7 ms·
It's not really surprising. The use of lithium batteries to replace fossil fuels is really just shifting where and what environmental impact is produced. It's n
by giantg2 5y ago
It's not really surprising. The use of lithium batteries to replace fossil fuels is really just shifting where and what environmental impact is produced. It's not as clean as they claim to be. It's like coal plants with scrubbers saying they are clean. They are only relatively clean, just like lithium is only relatively clean.
At least the lithium deposit near the Salton Sea is already in an area that's an ecological disaster. It makes sense that Maine would want to protect their natural resources.
- goohle 5y agoLithium hard rock mining produces about 15 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of Lithium, but Lithium geothermal mining generates energy instead: https://cornishlithium.com/projects/lithium-in-geothermal-waters/geocubed/ https://cornishlithium.com/projects/lithium-in-geothermal-wa...
- sabertoothed 5y agoUnlike coal, lithium does not get burned or used up. At least in principle, it can be recycled.
- hammock 5y ago>it can be recycled Yet here we are talking about a lithium mine, which is not clean.
- gameswithgo 5y agoCan you go into detail as to how specifically it is not clean, and how it compares to the resource extraction of other things like steel, aluminum, oil, etc.
- wil421 5y agoSo you’re saying we should continue to burn fossil fuels in our cars because lithium mining is dirty?
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoIt's okay to point out problems with a path to the future. It's also okay to still take that path even though it's not perfect. Eyes wide open. Lesser of two evils.
- jcims 5y agoI'd promote it to essential. The problem is that in open conversation like this a simple statement like 'Yet here we are talking about a lithium mine, which is not clean' is insufficiently contextualized to know where the commenter is coming from. Are they just trying to be transparent and realistic? Are they someone that has no dynamic range in their understanding of ecological harm? Are they long in petroleum and want to throw interference up at any point where electrification of transport comes up? Are they just being a contrarian troll?
- hammock 5y agoI'm saying "lithium recycling" isn't yet such a benefit that we don't need to keep mining additional lithium. Not to suggest OP was doing this, but it seems a bit weird to start your mouth watering at the notion of "I can't wait to strip 11 million tons of rock out of the side of this mountain, melt it down and refine it, so that we can start being clean with it by recycling."
- _coveredInBees 5y agoA big factor there is that demand for Lithium is growing drastically and we don't really have that amount of Lithium pre-mined and ready to be recycled in the first place.
- supperburg 5y agoYes. The narrative that electrification just shifts around the pollution is so tired and untrue. The end to end pipeline of EVs is much more efficient than that of gas cars, so even if we start synthesizing fuels that are carbon neutral gas cars will lose. The only reason gas cars could ever exist is because of cheap and dirty fuel. The only car that makes sense in a sustainable system is an EV maybe with synthesized and carbon neutral hydrocarbon range extension for emergencies.
- wibagusto 5y agoI don’t think the point of contention is whether it’s recyclable. Primary issue is: what is the local environmental impact of MINING lithium? For folks who don’t live in Maine it’s a no-brainer: sure, go for it! Bring the USA more domestically produced lithium. But… mining fucks up entire ecosystems and pollutes water etc… and even if companies can “promise” the operation will be clean, come to implementation they likely walk back on that and the damage is done.
- supperburg 5y agoI don’t suppose there’s a mining expert who could weigh in?
- wibagusto 5y agoFor what it’s worth you don’t need a mining expert to know that establishing a large scale mining operation will fuck up the local region somewhat. At the very least, all the demolition and vehicles, fuel, explosives, chemicals. Shits going to leak into the rivers one way or the other. In addition, they would likely use up a ton of local water supply. It’s a no-brainer. Maine is not in the middle of some desert.
- hutzlibu 5y agoFor what's it worth, I live in a area that has done extensive mining for over 1000 years with no big natural disaster caused by it. Today it is only operational by small scale in comparison, (and it never experienced the big chemical industious mining), but you absolutely can mine the earth without creating havoc. It is just a lot more expensive then. Which is why most mining is done in remote, or poor areas, with laughable regulations, where no one dares complain for the jobs.
- SEJeff 5y agoLithium Ion batteries can mostly be recycled: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/04/10/tesla-jb-straubel-redwood-materials-battery-recycling.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/04/10/tesla-jb-straubel-redwood-ma...
- Pxtl 5y agoIf people want truly green infrastructure, the only practical options are nuclear power and densification -basically turn as many cities as possible into Paris. LRTs don't need batteries because they're hooked into the grid with catenary lines, subways have 3rd rails, bikes run on human, and e-bikes use only tiny batteries. And while nuclear power isn't ideal, it's the only tech that has fully decarbonized power grids at State level. Otherwise we need battery power on an utterly insane level.
- crowbahr 5y agoInterestingly if we have significant excess production from intermittent sources we can reduce our battery needs. Last I read the best cost/benefit ratio was something like 7x the energy production. That said nuclear base load makes a _lot_ more sense.
- Pxtl 5y agoI point to nuclear power simply because it's already proven to work. Overbuilt wind/solar should work in theory, but primarily nuclear-powered grids exist right now.
- mrep 5y agoWhere did you read that? Methane which already powers 40% of the US electrical grid can be created and then turned back in electricity in a Electricity→Gas→Electricity process with a round trip efficiency of 30–38% [0]. There is no way you'd need 7x production when you can use surpluses to make methane or hydrogen. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-to-gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-to-gas
- crowbahr 5y agoThe goal was to have a long term hydrogen, mid/peaker battery setup with the minimum cost while providing for the entire grid. Unfortunately I didn't take notes as to what the source was and I read this about a year ago. Google has been entirely useless as I've tried to dig it back up.
