20 ms·
The fatiguing effects of camera use in virtual meetings
- crummy 5y agoAs someone in a leadership role is it more important to keep the camera on?
- djbusby 5y agoWhen I'm chair, I keep the camera on, else, depends on the room.
- peakaboo 5y agoYes it's an advantage if other team members feel inspired by seeing you on camera. But if you don't like it, you have to decide if it's worth the discomfort to get that advantage. The way it works is... You make a decision like that, people will ask you why. You explain it by saying you don't want to be on camera a few times. After a while it becomes normal and nobody ever asks again. It's very simple.
- jimbob45 5y agoMost people at our company just have their camera on for the start of the meeting and then drop off as the meeting progresses. As long as you cam up for the first 3-5 minutes, no one really cares.
- baby 5y agoI too find it tiring, but I too like having my camera on sometimes. I had meetings were I wished we had camera on because nobody was paying attention and I know that things would have been different with cameras or IRL. For the most part I don’t enable my camera, unless I’m going to speak in which case i turn it on once for the duration of my speech
- rytcio 5y agoI know this just from a Twitch streamer I watch. He'll occasionally have to stream with the camera off because having the camera on takes a lot of energy
- thewhitetulip 5y agoI've never had a camera on during meetings. The profile pictures of people also make me feel the same way as video.
- jcun4128 5y agoI feel bad about it, used to have the stand up scrums and then just disappeared behind a computer oh well, been like that over a year and a half now. Only 1 out of say 10 people have their webcam on now used to be more early on.
- thewhitetulip 5y agoIt is tiring. Even more so for me as I joined remotely a few months ago in my new job. Knew 0 people in the new company!
- sharken 5y agoHaving the camera on is not a requirement for doing actual work. It can be nice to see your fellow coworkers, but it's no substitution for an actual physical meeting. Having worked both in a remote and office setting, i much prefer the latter as it makes for better relations and getting to know people. I guess remote work is just not for everyone.
- thewhitetulip 5y agoExactly! And due to WFH we have to set a meeting for every little thing.
- f311a 5y agoI think streamers get used to it because a lot of them stream for 4-8 hours a day.
- digitalsushi 5y ago
- woleium 5y agoJust turn off self view. It's distracting and weird to see yourself in a meeting.
- adelpozo 5y agoIn the other hand, I look at myself. I place the selfview close to the lens and it appears that I am looking directly at the other party. Idk why it works but I find it smoothing and allows me to control how I am being seen. Just my personal experience.
- underwater 5y agoIf you extrapolate that then you have a bunch of people all staring at a video of themselves for the duration of the meeting. No one is looking at you, but you feel on display and mentally fatigue yourself for nothing.
- haswell 5y agoI also keep an eye on my self view, but not continuously throughout the entire call. I'll still pay attention to the person speaking and scan the rest of the cams like I would if I were in a conference room. Doesn't need to be a constant thing, but more like glancing in the rear view mirror while driving. It's there when you need it, also there when you just want to check, but not going to keep you from the task at hand.
- agustif 5y agoFunny you used that word, there's a mac app for that https://apps.apple.com/us/app/rearview-handy-mirror-camera/id1459730659?mt=12 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/rearview-handy-mirror-camera/i...
- data_ders 5y agowhy doesn't Microsoft Teams have this?!
- boglurker 5y agoI haven't turned my camera on in meetings for over 8 months, I don't think anyone really cares that much, and I find some people like it because they feel less pressure to keep their own cameras on as a result. That's been my experience at least, I'm sure some people have bosses that require it for whatever reason which might make that not an option for everyone.
- macintux 5y agoBased on a discussion here several months ago, it seems to vary by workplace. Some companies rarely use cameras, some use them all the time. Very grateful I work for the former.
- Buttons840 5y agoThe ability to have someone instantly available, without requiring 100% of their attention, is useful. I have no problem with some people multitasking in meetings, and I don't judge people if they say "sorry, I wasn't paying attention, can you repeat that". I've learned to ask better questions that people can answer even if they weren't paying attention.
