8 ms·
Orbital Reef: Commercial space station by BlueOrigin, Sierra Space, Boeing
- the-last-user 5y agoPerhaps a cynical view but can this be an optimal way of avoiding taxes/laws? Any in-orbit trades would be completely unregulated. This combined with the fact that only the <1% of the world population would have access to it
- jonititan 5y agoIs this a real thing? What happens if you make a trade on a boat in international waters? Same rules would apply I expect.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Any in-orbit trades would be completely unregulated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_law "Objects launched into space are subject to their nation of belonging, including people." The US will happily prosecute you for going to Thailand to sleep with underage prostitutes. They'd be happy to do the same here, especially as you're probably launching from and landing on their territory anyways.
- xvilka 5y agoTheir logo reminded me of Quake.
- an9n 5y agoSeems to be lacking in ambition given the rapid pace of innovation elsewhere. Still, let's hope they focus on this rather than disparaging and suing SpaceX.
- makerofspoons 5y agoIt seems like too big of a leap for a consortium of companies that have yet to field a single manned orbital vehicle to be planning a space station.
- technofiend 5y agoWell, maybe. On the other hand a "moonshot" program is designed to give you a huge goal with a long list of challenges that get there, so this seems like a good way to get a consortium-owned space station done. On the gripping hand the original moonshot had a national context that a corporate space station does not.
- nickff 5y agoThe USA committed to landing on the moon without having "field[ed] a single manned orbital vehicle".
- PeterisP 5y agoThe issue here is that for a commercial venture, cost matters a lot. USA in 1960s did not have an alternative option of using someone else's launch vehicle for a fraction of what it would cost to build one themselves; companies who want to build a commercial space station do have an option to buy launch capacity from SpaceX instead of Boeing/BlueOrigin, which would still be more expensive even if all their plans and promises materialize on the scheduled time.
- comeonseriously 5y agoPonzi type scheme. They want to use funds from investors for Orbital Reef to fund their existing efforts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pjscott 5y agoSierra Nevada Corporation and Boeing have been making miscellaneous space systems for decades. Maybe neither SNC nor Blue Origin will be able to deliver on their launch system promises, but it seems plausible that they could make a space station, eventually, with enough money and luck -- and there are other manned launch options.
- 5y ago
- willvarfar 5y agoThis is like a who’s who of companies that spacex have been making look bad recently. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/25/jeff-bezos-blue-origin-unveils-ocean-reef-private-space-station.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/25/jeff-bezos-blue-origin-unvei... is good coverage with some links to various previous episodes.
- _joel 5y agoTBF, they've been making themselves look bad, SpaceX have just been keeping their heads down and ploughing on where they can, when not dealing with litigation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- varelse 5y agoThe mice were furious and they demanded the cat bell itself!
- adriancr 5y agoI'm betting spaceX will land on the Moon and then Mars before this space station ever gets launched. From the article you linked it's going to be between 2025-2030... which by previous history of these companies it's likely going to be 2040+ > This is like a who’s who of companies that spacex have been making look bad recently. Their own lack of innovation and constant delays are making themselves look bad. (and outright maliciousness on blue origin with moon contracts).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _joel 5y agoWell, that'll be interesting, from a company yet to do an orbital launch that's been operating for 20 years and an old aerospace dinosaur that can't even fix the issues with their crew module.
- bell-cot 5y ago"One small step for a Musk, but one pipe dream leap for Marketingkind."
- motohagiography 5y agoThe economics are probably analogous to the cruise ship business, which somehow makes it viable to build and maintain these behemoth machines: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_cruise_ships https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_cruise_ships A space version of The World (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS_The_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS_The_World) is something you will probably see in your lifetime. Btw, if James Cameron is reading this, maybe it's time to reshoot Titanic as a space opera? Thing hits space junk starts crashing toward earth, burning up in atmosphere, involves a Baumgartner level skydive from an escape pod, Tom Cruise does his own stunts. Call me.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoThe Arthur C. Clarke novel "Islands in the Sky" covers something similar, including a reckless actor who decides to do his own stunts. Things don't go well. Still a fun book, though probably more aimed at kids.
