9 ms·
20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction
- causi 5y agoInteresting. I wonder how you square that with results from "are you happy?" surveys comparing the religious and irreligious.
- xabotage 5y agoSurvivorship bias. Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. This leaves those who are either too afraid to confront the cognitive dissonance or who were already happy in the first place.
- azinman2 5y agoWhere do you get the premise of religion being a happier life?
- xabotage 5y agoI never said it was, I'm not sure why you think I did.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoYour answer of "survivorship bias" hints that you are assuming the parent's "are you happy" is a yes. Assuming for argument's sake, that is.
- xabotage 5y agoThe post title implies religiosity != happiness, the parent implied other results might differ, my comment was a response to that possibility, for the sake of argument as you said.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoFor most faithful, the answer would be 'experience'. People happy in their faith tend to stay. Those who aren't tend to leave eventually.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. I think there's a chasm or 10 between declining a responsibility and denouncing your faith.
- dash2 5y agoReverse causality or unobserved confounds. Maybe happy people are more likely to become or stay religious. Maybe living in an area with strong community makes you happier and you also get dragged along to church (but the two do not influence each other).
- onion2k 5y agoBelieving you are happy and actually being happy are different things. Religious people believe that they're happier than other people, but they're not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- inter_netuser 5y agolink? is that in the study?
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago>Believing you are happy and actually being happy are different things Even if that were true, the two likely wouldn't be distinguishable in any meaningful way.
- onion2k 5y agoYes they would. If you ask people if they're happy they'll say yes. If you actually measure it by observing what people do they'll exhibit behavior that shows they're not actually happy. Self-delusion is a well researched topic. There are many studies.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> If you actually measure it by observing what people do they'll exhibit behavior that shows they're not actually happy. The best part of this notion is the inverse where miserable people are doing happy people things.
- sammalloy 5y ago> The best part of this notion is the inverse where miserable people are doing happy people thing Sartre called it “bad faith”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_faith_(existentialism) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_faith_(existentialism) I know a lot of religious people like this. On the outside, they seem like the happiest people you’ve ever met, but once you get to know them, it turns out that they are miserable, and that the religious beliefs and behavior that they embrace are used to self-regulate their mental states. The more extreme religious people appear to be suffering a type of scrupulosity unique to disorders like OCD, and many sufferers will tell you that they are not happy.
- mensetmanusman 5y ago“ Meta-analyses have pointed to a positive relationship between religiosity and a person’s evaluation of their life, suggesting that people who are more religious tend to feel better about their lives. But researcher Mohsen Joshanloo remarks that these studies have not offered strong evidence of a causal relationship between the two variables. “ E.g. maybe happy people are more likely to be religious, but like with most social science, there is no way to test this with the scientific method because of ethical reasons. My favorite stat is that weekly church goers report the highest satisfaction in their sex lives.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> My favorite stat is that weekly church goers report the highest satisfaction in their sex lives. That's really interesting. Is there more data? Any differences between the sexes? Age?
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> My favorite stat is that weekly church goers report the highest satisfaction in their sex lives. Going by kid-count I'd wager we're talking Catholics and Mormons.
- paulryanrogers 5y ago> My favorite stat is that weekly church goers report the highest satisfaction in their sex lives. While I can't find the source now, my favorite stat is that paid-per-view porn spikes during Christian men's conferences. EDIT: ^at hotels
- rahimnathwani 5y agoThe attendees watching at hotels? Or their families watching back at home?
- paulryanrogers 5y agoAttendees at hotels
- dustingetz 5y agoThe point of religion is to solve civilization-scale game theory coordination dilemmas. "Thou Shalt Not Kill" is a mutually beneficial metastable equilibrium but is only stable to the extent that it is a universally adopted principle. A lot of modern tragedies like climate change can be tackled in this way if we can establish universal shared values that apply to all people independent of nationality, status and in particular, education. It needs to be comprehensible to all 7 billion people for them to adopt it, including areas of the world with low literacy.
- netizen-936824 5y ago>"The point of religion is..." Citation please
- inter_netuser 5y agoExcellent demonstration of the point of the peer-review religion.