- MivLives 5y agoOne thing I always found helpful with that is to lead with the person's name. So "Bob, do you have an opinion on this specific thing, in the context of this other thing?" I totally understand drifting off in meetings especially virtual ones.
- matsemann 5y agoThey care, they just don't want to pick a fight. They might judge you and believe the reason you're not on camera is because you're busy doing something else.
- hnzix 5y agoThese are probably the same people who care if I leave the office on time instead of staying late every night. I don't care to please these people.
- noisy_boy 5y agoI just blame it on poor webcam support over Citrix for Linux. All others run Windows but some dont turn on video just because. Management raised the point of video for a while and then basically gave up. Good. For technical meetings you dont need to see my face to evaluate the merits of my point. Performance review type stuff is a different matter.
- blowski 5y agoIf it’s a purely technical meeting, I’d wonder why it’s even a call rather than writing. But I’d guess that some might disagree that it’s “purely technical”, and there the video call makes sense. Perhaps there’s more need than ever to establish a purpose for the meeting before you start.
- diroussel 5y agoBecause sometimes you don’t need to write a whole load of justification if everyone on the call already agrees with you.
- cblconfederate 5y agoZoom should add a pause button. Freeze the camera, people can see your face but it doesnt have to be live. Or use a photo instead
- lwhsiao 5y agoYou can basically do with with OBS.
- whateveracct 5y agoYou can set a profile picture in Zoom at least
- ArtDev 5y agoI wish I could disable the video for people that have their cameras on. I find video distracting and it takes away from a genuine conversation.
- diroussel 5y agoThis now an option in zoom as of a few weeks ago. MS Teams has had this for a long time.
- ratww 5y agoA friend experimented with using an animated background with him paying attention, coupled with closing the camera lid. Some people failed to notice, but for those who did it was a bit like uncanny valley.
- peakaboo 5y agoI never gave my camera on. Engineering lead role.
- newshorts 5y agoHave they also considered the fact that I’m literally hopping from one meeting to the next with zero minutes of downtime? I mean when I was in the office we at least had to walk to a new room, now I’m always a few minutes late to the next meeting and literally just signed out of the previous one. I used to also take a lunch break, now I eat at my desk during meetings.
- matsemann 5y agoYes, and that it's 100% business. Hard to get a good social conversation in a remote meeting with 5+ people, so the real meeting starts right away, and when it's done everyone disconnect. Compared to a physical meeting where people will talk in smaller groups before and after.
- konschubert 5y agoIt's a cultural choice. In my team, standup takes 30 minutes because we spend the first 20 chit-chatting. It may seem like a waste of time but honestly it's a great mental kick-off for the day.
- fegu 5y agoWe always schedule meetings to end at 5 minutes to the hour, so people can get time to fetch another coffee etc.
- matsemann 5y agoTo make a different point than all the camera naysayers so far: I I'd be WFH for two years during covid, and everyone had their cameras off, I'd go crazy. Not seeing a face for months, being stressed about the other party in a meeting not even paying attention, just speaking into a void etc.
- tomrod 5y agoI actually enjoy video-off-first with the very occasional video share invitation. At first I thought I'd hate it, but now the stress of maintaining "meeting face" for hours on end is removed.
- jacobmischka 5y agoIt's extremely rude in my opinion when people simply don't turn their cameras on in virtual meetings. Unfortunately, no one at my workplace except me does.
- piva00 5y agoRude? Have you considered the other side? I'm extremely fatigued by having the camera on, I feel surveilled and every movement I do in front of it is calculated by my unconscious mind. It takes a real toll on my productivity having to have the camera on for a string of meetings. I feel it's extremely rude to dismiss others' experiences with the damn camera on for a virtual meeting. What is up that you need someone else to have a camera pointing to their face that you can't have with their voices? For most meetings that I don't require my computer I'll even go for a short walk around the house, while bouncing ideas, raising questions and so on. I feel much more productive in the meetings I'm able to disengage from my computer and surroundings and immerse on the conversation without having to care about a camera showing my face. Being very honest, being forced to turn my camera on is a major red flag, the fatigue is real and consumed me after a year on this, since last December I've been turning my camera off and it's been incredibly productive. Judge as much as you want but it seems you have no empathy, worse than that, you want to force your ways of working unto others without even considering others' struggles with it.
