7 ms·
Truckers are leaving containers all over Los Angeles.[1] Allowing stacking over 2 high is only useful if you have the equipment to stack over 2 high. A place t
by Animats 5y ago
Truckers are leaving containers all over Los Angeles.[1]
Allowing stacking over 2 high is only useful if you have the equipment to stack over 2 high. A place that just stacks empty containers 2 high probably only has large forklifts. The special equipment for high stacking is far more expensive, and only bought if you need it.[2]
A more useful proposal is a "peel pile".[3] This is a system which assigns outgoing trucks an easily accessible container to deliver, rather than a specific container that has to be retrieved. There's an app for that. This is being implemented by IMC, the largest marine drayage company in the US. They say they're already up to 8 high stacks in the LA area. The higher the stack, the longer the retrieval time.
"This keeps drivers moving and productive, even if they don’t know the exact load they’re getting or the delivery location." So it's really dumping the sorting problem on drivers. They have no idea where they're going next. There has to be some way to separate containers by approximate location to make this work, so a driver knows how far they're going to be asked to take the thing.
How well this all works depends on how well the software organizing the stacking works.
[1] https://jalopnik.com/the-streets-of-los-angeles-are-overflowing-with-cargo-t-1847917927 https://jalopnik.com/the-streets-of-los-angeles-are-overflow...
[2] https://www.bison-jacks.com/why-bison/blog/how-to-lift-a-shipping-container/ https://www.bison-jacks.com/why-bison/blog/how-to-lift-a-shi...
[3] https://www.peelpile.com/ https://www.peelpile.com/
- jasonhansel 5y agoThough efficient, this sounds incredibly stress-inducing for drivers, since it makes them even less able to plan ahead and know their future work schedule.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoCouldn't large forklifts that have enough weight capacity to lift one full container and enough height capacity to lift an empty container on top of another simply pick up a stack of two containers from the bottom at the same time and put the two on top of a third, making a three-high stack?
- JohnHaugeland 5y agothe top one will fall off in the process, and most of the forklifts aren't meant for that angle of leverage
- wbl 5y agoThe driver has a cellphone no?
- wcarss 5y agoThat's neat, but isn't this whole thing about stacking restrictions on empty containers? My understanding of what the Flexport CEO said in their twitter thread was that the best example of the problem is the haulage company that's keeping its driver count * 3 empty containers around on-chassis (which I think means on wheels), just sitting in their parking lot, because they have nowhere to put their empties, because they empty-storage is maxed out at the 2-height capacity. All/most of the haulage company's chassis are now tied up with empty containers, which prevents them from being able to go pick up filled containers to ship, which stops the full containers from getting picked, etc.
- jeffrallen 5y agoIf they are getting paid per delivery, it seems they could find a quarry or an unused airstrip to dump empties on for a small price. When Tesla needs space urgently, they put up a tent. When the military needs to start a war they manage somehow to unload their tanks. Come on, USA, we still know how to do stuff...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 5y agoAll places I have done real estate development require permits for putting containers on your land, and it is not a quick process to get one. At the least, you usually have to justify why you need the container space and for how long. And I cannot imagine a local zoning board wanting to go out on a limb to do something novel like approving containers just because a port is backed up.
- lostapathy 5y agoAs this is a short term problem and part of a national crisis ... just stack them up, and get them removed in the near future. Any place big enough to stack up enough containers to matter (stadium parking lot, dead airport, etc) isn't going to have neighbors that raise a huge stink immediately, and the wheels of zoning disputes take times. Heck, budget the possible fines into your business plan for holding the containers. Delivery firms already budget for tickets from parking illegally to make deliveries. This isn't so far removed from that.
- polote 5y ago> Truckers are leaving containers all over Los Angeles.[1] There are so many of them, that they couldn't find a picture of one of them to illustrate the article
- GuB-42 5y agoG/O media is particularly terrible with illustrations. They once had an article abut the ISS with a picture of Mir as an illustration. I think they have a contract with a stock image provider, no photographer, and no one to seek out and license original pictures. Writer are probably asked to select an illustration in their stock image library. I think it is a disgrace to journalism. The front picture is, with the title, the most important part of the article, do some effort FFS, or don't put a picture at all.
- irrational 5y agoWhat is G/O media?
