9 ms·
Employees pleaded with Facebook to stop letting politicians bend rules
- voidfunc 5y agoFacebook: Shutup and take the money, or leave.
- pacifika 5y agoThe employees ARE facebook aren't they.
- datavirtue 5y agoYes. See Workers Union.
- ikerdanzel 5y agoYes. But you need to view employees are just instrument or slave. The actual Facebook as general consensus is mainly Mark. He holds the controlling share and can do whatever he wants even bordering grey area as he seems to enjoy some protection from US government.
- bognition 5y agoMark Zuckerberg is Facebook. He owns more than 50% of the stock and as such has no accountability. “In multiple cases the final judgment about whether a prominent post violates a certain written policy are made by senior executives, sometimes Mark Zuckerberg,”
- thewhitetulip 5y agoPeople forget that he has absolute control over the company. Absolute power corrupts absolutely
- ashtonkem 5y agoHonestly I think it’s less “power corrupts” and more class interests coming out.
- thewhitetulip 5y agoI'm sorry, class interest?
- ashtonkem 5y agoHe’s a billionaire. It’s not exactly hard to figure that he’d largely agree with Murdoch and the “don’t tax the rich” side of the political spectrum.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Nasrudith 5y agoAsking in terms of brands is sort of asking to confuse given how many things are shoved under the label. I'll take the statement as "Without them Facebook would cease to exist entirely as a company." But no - if every last employee below a CxO status vanished one night without a trace the company and the website would still be around. It would be diminished and start encountering problems without any employees for maintenance, business expansion, and administrative needs but a great deal is automated by software in the first place. The site would still run, ads would still be placed, money would flow in. A zombie minimal company could be left adrift and could stay that way indefinitely if their user base didn't mind. A law office, a doctor's office, those practices - in those small scale cases the employees are the company - without them you have furniture and maybe some soon to be redundant support staff. Said staff would be very limited in what they may do without breaking the law.
- belter 5y agohttps://archive.md/wip/vLth0 https://archive.md/wip/vLth0
- Maxburn 5y agoThank you.
- Kaze404 5y agoRecently Facebook took down a livestream of Brazil's president where he linked Covid vaccines to HIV, which I believe would've been a great move had it not happened 72 hours after the fact. What's the point of doing that when you also give them enough time to spread the lie on your other platforms (WhatsApp)?
- mam3 5y agoEnjoy the decline. You cany bend an entire country anyway
- dang 5y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments. Not what this site is for. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- ikerdanzel 5y agoThere are confirmed DNA analysis that Covid has HIV fragments. You can search that. Vast majority of this info from medical communities have been actively surpress to the point any researchers mentioning it will be "censored". I recalled both India and Thailand researchers made those discoveries early last year. But all mainstream media very strangely suppress it.
- themitigating 5y agoHIV doesn't have DNA
- gus_massa 5y agoDo you have a link? i remember something like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27324055 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27324055 Note that it is based in a retracted preprint, so it's not confirmed at all. The idea of the paper is that they look for parts in one f the proteins of covid-19 that are not in other covirus they already know. Then they searched for these new parts in the proteins of other virus, and one of this parts "is" in HIV. The first problem is that the fragment is too short. So there is a huge chance to find it somewhere just by luck. It's like if I edit may comment and add the word "revenge", and then someone claims I copied that word from a famous book that uses it. The second problem, is that they didn't find exact matches, the examples they got are very short but have gasp in the middle. It's much easier to find a coincidence. It's like if I edit may comment and add the word "revenue", and then someone claims I copied that word from a famous book that uses "revenge" instead.
- zpeti 5y agoI hope Facebook employees also plead to take down AOC when she says the world will end in 12 years. And that was 2 years ago so only 10 years left!
- cbg0 5y agoNice whataboutism.
- datavirtue 5y agoSounds like they need a union.
- mabbo 5y agoAre there tech companies where employees have any power to effect real change? It seems that all the successful tech companies have a model where the power is either in the hands of the stock market, where the leadership has been told 'do whatever it takes to make money or you're fired', or its consolidated in the hands of less than 3 people, who are hell-bent on making as much money as possible. Why can't we invent a system of corporate management in which the employees have the majority stake in how the company operates? How about the employees are all voting members in an organization that holds a stockpile of 100X voting right shares? There's got to make a way to make that happen. I suspect such an organization would be radically different than most companies today, but that it would attract talent too.
- seneca 5y ago> Why can't we invent a system of corporate management in which the employees have the majority stake in how the company operates? We have, it's called a co-op. There aren't many that are terribly successful, but no one is stopping you from starting one.
- denton-scratch 5y agoMondragon, the Basque truck-making coop. They've been going for as long as I have, because they were founded in the year I was born. John Lewis, a UK department store. It's not exactly a coop, but it's pretty close. The staff are referred to as "partners". They're in financial difficulties at the moment, I think, but that's not because workers participate in the company. They're one of the few UK department stores still standing. Waitrose (a John Lewis brand) is easily the classiest supermarket/grocery in the UK - people choose where to buy expensive homes based on how close the nearest Waitrose is. It's easier to set up a private company than a joint-stock corporation, and it's easier to set up a joint-stock corporation than a cooperative. It should be easiest to set up a cooperative, rather than hardest. Oh - and there's the Coop Bank. Wait - that went broke due to dreadful mismanagement, and was bought by a VC outfit. So how come they're still allowed to call themselves that? There's still a number of local chains of fairly small grocers, operating as autonomous members of the Cooperative Wholesale Society (the bank was originally part of the CWS). These are decent shops, well-run at a local level, but I'm not impressed by their head-office management. If you take their discount card, then you get to participate in board elections and so on. It's a "customer coop".