- lucumo 5y ago> following a day of virtual meetings I've done full days of real meetings. Those were exhausting and very draining. I'm surprised that anybody would expect anything different from virtual meetings. I have noticed that it's harder to feel people as fully human when they're little 2D movies. Even moreso when they're disembodied voices. It's less so when I've met the people IRL. I'm guessing I can then link their image or voice to the human I know. In my experience, there's also far less participation when everybody has their camera off.
- Gigachad 5y agoPersonally I have started leaving the camera on because it’s incredibly tempting to just use my phone and tune out with the camera off. I have also noticed that camera off people tend to speak a lot less than those with it on.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- b3morales 5y ago> I have also noticed that camera off people tend to speak a lot less than those with it on. I think you're implying causality from camera off to speaking less, but I'd bet that it's more likely the other way around. That is, people in meetings where they're pretty sure they have nothing to say don't feel they need to be seen if they're not going to be talking.
- fartcannon 5y agoLike those who can't touch type now, being exhausted by video calls may eventually be the exception. I expect to see a generational gap here. The twitch streaming, discord VC generation are not going to have the problems you're describing with video calls.
- BlargMcLarg 5y agoI'd argue against Twitch since these are more consumer-supplier. If anything, that'd prove the point of having only the primary speaker be visible while the remainder stays largely quiet or asks questions Q&A style. On the flipside I could argue the situation is more akin to playing a multiplayer game over VC, at least for meetings that aren't "let's stare at cameras for (half) an hour". Your virtual space is limited, so audio becomes a more favorable channel and cues on the visual side need to be a lot stronger than wishy-washy human cues to be effective (e.g. explosive sticker emotes, popup text). I'm sure anyone who has an idea can compare this scenario to your average "look at my screen" video call.
- beermonster 5y agoI found out early on on that meetings are much less fatiguing if I’m not looking at the web meeting app at all i.e. I have some document/code on my screen instead. If there is screen sharing involved so I have to look a the web meeting screen, I go full screen and minimise all their video streams which a) gets me more screen real estate, b) means it effectively becomes an audio only meeting at that point. We used to have a shortage of meeting rooms when having them physically and locally. This was great as it meant they naturally spread out over the week. Nowadays folk think they can get you to hop on a virtual meeting room in minutes regardless of what you’re doing. I’m very good at declining meetings where I think I’ll not be offering much value giving a reason why. I find quite often people want me in because they think I’ll enjoy it, or don’t want me out of the loop. They can summarise after by email if that’s all they want.
- vladvasiliu 5y ago> They can summarise after by email if that’s all they want. I sometimes get the feeling that, for some people, not having to write that (or any) email is the whole point of having people in meetings.
- zimpenfish 5y ago> for some people, not having to write that (or any) email is the whole point of having people in meetings Which can lead to some annoying problems where, for example, you might have several meetings where people harangue you for wanting things done in way X but then find out after you've spent two weeks doing things in way Y that they actually conceded on way X after those things but no-one bothered to write it down or communicate it in any way. (Not that this was a one-off; the whole company had a culture of meetings without notes or any kind of documentation.)
- sandos 5y agoNobody has the camera on at the engineering companies Iv'e worked. My SO though works in school kitchens, and they seem to have cameras on during meetings. I would find that really weird.
- mkl95 5y agoI find camera use exhausting. It feels considerably more demanding and awkward than meeting IRL. There are many benefits to working from home but avoiding endless meetings is still not one of them. I attribute it to all those years working at an office, which have made many people frustratingly bad at written communication and asynchronous work.
