4 ms·
Here is a concrete example where this mentality really hurt Google in the cloud space: App Engine. App Engine was really Google's first foray (or one of the fir
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Here is a concrete example where this mentality really hurt Google in the cloud space: App Engine. App Engine was really Google's first foray (or one of the first) into the cloud space. When it was first released, the only persistent store available was the Datastore. The Datastore was/is a great piece of technology, but it was painfully clear that this tool was optimized for Google's use cases and came from the mindset that things need to be infinitely scalable/shardable, e.g. eventual consistency and the fact that you couldn't have indexes with inequalities in different directions, so doing a query that is trivial in a DB (e.g "dateCol > someMinVal AND dateCol < someMaxVal") was annoyingly difficult.
So the early days of App Engine were really cool, but it took some time before Google actually made a plain ol' database (their Cloud SQL tech) available. As someone looking in, and as someone who has talked to a lot of ex-Google employees, it was clearly a cultural shift for them to need to focus on standardized enterprise tools that so much of the industry is familiar with, rather than all the tons of custom shit Google has due to their scale.
- macNchz 5y agoThis makes a lot of sense and totally jives with my brief experience of working on a single App Engine app years ago. It felt like an easy platform to spin up a simple web app at first blush, but was actually such a frustrating experience when trying to do a lot of actual simple web app things.
- stavros 5y agoThe Datastore could do simple things well, and hard things well, and both exactly with the same level of effort.
- Dylan16807 5y agoHow would you do a range query "well", then? With filtering on your own server definitely not being "well".
- pas 5y agoThe same was true of early Firebase. (Which Google acquired.) Sometimes a "general" backend/datastore just sucks independent of scale.