14 ms·
20 years of the iPod
- comeonseriously 5y agoA shame the only option today is the iPod Touch. Might as well just use an old phone...
- gumby 5y agoTIL there is still an iPod for sale.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI was surprised that Apple still sells the iPod. It is not on the front page of their store, but if you search for it, there it is sporting a new’ish A10 chip. Looking at the specifications, it would not be a bad device for traveling if you object to phone for privacy reasons. Really light weight.
- mobilio 5y agoAnd was used in some spy activities: https://tidbits.com/2020/08/17/the-case-of-the-top-secret-ipod/ https://tidbits.com/2020/08/17/the-case-of-the-top-secret-ip...
- mobilio 5y agoOriginal discussion is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24188791 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24188791
- adamgordonbell 5y agoFun fact: the software, or at least the filesystem code, for the original IPod was developed on Windows because the ARM toolkit was windows based https://corecursive.com/063-apple-2001/#the-first-day https://corecursive.com/063-apple-2001/#the-first-day
- sn_master 5y agoFun fact 2: Most of Google was using Windows in the early 2000s because of the need for Outlook and similar software that was Windows-only as well. Even now that Macs are an option in most FAANG+, most non-fresh-grad hires either pick Linux or Windows machines and completely avoid Macs.
- jboy55 5y agoIn support for your first sentence, Macs were very unusual for techs in the valley until OSX. I ran a linux laptop for a long time until I gave in and stopped doing my own IT and got a Macbook.
- fzzzy 5y agoUm, OS X was 20 years ago
- jboy55 5y agoYup, I've been a mac user at work for the last 18 years. Before that it was linux on laptops.
- short12 5y agoTo be fair at that time macs were extremely niche in every industry. Even graphics was dwindling. Now mac's are still niche just not as tiny as before
- sn_master 5y agoI still use my iPod Nano 7th Gen. It's just beautiful. Very lightweight, no Internet distractions, the hardware buttons for volume and next/prev are excellent to use when it's in your pocket, the screen is just the right size for showing and navigating names of albums and songs. Only thing its missing is LDAC for Bluetooth. The difference is noticeable when you have headset that actually supports it.
- extra88 5y agoI used a Nano 5th gen, the last to have a clickwheel, until 2019. It was primarily for use at the gym but because I mostly listened to podcasts and didn't want to try to keep everything synced with Mac, Nano, and iPhone, it was the only thing I used for portable audio. I've switched to using an Apple Watch to have wireless headphones but it's not great; syncing to the Watch's storage (I don't want my phone on me at the gym) is slow and the Podcast app can be wonky. Just today it stopped playing an episode in the middle for no apparent reason and I couldn't get it to start again. Some of this may be because it's a Series 1 Watch but newer models seem too expensive for possibly not that much better an experience.
- Voline 5y agoI also don’t want to take my expensive and distracting iPhone to the gym. To this day I use an iPod Shuffle. I have one playlist that I change over time in iTunes, sync up, and play on shuffle. And a new-in-box Shuffle pod in a drawer for when this one dies.
- justinator 5y agoCan you use one of those dongles made for a car stereo?
- FridayoLeary 5y agoThe last ipod nano must be one of the most beautiful products that Apple ever made. A fantastic screen, unrivalled touch and extreme thinness conspire to make it an audio player that nothing else even approaches. It's tragic that it's such a dead end now. I hope one day Apple revives it because it's one of the most complete products out there. (more memory wouldn't hurt though)
- ghaff 5y agoI'm tempted to say that this story uses hindsight to maybe give Apple at least a bit too much credit. When the iPod first came out it wasn't anything obviously special. The famous clicky wheel didn't come until I think the 4th generation and I believe iTunes was originally Mac only. And Macs were pretty fringe at the time. And while legit digital music downloads would set the stage for today's online music scene, digital purchases were never that big a chunk of the market and declined fairly quickly given streaming.
- alphabettsy 5y agoI can hardly recall anyone having an MP3 player that wasn’t an iPod when I was young. Other than that Sony and the Zune are all that I remember seeing and that was very rare. There’s also the ecosystem to consider. Cars, gyms, hotels all started offering ways to connect an iPod. Accessories for iPods were everywhere.
- ghaff 5y agoIf you remember the Zune you're talking about a later period. The Zune wasn't introduced until 2006, just before the iPhone. The other MP3 players people are talking about here were early 2000s.