- jrockway 5y agoThat's the name of the company that publishes Jalopnik. Scroll down to the bottom, "Copyright 2021 G/O Media Inc".
- dangrossman 5y ago> G/O Media Inc. is an American media holding company that runs Gizmodo, Kotaku, Jalopnik, Deadspin, Lifehacker, Jezebel, The Root, The A.V. Club, The Takeout, The Onion, and The Inventory - Wikipedia
- saagarjha 5y ago> G/O was formed in April 2019 when Great Hill Partners, a private equity firm, purchased the websites from Univision for $20.6 million. Is it just me or is that a shockingly low amount for those websites?
- potiuper 5y agoMost of the stacks are already at 6 high https://www.tiktok.com/@stanimal18/video/7019310183545376006 https://www.tiktok.com/@stanimal18/video/7019310183545376006. The automated storage & retrieval system cannot go higher. Peel pile would be great if the empty containers did not have to be taken to Dallas. It is questionable if this is a government failure to zone empty buffer yards out in desert as there would be even less of an incentive to return the empty containers; changing the zoning at the secondary yards does not fix the underlying incentive issue and should only be put in place once the ratio of the rate at which new containers are being received to the rate at which containers are leaving begins to decline to accelerate the removal of the bottleneck. The storage fee needs to be raised to a point at which it is justifiable to move the empty containers out over processing fully loaded containers until the storage bottleneck is removed. Changing the zoning before figuring out the rate problem almost surely will just make the bottleneck worse. It would also be interesting to know if it would be feasible to make the containers able to be disassembled and multi-packed into an empty container.
- Jolter 5y agoThe way I read the linked article, the idea is to use peel piles for drayage only. That is, for goods that is due for shorter trips within the same urban area, not for long-haul freight. I think it seems like a part of the solution by virtue of having some potential for lowering drivers’ waiting time and maximizing the speed of emptying out a fully stacked terminal.
- toast0 5y agoThose 6 high stacks are the ones at the port. From the thread, there are plenty of smaller secondary lots outside the ports where empties are being stacked, because the ports won't accept them, and there's room. The zoning based stacking limit affects those secondary yards, but not the port yards. A real question is if the secondary yards have equipment to stack higher or if they can really only go two high, because they were limited by zoning anyway. > It would also be interesting to know if it would be feasible to make the containers able to be disassembled and multi-packed into an empty container. Not really; everything's welded together, and if you unweld and reweld, it's not going to be as strong. Plus that's a lot of labor. There are some collapsible containers, but those tend not to have sides or a top, which is not ideal for ocean shipping.
- btown 5y agoIt sounds like these are complementary solutions, no? Some yards have stacking equipment, some don't. It seems far more reasonable to let them become "sinks" for containers, which they'd gladly do and which would require nothing other than removing red tape, rather than requiring adoption of a more complex routing system.
- intricatedetail 5y ago> This is a system which assigns outgoing trucks an easily accessible container to deliver, rather than a specific container that has to be retrieved. This is such an obvious thing. Do they really have people so incompetent they didn't think of that? Wow
- bobthepanda 5y agomy understanding is that not all containers pay the same (since they are different weights, have different destinations, etc.) and so this mostly screws over the driver who loses the ability to select the best offer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SteveGerencser 5y agoNot only do containers not pay the same, but containers to the same location often don't pay the same. So many variables and often the driver is the one that ends up getting screwed in the process. I completely understand why so many simply refuse certain loads. And getting assigned a load you know nothing about before it's on your truck is a no go for most drivers.
- eecc 5y agoIsn’t that a market failure? I mean the rhetoric of free unregulated market is that the “homo economicus” would use total information and make fully conscious decisions. Seems like some are withholding information to push other actors to make bad deals, externalize losses and generally speaking skirt from supply/demand dynamics.
- SteveGerencser 5y agoNo, it isn't. Most, or at least a very high percentage of independent truckers bid for cargo runs. Your cargo needs to get from point A to point B and weighs X amount and needs pickup and delivery at certain times. Truckers bid on the those routes and the the winning bidder gets the route. If you don't want a delivery you don't bid on it or you set your bid high enough to make you want to take it. If no one bids on a delivery then the shipper raises the maximum they will pay and the process starts all over. Delivery location or pickup location a horrible place? Again, don't bid or bid high. This is exactly the definition of a free market. Telling an independent that they must take the next load available without letting them decide if they even want it is not. That's being an employee. And shipping companies have spent years getting rid of their own fleets and drivers to push the cost to the individual drivers. And yes, there are a LOT of apps for this.
