7 ms·
Hello advertisers. You are being manipulated and abused just like the consumers you are targeting. There is very little evidence to show that invasive digital
by jqpabc123 5y ago
Hello advertisers. You are being manipulated and abused just like the consumers you are targeting.
There is very little evidence to show that invasive digital advertising is actually effective. When was the last time you clicked on one of these ads and actually made a purchase?
Bad for consumers and bad for advertisers. Why continue with this opaque, profit sucking charade that mainly enriches those selling the ads?
- corobo 5y ago> There is very little evidence to show that invasive digital advertising is actually effective Wish.com would heavily disagree with you I'm sure. Almost everyone I know has ordered at least one thing off them, some use it more than Amazon these days for their overpriced useless junk needs
- criddell 5y agoWhere do they advertise? I've never heard of them... When I go to the website I can't see anything without logging in. What do they sell?
- corobo 5y agoFacebook and Instagram They sell random guff. They're eBay if you replace other sellers with Alibaba You're on hacker news mate, you are not their target market. Don't judge popularity with your blinkers on haha
- drunkpotato 5y agoWhat we found at a previous employer through extensive testing: advertising on Facebook works pretty well, but the highest return on ad spend was to not use any of the demographic tools at all. Also, weirdly, having an attractive product and displaying it well in photo and video ads did very well. Almost as if there is no real magic trick of effectiveness at all.
- corobo 5y agoNot even country based? When I tried without targeting I got a load of bots that tanked my page reach I paid to destroy my page haha. Fuckin Facebook
- drunkpotato 5y agoHmm, it may be that shopify blocked some bot traffic automatically.
- secondaryacct 5y agoFor us google ads was insane. I d encourage Google to keep record on everyone and everything after having seen how incredible their client to business matching is: as a small company, in a niche b2b product (waste management software), we got big name random calls days after starting to pay Google. In another company we spent millions on Facebook and got relatively little out of it (predatory lending marketing), we had again more success just reducing friction, simplifying the message and putting it on Google with massive keyword spam. The least we protected users, the more they paid us.
- dylan604 5y agoYou brag about having success advertising a predatory lending product?
- Dma54rhs 5y agoYou're tricked if you think so yourself, all the small businesses measure it and that is why FB and Google are so rich. Its like saying you're been tricked to think computers are useful for your productivity, it's insanity. You can argue if big corps spending just to keep coca cola on in front of your eyes is useful or not. To what extent but that's entirely different conversation. When was the last time you died? Death still exists.
- kbos87 5y agoAgree completely. The sentiment that this is all a shell game and advertisers are being completely manipulated always seems to come from people who don’t have much domain expertise. I’d be quick to throw digital advertising to the wolves but the reality is that it’s extremely effective. Is there a level of opacity? Yes. Are there tranches of junk traffic and ineffective tools put forth by the ad networks? Absolutely. But these are problems at the margins, and don’t invalidate the fact that advertising on Google and Facebook in particular are very effective, and measurable to enough of an extent that it makes sense to keep doing it and growing your level of investment. The majority of advertisers both large and small get that they can’t let the quest for perfection in advertising attribution be the enemy of progress.
- mdoms 5y agoNo one is saying "advertising doesn't work". We're saying that massively targeted invasive advertising is not significantly more effective than content based advertising. There's plenty of evidence for this assertion.
- amirhirsch 5y agoProvide some evidence then. Half of the people on this forum can contradict your comment from experience.
- mdoms 5y agohttps://techcrunch.com/2019/05/31/targeted-ads-offer-little-extra-value-for-online-publishers-study-suggests/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/31/targeted-ads-offer-little-...
- lordnacho 5y agoI don't know, I dabbled in ecommerce and while it wasn't a roaring success, people definitely did click the ads and buy the product, and I made a tiny bit of money. My guess is if someone actually knew a few more things than me they could make it work properly.
- croes 5y agoIt's not about effectiveness of ads but if it's more effective as previous methods and are the huge data collections necessary for the effect.
- y4mi 5y agoI'm pretty sure that most previous methods have had their effectiveness significantly reduced by how our society works nowadays. Most non-IT workers still don't use an AdBlocker, so you're actually getting your ads in front of the majority of the population. If you did the same with TV or even worse magazine ads you'd reach only a tiny segment of people, as the quantity of people consuming this kind of content has been drastically reduced.
- saimiam 5y agoWhile technically you’re right that most people don’t use as blockers, I was surprised to see that it’s as high as 42.7% that this link seems to claim - https://backlinko.com/ad-blockers-users https://backlinko.com/ad-blockers-users
- y4mi 5y ago> 42.7% of internet users worldwide (16-64 years old) use ad blocking tools at least once a month. That statistic is incredibly misleading. The amount of page views without adblocks is much higher then the insinuated 58%, because they're counting everyone as "using AdBlock" if they've used any device with an AdBlocker installed at any time within a month And a lot use AdBlock Plus, which also sells your usage statistics and only blocks ads from corps that didn't pay them.
