2 ms·
There's a huge tangle of things with "Apple owns your computer" but I don't think most of it applies to the icloud question. If you wanted to store photos in
by aidenn0 5y ago
There's a huge tangle of things with "Apple owns your computer" but I don't think most of it applies to the icloud question.
If you wanted to store photos in icloud on a Windows machine, you'd be using the Apple icloud client. Apple has at least some control over what software they write and ship does[1]. They can break 3rd party clients almost at will, so if they choose to be hostile to 3rd party clients that control is fairly strong.
Arguing over what amount of control Apple should exercise over what software runs on a device purchased by a consumer is mostly orthogonal to arguing over what amount of control Apple should exercise over what software can connect to their servers.
1: On a general purpose machine, debuggers and emulators can influence what software does, obviously, so the control isn't absolute.
- Dylan16807 5y agoWell services generally shouldn't be controlling what software can connect either! The argument over whose computer it is applies pretty similarly. My computer is not part of their infrastructure, and they should only be controlling the software on their infrastructure.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- someguydave 5y agoIt seems to me that Apple does their best to ensure you end up using icloud against your will through a a series of very confusing opt-out prompts and defaults. Maybe it would be nice to have a tool that would allow you to see exactly what data the client side scanner is “allowed” to “see”?
- mro_name 5y ago… or have regulation that enforces such.