6 ms·
Honestly, I am generally a big fan of pg, and many/most of his points I agree with. But every time he puts out a new blog post I feel like I'm now reflexively s
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Honestly, I am generally a big fan of pg, and many/most of his points I agree with. But every time he puts out a new blog post I feel like I'm now reflexively starting with an eye roll: "OK, what quality that pg has in spades has he decided to laud now as the one thing that's super important for success, happiness and societal progress?"
It's not that I really disagree with him that much, but for a man who is obviously very smart, and who can come up with lots of new ideas, I find his blog posts shockingly lacking in introspection. It's basically all the qualities that are needed to build a startup are the most important qualities for society at large. What I never see is thought processes along the lines of "Gee, how can my world view be colored by my unique experiences, and how might I think differently if I had a different upbringing or experiences contrary to the ones that actually occurred?"
As another commenter mentioned, so many of pg's posts seem so concerned with "sorting" people: you're smart or not, you've got lots of new ideas or you don't. And it's not hard to surmise why he has this worldview: literally his whole job is to sort through people pitching to find the winners from the losers.
But I wish he would just step back once and think a little more broadly about some contrarian ideas that don't just totally support his vision of success in the world.
- maxerickson 5y agoTypically they are persuasive essays with all the furniture of an expository essay or research paper.
- nopinsight 5y agoIf you subscribe the general worldview that human well-being is an important goal for society and believe that we have progressed so much in the last few centuries because of scientific knowledge and technological inventions, then it becomes clear that the qualities described in this post, intelligence and the ability to come up with useful new ideas, are useful for society. In my reading, PG did not claim that these are the most important things for society.
- tomp 5y ago> As another commenter mentioned, so many of pg's posts seem so concerned with "sorting" people: you're smart or not, you've got lots of new ideas or you don't. Not sure which posts you mean, but this post is explicitly about examining the difference between intelligence and having new ideas, in hopes of eventually being able to list the ingredients of the latter (the former seems mostly inborn) to be able to cultivate them more broadly in society.
- sbt 5y agoPGs personality has been great for attracting the kind of college graduate clientele YCombinator has catered to.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoCould you quote a specific sentence that supports any of your claims here? > I grew up thinking that being smart was the thing most to be desired. Perhaps you did too. But I bet it's not what you really want. Imagine you had a choice between being really smart but discovering nothing new, and being less smart but discovering lots of new ideas. Surely you'd take the latter. I would. This seems like the closest thing. But it's perfectly fine to mention one's own childhood experiences. You might want to read http://paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://paulgraham.com/disagree.html, since it sounds like you don't actually disagree with him on anything. Which is to say, your reply is a DH2 at best. Wouldn't it be better to comment on the actual essay rather than its author? It'd probably be more interesting.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoLet's take a look at pg's most recent essays: 1. This one, which is basically saying one of the most important things for society is coming up with new ideas. Not hard to see why someone who built his life around startups would think this. 2. "Weird Languages", touting the benefits of Lisp among others. Kinda feel like "nuff said" on this one. 3. "How to work hard", which I read basically as an overview of "how to work like you're running a startup". 4. "A project of one's own". How you should work toward your own goals, instead of someone else's. Again, I don't really disagree with pg's essays, I just no longer find them interesting because I think they are now utterly predictable at this point. I'll give you a concrete example: while I was definitely a tech and startup fan boy through the early 00s, I definitely have some amount of disillusionment around the whole startup ecosystem, and its effects on society. I never hear pg talk about really any of the downsides or regrets about the startup ecosystem that he helped unleash. If I already know pretty much exactly what someone is going to say (and nearly all of it is self-serving), I'm not going to be that interested in listening.
- lpa22 5y agoI think PG has definitely made the move at this point in his career from the previously more niche (interesting) insight years ago => mainstream (less interesting, more predictable) insight lately. It likely won't interest you and a non-negligible portion of the HN crowd at this point. But for the rest of society, he is still interesting and he is growing his following.
- throwaway2474 5y agoWriting a piece called “Beyond Smart” where you literally equate yourself with Einstein in the first paragraph is a special level of arrogance. His essays used to quirky, interesting and surprising. They have increasingly become predictable rants about how he’s uniquely great, and (ironically) contain less and less actual new ideas.
- defen 5y ago> Writing a piece called “Beyond Smart” where you literally equate yourself with Einstein in the first paragraph is a special level of arrogance. He didn't equate himself with Einstein, in either the first paragraph or the rest of the essay. Furthermore, I interpreted the "Beyond" in the title in the sense of Nietzsche's "Beyond Good and Evil" - "Beyond Smart" doesn't mean "extra-super-duper smart, above and beyond smart". It means, we cannot ascribe such things to a simplistic concept of "smart", such as the kind that would be measured on IQ tests.
- evgen 5y agoI am assuming either you are joking or you are failing to see the ham-handed self-congratulation pg gives himself through this entire piece of shit. Paragraph 1: Einstein was smart, but he also had 'new ideas' Paragraphs 2-15 : Reasons why I am smart and also have new ideas and you should remember to think of me like the Einstein of VCs. Just in case you missed this repeated point I am going to title this little think-piece 'Beyond Smart.' I would trot out metaphors about Fonzie and water skis, but when it comes to pg that ship sailed years ago.
