4 ms·
Hooray for him. Patent trolls have a business model, which he's disrupted: 1) buy a patent, the broader and better-tested the better 2) start threatening the
by AlbertCory 5y ago
Hooray for him.
Patent trolls have a business model, which he's disrupted:
1) buy a patent, the broader and better-tested the better
2) start threatening the easy marks; the ones who roll over and write you a check right away.
Their trick is to ask for a settlement small enough to say "hey, it'll cost you more than that for attorney's fees!"
3) use that money to threaten the harder targets: the ones who will fight back. Those people get asked for much larger sums.
4) maybe actually go to trial with a very big target, one that'll get dinged for a 9-figure judgment if the troll wins. In the Eastern District of Texas, juries tend to do that.
Researching the validity of a patent does not require $400/hour attorneys. Anyone with a basic knowledge of patent law and computer science can do it. (And no, I'm not advertising for myself. I'm retired.) Do you think those expensive attorneys do it themselves? It is to laugh -- they assign it to a junior who knows technology.
- shmerl 5y agoMore like they have shakedown and protection racket model they call "business". Just highlights how messed up the legal system is, if someone has to do so much work to disrupt racketeers.
- freejazz 5y agoJunior attys at BigLaw firms are billed at the $400/hr rate...
- srcmap 5y agoAnti-Patent troll model: Talk to EFF, start a go-fund-me campaigns, wild up the public opinions,
- Jake232 5y agoFirst year associates at the law firm I use charge over $500/hr. Senior lawyers/partner cost well over $1,200/hour in 2021 at many of the largest / most successful firms now.
- AlbertCory 5y agoOK, you don't need any of those. Certainly you need lawyers to actually write the IPR & conduct it, but nothing starts until someone finds that killer prior art.
- rhino369 5y agoI find the profession prior art search firms; global, CPA, Cardinal, Nordic, etc. are pretty garbage. I always use one for my cases, but I, the attorney actually writing the IPR/invalidity contentions, have generally found the best art. The search firms get hung up on superficial similarities. So I wouldn't prevent your attorneys from doing some digging on their own. But I wholeheartedly agree that you shouldn't start down the IPR road before you find the killer art (for all potential claims). I've seen to many instances of people rushing to file an IPR and then later finding better art.
- musicale 5y agoI wonder how many attorneys have a good understanding of prior art for patents in computing. Judges, juries, and the patent office don't seem to. And as Sparkfun points out, this patent is nonsense and should not have been granted in the first place.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI wrote a post about the search firms, then I saw this, sorry. Yeah, a lot of the firms are garbage, but I remember a couple being pretty decent.
- ridaj 5y agoI feel that's the case in many professions like plumber or car repair that people are reluctant or unable to DYI, whose services aren't going to be needed often, but that are accompanied by acute pain when they're needed. That tends to make people cost insensitive because they need pain relief, they have few points of comparison, and don't anticipate needing the same service again soon. Sorry to say, but I'm not sure the IP law profession is different... I probably have worked with about a dozen attorneys hired by my employer to file patents on my behalf, and there were two lawyers that stood out a lot. They understood the inventions, what we claimed to set them apart from prior art, and produced filings that were relatively brief and to the point. The rest of them didn't really get the stuff, sent us draft filings that made me cringe because they were shallow copy-paste jobs, etc. If you're one of the better lawyers out there, I hope your clients are rewarding you appropriately for it!