- jstummbillig 5y ago> There is very little evidence to show that invasive digital advertising is actually effective. Ignoring the "invasive" (being a matter of definition) there is an absolute mountain of irrefutable evidence for google-type digital advertising being "effective", in the sense that an advertiser can spend 1$ to make 2$, measurably. > When was the last time you clicked on one of these ads and actually made a purchase? The answer is: It doesn't matter. Ads being clicked and thus stuff being sold is not a matter of personal opinion or observation. Spending and tracking online ad money works. Of course, on an individual level you can still lose money while advertising for a myriad of reasons. By the way, this is by no means an argument for advertisements (online/offline, "invasive" or otherwise). Advertisement as an industry does not create value. It's steering attention while sucking up money and there is also no reason to assume that it provides an inherent bias towards better products (the opposite likely being true). Also Google/FB could be defrauding their ad customers to an absolutely mind boggling degree. Being the deliverer, and also reporting on deliveries, it's insane that they can operate basically unregulated.
- Closi 5y ago> When was the last time you clicked on one of these ads and actually made a purchase? Also how often are the metrics inflated by people who were going to purchase anyway? I was booking a holiday yesterday and knew the company I wanted to book from - I typed in their name and clicked on the top result as that was the company I wanted. When I clicked back I noticed that they had the top two results - the first was an ad and the second was the organic link. I wonder if things like this really inflate the calculations companies do on how many acquisitions they get through the ad and their spend on the ad. I went back and clicked on the organic link instead and then checked out - but still wonder if somehow that counted as a “sale” from an “advert” in google analytics rather than me just wanting to find the company and book through them.
- cyborgx7 5y agoI read a lot of companies buy advertising specifically for their own name, because if they don't, a competitor will, and will appear first when someone googles the company name.
- Closi 5y agoYou are right - That’s another practice is morally dubious (And imo should be outlawed!) (Not on the purchasing companies side, but on google selling keywords for someone’s brandname which effectively forces companies into bidding for their own name)
- sharemywin 5y agoBut don't consumers have a right to see options. To me it's like a competitor buy a billboard or the location next store
- Closi 5y agoEh, I see it as different to a billboard - a lot of people use google as the only way to find your site where they type in a brand name to find your business (ie lots of people don’t use urls). This is putting a step inbetween someone trying to access your website where they HAVE to read about a competitor (because they have to read to see if it’s your site or not). Your competitor can even choose the wording of their link and description, while you are stuck with something google has arbitrarily chosen. It’s more akin to hiring people to stand outside the entrance of your competitors store, and when they see people going in they go up and try to convince the people to your store rather than the competitors.
- beefield 5y agoI dipped my toes to google ads the first time a few months ago. I am definitely not sure I understood it correctly, but I gave up very quickly as I got following impression[1]: 1. Google seems to define what are "relevant ads" for a given search term and if they are not deemed relevant, you are pretty much out of luck. 2. Google defines a minimum price for the auction, and won't show your ads below that even if there are no other ads shown 3. Google very aggressively pushes for me letting them define my bids for the ads. Like... What? Who and why in their right minds would let them do that? Like me going to buy a phone and the sales clerk told me that okay, give me your wallet, I'll tell you afterwards what you want to buy and how much you want to pay for it. [1]Also I admit, online ads were not that important for the business case, it was more curiosity than real need
- lazide 5y agoGoogle only wants to show ads that people will want to click on and are relevant, or they are wasting their own revenue by wasting the display slot. And one (but definitely not the most important one per your point #1) is how much someone is willing to pay for the slot. If you’re paying $100/click, but no one ever clicks on it because it isn’t relevant (like trying to sell real estate to someone trying to find used computer parts or whatever), they’ll still not show the ad.
- prepend 5y ago> 2. Google defines a minimum price for the auction, and won't show your ads below that even if there are no other ads shown This is the most frustrating one for me. It’s like if eBay enforced a minimum bid and wouldn’t list items. It’s not a true auction because of these minimum prices. It just doesn’t seem fair and transparent. Of course, it’s Google’s site so they can choose what they like. Unless they start breaking laws. For now, it’s just the annoyance of them not using “digital principles” by sticking to real world rules that they can make more money by adding friction rather than having an automated auction.
- jollybean 5y agoThis kind of rhetoric is problematically naive. Advertising effectiveness is often vague, but it also works well in many circumstances. It takes a certain kind of hubris to suggest that all these companies spending $500B on advertising have no idea what they are doing, and that if only they listened to HN/Reddit they could save so much money and make the world a better place. The issue here is to what extent G has manipulated their own auctions for their own benefit, and what kind of anti-competitive actions the relationship with FB amounts to.