- panick21_ 5y agoThe economics is basically 'hope NASA pays for part of it and is a base user'.
- _joel 5y agoSet the bid really high, get the knock back, then complain to the authorities, then get a rerun on the tender with a magically cheaper price submitted for the same thing.
- panick21_ 5y agoNASA has been good at running the contracts (mostly). When the new Head of Human Spaceflight tried to give Boeing insider information he was strictly fired. BlueOrigin has endlessly complained about SpaceX selection of HLS but so far nothing. This strategy doesn't work when a better and cheaper competitor exists.
- 5y ago
- bpodgursky 5y agoI very much hope it succeeds, but I very much expect this to be vaporware, given the players.
- kposehn 5y ago1. I am all for space exploration. I consider getting all our eggs out of one basket to be the single highest strategic imperative for humanity. 2. I do not for a second believe Blue Origin and Boeing can deliver on this. 3. I really want them to prove me wrong.
- coldcode 5y agoYeah end of decade, as long as you don't specify which decade. I wish I could go into space, but don't expect to become a billionaire or live long enough for it to be cheap.
- kposehn 5y agoI'm more pessimistic about BO+Boeing than I am about SpaceX simply because of massive cultural differences between them all. While Elon is...eccentric...he managed to assemble the team led by Gwynne Shotwell at SpaceX which can accomplish massive amounts in very short periods of time. Their success rate is extremely high so I would hesitate to ever bet against them. Blue Origin has for a long time been a side-thing for Jeff. As a result, it apparently suffers from a serious lack of focus, commitment and sheer f'ing will. This is not a judgement of the front-line employees, but of the leadership which has let them all down. Boeing is...well, Boeing. I want to go into space as well. And I'm actually much more optimistic than you about the price and accessibility. At our current rate of change, it'll not just be possible within our lifetimes - it'll be commonplace. Why? Take the example of landing first stage boosters. This was something that had never been successfully done. SpaceX started working on landing in 2013 and successfully did it in 2016. Since then it has become commonplace - sticking the landing isn't even newsworthy. Each tipping point, such as reusability, is happening faster and faster.
- _joel 5y agoI'm 100% in agreement with this. I'm optimistic that we'll have intraplanetary flights by the end of this decade that would at least let me experience micro gravity and take a holiday in Australia at the same time :)
- stan_g 5y agoI bet the tourism thing will be great for our planet.
- jonititan 5y agoI like the name for this endeavour. It speaks of a structure growing and evolving over time. Teeming with spaceships going hither and yon. Each distinct and different with unique roles and purposes.
- qnsi 5y agoalso, coral reefs are places where there is surprising amount of life in small area compared to vastness of the oceans.
- panick21_ 5y agoIts kind of interesting how all these other companies need to combine their efforts, no company really has a shot to compete by itself outside of SpaceX. SpaceX has the massive rockets, crew vehicles, cargo transporters, experience with human space flight and are vertically integrated to build these station modules as well. Blue Origin has the big rocket to launch it (at least in theory). Boeing has the crew transport (again in theory). Sierra Nevada has the cargo transport (at least in theory). Will be interesting what design SpaceX will come out with. They often surprise. Many people believed they would bid Starship for the Lunar Station resupply but they came out with Dragon XL. Many people didn't believe SpaceX would use Starship to bid on Human Lander for the Moon landing. I would be shocked if its not designed around Starship. But the question is if they would just launch huge modules with Starship or literally build the station out of Starships. You could even use the gigantic tanks of the Starships as living room. You just need to make the likeable in orbit. I hope the integrated something to test different G forces. Would be great for testing things that need to work on moon, mars and so on. P.S: Those that have missed it, Lockeed Marin and Nanoracks are another competitor. That system seems smaller and they can use current rockets and they will use Dragon for Transport. See: https://spacenews.com/nanoracks-and-lockheed-martin-partner-on-commercial-space-station-project/ https://spacenews.com/nanoracks-and-lockheed-martin-partner-... Axiomspace will almost certainty bid something too. They are working Thales Alenia Space for manufacturing. So far Northrop Grumman is not in any of the camps as far as I know.