- 5y ago
- wibagusto 5y agoLet’s hope it stays that way. But $1.5B is not a tiny sum and I’m willing to bet the government will bend over backwards to bring a bunch of “jobs” to the area at the expense of all environmental concerns.
- tata71 5y agoIn Maine? No shot.
- afarrell 5y ago> at the expense of all environmental concerns Greedy lobbyists in the state capital would object to this. Ecotourism is seen by voters as one of Maine’s largest industries. Much of its real estate industry and its most well-known brand (LL Bean) relies on it.
- wibagusto 5y agoThat’s good news!
- InitialLastName 5y agoEven its second most well known brand (Stephen King) relies on it indirectly.
- panick21_ 5y agoYou have a delusional believe in the power of lobbying. Establishing a mine in the US is incredibly hard. Even in places with existing mining, establishing a new mine is a major undertaking. Mines even in mining friendly places is very, very hard. Doing it mining unfriendly places where you have real popular opposition is bordering on impossible.
- torpfactory 5y agoThe issue is that while mines produce relatively localized environmental damage, climate change will produce globalized damage by ecosystem collapse and sea level rise. The sum total of this damage will be far greater than the marginal increase in mining required for battery production. Shifting, for sure, but the scale of destruction is the real question.
- dbatten 5y agoI'm not even convinced that there will be a "marginal increase in mining required for battery production," nor that there will be an associated increase in localized environmental damage. Lithium mines produce localized environmental damage, _but so does fossil fuel extraction_. Think about environmental damage from mountaintop removal coal mining, fracking, offshore oil spills, etc. With fossil fuels, you get localized environmental damage, _plus_ climate change. With lithium, you get localized environmental damage, but you hopefully support a transition to renewables.
- giantg2 5y agoDoes Maine allow for those other actions, like strip mining coal?
- thrower123 5y agoNo, not at all. In the past year, they attempted to shut down one of last remaining paper mills that is keeping the beleaguered forestry industry alive by ordering the removal of a dam that alteady had had a fish ladder installed at great cost, because it might possibly still impact the spawning of a miniscule subpopulation of salmon. There's been enormous conflict about simply building a high voltage transmission line across the boondocks of the western mountains to bring cheap green power down from the Quebec Hydro dams.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> There's been enormous conflict about simply building a high voltage transmission line There might be less conflict if that line wasn't solely for the benefit of Massachusetts.
- hurgs 5y agoIt's a very misleading statement to bluntly compare a consumable Ressource with a recycle metal. While it is known that lithium itself has environmental issues the potential reuse and benefit of pulling it out of the earth to make batteries will have a very long and positive outcome for us. And to a certain degree the initial disruption might be totally worth it in the long run in comparison to stuff we just burn away.
- gameswithgo 5y agoSuppose 150k mile car that averages 30mpg. That is 5,000 gallons of fuel weighing 30,000 pounds. The amount of crude to make that oil varies, so actual oil you have to extract and ship and refine will be a bit more than that, and the refinement process is also dirty. So compare that 30,000 lbs of oil to the amount of lithium in a Tesla battery pack, which is about 138lbs. 138lbs < 30,000lbs Then figure in that those 30,000lbs of oil all go into the air producing not only c02 which is changing our climate, but particulates which are bad for our health and cognitive function, vs the lithium in a battery pack which can be recycled and/or re-used This seemm like a large net win to me. All of that said, yes, all of the resource extraction industry, from the iron and aluminum to the oil and lithium, has a bad history of responsible stewardship of the lands they exploit, and I support forcing them to do a better job.
- elif 5y agoAgree. The comparison drawn by the original commenter is completely devoid of scale and avoids the existential nature of global climate change.
- rlpb 5y ago> So compare that 30,000 lbs of oil to the amount of lithium in a Tesla battery pack, which is about 138lbs. 138lbs < 30,000lbs I think you need to account for the amount of material that was mined to get to that 138lb battery. My understanding is that it's orders of magnitudes more than what gets removed/disrupted for oil. I don't know the figure (and I welcome someone telling me) but I think it could well be in excess of 30,000lbs of raw material mined. There's also battery recycling to consider. I don't know which way the result swings; I'm just saying that it's much more complicated to figure out, and far less clear cut, than you suggest.
- panick21_ 5y agoThat is true. However much of that stuff can basically be piled and is not really damaging to the environment. Lithium is usually only about <5% of any given rock. That is far better then blowing tons of things into the air. Its just a stack of crushed rocks.
- KarlKemp 5y agoYes, neither option may be perfect. But just claiming that, therefore, they are equally bad is philistine. It's a full embrace of a talking point even ExxonMobile has retired.
- epistasis 5y agoI wish that the damage of lithium mining would be specified and put into specific terms about what the damage is and what's it's doing. For example, fracking in California results in 26 acres of toxic storage pools that are leaking and contaminating ground water with specific toxic chemicals: https://grist.org/accountability/fracking-waste-california-aqueduct-section-29-facility/ https://grist.org/accountability/fracking-waste-california-a... However, every single story about the toxicity of battery production remains vague and I haven't been able to find any that specify what the damage is. I have found that indigenous people are having their land used without much permission or process, but the damage has never been specified. Does anybody have some specifics about what's going on? Presumably there must be an environmental cost but it's really unclear what it is, or how it compares to the regular destruction that we embrace from fossil fuels.