12 ms·
We are recreating the entire planet in Minecraft
- codefeenix 5y agooh, its the 11pm/2am HN front page.
- iamevn 5y agoI'm curious to check back in now that there seems to be a decent amount of stuff built. I explored a bit on a local copy last year and found the 1:1 scale combined with 1m³ resolution really disorienting. I wonder how they handle buildings being at angles that don't line up perfectly with compass directions.
- wyattpeak 5y agoSeveral of the example pictures show buildings at other angles, and they look like they handle angled lines in the obvious way, recessing the wall one block for each x blocks sideways. It looks a little odd but only in the same way a low-resolution undithered image does.
- tjs8rj 5y agoIs this all one large map? If so, since minecraft is flat, where do they cutoff the map (presumably you can’t go around the globe like in the real world)? Are they building based on the Mercator projection?
- loloquwowndueo 5y agoEverybody knows the earth is flat. Also before you ask - four elephants and then it’s turtles all the way down.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoNo, there is void under the bedrock.
- techbio 5y agoYes, the void causing what we experience as gravity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 5y agoIf they cut out the oceans they can kinda squish it flat
- dustintrex 5y agoThat's pretty much exactly what the Dymaxion projection does. Animated version: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dymaxion_map#/media/File:Dymaxion_2003_animation_small1.gif https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dymaxion_map#/media/File:Dymax... Fun fact: Dymaxion was invented by Buckminster Fuller of geodesic dome fame.
- dn3500 5y agoIt's a Dymaxion projection. It has low distortion over land at the expense of leaving huge gaps at sea. So you can't swim or fly across the oceans, or go around the world, but distortion will be low within each continent. https://www.gislounge.com/dymaxion-map-projection/ https://www.gislounge.com/dymaxion-map-projection/
- staplung 5y agoThat's a cool projection that I had never heard of. One thing it's also going to do is mess up the cardinal directions. E.g. in North America, north will be to the left. Might make things slightly confusing when you're trying to recreate stuff.
- peanutz454 5y agoThis is lovely, if only I could find a printable map so that I can paste it to cardboard to create flatable + 3D foldable - map + globe. Edit: First result on Google search (I was absentmindedly using bing earlier) is what I need : https://www.instructables.com/Dymaxion-Earth/ https://www.instructables.com/Dymaxion-Earth/ https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/smaprs/diary/39829 https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/smaprs/diary/39829
- tristanc 5y agoNot directly related to this project but in a similar spirit. Recently, while exploring france’s national geography department (Institut de Géographie Nationale [1]) website, I came across a page [2] which allows anybody to download a Minecraft world representing any 25km^2 area of France. The page lets you set the precise center and many other parameters such as whether to include buildings or even stylistic options. The maps are generated on the fly and make use of a combination of the department’s own datasets (digital elevation, road networks, land parcels, building dimensions and height, and even forests). I wish they would release whatever code they use for the terrain generation as I’m sure the open-source community would enjoy extending it with OpenStreetMap data! [1] https://www.ign.fr/ https://www.ign.fr/ [2] https://www.ign.fr/minecraft/ https://www.ign.fr/minecraft/
- nerbert 5y agoOn your second like it says that it works for the whole world (just tap "how it works")
- samplatt 5y agoSomeone got paid to make that. That was someone's job. That's freaking awesome. ...I wonder how tricky this would be to auto-generate in Unreal Engine.
- EamonnMR 5y agoThat would be an incredibly useful tool for prototypes
- ics 5y agoAutodesk Infrastructure is used in the architecture/engineering/construction world for this sort of thing. It is essentially a prototyping tool to combine any early stage data you have (aerial surveys, a mockup 3D model for a building, etc.) with existing geospatial data. It will give you terrain, roads, and buildings to varying degrees of accuracy. https://www.autodesk.com/products/infraworks/overview?term=1-YEAR&tab=subscription https://www.autodesk.com/products/infraworks/overview?term=1...
- alexshendi 5y ago"We are recreating the entire planet in Minecraft" Nice move, then we can all move to Minecraft, when we are finished with this planet and have used it up.
- Loveaway 5y agoMaybe we can. If you assume the mind is the constant in our reality - opposite to the traditional view, in which the physical world is supporting the mind - then we should be able to move into a virtual one. Maybe we're just layering worlds on top of each other, and old ones can become irrelevant, forgotten and disappear. Our current world could be just a virtual one, built on top something long forgotten, and will in time vanish when we move into Minecraft.
- grp000 5y agoI'm not sure about that. Spending any decent time in nature has a wholeness to it, it can feel "attuning" to some weird sense of self and how we fit in with it, maybe having to do with an evolved response?
