5 ms·
Credit card transactions take far less, and they deal in legitimate risk (chargebacks, stolen cards, fraud, etc). As developers, we don't even need app stores.
by echelon 5y ago
Credit card transactions take far less, and they deal in legitimate risk (chargebacks, stolen cards, fraud, etc).
As developers, we don't even need app stores. They're an artifice that got shoved down our throat by trillion dollar mega corporations. A taxation clearinghouse. You can distribute the same program bytes from anywhere, most notably the web.
It's Steve Ballmer's old dream of taxing all software. There's just no point in it. It's massively unfair.
The excruciating review process adds insult to injury. And it makes fixing bugs a slow and stressful nightmare.
If smart phone manufacturers really want to protect customers, the best way to do that is to store signatures of known bad applications and provide solid permissions-based access to system resources.
Screw app stores.
- beojan 5y agoFrom a user's perspective, the review is absolutely necessary and really needs to be much better on Android. Proactive vetoing of malware from distribution is much better than reactive malware scanning against a signature library. That doesn't really justify a slice of subscription revenue though.
- echelon 5y ago> review is absolutely necessary Wholeheartedly disagree. I download software on Linux and Mac frequently without ever having it reviewed. I buy physical products that have sensors. These don't get scrutinized. If we truly need a "health inspector", then it should be a third party. Not the mafia that makes the device and frequently launches competing apps and features. And it seems totally uneven that websites can access and deal in the same data, yet they escape review. It's an invented charade that is brutally unfair.
- hutzlibu 5y agoBut you know, that you can also just download and install software on Android? But yes, this requires knowledge of what you are doing. So most people rightfully choose the playstore - and maintaining (and curating) the playstore requires work. So I also think it is fair, if google gets a cut. But 30% and also 15% is just cutthroat price range.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ethbr0 5y agoFrom a user's perspective, what do they want? Availability, cheapness, quality, (all other things), security, privacy Android users don't care that they're being tracked, as long as it doesn't break their app or drain their battery too fast. Google cares that apps track users, because (a) it allows apps to end run around their own ad offering & (b) it provides Apple with a talking point to bludgeon them about the head with. Review is a PR measure masquerading as a user benefit, in order to technically enforce a centralized toll gate.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoThe review focuses at potential damage to Apple (their "guidelines"), not for user.
- sofixa 5y agoAs a consumer, i want app stores. It's million times better than the default Windows situation downloading random binaries off the Internet. Code signing and malware signature matching are at best bandaids on a waterfall. Having a centralised place with reviews categories, updates etc. is very valuable.
- smoldesu 5y agoNot all app stores are centralized, Linux has had this figured out for years.
- justapassenger 5y agoAnd yet, year of Linux on the desktop never happened. Geeks are very different audience from general public.
- Grimm1 5y agoSuggesting that App distribution is even part of the consideration for why Linux didn’t catch on is kind of hilarious to be honest. Their app distribution methods being good or not had nothing to do with their lack of adoption and it’s kind of a non sequitur. If I dropped their app distribution onto Windows it would also succeed there with the general mainstream public, in fact even more so, because of the garbage state for app management there.
- Sohcahtoa82 5y ago> Geeks are very different audience from general public. HNers forget this quite often.
- smoldesu 5y agoSorry, I'll let the general public decide which package manager is more ethical.
- 5y ago
- toast0 5y ago> Credit card transactions take far less. Depends on the payment processor/mechant bank/payment network/issuing bank and the fixed fees vs transaction amount. 3-5% is in range for a card not present transaction for a low dollar amount with not a lot of volume. If Google or Apple gets a good deal on credit card processing because of volume and takes that plus a little extra to pay for their services, that's a lot more fair than 15-30%; high volume developers might want to shave that margin a bit more, but low and medium probably wouldn't bother.
- wastedhours 5y agoAs a developer I want the option of App Stores taking their cut - them being the Merchant of Record takes out a monumental admin overhead from selling apps globally for a small developer. I also work for a global tech company whereby that approach isn't needed as we have our own payment processing to handle that, but as a part-time indie, I want the option of deferring to the stores for payments.
- commoner 5y agoAs long as the cut is priced into that option (as in, the fee is passed on to the customer through a higher price for app stores) without affecting the price of buying directly from the developer, and without any anti-steering rules that prevent the developer from presenting the customer with all purchase options and prices in the app, there shouldn't be a problem. Developers who don't want to set up payments outside of the app store can choose not to do that. But that choice should not prevent the developers who do want to offer a lower-cost payment processing option to their customers from doing so.
- cptskippy 5y ago> Credit card transactions take far less, and they deal in legitimate risk (chargebacks, stolen cards, fraud, etc). For high volume merchants. For mom and pop shops they usually pay a fixed fee + %. For transactions under $5 they can lose money on a sale which is why you quite often see minimum purchase prices or discounts when paying with cash. In some states however there are no laws protecting small businesses and processor contractors usually have a clause forbidding merchants from steering customers away from paying with a card. A local baobao shop by me offers a 10% discount for cash transactions, that tells me they make more money offering a 10% discount than accepting a card. When I was in Georgia my drycleaner told me she didn't make money on any card transaction under $25.
- fredophile 5y agoPart of the savings on that cash transaction may be from not reporting the income for tax purposes.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoAs a consumer I’m somewhat glad I don’t have to deal with the cesspit that would be app stores home rolled payment gateways.
- notreallyserio 5y agoAnd update mechanisms! I don’t really want to log in to my phone to get several different shaped and sized and placed popups about updates.
- desiarnezjr 5y ago> Credit card transactions take far less, and they deal in legitimate risk (chargebacks, stolen cards, fraud, etc). Actually the merchant takes practically ALL the risk and the credit company has relatively little. If a stolen card is used or fraud is perpetrated, typically the merchant takes the hit depending on the type and scope of the fraud. If there is a chargeback, that money is held indefinitely until there is a resolution, but the merchant needs to dispute and prove that the product or service was rendered without any uncertainty, and much of the time the card company will favor the cardholder. On top of that, the credit card processor will charge you the merchant a hefty chargeback fee regardless of resolution (as I recall, though they may reverse it if the decision ruled in your favor). Most of the time it's not worth the effort to dispute smaller chargebacks for smaller amounts. It's fair amount of work that just may not be worth fighting. If your business is deemed in any way high risk, your merchant fees can be as high as 30% or more, but those are unusual edge cases. When dealing with consumers directly that's the inherent risk and overhead.