5 ms·
I mean, the only real answer is "it depends on the writer," but given the general way the transporter is supposed to work most of the time (converting matter to
by krapp 5y ago
I mean, the only real answer is "it depends on the writer," but given the general way the transporter is supposed to work most of the time (converting matter to energy, transmitting the energy somewhere, then reconverting the energy back into matter and reassembling the original thing) then... yes, the original Kirk dies, and a facsimile Kirk comes out the other end.
If that kind of technology really existed (especially given its 'fail states' like merged beings and clones,) I would assume people's concept of what "life" and "death" and "self" were would be radically different than today. If what comes out the other side is you, down to the quantum level (the show had to come up with a "Heisenberg compensator" to explain how this was possible,) what does it matter if the "you" entering the transporter ceases to exist?
- mromanuk 5y ago> I mean, the only real answer is "it depends on the writer," but given the general way the transporter is supposed to work most of the time (converting matter to energy, transmitting the energy somewhere, then reconverting the energy back into matter and reassembling the original thing) then... yes, the original Kirk dies, and a facsimile Kirk comes out the other end. I agree. > what does it matter if the "you" entering the transporter ceases to exist? A lot! Most of us are hardwired to know that If you die, you die and knowing that a perfect copy would exist, doesn't compensate that.
- imtringued 5y agoSeparate the body and mind. Attach a special device to the head that lets you store the digitalized memories of that person in a chip. Remove the chip, transport the body and then reinstall the chip. Go one step further and digitally transfer the chip's data to another chip at the other end, insert the chip into the body. It's clear that each new body is a new person but with the same memories. For outside observers the chip is precious, the body is not. In other words, death and murder are socially accepted.