- maxk42 5y ago> Allowing stacking over 2 high is only useful if you have the equipment to stack over 2 high. A place that just stacks empty containers 2 high probably only has large forklifts. The special equipment for high stacking is far more expensive, and only bought if you need it. This begs the question: If container storage were the only bottleneck, wouldn't operators merely lease space further afield? There's plenty of space in Corona, San Bernardino, and environs that wouldn't take more than a 30 minute commute each way. I can't help but feel like there are other confounding factors at play.
- twic 5y agoWhat if they stood the containers up on end?
- kayodelycaon 5y agoThe ends aren’t flat and the containers aren’t structurally designed for that. You’re putting twice the designed load for the bottom of the container on an end that wasn’t made to support that. I’d imagine it would do a fair amount of damage.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThen you have the problem of picking it back up again. When it's right-side-up, you can get under it. When it's on end, you can't.
- CalChris 5y ago> Allowing stacking over 2 high is only useful if you have the equipment to stack over 2 high. These are empty containers that are getting unloaded and stacked in order to free up the truck and its chassis for another load. The equipment for doing that stacking/unstacking is called an Empty Container Stacker [1]. These are different from a Reach Stacker [2] which will have much less vertical reach and are also different from Container Cranes [3]. [1] https://www.goldbell.my/material-handling-equipment/port-handling-equipment/91-empty-container-stacker https://www.goldbell.my/material-handling-equipment/port-han... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reach_stacker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reach_stacker [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Container_crane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Container_crane
- sbierwagen 5y agoOkay, how many empty container stackers are there in LA county?
- CalChris 5y agoPlenty. That isn't actually the important question or rather important problem. The storage yards are currently stacked X x Y x 2 and now they need to be re-stacked into something like X x (Y / 2) x 4 to free up space for more empties but that re-stacking has to happen from the edges. That will take a little time.
- test6554 5y agoA couple strategic gaps between the stacks could make this process go much faster. The short-sighted lack of these gaps could make things slow going.
- ars 5y agoYou only need a single lane free. You start on one side of the yard, and stack it to 6, then work your way across the yard building rows.
- 5y ago
- gpspake 5y agoSidenote... I think this might be the first time I've personally heard "There's an app for that" to essentially indicate "this is a solved problem" - even if in this case it does kind of mean "software exists to solve this problem" in a literal sense. We're only a decade or so out from when "there's an app for that" represented this cool new novel idea that you could install an app on your fancy new smartphone to do something useful. Now it's trivial and commonplace but I could see this slogan sticking around in our vernacular outside of its original context kinda like the save icon. Neat.
- Animats 5y agoI wrote "there's an app for that" because IMC does have an app for that.[1] Also a web site.[2] Drivers need to be able to talk to the container dispatching system. That's a side issue, though. As the number of containers in temporary storage increases, system throughput drops. So, once you get into overload, you're stuck there until you somehow reduce traffic or get more capacity. That seems to be the current situation. It's not just at the US end. Shipify reports about 200 ships stuck waiting to get into Chinese ports.[3] (That article has a good overview of the situation.) At the China end, there's an empty shipping container shortage. Back in July, US farmers were also complaining about an empty shipping container shortage.[4] Ship lines wanted to load up and get out, because the China->US rate is currently much, much higher than the US->China rate. So loading up containers at the US end apparently cost time and profits. The way empties are handled is driven by a system of economic incentives to not hold onto empties, and apparently that's not working well enough to get containers back to someplace useful. Someone has to pay to ship the containers back. [1] https://apps.apple.com/us/app/imcs-mydriver/id1299727364 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/imcs-mydriver/id1299727364 [2] https://www.imcsmartstacks.com/ https://www.imcsmartstacks.com/ [3] https://www.shiplilly.com/blog/container-ships-now-piling-up-at-anchorages-off-chinas-ports/ https://www.shiplilly.com/blog/container-ships-now-piling-up... [4] https://www.farmprogress.com/trade/shipping-container-shortage-getting-worse https://www.farmprogress.com/trade/shipping-container-shorta...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]