- ivalm 5y agoI’ve now worked at two companies in remote setting. First had cameras mostly off and my current (remote first) has cameras on. I vastly prefer cameras on as putting a face to a person makes interaction feel much more personal and connections much more real.
- fareesh 5y agoI don't turn on my camera for meetings. You really don't need to see my face. Anyone who says otherwise is not a serious person. We have been multitasking while on the phone for decades. This is no different.
- djmips 5y agoI think it's OK to have the camera turned off for meetings but if it's a company meeting or a more social catch-up I'd like to see my co-workers. So 99% of the time no problem. But once a week or once a month I'd like to see everyone.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- diroussel 5y agoDo you never nod in agreement when someone else is making a good point. Or use hand gestures? Also you can smile at a joke when you have your camera on. Sometimes it’s nice to have a joke with colleagues.
- skydhash 5y agoNice, but not required. I can share a joke fine over a phone call.
- kitd 5y agoWhere I work there are basically two types of meeting, one for mass participation (> 10 people) when a few are speaking and most are listening, and one for small team discussion, which tend to be focussed on screen sharing one or more person's screen. Neither of those need a camera. When meetings are 1-1, or maybe < 5, then they make sense, but I don't really feel the need for them otherwise.
- ratww 5y agoMy team had a discussion about that at a previous job. I also don't find cameras necessary, but me and some other people I know find that long 1-1 meetings with the camera turned off feels like a prolonged phone call, which is extremely tiring for people who also dislike long phone calls. Short camera-less meetings with quick, focused, telephone-like discussions are perfectly fine, of course. But if one of the parties has to keep going into a computer type a bunch of stuff in-between all the time, it suddenly feels like I'm trying to cancel my cable or newspaper subscription. It's better to have notes and do it later, or at lest share the screen, rather than only using 5 minutes out of 30 for actual talking. I found that some people who use Discord audio chats are used to having calls like that, but I'd check with the other person if they're ok before.
- magicalhippo 5y agoWhile I also find long 1-1 meetings tiring, the camera does nothing to improve this for me regardless of who has it on. What about seeing a face makes it less tiring than not seeing a face? Is this possibly an introvert vs extrovert thing?
- thinkingemote 5y agoFor me it's not seeing a face but also having my face seen. It's basically a kind of raised attentiveness. But generally virtual meetings are easy but that doesn't mean they are cheap. Where in person meetings were hard you knew they were expensive and had a kind of built in value of worth. Virtual meetings are easier but the costs are more hidden.
- 5y ago
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoIn my opinion more important than the cameras, we need to standardize some sort of 3d audio to distinguish 'spacially' between different speakers in meetings.
- klodolph 5y agoCisco has some systems like this. I've used them. It's neat, but it only really helps with a small number of participants. Also note that while audio is physically 3D, we are only good at distinguishing on a 2D plane. Basically, you easily get left/right, and you kinda get near/far, but you don't get up/down. Not unless you cock your head.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoI haven't found camera usage in meetings to be useful for anything other than raising the stress level of the participants. One of the benefits of working from home is not having to be dressed up for work when you aren't doing any client-facing activities.
- TrianguloY 5y agoFor me, camera off if possible, but don't mind turning it on if required. I also don't care if the other users have, and usually I prefer them off, but strangely I like it more when they have a profile picture, either a real life foto, an avatar or even an abstract drawing, something that allows me to "map" the sound to something while hearing it.
- INTPenis 5y agoOne advantage to virtual meetings is that we're no longer suffering the portal effect when we exit the conference room. I had one particularly bad manager who treated meetings like coffee brakes, anything we said or did was forgotten as soon as he stepped out of the room. There has been research done on this portal effect and how it makes us forget our current task.
