6 ms·
Toki Pona: A Language with a Hundred Words (2015)
- flerovium 5y agoNote: it's a constructed language. You can halfway through the article without realizing this.
- leke 5y agoI found the ambiguity in toki pona too much a hurdle when I was trying to use it some years ago. The best minimalist conlang I ever found was Angos https://qdoc.tips/angos-grammar-pdf-free.html https://qdoc.tips/angos-grammar-pdf-free.html https://www.reddit.com/r/angos/ https://www.reddit.com/r/angos/ I couldn't really get into it though. Nowadays, it's all about ido!
- Vanderson 5y agoI made a game based on the idea of Toki Pona using a sub-set of English. Instead of learning a new language (I tried to learn Toki Pona) I used Toki Pona as a template for basic English, Toki English, a subset of English. The benefits of Toki English are this: * English speakers already know all the meanings of all the words, and can use it right now. * Non-English speakers learn BOTH some English _and_ a basic structure to speak to anyone else that learns Toki English and English. * It's actually hilarious to try and speak with it. The game I made (very rough) is like a form of charades, where you have 2 teams. One person gets a phrase/idea/object that they must convey to their team using only Toki English. The props are simple, a printed sheet of paper with all the Toki English words. [edit for clarity]
- coolgeek 5y agoI haven't even looked at your game. And I'm not particularly interested in conlangs. But I want to say thanks for making a game that people might learn something from, rather than the mindless crap that the industry mostly produces.
- Vanderson 5y agoThere's nothing to look at for the game. It's just a spreadsheet where I picked the English words from the Toki-Pona lexicon, and printed them out on paper. :)
- jose-cl 5y agoprev discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22689959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22689959
- dang 5y agoThanks! Expanded list: Toki Pona - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23402374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23402374 - June 2020 (38 comments) Ilo sitelen, a handmade computer for Toki Pona - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22788011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22788011 - April 2020 (89 comments) Toki Pona: A Language with a Hundred Words (2015) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22689959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22689959 - March 2020 (127 comments) Toki Pona (a minimal language) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16018991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16018991 - Dec 2017 (1 comment) How to Say (Almost) Everything in a Hundred-Word Language (2015) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14191186 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14191186 - April 2017 (102 comments) Toki Pona: A created language that has only 100 words - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11153406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11153406 - Feb 2016 (88 comments) Toki Pona: a human language with 120 words - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9914534 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9914534 - July 2015 (110 comments) Creating your own language. For example, Toki Pona has just 120 words. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=54392 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=54392 - Sept 2007 (1 comment)
- b0rsuk 5y agoWhat you just did sounds like an interesting "Show HN" project. Automate the thing, so that a HN bot posts a comment with previous talk about the topic.
- anitil 5y agoFor those interested, 'The Allusionist' had an episode where they learnt Toki Pona with a friend. I'm no longer subscribed, but I remember this episode fondly. https://www.theallusionist.org/allusionist/tokipona https://www.theallusionist.org/allusionist/tokipona
- nxpnsv 5y agoI learnt this with a friend once, it was a nice experience. Forgotten pretty much all of it now though :D
- galkk 5y agoThe article casually mentions Koko, and it's a bit sad that the story of Koko's "language" is still alive... I can not remember book exceprt, but recently there was a great video about Koko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7wFotDKEF4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7wFotDKEF4
- rich_sasha 5y agoFor those interested enough to read but not to watch: what is wrong with Koko's language? I vaguely remember (and the article mentions) it was a primate who learned sign language, but your comment suggests the story is more complex?
- overboard2 5y agoTLDR: There's no evidence she was doing anything but brute forcing word combinations in order to get rewards.
- rspk 5y agoIf anyone is interested in learning about conlangs, jan Misali has an interesting playlist[0] with reviews on various contructed languages including Toki Pona. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLn6LC1RpAo&list=PLuYLhuXt4HrQqnfSceITmv6T_drx1hN84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLn6LC1RpAo&list=PLuYLhuXt4H...
- an_ko 5y agoHe also has a whole playlist with lectures specifically about Toki Pona: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjOmpMyMxd8T9lZjF36c4mn4YgwZ4ToT6 https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjOmpMyMxd8T9lZjF36c4mn4Y... Great channel; I second the recommendation.
- thewakalix 5y agoNote: he is a fraud, albeit a cute one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3aUx7ajQrys https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3aUx7ajQrys
- b0rsuk 5y agoThere should be a singer which sings in Toki Pona. It's pretty common for singers to invent their own languages, for example Enya or Elisabeth Fraser(Cocteau Twins). In modern (pop) music, lyrics are unimportant and often unintelligible. No one would be bothered, the language sounds pretty* and fans would be delighted to have a secret language. * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdRBD7dfdlU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdRBD7dfdlU
- dogsandcats 5y agoToki Pona is great as an introduction into language learning. As many English speaking people seem to be functionally monolingual they could greatly benefit from learning it. It would probably be the human language equivalent of a pure Java programmer spending a weekend hacking Lisp in broadening your horizon. Even if you don't end up using Toki Pona, you will still benefit greatly from it. Due to its small size you will be able to acquire a certain "mastery" over it in just a few days which can be greatly motivating for tackling bigger languages.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoYou can learn 100 words from any natural language.
