10 ms·
There is endless amounts of lithium deposit everywhere. A lithium deposit is essentially worthless. What matters in lithium industry, is chemical processing. N
by panick21_ 5y ago
There is endless amounts of lithium deposit everywhere. A lithium deposit is essentially worthless.
What matters in lithium industry, is chemical processing. Nobody cares about a lithium mining company. What matters is lithium processing.
Lithium is not like a base metal, its more like a specialty chemical. The output from every mine is unique, there is not overall standard. Each output from each mine has to be qualified with each major battery manufacturer.
Nevada has 100s of billion of dollars worth of lithium by itself probably.
This will almost certainty not be mined. Making money from this kind of rock is difficult in the first place and doing it in a place with little mining industry makes that even worse.
Edit:
If you want insight into lithium industry, I recommend 'Global Lithium Podcast' by a guy that has been in that business for many decades and has worked for all the many of the major producers.
- bkovacev 5y agoWe have lithium and Jadarite[0] reserves in Serbia. Is potentially just trading the ore and/or moving the processing out of Serbia viable? However, with Rio Tinto investing, we're not looking solid environmentally. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jadarite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jadarite
- capableweb 5y agoBut, seemingly, this one is "The richest known hard rock lithium deposit" so it's got to be worth something, at least it's newsworthy I guess. Anyway, the article is not about the operation of mining lithium, how to earn money on lithium or even chemical processing, it's about regulation about mining in Maine, the deposit itself just being the driver of the story. It also goes into describing the supply chain around lithium and some other goodies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- washadjeffmad 5y agoIt doesn't cost much to get a few inches of buzzword copy that makes people ask "why won't they just lift the regulations so we can have the free money?" without really writing anything that leaves readers better and truthfully informed about a topic. We've got good responses by disinterested parties who know a lot about lithium and mining here, and it's the single sided argument funded by unknown sources that is generating the sticky "but what if"s.
- cortesoft 5y agoI did find it interesting that the primary source for this article appears to be the couple who owns the land the deposit is on. They would obviously have an interest in making this deposit seem special, especially since it seems like they want to pressure the state to allow them to mine it.
- bcrosby95 5y agoHow do they define richest? Searching online, there's lots of mines with more tons of ore. This one doesn't come close to being within the top 10.
- capableweb 5y agoSeems to have to do with that it's "hard rock" instead of something else, and the purity? Not sure, not a chemist/geologist, but here is what they say in the article about it: > The Freemans and researchers at Plumbago North knew the crystals they found were extraordinary as soon as they uncovered them. To determine the concentration of lithium, they sent bulk samples for analysis at labs in Australia and Germany. > The results, said Simmons, were astonishing. The deposit showed an average lithium oxide content of 4.68% by weight. That’s three times the average concentration of the world’s top 10 hard rock lithium mines. By comparison, the world’s second-richest hard rock lithium deposit, the Bernic Lake mine in Manitoba, has a lithium oxide content of 2.76% by weight and contains roughly eight million tons of ore.
- panick21_ 5y agoThis is actually quite significant, I must have missed that.
- sanxiyn 5y ago"Rich" means high concentration of lithium in ore. This deposit does seem to be top 1 in that measure, 4.68%. For comparison, Greenbushes, THE lithium mine in West Australia, is 1.60%. Note that Greenbushes is actually famous for its high concentration. More typical is Mt Cattlin at 0.50%. This deposit is 3x richer than Greenbushes and 9x richer than Mt Cattlin, which is in fact astonishing as the article says.
- traveler01 5y agoWe have a deposit here in Portugal too. Didn't know Lithium production had all those complications. But wouldn't mine it and move it away to processing be an alternative? I don't know, the US has a lot territory and probably lithium, wouldn't mine it and move it be profitable?
- goblinux 5y agoLithium mining isn't like gold/iron/other metal mining. It's more like salt harvesting. So trucking away loads of dirt/salt/rock/ore to a processing plant isn't viable. You have to process it on site which means huge ponds for evaporation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8-YDMzg2bY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8-YDMzg2bY Interesting video on the Lithium extraction
- panick21_ 5y agoThis is not correct. Lithium Spodumene Ore is often transported from West Australia to China for processing.
- ineedasername 5y agoDo processing facilities like this exist closer to Maine than China? If not, a new one would need to be built, so I think the GP is still generally correct about the local impacts.
- rmm 5y agoTianqi built a converter in Kwinana for hydroxide (I was part of the build). But yeah you are correct for all the other small mines all sell to converters in China often through offtake agreements.
- panick21_ 5y agoI knew there were projects going on didn't know any of them were done yet.
- thrower123 5y agoThat area of Maine has absolutely no infrastructure to be able to do anything with such a deposit, and there's no way that the sclerotic government and regulatory agencies would allow you to build such infrastructure to process it, or even transport it elsewhere to where it could be processed.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIt's basically on US2. That's not very rural as far as mines, logging and other resource extraction goes. You don't really need "infrastructure" to build a resource processing facility since everything is global these days anyway. You need a road that can handle truck traffic. The days of a paper mill having parts made by the toolmaker across town are long gone. Your specialty stuff will all show up in trucks that say Fedex or XPO on the side and the special people who help you get it running will all show up in cars with the little Enterprise sticker on them.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoNo one is going to ship lithium ores overseas or down highways to a processing plant, regardless of what the property owner imagines. That burns a lot of diesel and costs a lot of money to move a product that’s over 90% unwanted dirt. The economics aren’t there. Purification on site is much more efficient. If they can’t purify it in Maine they’ll mine it somewhere else.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThey're gonna ship it across the street for processing and then that stuff is what gets trucked out of state.
