to the federal estate tax.
- WalterBright 5y ago20% is still far from "a world without an estate tax".
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWA state has a population of about 8M. Its citizens decided in 1981 to switch from an inheritance tax to an estate tax. This citizen-driven state law affects slightly more than 2% of the US population, in theory. In fact, median household income for WA in 2019 was about $78k, median household net worth in 2019 was about $400k, and median family net worth in WA in 2021 was $865k. So in reality, even within WA state, almost nobody is paying the state estate tax. Here's the Seattle Times from 2019 on the incongruities in state wealth distribution. But notice that even in their numbers, home owner median net worth is still only $900k, less than half the state's estate tax threshold. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/data/seattle-household-net-worth-ranks-among-top-in-nation-but-wealth-doesnt-reach-everyone/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/data/seattle-house...
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoAlmost nobody pays the estate tax. >When a person dies, their assets could be subject to estate taxes and inheritance taxes, depending on where they lived and how much they were worth. While the threat of estate taxes and inheritance taxes does exist, in reality, the vast majority of estates are too small to be charged a federal estate tax—which, as of 2021, applies only if the assets of the deceased person are worth $11.70 million or more (Investopedia; https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/120715/estate-taxes-who-pays-what-and-how-much.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/12071...)
- WalterBright 5y ago> applies only if the assets of the deceased person are worth $11.70 million or more And hence they apply to billionaires, which is the topic of this page.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoActually most billionaires manage to reshuffle their assets to that their estate, such as it is, is under the limit by the time they die. The main people hit by it are those holding large amounts of valuable land, and there are very few of them. Almost all mentions of the estate tax in this thread has been generic whining about the fact that there is an estate tax. For almost all US persons, there is no estate tax.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> Actually most billionaires manage to reshuffle their assets I was talking to some people sufficiently wealthy that this is a concern, and their point is that the only reason some don't transfer their assets like this is fear of their own children. Unless you really are a farmer, or small business owner, the estate tax is completely optional if you trust your kids. In 2019, there were only 2,570 estate taxes filed. > Almost all mentions of the estate tax in this thread has been generic whining about the fact that there is an estate tax There is also whining among people that they need to spend so much on accountants and lawyers to avoid what is essentially a completely bypassable tax. So you can see how socially it is not a good use of our human capital to create this enormous tax avoidance industry, and how it would be much better to pass laws that didn't need to do things like value privately held businesses or artwork in order to determine your tax liability.
- mandevil 5y agoI buy stock at price A and sell, it later, at price B. Assuming B > A, (if it isn't this is a whole different thing) then I am taxed on the gain the stock made, I pay tax on the value of (B-A). On the other hand, I do have all of the (B-A) cash, which is nice. (Or as my tax professor once said, it's always better to have more money rather than less, and to die later rather than sooner.) Now let's say I still buy the stock at price A, but instead of selling I hold until my death and my heirs inherit. They pay the estate tax, yes (presuming that my total wealth is massive enough to reach that level), but they pay it as a % of value B- at this point no one owes the government any of that (B-A) tax. Is that "double taxation"? Well, it kinda depends on your perspective, and this is a situation where perspective seems to be determined by bank balance. If you are wealthy, of course you feel that it is double taxation- it's two separate bites of taxes on the same underlying asset! If you aren't, then what you notice is that somehow this death has created a situation where the government never got it's cut of that (B-A) difference, so this is avoiding taxes.
- necovek 5y ago> If you aren't, then what you notice is that somehow this death has created a situation where the government never got it's cut of that (B-A) difference, so this is avoiding taxes. While capital was transferred, value increase was never really monetized. Would it not be fair to say that it will be taxed only once it turns into money, against the B-A gains, and A is taxed according to normal inheritance rates. Of course, this has a huge practical issue of knowing what A was, which could be a while back.
- torstenvl 5y ago> this has a huge practical issue of knowing what A was, which could be a while back So why not put the burden of establishing a basis (A) on the person seeking to claim its benefit — who, in this case, is also best-positioned to gather such evidence? Should they keep poor records, they lose the benefit of that basis, and will instead pay taxes on (B-0).
- mandevil 5y agoTaxing the B-A gains when they are sold, even after death, is what people mean by "eliminating the stepped-up basis" as the original poster suggested doing. At present, when a heir inherits at B they pay estate tax at B, but then if they sell at price C they only pay tax on (C-B). As for knowing what A is, if you don't know it you can always fill in 0 and pay slightly more tax than you should, to be safe, so you don't caught in an audit. As of 2011 the IRS requires all brokers to track and report the cost basis for all purchases- that is, any purchase made after 2011 when you sell it they will tell you and the government what the value of A should be.
- tfehring 5y agoThe estate tax is almost always double taxation in general. If you just save up money from working and then you die, you'll have paid income tax on that money, then you'll be taxed again on that same money under the estate tax. If you invested it and realized capital gains, you'll pay capital gains tax on those gains, then you'll be taxed on those same gains again under the estate tax. Unrealized capital gains are the exception and not the rule here. There's nothing fundamentally wrong with "double taxation," no rule that says every dollar must be taxed exactly (or at most) once. Sales tax is also "double taxation," for example. It's a useful heuristic for determine what should and shouldn't be deductible from a particular tax base but it's not a hard-and-fast rule.
- ric2b 5y agoIsn't double taxation when a tax applies on top of another tax? I think some people are trying to co-opt what it means to apply the "bad" reputation of double taxation to other things. My own country has a famous issue with double taxation as I know it: diesel/gasoline have a specific tax and then VAT is calculated on top of original_price * gas_tax, instead of the original price. So if the gas tax goes up 1% we end up paying more than 1% because it also the increases the value of the VAT.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoDiscussing the estate tax without mentioning how few people are even subject to it is seriously misleading, even if you're not intending to be (and I don't think you are).
- kmonsen 5y agoI was going to mention sales tax, but many other taxes are also double taxation I think like property tax or gas tax or whatever is not income tax since you will pay for them with whatever you have left after paying for income tax.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYou don't pay estate taxes in 2021 unless the estate is worth more than US$11.7M