3 ms·
if you tax unrealized capital gains, it's only fair to return unrealized losses. so > stock tanks to near $0 means you get all your paid tax back.
by chii 5y ago
if you tax unrealized capital gains, it's only fair to return unrealized losses. so
> stock tanks to near $0
means you get all your paid tax back.
- ethbr0 5y agoWhich opens the government up to actually having to pay back substantial sums from the IRS, in the event of an equity downturn.
- gruez 5y agothat's going to wreak havoc on finances during a recession. if the economy goes to shit, the government has to come up with money to stimulate the economy AND pay back all the capital gains taxes they collected during the boom times, all while tax revenues are down because businesses are imploding.
- chii 5y agowhich is why academic professionals such as Aswath Damodaran say that this law is a bit stupid, and poorly thought out - it appeals to popular mindset, but it would be ineffective at collecting new tax revenue, and at worst discourage entrepreneurship leading to long term damage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQddA58hZdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQddA58hZdQ
- dragonwriter 5y ago> that's going to wreak havoc on finances during a recession. No, among other reasons, because its not going to happen, just as it doesn't with the taxes on realized capital gains and losses, where losses can offset gains, and if there is excess a certain amount of regular income, and if there is still excess (or not enough taxable regular income to use the full offset) end up as carryforward losses that can be used as future-year losses, but don't result in negative liability on their own. > if the economy goes to shit, the government has to come up with money to stimulate the economy AND pay back all the capital gains taxes they collected during the boom times If they were to write the law so that unrealized capital losses resulted in tax refunds, that would be stimulus, not an extra thing on top or stimulus. It might not be optimally targeted stimulus, but that rarely happens, anyway.
- dragonwriter 5y agoI think that the proposal is, much as with taxes on realized gains and losses, unrealized losses would be allowed to offset unrealized gains and be carried forward if there was an excess of losses.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoOuch. If I understand you correctly, this is then a really awful scenario for founders. As a founder, my only assets were the stock of my company . I don't own any other stock, certainly none that would go thru the roof over a year or 2. If the company goes south after a hot streak, I end up with excess unrealized losses that I can't use, because I have no other assets with unrealized gains to book against my carryforward losses.
- neltnerb 5y agoI am not an accountant, but I believe this to indeed be the case. If you previously took losses, you can carry them forward but not get an actual refund. It might not be practical to do because what tax bracket do you use? It's simpler as an offset, so I guess they just have to pick a rule and so they picked one that is advantageous to them. The only other option that comes to mind is that if you take a significant loss, you get to retroactively get refunded from a previous year. This actually doesn't seem that intractable, it shouldn't be all that complicated to implement.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If I understand you correctly, this is then a really awful scenario for founders. It makes having all your eggs in one basket (very slightly) worse than the generally bad idea it already is (if its a billion dollar basket so that you qualify for this treatment in the first place.) But if all your eggs are in that basket, either the company bounces back later or you are wiped out anyway, so its not that much of a change from the status quo in that respect. Not that I like the proposal, mind you
- ncallaway 5y ago> As a founder, my only assets were the stock of my company . I don't own any other stock, certainly none that would go thru the roof over a year or 2. - Is it a publicly traded company? Or do you readily trade shares of it on the secondary market? If not, then you wouldn't owe any taxes under this scheme, which only applies to "tradable covered assets" (leg. text is here: https://www.finance.senate.gov/chairmans-news/wyden-unveils-billionaires-income-tax https://www.finance.senate.gov/chairmans-news/wyden-unveils-...) - Are your personal shares of the company worth > $1B? If not, then you also wouldn't owe any taxes under this scheme, which allows you to designate up to $1B of normally "tradable covered assets" as "non-tradable covered assets".