- defen 5y agoOne way to test out your theory would be to pretend that someone else wrote the essay. If the essay no longer makes sense, or if it still comes across as self-congratulatory, I would agree with you. However if you perform this thought experiment I think you'll find that neither is true, so I think you're just reacting to identity of the author and not his actual point.
- 5y ago
- shoto_io 5y agoI agree with you wholeheartedly. A perfect human through this lens is - smart - hard working - has many ideas - wants to change the world - gives back Right? What I don’t understand: why do you wish him to step back and reflect?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> What I don’t understand: why do you wish him to step back and reflect? Because I used to look forward to his essays. I found them interesting, insightful and witty. Now I just find them predictable and self-serving. I'm probably just feeling disillusioned with someone I greatly admired, that's all, and I'm wishing I could feel about that person the way I used to feel.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andkon 5y agoIt's not just that he has to sort winners from the losers. It's that he has to be the first most important seeming VC in their minds. And he accomplishes that with these blog posts. That, and by using these posts to posit that people like him really are the best, he has a big hand in getting people to self-sort into venture-seeking types in the first place. If you think of his posts as self-serving, that's true. But they're also propaganda meant to influence what we think of as being a worthy pursuit, and meant to define who should pursue such things. The more people believe his worldview – one where smarts dominate and make one powerful – then the more status he has, and the more easily he can do his job. People come to him whereas before he would've had to go to them! I think he really believes what he writes. And I think it is true that smarts as defined by him are helpful to the kinds of entrepreneurs who see themselves in pg - like, the people he describes really are a type of person, and they should lean on their strengths. But I think it's not at all clear that pg-measured smarts matter more than other qualities for entrepreneurship, or that people like him are remotely close to the best sort of startup founder. Maybe he's just found a way to seem high status to a subset of a population, and his success flows from that: he gets his pick of that subset, even though it is a tiny chunk of the world. Sure, he gets notoriety and status in a big chunk in status-seeking coders! But that needn't mean that he's actually cracked the code on entrepreneurialism. He has ABSOLUTELY cracked the code on how to speak to young men who feel like they can use what they're good at to achieve power and status. Here's a scary thought: it's possible that by so completely dominating the conversation about what a startup founder should be, and by making the ideal startup founder seem like a reflection of his image, he's caused far greater numbers of more capable entrepreneurs to self-select out of entrepreneurial pursuits, because they aren't pg-like enough. Not saying that's true, or provable (though I have many many anecdotes that lead me to feel something's going on there). Just that it's important to consider that in making a hagiographic ideal the epitome of a startup founder, that you're necessarily excluding so so many other people for reasons that boil down to... pg got there first. HN likes to point out just-so stories, and I think the stories he tells us are that. When we read posts like this and they seem to speak spookily clearly to something in us, it's probably because he's doing fanservice to people who serve to give him a tremendous amount of influence and power by believing him when he says we're special.
- mcbishop 5y agoMy experience here reflects my general pattern: 1) Read an article via HN 2) Return to HN, to smash the upvote button 3) Go to the article's comments 4) Realize that there are problems with the article that I was totally oblivious to 5) Remind myself to not be so damn naïve So big thanks to HN people, and PG.
- gfodor 5y agoPlot twist: pg writes the articles to generate this effect and it’s consequences.
- mcbishop 5y agoHaha. Maybe he's testing the good-spirited rebelliousness and critical thinking of the HN community. (Or maybe not.)
- beckman466 5y agoi doubt it. ownership/capital and it's privileges/power corrupts people. i believe he drinks his own kool-aid.
- maxerickson 5y agoBe sure to drink your Ovaltine.
- Gatsky 5y agoI think one should just take the blog post for what it is. It isn't a UN resolution. He actually has thoughtful opinions that he is happy to put out there without endless qualifications. That is what makes it valuable, not why it is problematic. The broader relevance, the applicability of the notions to one's own life, the motivations of the author are all left as an exercise to the reader.
- iambateman 5y agoHis essay says that we overrate intelligence and underrate independent-mindedness and writing. This is actionable - we can cultivate both with some minor changes, and meanwhile we aren’t likely to get much marginal return on trying to improve general intelligence. If you’d like to provide an alternative theory, please do. But 100 words of eye-roll aren’t moving society forward either. FWIW I was homeschooled and now work from home with a large team of folks in an office. I see a lot of people struggle with independent-mindedness, and I think it hurts our team’s productivity.
- xyzelement 5y agoI don't understand the complaint. Everything that everyone writes is intended to be prefixed with a big fat "this is what I think. You can disagree, my job is present to you with the facts as I see them" I read this article and it was an interesting way to crystalize an idea I observed myself (I made a comment in this thread about my experience with smart but non-impactful people.) So I got value out of this post in that it names a concept for me. So your concern is not that the author is wrong, not that the idea is bad, not that it will lead to a bad outcome - but simply that the author wrote about something they thought was important?
- soared 5y agoMost often my initial reaction is a clear awareness that pg doesn’t spend much time outside of the Vc/start up bubble.