7 ms·
Well, one workaround would be to treat securitization of shares (eg for a loan) as a taxable event. This is a common (and currently legal) tax avoidance strateg
by anigbrowl 5y ago
Well, one workaround would be to treat securitization of shares (eg for a loan) as a taxable event. This is a common (and currently legal) tax avoidance strategy.
Another consideration is that maybe having sole control of a massive pot of cash or financial instruments by an individual is just a Bad Thing. Consider how Zuckerberg structured FB so that while he it's a public company, the bulk of the stock is non-voting so he has de facto sole control of the firm. No matter how destructive of shareholder value or public goods his executive decisions, it's virtually impossible for anyone else to overturn them barring some novel legal line of attack.
I have no particular feelings about Tim Sweeney/Epic, but would the economy or the gaming world be worse off if he no longer had founder control? If he's great at his job I presume shareholders would want to keep him on as CEO and would compensate him handsomely in cash money.
- dsizzle 5y agoActually, why wouldn't the Epic's of the world just issue themselves shares with super voting power, like what Facebook and Google did. That would address the concern in his tweet.
- yodon 5y agoYou only get to do that if you're printing money at such an astounding rate that investors will do anything to get you to let them invest in you. FB and Google, yes, most other companies, not so much.
- dsizzle 5y agoLots of companies do it, most of which are not as dominant as FB and Google https://www.cii.org/files/3_17_17_List_of_DC_for_Website(1).pdf https://www.cii.org/files/3_17_17_List_of_DC_for_Website(1).... It only really requires that shareholders trust the owners of the special class shares.
- fernandotakai 5y ago> Well, one workaround would be to treat securitization of shares (eg for a loan) as a taxable event. This is a common (and currently legal) tax avoidance strategy. agreed. that should 100% be a taxable event and it's totally absurd that it's not. and i'm sure there's a lot of... lobbying that will never allow that kind of law to pass.
- kyleee 5y agoIt does seem like a loophole, such funds when used as income should be taxed. Probably more complicated in practice but it does seem like a strategy that runs counter to the intent of taxation laws. And I'd bet if it was a strategy employed effectively by the 99% it would be vigorously labelled as tax evasion and dealt with accordingly
- bananabreakfast 5y agoThis is not a loophole. Collateralizing a loan against assets does not produce income. It produces cash and an even larger liability. That loan still has to be paid off with separate, regularly taxed, income. Also this is a strategy used all the time by the 99%. It's called a second mortgage. This proposal would mean that taking out a loan against the equity in a home would become a taxable event.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoOf course it's a loophole. Elon Musk takes essentially no salary, never sells his shares yet lives the life of a workaholic billionaire. The only reason he has any taxes at all is because he is taxed on his stock grants. He also has > $1B in debt. The first $500K in residential capital gains aren't taxable. I sure hope your second mortgage is less than that. Taxing the securitization of assets should cause a step up in the base cost of the asset. So it doesn't reduce the amount of tax you owe, it just changes when you owe it. (Unless you avoid the tax by dying).
- ethbr0 5y agoI don't think anyone's arguing people should be taxed twice. What they are arguing is that individuals should be taxed at the event of first utility (that is, realizing value from the gains). And then the tax is paid, so not paid again, or offset, later. And what we're really talking about here is individuals using equity loans for the majority of their income.
- yyyk 5y ago>No matter how destructive of shareholder value or public goods his executive decisions, it's virtually impossible for anyone else to overturn them barring some novel legal line of attack... IMHO, if the CEO's decisions are destructive of public goods, shareholders aren't the ones we should go to. We should be able to stop the CEO via government powers. >but would the economy or the gaming world be worse off if he no longer had founder control? Shareholder activism has a very double edged record. Their interests aren't necessarily the public's interest or the company's. Maybe they like dividends now rather than investment - their incentives definitely point that way. Giving them more power is unlikely to end well.
- WalterBright 5y agoI doubt SpaceX or Tesla would exist if they were controlled by a committee. Doing great things usually requires control by a single person who is able to say "screw it, we're going for X".
- threeseed 5y agoThis is simply nonsense. All companies once they reach a certain size (including Tesla, SpaceX) have a Senior Leadership Team which decides on the critical decisions affecting the company. This personality obsession is really only perpetuated by people who haven't worked in business and don't realise just how much of a team effort it is.