- raz32dust 5y agoIn my experience, meetings definitely feel more productive when at least the key participants have cameras on. So I would not advocate for a "camera off" culture. Instead, something that helps me and might help others - When I am not speaking, I keep my camera on, but I don't keep the camera view myself - i.e, I don't watch myself or others. Instead, I switch to the content being shared/presented, if any. This helps me a lot, as I think a lot of the anxiety comes from having to watch myself, which is always uncomfortable and not something that we are used to. Secondly, I think virtual meetings are fatiguing also because of the constant staring at the screen. In in-person meetings, you spend a lot of time not looking at a screen, whereas you are constantly staring at a screen in a virtual meeting. Something that helps me is to take some of the meetings like 1:1s while walking with only audio.
- makeitdouble 5y agoSomething that is throwing me off in these discussions is how do you deal with documents ? You do have written support to guide the meeting, right ? Won’t you all be looking at that document, eventually taking notes, and not looking at the speaker ? Even when some people turn the camera on, I can’t imagine anyone in the meeting seeing more than their small tile in the corner while the main doc is front and center covering 90% of the window.
- Buttons840 5y ago> meetings definitely feel more productive when at least the key participants have cameras on. I agree with the corollary at least. If someone hasn't spoken for the last 5 minutes, they are not a key participant and can turn off their camera. The optimal middle path is probably that people sometimes have their cameras on, and sometimes don't. This option seems to get the least amount of consideration.
- DharmaPolice 5y agoI personally find the most productive meetings are where there is some kind of screen sharing on a document/something else. It gives something to focus on (so you're not tempted to read emails/do other things) and you don't have the annoyance/distraction of cameras (or they're only a small part of your screen). It's got better now days but at the start of the pandemic every other video call with over n people would have interruptions/digressions when someone's dog/cat/kid walked into the background of someone's video.
- yosito 5y agoNow that companies have recognized that remote is the norm and not a perk, I hope we start to see companies offering "Zoom-free remote" as a perk.
- pugworthy 5y agoAs someone who's partially deaf, I really appreciate camera on. It's a lot easier to understand people. I actually like Zoom meetings more than F2F at times, simply because everyone (with a camera) is equal - I see all their faces (and mouths) the same. F2F? Masks cover up faces, and we all have to stand far apart - horrible conditions for someone HoH.
- beranabus 5y agoI'm completely deaf and I can only recommend transcripts. Both zoom and teams have built-in transcription systems (though you have to enable them) and there is also an Android app called Google live transcribe. The former two work the best since everyone has a mic to their mouth and their voice never mix before going through the transcription system.
- baby 5y agoDid you see that google meet now live transcribes meetings? It’s insane!
- agustif 5y agoTranscripts (Used them in google meets, didnt knew about zoom and teams) are awesome also for non native english speakers too! Helps a great deal to have all (audio+video+text) to follow a conversation
- tomduncalf 5y agoAt my last workplace, we got into a “camera off” default in my team during the pandemic because one person initially had lots of connection issues with their wi-fi, and it kind of stayed that way even after that was resolved, but I felt meetings probably suffered from this in terms of people not participating (plus it’s nice to see people’s faces!). My new place doesn’t say anything about cameras but most people seem to go for camera on - but their policy (which was agreed upon by the team and is written down, which is great when you’re a new starter trying to work out the culture) is that they’d rather more people were invited to the meeting than fewer (so people don’t miss out on potentially relevant topics), but if you don’t think it’s relevant you’re under no obligation to attend and if it’s only somewhat relevant, you should feel free to get on with some other work or whatever. This seems to work pretty well in practice as there’s no “shame” to having your camera on and clearly be looking at another screen if the topic isn’t relevant, while still having the benefit of keeping your camera on if you are happy to.
- janto 5y agoI make a point of leaving my camera on, especially if I would tune out and do other things. The visual feedback is important for the speaker.