- dustingetz 5y agoMyerson, Roger B. 2009. "Learning from Schelling's Strategy of Conflict." Journal of Economic Literature, 47 (4): 1109-25. http://home.uchicago.edu/~rmyerson/research/stratofc.pdf http://home.uchicago.edu/~rmyerson/research/stratofc.pdf "To focus attention on one equilibrium with no higher appeal, it would be best to consult the highest possible authority. If the players share a cultural understanding that certain unpredictable processes may be used by the fundamental divine spirit of the universe to answer questions, and that this divinity cannot be bothered about the same question more than once, then a recommendation that is based on such a sacred randomization can serve as a focal coordination device that cannot be appealed to any higher arbitrator. Then the oracle's recommendations can be self-enforcing, without any further intervention by the divine spirit, provided that the recommendations to the players form an equilibrium. Thus the focal-point effect can admit a socially significant role for oracles and divination, as an effective foundation for social coordination. Indeed, when we look for effective focal factors, what can command people's attention more than the overall pattern of the whole universe? This divine pattern can serve as a focal determinant, however, only when players have a shared understanding about it can be interpreted into a selection among the set of Nash equilibria of their game. ... "In any society, it is vital to maintain a broad general agreement about who has legitimate authority in any situation. Thus, from our earlier remarks about the focal power of the divine, we can see why societies may find it useful or even essential to call for frequent testimony that the local system of rules and authority is compatible with the divine pattern of the universe. Although coordination within a society can be improved by such belief in the universal nature of its principles of justice and legitimate authority, such universalization of local law and authority makes it harder for people in one society to recognize the different forms of justice and authority in other societies (see Myerson, 2006). That is, the same forces that help people to achieve consistent coordinated expectations in a successful society can become forces for inconsistency of expectations across societies in international relations. Indeed, in international conflicts throughout history, people on each side have regularly failed to understand the other side's perception of justice in their conflict. ... "The focal-point effect may even offer a perspective on some ideas of theology, not about the nature of the divine, but about how societies use the divine. The focal-point effect is about environmental parameters that attract people's attention to one of many equilibria, and no aspect of our environment has a stronger claim on our attention than the divine pattern of the entire universe. Thus, coordination in a society can be strengthened when it culturally portrays local forms of law and authority as derived from universal divine principles."
- dash2 5y agoNot sure I like the easy assumption here that "panel study" = causality. Suppose I get happier. Then I go to church more. The use of some complicated-ass Granger-causality-style technique also makes me trust it less. This natural experiment looks more interesting, although it exploits just a temporary shock (variation in the length of Ramdan): https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/130/2/615/2330341?login=true https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/130/2/615/2330341?login... "We study the economic effects of religious practices in the context of the observance of Ramadan fasting, one of the central tenets of Islam. To establish causality, we exploit variation in the length of daily fasting due to the interaction between the rotating Islamic calendar and a country’s latitude. We report two key, quantitatively meaningful results: (i) longer Ramadan fasting has a negative effect on output growth in Muslim countries, and (ii) it increases subjective well-being among Muslims. We find evidence that these patterns are consistent with a standard club good explanation for the emergence of costly religious practices: increased strictness of fasting screens out the less committed members, while the more committed respond with an increase in their relative levels of participation."
- noobermin 5y agoDid I misread the article? They just found that it was uncorrelated for individuals who became religious during the study (that is, temporally there is no effect) but positively correlated between people, and neither of those shows causality. For the temporal result, it at least negated it being causal.
- dash2 5y agoA zero correlation across time also doesn't prove that there isn't causality. Suppose that there's (e.g.) a positive relationship due to an unobserved third factor, and a negative relationship which is genuinely causal. These two could cancel out in the observed data.
- mistrial9 5y agonext up - two thousand year study shows religion is not going away. signed - religious person
- Yoric 5y agoI know a few other religions with prior art on the topic :)
- orwin 5y agoTen-thousand year study, you mean. At least. I'm not an antiquity specialist, but from what i've heard the first monotheism was probably zoroastrism (might have been a duotheist religion as first, with their Satan equivalent being as powerfull as their version of god), and might have appeared more than ten thousand years ago. Followed by some version of Hinduism, then either the Aton cult or judaism (i've heard theories about Judaism started becoming a monotheism after an exile from egypt of Aton priests).
- mistrial9 5y agoGnosis magazine -- recommended
- kirse 5y agoOn hearing this, Jesus said to them, "It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners." -Mark 2:17
- mgamache 5y ago“It is impossible to manufacture or imitate love”. – Horace Slughorn, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
- pessimizer 5y agoIs "life satisfaction" a virtue? Are better lives distributed to better people?
- chippy 5y agoThere was an interesting little snippet I heard the other day, it was something like "the idea that Religions are things to do that improve ones life puts it in the self-help section of the bookshop." The answer to that I'm more foggy on but its something like "religion is something we are called to do, it's not a shelf in a bookstore or something to be bought into. It's the entire bookstore and it's the city the store is in."
- xabotage 5y agoMore appropriately, Religion is the rent-seeking landlord of the bookshop who skims all the profits, provides little to no value, and takes all the credit for the literacy of the townsfolk.
- curiousgal 5y agoPerfect example of why I firmly believe psychology research is trash. Studied population: 4167 American adults. Conclusion: All religions are bad.
- noobermin 5y agoN=4167 for a longitudinal study is fantastic, actually.