- _joel 5y agoThere are a few other interesting companies at the smaller scale and seem to doing fine (albeit some with hiccups and bankruptcy/reincarnation but alas, that's business). RocketLab are going great guns as are Firefly and companies like Astra and Relativity Space (cool 3d printed rockets!) are closely following the pack. It's only because of Bezos's profile and the fact it's been running for decades with no real results that make it seem SpaceX are the only ones killing it.
- panick21_ 5y agoThese are all rocket companies, I was talking about space station companies. RocketLab, Firefly, Astra, Relativity Space are all small and have proven little. RocketLab has the most but its still a tiny rocket with a high failure rate so far. But yeah great that they exists. ABL Space belongs in that group. I think the companies that actually want to do things in space are just as interesting and get less talked about.
- sschueller 5y agoPure vaporware, I feel sorry for any investors who actually believes this is in anyway realistic. Then again anyone who invests in such vaporware should not be an investor.
- panick21_ 5y agoThe main costumer would be NASA. This would essentially replace the ISS. Different companies are competing for a contract.
- thomasfl 5y agoSeems like anybody that can go out in space, can use as much space as they want for space stations or whatever. According to the space law, no one nation may claim ownership of outer space or any celestial body. Activities carried out in space must abide by the international law. That may cause conflicts in the future, when companies are able to reach other planets.
- dang 5y agoWe've taken the title from their corporate press release which is https://blueorigin-static-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/assets/orbital-reef-press-release.pdf https://blueorigin-static-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/assets/orb... (Submitted title was 'Orbital Reef – 'Commercial' Space Station by Boeing, BlueOrigin and Co')
- panick21_ 5y agoThe problem with this is that this is just dishonest. Its basically mostly a Boeing station. They are just trying to hide the name because Boeing has been executing terribly. The station will be built by Boeing and operated, so I thought it should be in the name.
- dang 5y agoOk! I've amalgamated the two and re-Boeinged it. We don't want misleading titles and of course you're right, corporate press releases tend to do that. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=corporate%20press%20release%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- panick21_ 5y agoThank you.
- rdascalu 5y agoWill it host a Hal 9000 computer on board as well?
- ChuckMcM 5y agoIt is an interesting pitch. So far the two "biggest" companies involved, Boeing and Blue Origin, have yet to demonstrate their ability to execute on more modest goals, much less this giant vision, so it is difficult to take seriously. BO needs to figure out why the BE-4 engine has been such a challenge, and Boeing needs to figure out why Starliner has been such a challenge. If they credibly re-build the teams on those projects and turn them around, then perhaps that will inform their efforts on something grander.
- _joel 5y agoI'd say part of the BE-4 failure to deliver is around culture, they're using the old playbook and not an agile process. Plus they've had a lot of staff leave, although that's been fairly recently after the shennanigans the management were playing. The consultancy that B.O. secretly asked to do around SpaceX was pretty eye opening. Although, granted, even with waterfall style it should have been delivered already.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoI have read and heard a variety of reasons why BO is not able to execute, some from the press, some from people I know who either worked there or were close to someone who did. Culture is a defining characteristic of an organizations ability to execute against a plan or vision. So I agree it is a large part of the problem, or more simply a great place to start on the solution.
- hugs 5y agoThe only video hints at it, but what is something that can be manufactured in space in their station that can't be manufactured on earth?
- johncalvinyoung 5y agoI think the current ISS is hosting an experiment at making ultra-high-purity optical cables.