- thrower123 5y agoRoute 2 out through Bethel there isn't much of a road. It's a winding two-lane stretch of blacktop that isn't as well maintained as it used to be now that all the mills in Berlin are gone.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> What matters in lithium industry, is chemical processing. Nobody cares about a lithium mining company. What matters is lithium processing I've heard a lot about the difficulty in processing lithium into "battery grade" metal. Is there merit to this claim? If so, what's so hard about it?
- panick21_ 5y agoI'm not a chemist so I can't tell you what is so hard about it. I can only say that there are not very many companies that can do it and even those companies seem to struggle a fair bit bringing new supply to market. Many startup have for long time tried all kinds of ways of bringing new supply to market, and many have seen huge delay. Lithium was (and still is) a tiny industry and these process are pretty immature. Most lithium never needed to be as high grade as is required now. Every company seems to have a lot of its own secret sauce. The people that are really knowledge about the subject are very thinly distributed and given the growth of the industry I would assume there are very few veterans. You can just go out get a bunch of veterans that have done it many times before, buy some standard equipment and get going. Somebody in the comments here was involved in setting up such a project, so that person have some more insight.
- Lvl999Noob 5y agoNot an expert, or even an enthusiast tbh, but if I were to guess, I would say its because Lithium is way too reactive. It is basically impossible to find elemental Li and the compounds Li forms are difficult to break (I think). So unless the deposit is of some particularly easily collected and concentrated (removing the dirt and stuff, idk the technical term) or very easily broken, it probably won't be worth it to even try to get raw Li from the ore.
- Lev1a 5y agoFrom a quick search on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium#Environmental_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium#Environmental_issues : > Environmental issues > The manufacturing processes of lithium, including the solvent and mining waste, presents significant environmental and health hazards.[134][135][136] Lithium extraction can be fatal to aquatic life due to water pollution.[137] It is known to cause surface water contamination, drinking water contamination, respiratory problems, ecosystem degradation and landscape damage.[134] It also leads to unsustainable water consumption in arid regions (1.9 million liters per ton of lithium).[134] Massive byproduct generation of lithium extraction also presents unsolved problems, such as large amounts of magnesium and lime waste.[138] > In the United States, there is active competition between environmentally catastrophic open-pit mining, mountaintop removal mining and less damaging brine extraction mining in an effort to drastically expand domestic lithium mining capacity.[139] Environmental concerns include wildlife habitat degradation, potable water pollution including arsenic and antimony contamination, unsustainable water table reduction, and massive mining waste, including radioactive uranium byproduct and sulfuric acid discharge. Also from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium#Precautions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium#Precautions : > Lithium metal is corrosive and requires special handling to avoid skin contact. Breathing lithium dust or lithium compounds (which are often alkaline) initially irritate the nose and throat, while higher exposure can cause a buildup of fluid in the lungs, leading to pulmonary edema. The metal itself is a handling hazard because contact with moisture produces the caustic lithium hydroxide. Lithium is safely stored in non-reactive compounds such as naphtha.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoTesla’s suppliers are Ganfeng Lithium, China, mined in China and Australia. Kidman Resources, Australia, same, processed in China. Pure Energy Minerals, Canada, uses Chinese processing as of 2018. Your Tesla’s lithium was likely mined in Australia, tanker shipped to China, it leaves China as lithium hydroxide and may be final assembled into batteries in USA or Canada. Like almost all materials for “green” products, lithium, composites, aluminum, microchips, the western world has boxed themselves out of making these things. So China does it where they set their own carbon standards, and can manipulate value, pay, trade, subsidies. There is a ton more to the conversation when someone says “we just need stricter cap and trade” because China knows the grip over everyone else they have. I rarely see people who know how things are made make that argument with any practical effectiveness, unless it ends with “we go to war”. EDIT: So, to the topic, does it make sense to mine in Maine and ship to China for processing? Is this new reserve that good?
- panick21_ 5y agoIn fact most of the hydroxide goes threw Korea or Japan (sometimes even both I think). There the hydroxide is made into cathode materials. This cathode materials are then shipped to Nevada, where Panasonic creates cells, hands them to Tesla to put into packs. Packs get put into cars. Tesla always had the vision of doing cathode processing in house, but I think in Nevada they never went that far (unless this has changed). In Austin Tesla is planning a plant to transform Spodumene ore into hydroxide. This ore would come from North Carolina. However this mine project seem to be delayed so for quite a while they will likely continue to buy hydroxide (they have to buy anyway but buy less at least). They are also planning, and are already building a cathode materials plant. There they would bring together nickel, lithium hydroxide and co to make a cathode materials. They are also already building a cell plant where they would use that material to make cathode and cells. They are also attempting to mine their own lithium in Nevada, but that will take a quite a few years to come online (if ever). There are quite a few companies trying to get into all of these markets in the US, but compared to China its still a small amount and they are way behind
- SV_BubbleTime 5y ago
- twobitshifter 5y ago1. Canada has a huge mining Industry and that’s right next door to Maine. 2. It’s possible to bring in multinational consultant teams specialized in mining industries. A location doesn’t have a mining industry until suddenly a big deposit is discovered and they do.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThe price of Lithium seems to be extremely volatile. Currently it seems to be quite valuable. Probably highly dependent on how electric cars and general batteries are faring.