3 ms·
(I don't play, but I did in college.) The whole point of playing with a partner is exchanging information in legal ways (bids, the cards you play). When you're
by AlbertCory 5y ago
(I don't play, but I did in college.)
The whole point of playing with a partner is exchanging information in legal ways (bids, the cards you play). When you're playing online, no one can tell if you're exchanging it in other ways.
Bridge tournaments should just sit the players at really big tables so they're socially distant. No online at all.
- meragrin_ 5y ago> Bridge tournaments should just sit the players at really big tables so they're socially distant. Why? It seems people are packing large events without issue.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI'm sure that's right. I just meant "you don't need to have tournaments online if covid is the only worry."
- lsjvjn 5y agoI'd say it's a larger concern for Bridge, since the game is (unfortunately) primarily played only by older folks who are more at-risk.
- snarf21 5y agoWell, you can exchange in non-legal ways even in person. A simple wink pattern could convey lots of information about your hand shape or desire for game/slam. Even with the players unable to see each other visually using cross blinders, there are timing tells or hand placement tells that you can use to indicate some information as above when laying down your bid cards. They already removed talking during bidding because it could be used the same way. If it is possible, someone will try to cheat. The more beneficial it is, the more people will try. For in-person play, there could be a review of played hands by looking for lines or bids that seem "weird" and then going back and looking at the video for discrepancies. If caught, ban them and their partner from competitive play for life. Obviously this is cost prohibitive and could only happen for the highest level championship type events.
- AlbertCory 5y agoOh yeah, I remember all that. My partner had a joke "can I have a review of the bidding, with the original inflections?" There was a regular game in Google Ads. No one was over 60. But I'm sure eventually no one will play anymore.
- handrous 5y agoI played casually for a while, but I'm convinced it's just too broken a game to endure much longer. Besides, my favorite idea from it is secret coded bidding, but the game doesn't really support actual secret codes without falling apart past low-level play (they'd quickly become entirely opaque and extremely specific, making the whole thing kinda pointless), so they're not allowed, and leagues often outlaw most of the interesting things you could do with bidding (heavy jump-bidding bid systems, for instance) in order to keep the game from collapsing and/or to keep the people who want it to run just a certain way without any surprises or hiccups happy. I eagerly await my discovery of a card game that keeps the parts of bridge I want to like, without requiring a ton of extra restrictions that suck the fun (for me) out of it in order to keep the game working properly. It may be that no such game is possible, but I hope it is.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoSame with Euchre. Inflection in calling pass or pick up, even the way you breath, can lead to tipping your partner off at what you have/don’t have.
- bpodgursky 5y agoHere's an example of why it's still hard: you can use timing information to encode data. Pause for 5 seconds: signal your partner should not trump. Pause for 10 seconds: signal your partner should trump. It's almost the same as CPU timing attacks — there's always immense information leaking out if your sole focus is to capture what's going on behind the scenes.