- buro9 5y agoI've spent much of the last couple of years trying to understand online meeting fatigue and experimenting with ways to address the fatigue. The fatigue comes in several forms: physical, experiential, psychological. Physical as in the act of being seating in poor posture, for long hours at a time and how this makes us feel. Experiential as in the act of seeing someone on a laptop screen as we are hunched over, they are dithered and the lighting is poor and they sound (their mic + my laptop speakers) muddied and unreal. Psychological as trust, empathy, rapport is founded on presence and connectivity, being able to communicate using gestures, body language, expressions... and how these are all muted or eradicated by the above two. It is addressable but it doesn't come for free. The article tested camera on vs camera off, but not the quality of the experience offered by camera on. Similarly the quality of the experience offered by the audio feels to be even more important than that of the video. To continue their experiment to an extreme... meetings where both the video and audio off wouldn't be fatiguing at all :D To address my experiential side I started with a good microphone, then a better camera, then better (more neutral) speakers. Lighting and positioning of the desk to improve my health as well as how natural I look. For the physical a sit stand desk that I actually do use multiple times per day, and some Birkenstocks help too - I stand for about 1/3 of meetings, and I always keep a bottle of water on the desk. I'm in an engineering leadership role and it's not unusual for me to do 6+ hours of meetings in any given day. At the start of the pandemic I had a lot of exhaustion from such meetings, but where I am now having overhauled my setup and my thinking about it is very different and I find that I really do feel connected and restored through seeing people (I'm more an introvert, and this form now feels like being an extrovert... it's a form of meeting people that I can do). As with anything, seek to understand the fatigue, seek to see how you can overcome it. It doesn't need a big shopping spree, I tweaked one thing every month or two until it all fell into place.
- jacquesm 5y agoWe are pretty small and have a 'camera on' policy for our one one hour meeting on Friday every week, and if you don't want to have your camera on you are asked not to participate, and an eight hour interview day every Tuesday. The only exception is for observers present during the meeting (for instance: customer representatives that do not have anything to contribute but are just there to listen and make their own notes). We ask them very explicitly to turn their cameras off. The whole idea of having a virtual meeting is to interact with people, the alternative is called a voice call or telephone conference. Virtual meetings are fatiguing, but they aren't nearly as fatiguing as the pre-COVID alternatives: flying in to some different EU capital once every week and staying in hotels. So I'm pretty happy with the way travel has moved to virtual meetings, it saves me at least two days every week besides the irritation of being on the move all the time. If you can't be bothered to have your camera on in meetings then you probably shouldn't be in that meeting in the first place. There is nothing more annoying than to have an in-person meeting from the past devolve into staring at a wall of stills or icons and then to figure out who says what and to keep a conversation going. Virtual meetings aren't perfect, but if you put some time and effort in they can be an efficiency improvement over real ones.
- neximo64 5y agoWhat do your team members say of your view to the idea?
- nzmsv 5y agoNobody speaks out against this stuff. People just quit and go to a truly remote friendly place instead. Next time you are in a conversation about remote work, see if you notice this: the only people who speak up are the ones who say "I can't wait to go to the office". The rest smile and nod. And yet online polls show a very different picture.
- fleddr 5y agoA massive red flag indeed, the parent comment is a text book example of traditional "manage by presence", not to mention an authoritative top-down culture.
- fleaaa 5y agoEnglish is not my mother tongue and I really appreciate when someone's camera is on. Lip, gesture, any language cue is very appreciated in general, even for remote session. If someone's mic is shitty built-in one and camera is off, it's hard to focus TBH. But I do agree that turning on camera constantly is tiring thing. I thought turning off the camera in the meeting can be considered rude but now I've changed my mind. I wish there were a middle ground for having a language cue in the conversation while the camera is off.
- hellweaver666 5y agoI agree that virtual meetings ARE fatiguing but guess what... a full day of in-person meetings is also fatiguing. Meetings ARE fatiguing. At least when I'm virtual I don't spend my day bouncing from one meeting room (sometimes in different buildings) to the next hoping to find a toilet somewhere in-between or have time to grab a coffee. I'll take virtual any day.