- alphabettsy 5y agoYes, but iPods were popular well after the first iPhone because many people and especially young people couldn’t afford them and they had limited carrier availability. Also MP3 players in the early years were hardly common before the iPod that I can remember.
- sn_master 5y ago> iTunes was originally Mac only When Apple made iTunes for Windows, Steve Jobs called it “It's like giving somebody a glass of hell in ice water.” [1] I mean, was Windows Media Player really that bad? I still miss the visualizations and even the fancy skins. iTunes in comparison was very dull and barely changed in 20 years. [1] https://500ish.com/a-time-to-kill-itunes-2d9a24529b9a https://500ish.com/a-time-to-kill-itunes-2d9a24529b9a
- Causality1 5y agoThe ipod didn't shuffle music and tech into a new era. The iTunes store did. The iTunes store could've turned any PMP into a titan. One could even argue it was Rio's successful legal defense of the concept of a PMP that laid the foundation for the entire industry.
- sys_64738 5y agoMicrosoft is still working on a Zune 'iPod killer'.
- iso1210 5y agoThe most famous use of a Zune is almost certainly the quip in Guardians of the Galaxy 2 -- "It's called a Zune. It's what everybody's listening to on Earth nowadays. It's got three hundred songs on it." The ipod, perhaps more than google, was the harbinger of the downward spiral of microsoft's iron grip on the tech industry.
- ghaff 5y agoThe somewhat remarkable thing to me--and maybe it reflects how large dominant companies can be very resilient to market changes and competition--is that, under Nadella, Microsoft has been able to largely thrive. In spite of basically losing mobile in multiple form factors and device types, to say nothing of search, maps, etc.
- dehrmann 5y ago> say nothing of search, maps, etc. They're too busy selling OS licensees, Office licenses, cloud services, and running Xbox break-even.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat is due to increased download bandwidth everywhere, especially due to advances in mobile network technology, meant that computing could be offloaded from devices to the cloud. Of course, the cloud requires huge capital expenditures, and who better to capitalize on it than the incumbent giants.
- sorenjan 5y agoI think the iPod competed more with Sony than Microsoft.
- 5y ago
- thrower123 5y agoThe window of people who will be nostalgic about iPods is smaller than those who have nostalgia for 8-track tapes. It's an entire product category that swept in and had less than a decade of relavence before getting washed out in the tide.
- ghaff 5y agoOf course, most people haven't had smartphones for more than a decade at this point. (Certainly not much longer on the outside especially if you exclude Blackberries.) Not that smartphones are likely to evaporate anytime soon.
- dehrmann 5y agoI guess they were really only relevant for maybe 5 years, ~2005-2010. It primed Apple to make the iPhone (which is huge), but it ended up being a bridge technology between CDs and streaming.
- tomjen3 5y agoSpotify launched in the US in July 2011, that is well into the smartphone era. By then the iPhone 3g had been out for about 2 years.
- Apocryphon 5y agoWithout the iPod, there would be no iPhone. Simple as that.
- shp0ngle 5y agoFirst iPod was 2001; first iPhone was 2007. Apple developed a category of their own, and then killed it themselves.
- sn_master 5y agoDon't forget iPod touch which allowed Apple to slowly develop most of the iPhone features (e.g touch UI) and test it with customers before announcing the iPhone.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoIt never pays to be perfect. The ipod nano evolved to become everything it could possibly be and then died a natural death of stagnation mixed with increasing irrelevance. I wonder if the smartphone will reach a similar equilibrium until the manufacture and os become irrelevant. Obviously Big Tech are trying hard to tip the balance the other way so that their platforms grow ever more apart and increasingly isolated.
- ghaff 5y agoI assume a smartphone successor would involve wearables that make a palm-sized slab of glass in your pocket unnecessary. Don't really see that on the horizon but most people have only owned a smartphone for 10 years or so at this point so these technology shifts are over very short periods of time by historical standards.
- tempodox 5y agoAnd now, iFumes^W Apple Music is ruining it all. More profits for Apple, worse experience for users.
- smoldesu 5y agoC'mon, don't you want to hear the new Billie Eilish album in Dolby Atmos? Guess you aren't a true audiophile then...
- tempodox 5y agoIf it were only that. Have you tried the iPhone Music app with something not downloaded from Apple Music or the iTunes store? Like, music sampled from CDs or bought on Bandcamp or somewhere else? It will challenge your creativity.
- kall 5y agoI have a library that is a mix of Apple Music, iTunes Match and mp3s from some wild sources. It works nicely in the music app and is provided as an OS-level service to other player frontends. Seems great to me. It‘s a huge issue that you cannot add music from an iOS device though. You need to do that from a mac.
