3 ms·
You don't present it "to court" because that might be decided by a jury of unsophisticated people. You file an Inter Partes Review, which goes to the Patent Tri
by AlbertCory 5y ago
You don't present it "to court" because that might be decided by a jury of unsophisticated people. You file an Inter Partes Review, which goes to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, and is cheaper (note I didn't say "cheap").
The U.S. doesn't have a "loser pays" model like other countries. You can file for attorney's fees, but the barriers are higher.
- freejazz 5y agoIt's called an invalidity counterclaim.
- AlbertCory 5y ago??? what are you disputing here? IPRs, or defending against an infringement suit, or what?
- burnished 5y agoDoesn't look like a dispute? I think they were trying to supply you with a phrase that slipped your mind.
- AlbertCory 5y agothe question is the antecedent basis of "it"
- freejazz 5y agoYou don't need to get an IPR, you just make an invalidity counterclaim. IPRs may or may not be desirable for a number of reasons.
- AlbertCory 5y agoTIL. We're talking about US law, right? I've never heard the term "invalidity counterclaim" and I was in Google Patent Litigation where suits come in constantly. IPRs were pretty standard. Maybe the lawyers did use it and I just never heard it. If something was going to trial, then "invalidity" was one of the possible defenses, as was "non-infringement." Who are you making this claim TO? The court? The PTO?