- asoneth 5y agoTrue, but there will be very few documents you can read or conversations you can participate in with only a few hundred words in a natural language. The steep learning curve of most natural languages means it takes months before I can read or say anything nontrivial.
- IshKebab 5y agoI don't see why the small vocabulary would help learn it, if more complex concepts are built from that small vocabulary. English only has 26 letters! It must be really easy!! And they're fooling themselves if they think being able to express lots of concepts with only 123 words means it's easy to communicate by only learning 123 things. No. There are still a gazillion concepts. If you want to communicate "car" to someone you still have to learn that "space for movement" means car... Or is it a bus? Ok "car" is "small-moveable-space-on-four-wheels". Hmm, bit verbose. We'll just add one more word...
- fjfaase 5y agoI do not fully agree with you. Although it is a small language, it has language constructs that are foreign to English (and some of which I do not know of being used in any natural language, although I expect that there is an obscure language that does have them, as it is my experience that many 'wierd' language constructs found in constructed languages appear in natural languages). Just having fewer words, does not make a language simpler to use. It simply means that a lot of vocabular is created by combining words. This is also seen in a language like Chinese, where more complex concepts are made by combining two or more characters into a new concept. Over time, some of these sequences are used for other things than orginal intended to the extend that native speakers no longer are aware of the origin. You also see this in English and other natural languages. English is not my native tongue and besides my native tongue, Dutch, I also understand some German, a little French, and a very little Chinese (Mandrin). I made some attempt to learn Toki Pona (about 10 ago). Although, I am not particular good at learning languages, I am more of a visual thinker, I have always had an interest in languages and have a collection of foreign language books and linguistics, see https://www.iwriteiam.nl/BookShelves.html#1.1 https://www.iwriteiam.nl/BookShelves.html#1.1
- namenotrequired 5y agoWhat would a shopping list in Toki Pona look like?
- asoneth 5y agolipu esun mi: (shopping list, literally: my buying document) 1 kili palisa jelo mute (bananas, lit: many yellow stick-fruits) 2 kala pi loje walo (salmon, lit: red-white fish) 3 moku kasi laso supa (salad greens, lit: flat green plants for eating) 4 telo walo (milk, lit: white drink) 5 kili kiwen lili mute (nuts, lit: many small hard fleshy-plant-food) 6 pan supa sike (pita, lit: flat, round grain-product) It's worth noting that the translations are ambiguous and personal; if I gave this list to a stranger I might end up with pizza crust instead of pita, or nut milk instead of cow milk. If I wanted to explicitly specify nut milk I'd have to say something like "telo walo pi kili kiwen lili" (lit: white drink of small hard fleshy-plant-food). Having said that, even in English people generally wouldn't go into that level of detail on a personal shopping list. When my partner writes "milk" on the shopping list I know they actually mean a "half-gallon of whole milk" based on prior experience.
- brandonhorst 5y agoIt would work fine as long as everyone consuming the shopping list has a reasonable idea what normal things your shopping lists. Things like "kili sike loje" (red round fruit) are ambiguous but are no doubt close enough to jog your memory enough to work. The toughest part that comes to mind would be particular spices. You would probably need to start borrowing words to distinguish between things like thyme and rosemary ("namako Tin", "namako Loseli")
- dsr_ 5y agoOne key characteristic of natural languages is that when they don't work, people invent and share new words. kili sike loje isn't enough to distinguish cherries from cherry tomatoes, red grapes, cranberries, red currants, red plums or red apples -- every one of which is a perfectly reasonable thing for me to put on a shopping list. And so you'll note that we have the words tomato, grape, cranberry, currant, plum and apple. Now, French has a language academy to decree what is proper, and English -- "We don't just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary." -- James Davis Nicoll A language which isn't useful will either change or be abandoned. Natural languages almost always change.
- rich_sasha 5y agoInteresting that the creators of Esperanto and Toki Pona are both Polish. I wonder if there is something in Polish culture / "mindsphere" that encourages language creation. Ironically, Polish, by comparison to some other European languages of comparably-sized nations, is very uniform and devoid of dialects / regional accents. There are a small few regions that speak a proper dialect (not mutually understandable with regular Polish speakers), but otherwise, with minor exceptions, you cannot tell at all where in Poland someone is from based on how they talk. In the UK, by contrast, this is still a big thing. I believe German dialects are very diverse, heck, Dutch ones can pinpoint people to a village sometimes. French had very diverse language base before Napoleon. Spain still has regional languages that are very much alive and in use, Italian accents (dialects?) are too quite distinct. Maybe Poland is compensating for this here, by inventing whole new languages? EDIT my bad, the article mentions a Pole, Marta Krzeminska, but she is not the language's creator. It was a Canadian who created it. Oh well.