- fleddr 5y agoWe had a company-wide change where if you organize a one hour meeting in Outlook, it would actually schedule 45 mins. A well intended change allowing people small breaks, to stretch their legs, go to the toilet, grab a drink or just give their minds a break. Guess what the response was of the managerial class: alright, so to have a TRUE 1 hour meeting, I just schedule 75 mins? Way to miss the point. In my view, the costs of sending a meeting invite is just too low. There is no barrier at all to start useless and inefficient meetings whilst the human and productivity cost is enormous.
- noneeeed 5y agoWhenever this comes up in always surprised by how few people know they can turn off self view in Zoom. Doing this has solved this issue for.me. I wish Zoom would make it a default behaviour as I think it would help.a lot of people feel more comfortable in calls. Constantly staring at yourself in screen is weird and offputting.
- jsilence 5y agoGetting older my hearing starts to degrade and in addition to that I have a slight tinnitus in the cricket sound range. More than the camera bad audio quality it much more exhausting for me. Especially when project Partners are from other countries. Reverb, sub par microphone and a foreign accent is hard for me to compensate. Really wish everybody would invest in a decent lav mike and some acoustic treatment of hard walls.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andrewzah 5y agoIt’s interesting how people here are adamant that camera usage [all the time] is important or necessary. It isn’t. It's an opinion, and in my opinion, a bad one that isn't justified by anything. At my company we only use them if necessary, and I’ve been with them for over 3 years working remotely. We get work done quite well. edit: update wording for clarity
- varispeed 5y agoWe only use it for introductions and when someone has something to show, e.g. their pet. Unfortunately a new manager insists that everyone should have cameras switched on for "human connection" and so that people feel more integrated.
- avisser 5y agoI wouldn't discount human connection enough to quote it. I've been the only remote person on a team pre-pandemic. It was easy to see others as assholes who just cause work for me if you never/rarely put a face to
- foxfluff 5y agoI've also been the only remote person on a team pre-pandemic. I never needed the camera. We did use it for a stint but switched to audio only due to technical issues. Even when we had the cameras on, I'd quickly end up switching to another desktop and focus on information relevant to the discussion: issues, personal notes, meeting notes, code, schematics, datasheets, etcetra.
- prepend 5y agoYour anecdote doesn’t seem to convey that camera usage is not important, but it does show that it’s not necessary. It’s possible, I’d guess likely, that you’ve been able to get work done well in spite of no cameras. Of course, I doubt anyone would do an experiment to see if your statement is true or not. I just thought that your statement seemed so absolute but the evidence you present isn’t.
- incrudible 5y agoAnother benefit of just keeping cameras off is that it reduces the impact of lookism, which is exacerbated by camera distortion and unfavorable lighting. Of course, this puts stronger emphasis on audible cues. You may not realize it, but people can hear you smile. This is a bit anecdotal: People on the ASD spectrum may perform better on just auditory stimuli versus audio-visual integration. There's certainly a trade-off here, some people may strongly prefer having cameras on or off, but I feel that keeping cameras on is mostly just a default that is followed. Turning cameras off should at least be attempted.
- baby 5y agoLookism?
- incrudible 5y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27283466/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27283466/
- baby 5y ago> Lookism is a term that describes the discriminatory treatment of people who are considered physically unattractive. ... Many people make judgments of others based on their physical appearance which influence how they respond to these people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lookism#:~:text=Lookism%20is%20a%20term%20that,who%20are%20considered%20physically%20unattractive.&text=Many%20people%20make%20judgments%20of,they%20respond%20to%20these%20people https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lookism#:~:text=Lookism%20is%2....
- prepend 5y agoWouldn’t cameras off increase the impact of soundism?
- varispeed 5y agoWe had cameras on maybe for the first two weeks. Now nobody turns them on for meetings and I'd say it makes meetings so much more bearable, even better than in real life meetings. I have a condition where I can't sit still for an extended period of time. I have to move. So meetings where I couldn't just stand up and take a walk around the room or do some stretching were really really exhausting. Now we have a new manager who said he is planning to mandate that everyone has cameras switched on, so that there is "human connection" and to help people feel more integrated. Interestingly nobody said loud it is a stupid idea, but it's been two months since he announced that and still nobody is using cameras. I'll hand in a notice if it eventually goes through.