- FeepingCreature 5y agoWhy would this not work in the traditional view? I have a hard time imagining a mind that can only operate in one specific reality, even in principle. How would you condition on it?
- bcherny 5y agoI just finished Egan’s excellent Permutation City, which has a fun and CS-heavy take on this. https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Permutation-City/Greg-Egan/9781597805391 https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Permutation-City/Greg...
- pugworthy 5y agoI presume you mean Computer Science, not Counter-Strike
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- elias94 5y agoI'm not familiar with Minecraft, but is there a way to export/save all this effort?
- reificator 5y agoMinecraft data is stored in a mix of JSON and a well documented/understood custom format. It's even documented in the same wiki that players use to learn how to play: https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Anvil_file_format https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Anvil_file_format The world files are saved unencrypted on disk and can be backed up, edited outside the game, and even converted easily to another format if another game somehow dethrones Minecraft in this niche. There are also a variety of viewers that render Minecraft worlds to map images or interactive maps a-la Google Maps. Finally the official Minecraft launcher allows players to choose any archived version of the game instead of forcing the latest and greatest. The only missing versions are very early development builds from 2009/2010. This ensures that even if a newer Minecraft version is released that is incompatible with this effort, the last compatible version will always be available. (Players can and do archive these versions themselves as well, this is not reliant on the official servers)
- wuuza 5y agoThat was very nice to read... seems like there's several features I wish were considered standard.
- vortico 5y agoIs this survival or creative mode? How does it deal with spherical topology while keeping the 1m^3 block size?
- King-Aaron 5y ago> How does it deal with spherical topology while keeping the 1m^3 block size? The earth is flat, haven't you heard?
- itake 5y agoThis is a longer video about the how they "flatted" the earth using a dymaxion-like conformal projection. The good parts start about the 4min mark. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0eyyuNvKNzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0eyyuNvKNzw
- baby 5y agoIn the video they mention that it’s creative mode because it would be too hard an endeavour in survival mode.
- FearlessNebula 5y agoDo they have some sort of Minecraft version control system? Can people work on a local copy and then merge their changes into the main branch?
- uuddlrlr 5y agoI've spliced chunks together using sh, dd, and xxd before to resurrect my gf-at-the-time's wolf. I've also been meaning to play psuedo-multiplayer with my friends by us each claiming a region in a seed. Each region being 32x32 chunks and saved to a separate file (.mca), you can just drop their latest region into your world folder to see what they've been up to, or play on LAN and send it back after.
- AlexSW 5y agoThis first one entertains me greatly; how'd that go? Sounds like a pain!
- paraph1n 5y agoMinecraft is a real time multiplayer game. People build together collaboratively. Think Google Docs, not VCS.
- jazzyjackson 5y agononetheless, it’s also a game that can be run on customized servers and has the capability to import objects and run scripts during gameplay, so you certainly can merge changes in a patch kind of way.
- asdff 5y agobukkit tools worked kinda like this where you could rollback chunks
- gaetgu 5y agoIt certainly would be possible, though I am not sure how they are doing it. More likely there is a server constantly running and backing up data, that people can join and make edits in real-time. EDIT: After looking at the website a bit more, it appears that there is a sort of VCS that is managed by the admins. Users make changes and send them to the admins, and if they are OK then they get merged into the main world.
- anonu 5y agoFor someone whos a complete n00b to minecraft: why? Seems to me that satellites and AI could do this much faster while keeping up with the pace of change...
- paulcole 5y agoDo you think speed and practicality are the goals of the project?
- vb6sp6 5y agoWhat AI tool out there produces 3d images from satellite imagery?
- DaltonCoffee 5y agoSatellite radar without any AI is one of the main sources of elevation models.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoIt would be missing all of the places the US government restricts. Like Dick Cheney's house. Not that it matters, because there will be tons of cool stuff. Like the Grand Canyon or Machu Picchu.
- pugworthy 5y agoI don't mean this as a joke, but you do it because it's fun. I and a few co-workers share a Minecraft server and find it an engaging social and creative outlet.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BugWatch 5y agoConsidering the Minecraft (unmodded) resolution (that is, its lack of it), I cannot help but to look at this as a giant wasted effort... and I am writing this as someone who has seen some amazing looking creations. But, while it might be easier to do, one meter is just too large for any decent experience with a more personal "face-to-block" virtual street walk. Having it built out of 20-centimeter sided blocks (with 1 meter as a starting option, and maybe even 10 cm for high-detail) would make it wastly more useful. For example, those could be useful for OpenStreetMap, a project everyone benefits of. Meanwhile, this will likely just disappear and just be written about as a footnote somewhere. Of course, the whole issue could be sidetracked if other primitives (with unconstrained sizes) were allowed/used. This lack of detail in construction was always my main issue with Minecraft, and its large blockiness usually goes so far as to induce/exacerbate my motion sickness. Speaking of OSM, they are currently taking the very easy-to-produce and simplistic parametric approximation approach through surveys, mainly via the StreetComplete app ("How many floors does this building have?", "Shape of the roof", etc.). Also, and I really am compelled to say this, StreetComplete is one of the most functional and most logical complex android apps I have ever encountered. It really shows it is built by the users, for the users.