- rsj_hn 5y agoThe thing is, it's really critical to have that <strike>dictator</strike>CEO in charge of the company to reign in the senior leadership, otherwise what happens is the creation of fiefdoms and <strike>intra-oligarchic</strike>turf battles at the expense of overall success. Someone on this site mentioned Pournelle's Iron Law of Bureaucracy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Pournelle's_iron_law_of_bureaucracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Pournelle's_ir... And the CEO is the counterweight to that oligarchic rule. You see this, for example, in the constant battles that kings wage against the nobility.
- novok 5y agoI've been in companies that became founder led to professional CEO led, and you can see the difference in how effective a company is. I think there is great shareholder value also in founder led companies too, which have led to the growth of some of the largest and most successful companies in the world. When gates left microsoft was probably the begining of the company becoming somewhat irrellevant. Apple, tesla, epic, facebook, google, etc are all great examples of this. There is a really great possibility that america shoots it's future economic growth in the foot with something like this, just because it's future superstars companies are not led by their great founders.
- toast0 5y ago> Well, one workaround would be to treat securitization of shares (eg for a loan) as a taxable event. This is a common (and currently legal) tax avoidance strategy. I suspect it would be harder to stop this strategy than it might seem, because someone could happen to make me a large personal loan at a low interest rate when I happened to have a large portfolio with them. If the numbers are big enough, it makes sense to do. If you treated all loans as income, but got a deduction for making payments... Maybe you could make it work. Although, that's kind of rough for mortgage and auto loans.
- opportune 5y agoMortgage and auto loans are usually cash secured, so there are no gains to realize. This tax treatment could (I would say should) only apply to e.g. shares on the difference between the cost basis and amount used to collateralize the loan. One quirk of that is that regular Joe could then get a loan against their cost basis in their portfolio and still have no taxes. E.g. they bought 10shares of $X at $100 and now it’s $200. A loan secured against those shares would not be taxable up to $1000 and the portion between $1000 and $2000 would be taxable. This still stops mega billionaires from never paying taxes because the cost bases on their shares are usually very low.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- belltaco 5y agoA twitter reply says this: >I think everyone needs to read the bill and calm down. "Gains on private assets -- including harder-to-value assets like real estate, art and private companies -- would escape the annual levy, and only be taxable when sold. "
- itake 5y agoDoes that means founders would lose control when they IPO?
- codyb 5y agoIsn’t Sweeney talking about publicly traded companies here though?
- belltaco 5y agoOne of his tweets in the chain: >Every time a company’s value doubles, the government would force founders like me to sell 25% of our stake to pay the government. Epic’s value has doubled 8 times in the past 5 years. If this tax scheme had been place, I’d have been forced to liquidate nearly my entire ownership. Epic Games has always been a private company.
- satronaut 5y agowhat does the government need all that money for anyways?
- _carbyau_ 5y agoSame could be asked of any billionaire. Think about it. 1 Billion. A person who lived 100 years would have $27,397 a day to spend. Including as a newborn infant. At Bezos levels? roughly $5.3 million a day. What could you do with 5 million a day? Well for the first 3 months of your life as a newborn, not much probably. But as an adult certainly, you could find ways to spend it right? Great. Society would love to see some cash splashed around. The economics people always love to see money sloshing around society. So why can't these people simply stop accumulating and start letting it flow? They'd get to enjoy it. Their society would benefit from it. It'd be good for everyone. The more these people are forced to spend down their wealth - however they want to! - the better.
- Accujack 5y ago> If he's great at his job I presume shareholders would want to keep him on as CEO and would compensate him handsomely in cash money. This really isn't how the real world works. It's easy to design rules that would work acceptably if no humans were involved, but in reality this would ensure there are no sole owners of companies with control. Sooner or later, every CEO does something that "conventional wisdom" doesn't agree with, and if he doesn't have corporate control, he's out. Yes, this would "hurt" gaming and the economy, because it would change the ownership of companies for the worse. If every game company was Bethesda, mediocrity and micropayments would rule the gaming world, because every company would pursue whatever strategy is perceived to be "obvious" to make shareholders' money increase. If this tax had existed when Doom came out, Id software and the effects it had on gaming as we know it would never have existed. On a side note, the people here commenting that companies could just pay a salary to their CEOs large enough to cover the wealth tax apparently have never owned or run a company. Any company being forced to pay out liquid cash equal to 20% of its stock valuation would go under. The usual killer of small to medium companies is cash flow.. having enough money to buy what you need to keep producing and paying bills until your customers pay their bills. Also, if they're trying to tax theoretical gains, are they also going to pay out when companies' valuation decreases? In corporate performance, you get what you measure. If the tax is charged based on companies gaining value, companies won't gain value. That plus the fact that certain corporations are exempted from it (hedge funds) makes it a non starter.