- pram 5y agoYes, I download it from Bandcamp and iTunes Match adds it to the rest of my devices. Easy!
- tempodox 5y agoAh, another subscription. Things like that used to work without having to pay ransom. Apple deliberately deteriorated the user experience to bully us into buying those subscriptions.
- FabHK 5y agoIf you manage your music library via iTunes, you can sync with USB or WiFi and not pay at all, just like back in 2001 (though back then it was Firewire).
- dehrmann 5y agoIf we're going all nostalgic, remember the free ipod sites?
- wila 5y agoAlso see: https://panic.com/blog/a-prototype-original-ipod/ https://panic.com/blog/a-prototype-original-ipod/
- zafiro17 5y agoFond memories of my click wheel ipod, but I actually just bought a relatively generic MP3 player and am thrilled with it. Wrote about it here: https://therandymon.com/index.php?/archives/360-The-MP3-Player.html https://therandymon.com/index.php?/archives/360-The-MP3-Play... The hardware/software are nowhere as slick as that old ipod. But the freedoms this device give me serve as a reminder that all of the constraints of an ipod (one per user, no library comingling, needs itunes, etc.) were artificially imposed by a hardware striving to maximize hardware sales (and placate the music industry).
- SamBam 5y agoDo you have a name or a link for that MP3 player? It's exactly the specs I want (even has sort by genre! I couldn't find that anywhere), but most of the cheap Chinese-made ones I found online had very poor reviews.
- corin_ 5y agoFrom your blog: > Finally, here's what drove the purchase: I was taking a long car trip, and my wife was doing the DJ work using my device. Of course, every time she wanted to change tracks I had to unlock the device with my fingerprint. Ridiculous. This little device solved that problem Wouldn't telling her your phone's code, or temporarily adding one of her fingerprints to it for the duration of the journey, have been a much simpler solution...?
- tartoran 5y agoApple devices are very personal. There may be guest modes but that’s not the point, they are too multipurposed and yet artificially limited. A good generic music player is a straight forward stand alone device. Where they fail is where the content is online on some service
- corin_ 5y agoSure, but the complaint was written as it being annoying having to constantly unlock it for her to have access to it, not wanting to prevent her from having access to it.
- drewg123 5y agoI love Louis Rossman's video about why he does not use Apple products. Near the beginning, he talks about how he worked in a recording studio, and people would bring in background music they wanted to sing along with on MP3 players, and he was used to just copying files off. Which worked just fine until he encountered his first iPod: https://youtu.be/sfrYOWlKJ_g?t=163 https://youtu.be/sfrYOWlKJ_g?t=163
- laurent92 5y agoThe other mp3 players didn’t get MPAA’s approval because they allowed copying music, ie “they were tools for piracy”. Apple’s system was genius: It could only synchronize with the system it came from, making it a peripheral of the computer, not a node in a network. This restriction lived on for the iPhone, making Apple fans curse and Android fans laugh, when a computer was required to install an iPhone, for years and years after it wasn’t technically necessary. But binding with 1 (one) computer was the agreement if Apple wanted to host music under benevolence from the labels. Apple would have never been able to get agreements with music labels if the iPod had been open. And thus, it lived on, while all other mp3-player brands died. It is a consequence of the music industry and an emergent property of IP laws, not a standalone decision from Apple, as opposed to making all their products closed-source, which they don’t have to.
- FabHK 5y agoFWIW, you can trivially pirate music from an iTunes library [1] with an external hard drive or USB stick or, in fact, an iPod mounted as an external drive. You could also play music from an iPod that was plugged in, IIRC, which should have been enough for the recording studio/karaoke use case. But you couldn't just copy music from an iPod to your own library, indeed (I doubt the music industry would've gone along with that for very long, either). [1] except DRM'd music, such as music purchased on the iTunes Store between its debut in 2003 and 2009.
- musicale 5y ago> In October 2001, the music industry was riven by piracy and had no idea how to solve it. Enter Steve Jobs, whose new device created a digital music market – and made Apple into a titan Enter Steve Jobs, whose new device was perfect for playing those 1000 MP3 tracks you just downloaded from file sharing networks.
- Exmoor 5y agoIndeed, this is a ridiculous statement. The iTunes store didn't even launch until 2003, and I don't recall it actually competing with CD sales until several years after that. I suspect you'd find very few record label folks from that era who'd consider the ipod their "savior".