- dragonsky67 5y agoI think this is a wonderful project being worked on by dedicated people who are taking the shortcomings of the technology and creating something amazing. Like anything art, the value is in the joy of the creator. The consumer of course has the right to dislike or like depending upon their taste. That said, I believe you should always acknowledge the skill and dedication of the creator, whatever their creative choice of media.
- seoulmetro 5y agoWithout the use of computers, 1m^3 blocks seems bad, but 0.5m^3 blocks seems impossibly harder.
- tzot 5y agoI assume you mean (0.5m)³, which is 0.125m³.
- rationalfaith 5y agoLiterally anything but actually tackle real world problems. Literally just improve your neighborhood and family, but no. Let's waste time shifting bits in a meaningless virtual world that was built for entertainment but has turned into a bad addiction.
- Lurkars 5y agoI would love to see this in Minetest, so it would be easier for everyone to join and the lack of Minecraft feature seems completely unnecessary to me for this.
- culebron21 5y agoEarth surface is about 500 trillion square metres, and if they make only the ground, it will be just 133 trillion of surface cubes. IDK how Minecraft stores cubes, but probably this will be 16-byte int, which makes 266 Tb. Factor in about 10x LZMA compression, this will take a size of ~26 terabytes of hard drive, or that order of magnitude. Not too much, I'd say. Still I don't think this is worth a form of art, given that 99% of landscape will never be seen by anyone.
- omegalulw 5y ago> Still I don't think this is worth a form of art, The whole point of art is to make something cool and creative and entertaining - if it needs to be "worth it" (practically) then it won't be an art.
- culebron21 5y agoNo, art does not have to be impractical. It was practical all the history of humanity, till mid XX century, when state-funded art galleries were captured by context-violating "artists", who invented this kind of excuse.
- prox 5y agoI really suggest reading the book “But is it Art?” by Cynthia A Freeland. Because history and context was a lot different then you describe.
- culebron21 5y agoI'd appreciate if you explain in more detail what I got/put wrong. I do attend modern art exhibitions occasionally, from garage exhibits to Venetian Biennale. I have friends working in it, recently worked at exhibition myself, and read on biographies of Renaissance and XIX century artists. I find a large chunk of "modern art" boring and definitely not entertaining. I don't see why making something so grandiose makes it entertaining. The impracticality argument is just one excuse that artists make when criticized for bad artwork. Other arguments are: * art hasn't to be X => a claim that it's fine anyway * you don't get it => a claim that there is a quality criterium, but the critic doesn't know it. Regarding the Minecraft map in question: what if it were a small area, like just a real castle? Would it be art too or not? Or it's not art, because it's of reasonable scale? If it would be still art, then what difference does the scale make?
- moss2 5y ago...how? Minecraft is flat, the Earth is a sphere. What projection will be used? Mercator? What will that mean for places close to the poles, like Greenland or Canada?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yreg 5y ago>Build the Earth project created a new map projection called Modified Airocean, based on the Dymaxion/Airocean projection. This map projection provides an extremely low amount of distortion of both shapes and sizes on land, at the cost of heavily distorting the oceans. Unlike a typical Airocean projection, Modified Airocean is not intended to be unfolded into a 3D object like an icosahedron, and has its continents placed such that it looks somewhat similar to an equirectangular projection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dymaxion_map#Impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dymaxion_map#Impact
- wohfab 5y agoI think a few questions could be answered with this video: https://youtu.be/0eyyuNvKNzw?t=242 https://youtu.be/0eyyuNvKNzw?t=242
- ginko 5y agoKind of surprized this is not in the FAQ.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cwillu 5y agoI look forward to reading "If the earth is a sphere, how was minecraft able to map the entire planet onto a flat surface?"
- new_guy 5y agoWhat a colossal waste of time.
- cunidev 5y agoOK - but why, if at least the majority of the work can be done algorithmically from known 3d projections? Also, the marketing words are quite... excessive at times
- Hamuko 5y agoI wonder about restricted military areas, North Korea, etc.
- billfruit 5y agoIs Minecraft the best tool for large-scale terrain/scene modeling? Are there better tools which are designed for such an application.
- censormenow 5y agoWhat a stupid waste of time