- jqpabc123 5y agoPlease show evidence that Google's global privacy invading data collection network justifies their 3-4X premium in advertising cost over simple non-invasive alternatives. "Problematically naive" is assuming the cost is justified without any such evidence. Amazon's ad business is currently growing at a 70% annual rate by simply displaying ads based on search words --- probably because searching on their site is an overt expression of interest in making a purchase.
- webmaven 5y ago> Please show evidence that Google's global privacy invading data collection network justifies their 3-4X premium in advertising cost over simple non-invasive alternatives It really isn't. You can (maybe) justify a 2X premium on th basis of higher ad effectiveness due to superior performance. The rest of that margin comes from having the largest (by far) marketplace, which forces more buyers to bid against each other (raising ad costs), and more sellers to undercut each other (lowering publishers' ad revenues), in order to participate.
- floatingatoll 5y agoI happen to to agree with you, but this demand for proof is untenable and doesn’t promote good discussion. Any such proof would be guaranteed insufficient, as macroeconomics are by definition reductive and summary in nature, and the last thing we need is to nitpick econ to death in this thread.
- jeromegv 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beeboop 5y agomy fiance has bought several things that she saw constantly on instagram ads
- slavik81 5y agoMy mother bought water bottles with cat ears that were advertised on Facebook. My wife bought a Mandalorian carpet advertised on Instagram. I bought custom-printed Canadian postage stamps advertised on Google in wedding card-related searches. They're sold directly from Canada Post.
- goldenkey 5y agoMost of these products are leaded or toxic. I had a Mandalorian mug gifted to me by a dumb gen-Z friend of mine and it came with an Amazon return receipt showing it came from a 3rd party seller despite the availability of the same official LucasFilm mug being sold by Amazon.com. I don't trust products from random sellers so I scratched off some of the glaze and tested it for lead, and what do you know..it was leaded. Buying from random sellers is a recipe for allergic reactions, toxicity, bad airdoor air quality from off-gassing, ad infinitum. If you have pets, toddlers, or care about yourself, you should be very careful what objects you put around your home. A shady pillow or carpet could be destroying your air quality with VOC dyes. I gave the friend a stern talk but it's doubtful I changed the habits of an uninformed consumer. When shady manufacturers are willing to do this kind of substitution on pet food [1] and medical supplies [2], one should expect any kind of safety regulations for fabrics, dyes, paints, etc to be ignored as well. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_pet_food_recalls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_pet_food_recalls [2] https://www.cnn.com/2021/10/24/health/medical-gloves-us-thailand-investigation-cmd-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/10/24/health/medical-gloves-us-thai...
- slavik81 5y agoI'm not a very trusting person. The custom stamps I purchased were ordered directly from the government's official website. I simply didn't know the product existed before I saw the advertisement. The rug was from ruggable.com (which seems fine) and the water bottle was ZOQQ (which looks questionable no matter what store it's purchased from). I can't control the behaviour of others, but it's somewhat beside the point. I was giving examples of when the advertising worked. Whether it should or not is a whole different topic.
- dragonelite 5y agoThe thing is people assume everybody that is browsing is like your average hackernews user. But my mom for example continuously clicks on those ads on Facebook. I my self sometimes click on ads that shows some tooling usually I then go to Alibaba and find the unlabeled tool for like 1/3 the price drop shippers or asking.
- wildrhythms 5y agoI agree, reading these comments I get a sense of tunnel vision among tech-literate people. I used to work in IT and it is not hyperbole to say that average content consumers click on almost every even vaguely appealing ad put in front of them.
- phonebucket 5y ago> Hello advertisers. You are being manipulated and abused just like the consumers you are targeting. Do you have much evidence for this? Advertisers don’t spend big bucks blindly. Many companies have significant data science teams that keep an extremely close watch on ad spend return on investment.
- rrix2 5y ago> Do you have much evidence for this? Read the complaint in TFA... you can spend big bucks and even actually come out ahead in that, while being manipulated and filched by Google and Facebook. Both of these things can be possible while one of them is illegal behavior (engaging in price-fixing cartels) and one is simply immoral to many of this forum
- merrywhether 5y agoThat doesn’t mean they aren’t all being price-gouged (per the AG’s complaint) for instance. Paying protection to the mob also strongly correlates with your store not burning down in the middle of the night. We just don’t know how different things could be without this level of monopolistic distortion (which I admit could mean that without Google things _could_ be worse?)
- criddell 5y agoThe Freakonomics podcast did a short series on advertising and it turns out advertisers often do spend big bucks blindly.
- Verdex 5y agoThe only advertising that advertisers have to do that actually makes a difference is advertising their services to their customers (and this would include an in house advertising division convincing the rest of the company that they're sufficient effective). If they can actually show the effectiveness of an advertisement then good. If not they you fallback on "mindshare". Really the people we need to be reaching are product owners et al.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]