- malfist 5y agoMostly things that are to stay in space, or can't be launched assembled. The ISS was built after lots of launches of components, they can also build small satellites or other things that stay in space. That's the current use. But in the far future, space ships or habitats probably. Things that can't hold together under the weight of gravity or areodynamic drag. Like tyco station in the expanse.
- hugs 5y agoThanks. I was imagining something that would be made in space, then shipped back to earth... and thinking there is nothing that would be worth the shipping costs, except something small and (perceived to be) high-value, like synthetic diamonds. I could see someone spending $$$$ on an engagement ring made in space just so they can say it was made in space.
- PeterisP 5y agoThat seems to be the case now; perhaps if large scale operations of reusable vehicles make shipping costs decrease significantly then the economics of that would change.
- UnFleshedOne 5y agoI think fiberoptics is one thing that benefits from microgravity.
- Tossrock 5y agoInteresting that their renders show what appear to be inflatable modules a la Bigelow Aerospace's designs, but don't mention them as a partner. Wonder if inflatable is catching on for space station designers, it definitely has some clear benefits.
- panick21_ 5y agoBigelow Aerospace is defunct. The patents from NASA have run out. Other people can build these structures if they want to. Sierra Nevada has been involved in some research for these. I think they also did some thing for Bigelow as well. I'm not a big fan of these inflatables. They are good for the in-between space, larger then the biggest rockets, smaller then a really built structure. I prefer us to actually figure out how to construct real structures in orbit.
- PeterisP 5y agoIMHO the skill to construct real structures in orbit would necessarily come after forming a commercial/industrial space station (unlike ISS), not before it. You would need significant amount of equipment and people in orbit for the long term to work on that construction, so you need a sizeable station even if it's just "temporary construction crew quarters+warehouse".
- panick21_ 5y agoAnd those parts I would suggest you might as well prebuild on the ground and launch them. With New Glenn you can launch 6.3m modules, with Starship almost 9m. That should be enough, no additional blowing up required. From there you can then build real structures onto it.
- narcisists_anon 5y agoinvestors are going to get fleeced. I would be very scared of any partnership with Sierra Space. The new CEO Tom Vice just drove Aerion, supersonic business jets, into liquidation. That was only after forcing a $300m hq move from Las Vegas to Melbourne, FL where he lives. Prior to Aerion, he pulled the same move at Northrop Grumman Aerospace where he placed a major program in Melbourne. Then he was let go because the company missed a major hiring goal.
- Tepix 5y agoLooking at this concept, the concept for Orb2, a spherical, single-launch space station by ThinkOrbital looks wayy more exciting! Also probably a lot cheaper. And it offers a huge amount of pressurized volume: Twice as much as the ISS when launched on Blue Origin's New Glenn, four times as much (4000 cubic meters, 20 meters diameter) when launched on SpaceX's Starship. Video of the in-space assembly of Orb2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3GBE_NS6Y8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3GBE_NS6Y8 Orbital reef on the other hand looks like a rehashed ISS.
- panick21_ 5y agoReally cool idea, I not sure the company has the credibility to pull of a NASA contract. But it should really, really be researched.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoIs this going to be anything more than powerpoint and fancy videos? Here's another compelling video vision (CisLunar 1000) created by related companies 5 years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxftPmpt7aA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxftPmpt7aA
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoYeah whatever, I'll believe it when I see it. I remember when Hyperloops, tunnel motorways, and commercial electric planes were being promised with a deadline of 3+ years ago.
- sebazzz 5y agoIt looks that they want to partially use inflatable modules. The last organisation that tried that is the late Bigalow Aerospace. Has any of these companies purchased the intellectual property or will they be redeveloping it?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThis will be a 11 figure project, if not 12. That's fine if Bezos is paying for it, but it's a lot of dosh if the taxpayer is. For 9 figures you could take a Starship, kit it out on Earth, launch it into LEO and land it 6 months later, replenish supplies, swap experiments and launch again.