3 ms·
> Mandated ISO standards in 1947 was absurd secret law too. Democracy is not that new of a concept. In the 1940s, if you wanted to read legislation, there was
by skissane 5y ago
> Mandated ISO standards in 1947 was absurd secret law too. Democracy is not that new of a concept.
In the 1940s, if you wanted to read legislation, there was no downloading it for free off the Internet – either you purchased a printed copy, or found a library that held it – and you may have had to travel some distance to do so, there was no guarantee that your neighbourhood public library did. Most people viewed charging for printed copies of legislation as acceptable, given that it cost money to print them. So, in that sense, legally mandated ISO standards weren't fundamentally different from laws in general. Prior to the 1990s, when the Internet began to change people's expectations, the idea that everyone was entitled to a free personal copy of all legislation was not widely accepted, and few would have labelled that situation as anti-democratic or as "absurd secret law".
> It was not just a matter of getting in a phone and calling the ISO customer center.
In the 1940s, rather than calling the ISO secretariat in Switzerland directly, you would have called your national standards body, who acted as a reseller. Buying standards then was only harder than today in the sense that buying anything back then was harder than today.
- zinekeller 5y agoVery good summary. While it is true that ISO is stuck in time, at the same time its model weren't out-of-place when it was implemented, similar to how copyright laws now seems weird or plain wrong to many here while a century back (outside US, because theirs was weirder) it was widely accepted to compensate corporations who have took their time to record and stamp those phonographs.
- dataflow 5y ago> the idea that everyone was entitled to a free personal copy of all legislation was not widely accepted Was the idea that everyone is entitled to a copy of all legislation at cost widely accepted? Or did most people believe the the publisher (or the legislature?) should overcharge them and stand to make a profit off it? I don't know how much "at cost" would be for ISO, but something tells me it wouldn't be an identical 158 CHF for both PDF and paper.
- marcosdumay 5y agoNeither. Access to legislation must be possible at no cost for everybody. Otherwise you can't expect people to follow it. Of course, that doesn't entitle you to a copy, making it available at libraries is already enough.
- skissane 5y ago> Neither. Access to legislation must be possible at no cost for everybody. Otherwise you can't expect people to follow it. In the real world, most people follow legislation without ever reading it. People build a rough mental model, based on media sources, government websites, common sense, etc, which divides acts into "probably illegal", "probably legal", and "grey area". If they stick to the "probably legal", they are unlikely to have any legal problems. If they are seriously considering venturing into the "probably illegal" or "grey area" zones, a wise person hires a lawyer and gets some professional legal advice first. The majority of the population has no hope of ever understanding legislation – something people on this website tend to forget, because most people on this website are significantly more intelligent and better educated than the average person is. And even those of us who aren't intimidated by legislation and case law and law textbooks, in the way that the average person is, ought to remember the old adage "A man who is his own lawyer has a fool for a client"–if you don't have the formal training and real-world experience of an actual lawyer, it is easy to make a costly mistake–e.g reading some law literally, and unfortunately you never found the case law which interprets it to mean something quite different from what it literally says. Keep the amateur lawyering as a hobby, maybe some real world situations where the cost of being wrong is low (such as challenging a parking ticket), and rely on a professional for anything actually important. > Of course, that doesn't entitle you to a copy, making it available at libraries is already enough. Well, ISO standards are freely available at some libraries. Generally national libraries, major public research libraries, university libraries (some of which are open to general public, others restrict admission to staff/students/etc.) Your local public library probably doesn't have any copies of ISO standards–mine doesn't. But, my local public library doesn't seem to have copies of legislation and case law either – my local public library has very little in the way of serious/professional/academic legal texts, just some very introductory stuff aimed at the general reader.