- lettergram 5y agoI’m sorry, but perhaps I’m the only person who believes Facebook should just follow the laws and that’s it. I don’t understand why we are asking (employee or otherwise) to censor people. What happened to Galileo and many others throughout history was a tragedy. Who are we to assume we know better? Facebook became the town square, probably years ago... but definitely forced to be the town square by the pandemic. In other words, free speech should be protected and at least in the US that means barring direct threats or specific direction of violence all speech should be allowed.
- maxerickson 5y agoYou would need a law saying that they can only moderate according to the law. Otherwise they are going to tend to do what is profitable.
- lettergram 5y agoI tend to agree, then again historically (pre-1980s), the town square included where ever people congregated or traversed. For instance the sidewalk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama There’s quite a history there: https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/824/public-forum-doctrine https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/824/public-forum-do... It’s pretty hard to argue Facebook wasn’t an intended public forum. Literally you have your public wall and your newsfeed, etc.
- maxerickson 5y agoCasually glancing at the first paragraph of your second link, I see the phrase "government property".
- Jtype 5y agoRead more. If you delve into this topic a bit more you will see that free speech rights are also available in private spaces as well. Most notably in regards to unions
- temp8964 5y agoThe "employees" claim Facebook just bent rules for conservatives / Republicans. It seems everybody forgot Facebook (and Twitter) bent (created?) rules to censor the Hunter Biden laptop story ahead of the 2020 election.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoPolitics is preference. To one group it looks like bending rules, to another it seems reasonable. FBs only neutral action would be to ban it all, but that might be odd in a Liberal Democratic Republic.
- malloreon 5y agoCan’t read the article, but did they quit the company when their pleas didn’t work? If not, they changed their opinion and now support/accept their employer’s decision or decided the issue wasn’t that important.
- joeblubaugh 5y agoAnd how many of them quit, persuaded coworkers to quit or made other work stoppages to actually do anything about it?
- stronglikedan 5y agoQuitting doesn't do anything. Everyone is replaceable. That said, I think the time of affecting change from the inside has come and gone, in the case of Facebook. Unfortunately, it seems accountability's time has also come and gone in our society, so I don't know what the answer is.
- ashtonkem 5y agoDepends on the scale. Facebook needs so many engineers that a reduction in hiring or a jump in attrition could begin putting the hurt on internally. Heck, look at the stories coming out of AWS these days to see what hiring problems looks like. The issue is that Facebook has very effective strategies to deal with this, both in terms of money and social structure. We all know that they pay lucratively, but Facebook is also filled to the brim with people either working on non-core products that can think they’re doing no harm, and people who think they’re making a positive difference. I think the combination of these things is keeping Facebook ahead of their reputation problems with potential sources of labor, although I wouldn’t wager a guess how long it can last.
- numair 5y agoThere’s a giant conversation here about whether Facebook should be the “judge” or whatever. You guys don’t get it, do you? The senior execs and inner circle at that company are actively engaged in swaying political discourse, the way laws are written, US foreign policy, foreign elections, and so on... This is not like employees of a power company asking to turn the power off to a church or something totally bizarre and nonsensical. This is an intensely politically active organization that styles itself as a global shadow government and utilizes a massive revolving door of political employees, lobbyists, “advisors,” and “guest speakers,” being asked by its employees to use its self-ordained role as kingmaker and discourse-shaper in ways they feel would be less harmful to society. They have every right to argue for change, because they can see what a Death Star that thing looks like from the inside. As long as the Death Star exists, people are going to fight over where to direct that death-ray. Agree with the employees’ political beliefs or don’t — what should concern you is that such a weapon exists in the first place. This is not like AOL, and that wannabe Emperor and his pals specifically intended for that. This racket is not an inevitable consequence of technology — it’s a mind virus run amok.
- ljlolel 5y agoYou almost have it. But missing the part that other major media organizations (like NYT) are also “Death Stars” with political motivations run by execs—- and have caused and continue to cause things like the Iraq war.
- jessaustin 5y agoIndeed, the role, if not the entire existence, of the war media of which FB is now a part is predicated upon the inherently hazardous (to socialists overseas, but ultimately to domestic patriots as well) military-political system we've allowed to fester in USA.
- numair 5y agoI helped Facebook build the Platform, even going so far as convincing Dave Morin to leave Apple and work on it, because I was worried about evils of Murdoch. So trust me, I know all about exactly what you cited. Facebook is a very different sort of devil. To the point where all of the other devils are afraid of them. Even I didn’t realize how insane these people were, and continue to be. They’d be toast by now, if they hadn’t been able to successfully hijack the governmental and political machines to keep themselves seen as “essential” and worthy of protection — there’s that Death Star at work. I know, I need to write about this in more detail. It’s on my to-do list. I have spent a long time waiting to see if society would figure out what a giant scam these people were — I am pleasantly surprised. You’ve got to remember that, 10 years ago, people wanted to nominate those lunatics for the Nobel Peace Prize. Being an enemy of Facebook was equivalent to being an enemy of the state.
- nathias 5y agoThe central problem is that platforms were exmpted from being sued on the basis that they are neutral to content, and then they started using this privilige to manipulate content. Just revoke the privilige you granted them, and let all the useful web go back to protocols.
- spurgu 5y agoPoliticians are bullshitting people? Shocker. All this mainstream Facebook hate is starting to make me kind of wanna get back on FB.