11 ms·
I'm not a Constitutional scholar, but I would bet SCOTUS rules this kind of warrant illegal. Google certainly has the resources to take the case that far. AFAI
by AlbertCory 5y ago
I'm not a Constitutional scholar, but I would bet SCOTUS rules this kind of warrant illegal. Google certainly has the resources to take the case that far.
AFAIK a warrant usually is tied to a specific person or a specific crime. In other words, if an explosion killed Harry McHarryface, then it would be constitutional to ask for names of people who searched for Harry.
Or if the fertilizer used in the bomb was shown to have been purchased on March 10, then maybe a search for "fertilizer" in the weeks before March 10 would be allowed.
But not a generic search.
Just my opinion that's not legal advice.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gowld 5y agoYour first paragraph contradicts the next two paragraphs.
- UIUC_06 5y agoWould you care to explain that?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iammisc 5y agoDoes the current administration follow SCOTUS rulings? Edit: why am I being downvotes? The president explicitly stated his plan to ignore another SCOTUS ruling
- dahfizz 5y ago>why am I being downvotes? The president explicitly stated his plan to ignore another SCOTUS ruling People only think executive overreach is cool as long as they can ignore the downsides.
- adolph 5y ago%s/current/any/
- gowld 5y agoCan you link to info about that?
- RattleyCooper 5y agoAt least with the eviction moratorium, it was ruled unconstitutional by scotus and biden doubled down and enacted a new illegal eviction moratorium. Seems like they are kind of picking and choosing what rules they'll follow, and which rights they think people deserve
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mattkrause 5y agoNo, it wasn't. The Court originally declined to vacate the stay in a 5-4 decision. The fifth vote was from Kavanaugh, who wrote that he thought the stay should be vacated, but wasn't voting to do so because the moratorium was about to expire anyway. That concurrence is certainly informative, but doesn't override his actual vote to maintain the stay. The second moratorium was quickly overturned, with Kavanaugh voting this time in accordance with his opinion. In any case, the administration did actually follow that ruling. This is taken directly from the actual decision (the first round is discussed on page 4): https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/21a23_ap6c.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/21a23_ap6c.pdf
- iammisc 5y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-08-04/biden-s-rebuff-to-supreme-court-on-eviction-ban-will-backfire https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-08-04/biden-... > The president knows this. He told the press that his administration had surveyed the opinions of constitutional scholars, and that most thought an extension would be unlawful. Yet under political pressure from the left, Biden nevertheless ultimately decided to issue the extension. In other words: SCOTUS wrote words clearly indicating a ban would be illegal. By a technicality (expiration date), they didn't issue an explicit ruling. Biden did it anyway, while admitting he knew it was illegal.
- themitigating 5y agoCan you provide a source?
- iammisc 5y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-08-04/biden-s-rebuff-to-supreme-court-on-eviction-ban-will-backfire https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-08-04/biden-... > The president knows this. He told the press that his administration had surveyed the opinions of constitutional scholars, and that most thought an extension would be unlawful. Yet under political pressure from the left, Biden nevertheless ultimately decided to issue the extension. In other words: SCOTUS wrote words clearly indicating a ban would be illegal. By a technicality (expiration date), they didn't issue an explicit ruling. Biden did it anyway, while admitting he knew it was illegal.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> SCOTUS wrote words clearly indicating a ban would be illegal. By a technicality (expiration date), they didn't issue an explicit ruling. Biden did it anyway, while admitting he knew it was illegal. SCOTUS said the moratorium exceeded the CDC's legal authority, but declined to strike it down given it was soon expiring [1]. (They also strongly suggested that if POTUS tried renewing, they would strike it down.) POTUS tried renewing. SCOTUS struck it down. None of this is properly construed as POTUS ignoring SCOTUS. When SCOTUS struck down the law, POTUS obliged. [1] https://www.scotusblog.com/2021/06/divided-court-leaves-eviction-ban-in-place/ https://www.scotusblog.com/2021/06/divided-court-leaves-evic...
- iammisc 5y agoThis is next level rationalizing. For a president to say in no clear terms that he is going to make a rule he knows is illegal is something else. At least other administrations justify their attempts to break the law and mount some defense.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wayoutthere 5y agoYeah the SCOTUS has basically no legitimacy left at both the federal and state level. States are routinely ignoring Supreme Court rulings and have for years, and federal agencies don’t listen to them either anymore. The rule of law in the US is on life support right now. Another Trump presidency will kick the patient out the window.
- brobdingnagians 5y agoWe are in another Trump presidency for all practical purposes. Increasing surveillance, rule by executive order, no respect for the press, no transparency, business as usual, threatening other countries. Not much has changed.
- wayoutthere 5y agoYeah that’s the real bipartisan agenda.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoNot even close. Another Trump regime will spell the end of any democracy at all in the USA. He will finish the fascist insurrection that he started.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI don't really understand what Trump did differently, he just was more direct with implementing bad ideas. But surveillance steadily increased under previous presidencies. Government doesn't understand that this mistrust is mirrored by the populous at some point. In a democracy surveillance should be directed towards officials, not the populous. I think it pretty stupid to blame Trump. Yes, he was funny (as a non-American) but certainly not the reason for the structural issues and the split in political camps. A symptom perhaps and a predictable one I believe.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoAnother Trump presidency will be the end of democracy in the USA. He will install cronies at the top of the military leadership and do exactly what Erdoğan did in Turkey. It's as sure a thing as the sun rising. He will not depend on a bunch of untrained rabble to take over the Capitol next time.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThe President is basically the head of law enforcement in the federal government. Police organizations in the USA have a long history of pushing the limits of what is Constitutional. After all, they just want to get their job done and leave it up to the judiciary to decide what is Constitutional.