- curiousgal 5y agoFor a medical study sure, for a subjective field where society and culture play a major role, even N=1e7 of individuals living in the same country wouldn't be enough to draw a conclusion on the entire human population.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>wouldn't be enough to draw a conclusion on the entire human population. Which is why the study does not draw a conclusion on the viability of all religion, it merely says that it doesn't see much evidence that religiosity leads to life satisfaction. The author even notes "these results need to be evaluated within the context of the study." Hardly the wholesale dismissal of religion you claim it's making.
- srcreigh 5y agoThe author has done other studies for different questions. https://mohsenjoshanloo.weebly.com/publications.html https://mohsenjoshanloo.weebly.com/publications.html
- User23 5y agoDoes anyone know what the study author actually means by religiosity? I couldn't find the "supplementary material," just a three page paper that shows some tables. Without knowing what the term means in this context it's hard to interpret the finding. Are they lumping together Christians, Buddhists, Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Mormons, and every other faith tradition present in the USA in any quantity together? I'd be willing to bet that even within one of those religions you might find wildly different results. For example Latin Mass attending Catholics who honestly try to live the Church's teachings fully may report a different happiness level than casual Catholics who show up to Church occasionally and don't really live the life that the Church teaches them to. It's fair to differentiate between authentically lived religion and more hollow performative religion.
- m0zg 5y agoHaving an established social circle leads to greater life satisfaction - you don't need a study to know that. And that's the main thing churches provide.
- Grimm1 5y agoHonestly, and completely anecdotally, having been raised Catholic I would expect it to result in quite the opposite when so much of the doctrine is based on guilt. That said before anyone jumps on me, also anecdotally, I haven't found any greater life satisfaction by not being religious either. You do you. The article says the study suggests there's not a really strong causal relationship in either way which surprises me a little but yeah I can see it given the experience. And If I were to find religion suddenly again now I imagine it may only increase life satisfaction based on the fact I have no real community at the moment and that I think is probably a more interesting study. How much has external community (i.e. not close friends, partners and families) breakdown occurred over the last 40 years and what is the effect on our life satisfaction? My grandfather was a part of a bunch of men's clubs etc last I checked most of those are floundering now.
- phkahler 5y agoAside from that Catholic guilt and community aspects, people like to feel hope and purpose. Religious beliefs can offer both of those. I do like to point out that this effect will take place regardless of the truth of the belief system, so paint yourself a picture that brings "meaning" to your life however you want - as long as it's something you can actually believe ;-)
- Grimm1 5y agoYes, hope and purpose are important. I like existentialism and cling hard to thought of being able to define that belief system myself and what purpose I have from it. That said as of late, after years I seem to be going through a bit of a dark night of the soul with that chosen system, to borrow more from religious terminology. I guess one of the downsides of forming my own belief system versus religion is it's bedrock is just a wee bit younger and potentially less well formed as I've been learning. Back to the drawing board :P
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoNot all religious experience are based so much on guilt. There are strains of Protestantism where the emphasis is much more on grace.
- aaron695 5y agoBlue zone theory suggests religion helps people live longer. Which is the same as life satisfaction. (If you think people who live longer are unhappy or blobs stuck in a bed that's your bizarre world) Blue Zone theory isn't a great theory, but it's very logical. Ie. Religious people have support later in life, it's a life long hobby anyone can do etc etc. This 'meta study' of only 4000 is poorly written. I'll assume it's because they are Korean and not because in science poorly written Journal Articles do better. You can't read much from this study. Religiosity means little. They mention in the study they have no idea about attendance for instance which is what matters. It's not about how strongly you believe. More the fact to use the support structure when needed.
- jawns 5y agoI am a member of a religious group whose doctrine, practices, culture, etc. are very different from the doctrine, practices, and culture of other religious groups. Some people who identify as religious are monotheists, others polytheists, others pantheists, and still others agnostics or even atheists. (Yup, there is such a thing as Christian atheism.) So I always find it strange when 'religiosity' is used as a catch-all personality trait and everyone who identifies as religious is lumped together. I haven't been able to look at the specific six-question set used in the study to measure religiosity, but something tells me that with only six questions, we can ascertain the impact of a person's particular religious beliefs and practices on their life in only the vaguest way.
- geoduck14 5y ago>something tells me that with only six questions, we can ascertain the impact of a person's particular religious beliefs and practices on their life in only the vaguest way. This sounds like a game! 20 questions, but with religion!