- prepend 5y agoI hate having my camera on, but leave it on all the time as it helps others in the meeting understand me. Not only to tell when I’m muted and speaking, but when I’m about to speak or am confused. It also shows when I’m bored and distracted. I’d rather the others know I’m distracted than not know and assume they have my attention. The way I think about it is imagining live meetings where people have boxes over their heads. For me, it’s not a question about wanting to have my camera on, it’s about professional conduct. I mean, I don’t want to go to work either, but I do.
- ashtonkem 5y agoTurning off self view is a good middle ground. Seems like a lot of people are distracted by their own faces. But in the long run the answer is fewer meetings. If you’re finding ways to make your meeting load less unbearable, something else is wrong.
- flerchin 5y agoAll day in-person meetings are no less draining than all-day virtual. Anyone who has done SAFe can attest. I turn my camera on for _every_ meeting. Not for me, but for my coworkers, and especially the PHBs that maybe would prefer remote-work to be over. I've given presentations to entire grids of black boxes, and it's shockingly disheartening.
- nottorp 5y agoOf course, the real answer is to have text group chats for most issues. Cameras on wouldn't be so stressful if you only did it once a week or so.
- softwaredoug 5y agoI leave my camera on but make it so I can't see myself, far more immersive. I try to pretend I'm in front of them in person. Also I recommend you forgive yourself/others for getting distracted. If you were getting coffee together, you'd frequently get distracted by the surroundings and ask the person to repeat themselves. It's not like you're in a therapy session where you have to pay deep, undivided, focused, uninterrupted attention on one person over an hour. That's really hard.
- sundvor 5y agoI've put some effort into my setup in the past 24 months; multiple Elgato and Hue lights, a Streamdeck for macros and scene control, condenser microphone on an arm with an audio interface, OBS studio etc. I am not a streamer, but I'm likely set up like one; I've studied their methods of light and composition, and learned a lot. I have some serious scarring from facial surgery decades past, and being able to control the light and setup has made a big difference in overcoming issues related to this; it has really helped put myself forward in the best light (pun intended). In this area of exclusively working from home, it was one worth spending effort on. I'm happy to put my (ugly) face in there, and really don't mind the virtual office. (Fun fact my camera is "only" a Logitech StreamCam, but the lighting makes such a difference. The ability to bring up and down the meetings with a single macro button on the Streamdeck is also invaluable.)
- par 5y agoHello, would love to learn more about what hardware you are using. I am in the market for a high quality condenser mic and arm to hold it. I am already using a Scarlett Solo interface. But would appreciate any info you can share on your light and audio setup. Also why do you need multiple elgatos? Just for convenience?
- nanny 5y agoWhat is your use case? There is really no need for a high-quality condenser mic in the vast majority of cases. For work meetings, voice chats, streaming, etc. the difference between an AT2020 and a high-quality mic will be entirely imperceptible.
- sdw1 5y agoTo be fair, the AT2020 is a high-quality mic compared to the dollar store AirPods your colleagues are using...
- nanny 5y agoYes, that's pretty much my point. The commenter above asked for a high-quality condenser specifically. I doubt they want a U 87, so it's probably better to ask a different question (e.g. "what's the best condenser for the money?"). The difference between those dollar store air pods and any condenser on the first page of Amazon search results for "condenser mic" is going to be huge, but past like $50-100 nobody will be able to notice a difference over voice chat.
- cm2012 5y agoI run an ads agency and I recommend cameras off on every call except the very first one with a client. It's just distracting, plus most calls should be screensharing an agenda 90% of the time anyway.
- thrower123 5y agoWe never used cameras before, when we were essentially working remote from our spaces in the office, and we don't use cameras now, when we are actually working remote. 99% of meetings that we have, somebody is sharing their screen to show a slide deck or an agenda or to walk through and troubleshoot something.