3 ms·
I am thrilled to learn that the title of the book is about the absolute disaster inherent in typical geo-engineering ideas. But nobody talks about how, as the
by ncmncm 5y ago
I am thrilled to learn that the title of the book is about the absolute disaster inherent in typical geo-engineering ideas.
But nobody talks about how, as the oceans acidify, the basis for the whole, worldwide ocean ecosystem is teetering at the edge of collapse, and that, what, two billion? people today depend on that ocean ecosystem for their protein. (Calories are cheap. Protein is dear.) Wars will happen over access to the scraps.
Meanwhile, as extremely densely populated parts of the planet become uninhabitable -- first, the crops will fail -- the people who live there will not sit down and die. They will move, in their millions. (It is already happening, across and around the Mediterranean.) The places they will try to go are already populated, and crops there will be in trouble, too. There is a huge amount of barely populated northern land, in Asia and North America: Russia and Canada, perhaps about to become usably arable. But the refugees will not be going there, and will not be equipped to make the places livable. They will head for civilization, in places that do not want them.
Political pressure to try to keep them out will put right-wing extremists in power, whose solutions will resemble what were called "final". Once in power, they will start wars, as they do. Will those rapidly become nuclear wars?
Any ideas about how to prevent global collapse long before actual climate disaster takes hold would be welcome.
Anyway, if civilization collapses, fossil fuel production and, thus, consumption, will plummet, and atmospheric CO2 concentration might start down, provided we have not got a positive-feedback cycle already locked in, as the tundra melts and decays.
- krageon 5y ago> Will those rapidly become nuclear wars? No, because you are describing folks in shitty parts of the world. They will die just fine in regular wars and just because they aren't nuclear or the world will not end because we had them doesn't make it any less tragic. > Any ideas about how to prevent global collapse long before actual climate disaster takes hold would be welcome. Raise your children better than you were, because it won't be you dealing with the problems.
- Tycho 5y agoWhy would colder lands become arable at a slower pace than warmer lands becoming infertile?
- ioseph 5y agoTopsoil and rainfall doesn't magically appear when a tundra thaws
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is one thing to be technically arable, and wholly another to have infrastructure in place to take advantage of it. But there is also no reason for the rates to match. It might even happen faster, but that will not be useful until much later.
- b112 5y agoWhile not agreeing or disagreeing with your post, this part warranted I reply: There is a huge amount of barely populated northern land, in Asia and North America: Russia and Canada, perhaps about to become usably arable. This isn't really so for most, if not all crops. The problem isn't the cold, it is growing season length, and sunlight, and shade. I'm in southern Quebec, 300km from New York state. Some years, certain crops fail to reach maturity, as the growing season is shortened by too much rain / cloud cover. EG, old human editable yellow corn has a longer growing season than newer 2-colour/"peaches-n-cream" varieties, and sometimes never matures. And in the spring/fall, the sun, even where I live, does not get far about the horizon, even at peak. Many crops also cannot handle 24 hours of sun! Plants literally need rest cycles too. So it is not only cold which restricts crop growth, but the length of sun per day. Peat moss, and other such plants, do not need to produce large fruits or nuts to survive. And of course, our crops are picked for making the largest fruit/nuts, so require more time to be usable. Stepping back from this issue, one thing of note. Massive amounts of cropland is not used in southern Quebec, and other regions of Canada. Sometimes, it is not profitable to farm, and you can find lots of land sitting fallow. Canada could easily double or even triple its crop output if food was more expensive. I don't know how this applies to the rest of the world, but I do know that the EU does pay some farmers not to farm. Outside of the economic realities, there is the fact that sometimes more tha 50% of Canada's wheat crop rots in silos. This may seem horrifying, but is logical and sensible. Growing crops is not under our full control. Pests, drought, too much / not enough sun, means that there are bumper, and poor crop years. You always want enough, or in the bad years people could starve. Which leads to why the EU pays people not to farm, yet keep farmland. If conditions change, say some regions are at war, or have economic breakdowns, this fallow land comes into use, else again, we starve. Anyhow, point is, warmer Earth doesn't mean cropland opens up.
- CRConrad 5y ago> The problem isn't the cold, it is growing season length, and sunlight, and shade. > So it is not only cold which restricts crop growth, but the length of sun per day. > Anyhow, point is, warmer Earth doesn't mean cropland opens up. Oh, surely it will help to at least some extent? Wheat, and even more so barley and rye, have been grown up to at least the middle of Finland and northern(ish) Sweden for hundreds of years. And those were the old not-so-refined varieties.