- squarefoot 5y agoI'm pretty sure there are different groups also among the same exact religion. If we asked to a large group of Christians whether we, say, should help immigrants, we would probably end up with 3 types of answers: "yes, let's help them!" - "yes, but only for very basic needs, then let's kick them out" - "nope, let's build a wall and let them rot on the other side". Of course the 2nd and especially the 3rd group have absolutely nothing to do with anything christian, and they profess them as such only to not feel guilty, or possibly because the society they live in requires that (how many votes would a politician get is he/she admitted being atheist?) - religion for them is just a series of acts (go to church, make offers, say prayers aloud, etc.) intended to cheat the system and appear as good people while in realty they aren't. I am also sure that the 1st group live a better life, which doesn't mean they'll earn more, actually it's quite likely the opposite, but they grow better "antibodies" to overcome difficulties without anger. BTW, I'm writing this as a complete atheist. Spending most of my youth in catholic schools helped me to know many people of all those groups, and believe me, for us atheists recognizing someone that is just pretending to be religious is truly easy.
- nassimsoftware 5y agoI find this study problematic because it fails to take into account that life satisfaction is highly dependent on the exact moment when the respondents answers the questionnaire even if 10 years apart. If I had a bad day and it so happened that it was the day where I was supposed to fill in a form on my life satisfaction, my answer would probably be very biased regardless if I was religious or not. It also fails to take into account that not all religions are based on happiness meaning that life satisfaction in this world is not the be all and all. An example is Islam. In Islam this worldly life is considered as a test. So you're going to be tested with hardship, afflictions and so on. There is also the concept of this being cyclical. After hardship comes ease. (not really cyclical in the sense that hardship comes because you had some ease before it but more like tuples of (hardship, ease) coming your way one after the other) If you keep steady while you're being tested you'll be rewarded with paradise or/and a period of ease in this life. Otherwise if you disobey Allah's commandements and die upon disbelief (You did not repent sincerely while you were still alive.) you'll likely go to hell. Here it would be understandable to the believer that their life will not be all roses.
- PeterisP 5y agoYou solve for random noise like that simply by looking at sufficiently large number of respondents, that's how basic statistics works. Any particular respondent may have an unusually bad or good day, however, if there would be some real difference of a few percent in happiness conditional on religiosity, then given 4000 respondents it's extremely unlikely that the average responses would not reveal that.
- guscost 5y agoMost religions are not about life satisfaction, they’re about afterlife satisfaction...
- aabceh 5y agoAfterlife satisfaction is just a method of control. It's not what religions are about per se.
- jkhdigital 5y agoIs there any major religion which has an expressly stated purpose of increasing the “life satisfaction” of its adherents? I mean, hard to fault religion for failing to deliver something that it never really promised in the first place.
- geoduck14 5y ago>Is there any major religion which has an expressly stated purpose of increasing the “life satisfaction” of its adherents? Christian here. Our titular hero - the very God of our universe - was beaten and hung on a cross to die (slowly). It is hard to look at that and think "following this guy is going to increase my life satisfaction".
- tim333 5y agoI thought the idea was he died so we don't have to? "Happy people, singing people, party people, happy people Jamming on the party session, oh Lord Sing Hallelujah..." etc
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- elihu 5y agoThe way I think about it is that part of the point of religion, and perhaps more generally one part of the point of our strange existence on Earth is not to make us happy, but to make us into people who are capable of being happy. I mean, imagine putting someone into a world where every wish they had was immediately granted. Would they be happy? Probably for awhile, but I don't think they would be happy for long. Imagine a dire or generally unpleasant situation, and imagine who could get through that and still be happy. Or maybe happy is the wrong word, but at least to not give up and to be kind to others. That sort of thing, being able to make the most out of any situation, is difficult and usually takes a lot of practice. (Which isn't to say we should tolerate suffering because it's a good "learning experience" for someone. Maybe it is, but to be okay with someone else's suffering is also a learning experience that, in my opinion, reinforces the wrong sorts of behavior.)
- coding123 5y agoAs more people lose faith, you have higher numbers of people that have faith in only themselves. What replaces morality? I haven't seen a large movement to replace it.
- krapp 5y agoMorality doesn't presuppose religion, faith or belief in the supernatural. The religious can be amoral and selfish, atheists can be moral and selfless.
- _8j50 5y agoGood, the pursuit of truth should not be biased with the desire for "life satisfaction". Too many people confuse religion with self-help orgs.
- lowdose 5y agoIt is the normalization of men having one partner. By setting up this rule more men are able to marry a partner. On Tinder the top 2% handsome mej
- lowdose 5y agoIt is the normalization of men having one partner. By setting up this rule more men are able to marry a partner. On Tinder the top 2% handsome men get most dates.
- williamtrask 5y agoThis title could be more precise. It finds plenty of evidence across individuals who are religious and not (as have many studies) but little evidence temporally across the life of someone whose religiosity changes. I’d be curious to know out of the 4000 surveyed individuals the percentage that experienced nontrivial changes in religiosity and whether the life patterns/worldview (community, sense of morality, perspective of human life, personal values, daily habits, charitability, etc.) they inherited from their religion also deteriorated.