- RattleyCooper 5y agoLook at it this way, if a car is involved in a drive-by shooting the police can't get a warrant to search every single home that has the same year/make/model of car registered to with that address. For a legal warrant you have to have probable cause that a specific person committed a crime. You can't just search everybody and see what sticks, that's blatantly unconstitutional.
- 6510 5y agoIf the car was used multiple shootings, the same phone was in that area and the phone was used to search for the victims name every time then we have everything we need but are unwilling to use it? We can probably figure out how to extract such data and cross reference it without making any of it available to random government employees. Say you take pictures of license plates, store the data some place safe and allow a query of 5 recent armed robbery locations. If the result contains multiple cars matching 2 locations no results are returned. The moment a 6th robbery happens and a single car matches 3 out of 5 law enforcement can start looking for it immediately. Sure, you'd get pretty mad if every time you get robbed the police searches your vehicle but they don't need to break anything and you will get over it.
- Talanes 5y ago>Sure, you'd get pretty mad if every time you get robbed the police searches your vehicle but they don't need to break anything and you will get over it. Or I'll stop calling the police, especially if that first invasive experience doesn't end with my belongings returned.
- 6510 5y agoRight, that seems a whole different problem that should really be addressed. In the Netherlands the police are the politest people one could ever meet. It takes very few complaints about politeness or excess force to lose the job. Ofc on the flip side they are also highly incompetent, have no tools, get to see just about ever crook released, are under paid and are very unprofessional. But polite, woah!
- CoastalCoder 5y agoNeither am I a constitutional scholar, but I'm less optimistic about this being ruled illegal. But it's for a somewhat meta-reason: there have been numerous cases where something strikes me as blatantly unconstitutional, but the SCOTUS has allowed it anyway.
- LatteLazy 5y agoYou'd think so. But for 20 years plus justices at all levels have been very happy signing off secret warrants, ultra wide warrants, back dates warrants and other bs. It seems the judiciary don't (want to) understand computers well enough. They just accept government claims of necessity.
- 28uwedj 5y agoHey got a sec? check our this cute dog https://google.com/search?q=bomb https://google.com/search?q=bomb
- night862 5y agoThere's a big problem insofar as you need to have legal standing in order to bring the malfeasance to court (implying you must be able to demonstrate this has been used) This is so difficult, more or less impossible. Prosecutors and LE will likely not bring forward a criminal case based on this sort of unlawful search, as the discovery would detonate the case if brought before a mildly competent defense. The defense would have a really great speaking season following the court proceedings if they were to catch such a windfall. I speculate that these sort of illegal searches are conducted regularly, and serve to fuel parallel construction. In the OP article, it says that LE "did not need to use these search warrants to find the bomber" whose picture is inline, instead they correlated his "unique pink construction gloves" to some home depot footage of his purchase, linking his identity to the purchase with video evidence. I think it is very possible for parallel construction to provide the required leads to locate this video footage. The search warrants can be as illegal as the day is long, but their effect may remain invisible so long as it generates a lead which is not obviously poisoned fruit.
- eftychis 5y agoStarting replying then saw your comment. Just wanted to note you are spot on in my opinion. It will be hard to showcase parallel construction and I am not sure how some ngo of some sort can pursue this at court. Honestly, my feeling is the moment judges and congress felt OK with actions even pondering such acts we had a fundamental democratic problem in our hands. As they say if you put a cop car on someone's tail they are going to get a ticket.
- night862 5y ago>As they say if you put a cop car on someone's tail they are going to get a ticket. "Show me the man and I'll show you the crime." -Lavrenti Beria, ironically, before his 1953 trial and execution. Beria was a monster, hated by many of his countrymen. Who would argue against such a puppet trial? So long as justice is served.
- pvarangot 5y agoFor something like catching a bomber or people that just kidnapped a girl even if this warrant is deemed illegal the cops are probably making a bet that they'll be swimming in better evidence once they nail on a suspect and do regular surveillance.
- yaur 5y ago"probable" has a very specific meaning. If the police can construct a query that returns 1-2 results and on average one of those results is the killer than its "probable" otherwise its not.
- angelzen 5y agoGoogle has the resources. Is it sensible to expect a corporation larger than the oil giants to behave responsibly with its power?
- raxxorrax 5y ago> then it would be constitutional to ask for names of people who searched for Harry. I don't think putting people that want to inform themselves under suspicion is feasible and it probably should not be legal. This isn't conductive to solving crimes and has severe chilling effects.
- salawat 5y agoIt's sadly more nuanced than that because the answer to the question Can police do X? Is not effectively answered til binding precedent is created in the Courts, which requires someone to fight it all the way up. Remember, judges are signing these blatantly overbroad warrants in the first place. So there's a judiciary crisis already at play