- prionassembly 5y agoPolish grammar is very complex.
- int_19h 5y agoTo be fair, this goes for all Slavic languages.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> but otherwise, with minor exceptions, you cannot tell at all where in Poland someone is from based on how they talk. Not sure if that's what you had in mind by "minor exceptions", but there are certain shibboleths that can give away the area of Poland you're from (or at least causally associated with). For example, take the phrase "to go outside". In most of the country, it's "iść na dwór" (lit. "to go to court/manor"), but in the Lesser Poland voivodeship, especially around its capital city Kraków, we use "iść na pole" (lit. "to go to field") instead. Additionally, a rough determination of origin can be gleaned from various verbs and nouns. Poland was partitioned[0] for over a hundred years by Austria, Prussia and Russia, with each of the historical empires performing their own attempt at assimilating the populations in their partition. In the process, Polish spoken in those partitions borrowed many of the words from their respective occupants' languages. As a result, the way you refer to many everyday things (like whether you call a garden hose "szlauch" or "wąż ogrodowy") can give away which of the three ex-partitions you're from. -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland
- dvh 5y agoThe only authoritative source is paid book. Closed, commercial languages like Borland's Delphi or Toki Pona have no future. Don't waste your time.
- williamtwild 5y agoThis is about a language like English or Frennch not a computer programming language. Did you even look at the link at all?
- dvh 5y agoI know what toki pona is. Just like Delphi, you find little roadblocks. License problem here, can't legally give it to friend, can't put it on your website. These are all completely artificial problems that simply don't exist in free languages. That's why Delphi failed despite being superior at the time and that's why toki pona will fail. You are knee deep in a cow piss on a remote farm in Nebraska, offline and some library has some version issue with your proprietary licensed language. A trivial solution if it was free language, but now it requires 300 miles trip. You are in Nagorno Karabakh and just spoke to some random stranger about this new funny speak-language but you cannot give him PDF because it's not free. These issues stings very deep because how artificial and easily solvable would they be. Some things must be free otherwise they cannot be used to their full potential. So you stand there, in Nebraska or Nagorno Karabakh and swear - Never again will I use proprietary language. I have nothing agains proprietary software or linguistic books but the language itself must be free.
- demetrius 5y ago> offline and some library has some version issue with your proprietary licensed language How is this different from any proprietary book about a freely-licensed language? If you're in a remote farm in Nebraska and you only have a copyrighted Esperanto textbook, you can't share it, even though Zamenhof's materials might be public domain. I fail to see any problem with toki pona here. Something similar can be argued about Delphi / Object Pascal. Borland's compiler is non-free, but the language can be used with FreePascal. I'm happily using FreePascal on my personal projects and haven't touched Delphi in more than a decade; it's a nice language and there's nothing wrong with it. Sharing FreePascal is totally OK, just like sharing freely-licensed materials about toki pona.
- fhars 5y agoThe few Toki Pona speakers I know have this game where they make an appointment to meet for some purpose all in Toki Pona, and then when they next meet they compare where they were (and for what purpose) at the time they thought the appointment was at... The limited vocabulary makes precision hard, even if you are not on Tanagra.
- ArchieMaclean 5y agoRelated to [1] - since Toki Pona has such a limited set of sounds, it seems like it would be a great fit for stenography... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29035644 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29035644
- LVDOVICVS 5y agoThere are twenty three keys on a steno machine. With only a hundred-word language the current machine would certainly work. But with so few words even the machine could be simplified.
- garmaine 5y agoSimilar to Toki Pona but a bit more expressive is Mini: https://minilanguage.com/ https://minilanguage.com/
- pspeter3 5y agoThis is awesome, thanks for the link!
- naltun 5y agoLove Toki Pona.
- pavlov 5y agoThis bit in the introduction has an interesting blind spot: In Icelandic, a compass is a direction-shower, and a microscope a small-watcher. The author didn’t have to reach for Icelandic since “microscope” is already from Greek with the same construction small/watching.
- tablespoon 5y ago> The author didn’t have to reach for Icelandic since “microscope” is already from Greek with the same construction small/watching. Is it really from Greek, through? My understanding is that it was coined in some non-Greek language from Greek roots, which isn't quite the same thing. Google translate gives "smásjá" as Icelandic for microscope, which looks like it might be a compound using the languages "native" vocabulary ("smá sjá" translates as "little see").
- filmor 5y agoAccording to Wikipedia, the name Microscope was derived from the earlier "Telescope", which in turn was coined shortly after the object was invented: > Galileo's instrument was the first to be given the name "telescope". The name was invented by the Greek poet/theologian Giovanni Demisiani at a banquet held on April 14, 1611 by Prince Federico Cesi to make Galileo Galilei a member of the Accademia dei Lincei. The word was created from the Greek tele = 'far' and skopein = 'to look or see'; teleskopos = 'far-seeing'. The primary source for this is "Rosen, Edward, The Naming of the Telescope (1947)".