29 ms·
People who jump to conclusions show other kinds of thinking errors
- sharklazer 5y agoAn experiment based on drawing red or grey balls/fish/things... You know, this really isn’t a valid experiment. If you do the probability calculations then 2-3 draws is all you need. All this is based on the assumption getting red or grey is high probability, >90%. This is exactly how distributors do defect testing on lots incoming goods.
- travisgriggs 5y agoThis describes my world in programming. I have learned to be careful and deliberate in software efforts, and it pays. But I work with quite a few type 1 jumpers that spend countless wasted hours trying to solve problems because they jump too fast to conclusions. FD, I’m often accused by friends and family of overthinking things. I’m curious if there’s a correlation between type 1 jumpers and people who are more entrepreneurial risk takers.
- willvarfar 5y agoThe article opens with a couple of examples of people allegedly not doing research: 1. Most people make two trips or fewer to a dealership before buying a car 2. when picking a doctor, many individuals use recommendations from friends and family rather than consulting other health care professionals or “formal sources” such as employers, articles or Web sites And, of course, the last person I would look to for objective advice on buying a car is a car salesman! Surely people have a good idea what they are going to buy, what they are prepared to spend and how they are expecting to finance it etc before going to a dealership for the car? Ditto too the doctor; if you are searching for a doctor, do you go and cold call other doctors for an opinion? Or read the blurb on a website provided by or sponsored by the employer? Its much more straightforward to ask people you know which doctors they recommend. Is the subtext of the starting examples meant to be saying that people should defer to car salesman and should ask doctors rather than friends and family to recommend other doctors?
- cma 5y agoPeople may spend 3-4x as much time trying out and choosing a car as buying an expensive TV, even though the car costs ~20X more and more research, haggling, etc. on the car could be worth 3 TVs, but more on the TV could only be like at most .2 TVs.
- wongarsu 5y agoPeople don't value money linearly. You wouldn't pay an additional $10 for a cup of filter coffee, but most people wouldn't think twice about paying an additional $10 for a car. But it's the same amount of money, so surely that's irrational in that situation. In other situations it makes complete sense. If you have $1M, losing $10 isn't nearly as big a deal as when those $10 were all you had. If you try to apply game theory to economics you apply a utility function to money to model this, and a logarithmic function maps quite well to how humans think about money.
- FartyMcFarter 5y ago> But it's the same amount of money, so surely that's irrational in that situation. Not necessarily, since many people buy coffee way more often than they buy a car.
- vincentmarle 5y agoNot disagreeing with your conclusion but there’s a difference between spending $10 more for 3 years of utility vs $10 more for 3 minutes of utility.
- Ma8ee 5y agoYes, but you very soon reach the point of diminishing returns when you try to research any purchase. After a maximum a few hours it is hard to find any more useful information about most consumer goods. You have read all the specifications, and the tests and the reviews and went to the stores to look at the products in person. So even if you might spend half a day researching an expensive TV, you won't make a better buy of a car even if you spend more than a day or two researching. And if you spend ten full days to buy a car, you are most certainly wasting your time (and will lose more income than you can optimise your car purchase).
- cryptica 5y agoConspiracy theories aren't 100% irrational. It's irrational to assume that they are all 100% wrong and don't contain any correct or at least useful information. People do make plans together and influential people do tend to hang out together... It's not illogical to assume that they hatch plans to maintain the social order in a way that works for them and that some of these plans will be at the expense of the general population. Of course saying this isn't mathematically rigorous but each person who reads this should know axiomatically from first hand observation that rich people do hang out together and that rich people are generally good at implementating their visions/plans (how else they got rich?). This kind of logic is acceptable because decisions about one's life can never be made on the basis of mathematically rigorous information because you very rarely come across such kind of information in your day to day life. To suggest that the mainstream consensus is always accurate is to deny past history and present reality. No matter your religion, you can always point to incredibly large groups of people who believe some facts that you perceive to be incorrect.
- wongarsu 5y agoPeople conspire all the time, so there's bound to be conspiracy theories that are true. I think it's telling that the author uses the moon landing as an example, which to me seems to be among the least likely (but somewhat popular) theories. All credible evidence points to the moon landing actually happening, making it a good candidate for this study. Simply labeling that "endorse conspiracy theories" is a bit thoughtless though.
- denton-scratch 5y agoThe "fake" moon landings is an interesting example; although the number of direct eye-witnesses is tiny, there are thousands of scientists and engineers at NASA that will queue-up to testify they really happened, and nobody who actually knows anything will deny it. But the affirmers are all people in white lab-coats, and many people automatically distrust anyone in a white lab-coat. No "ordinary people" went to the moon and witnessed it themselves. I believe you could pick out the lunar lander from Earth, using a BIG telescope, as a small dot. But no amateur stargazer could do that. So all the affirmative testimony comes from a group of people who were all working for the same team. So if you don't trust that team, there's no reliable evidence against the CT. (There's no evidence for it either; but if you don't trust the people who know, then to doubt seems rational)
- RandomLensman 5y agoThat lake fishing example is terrible without any indication what "most" really means. If I take that to mean that 99% of all fish in one of the lakes are red, then seeing one red fish already makes me pretty confident which lake it is from. There is also this massive assumption in whole thing that investing time to study or decide actually increases positive outcomes. Might need to show that and then see if time spent vs. possible upside is well allocated.
- alistairSH 5y agoI'd wager that's part of the puzzle - lacking information, you jump to the conclusion that 99% are single color in a given lake. But, "most" could be 51% or anywhere in between. How many fish do you need to catch to be relatively confident you've covered the 51% possibility? 2-3? 9-10? I'm sure there's a mathematic solution, but my gut tells me I'd want more than 2-3. Maybe as many as 10 or 20, depending on how frequently fish are caught.
- hannasanarion 5y agoThe confidence is pretty easy to calculate with Bayes rule. p(redLake|redFish)= p(redFish|redLake)*p(redLake)/p(redFish). If you're doing multiple experiments, then you can say that p(redLake) is your belief and update it by multiplying by p(redFish|redLake)/p(redFish) every time you see a red fish, and its inverse whenever you see a grey fish. If both of the lakes are 49-51, the update size is 0.51/0.50 = 1.02. Each red fish you see should increase your confidence in the red lake by 2% over whatever it was before, and vice versa. Assuming your original assumption is 50-50: After you see one red fish, you can be 51% confident in the red lake. If you've seen 5 more red fish than grey, you can be 55% confident. If you've seen 10 more red fish than grey, you can be 60% confident. If you've seen 30 more red fish than grey, you can be 90% confident. If the proportion of fish in each lake is more substantial, your bayesian update is larger and your confidence increases faster. If each lake is 90% one color, a single piece of evidence should give you 90% confidence.
- droptablemain 5y agohttps://archive.md/49OLq https://archive.md/49OLq
- micdr0p 5y agoI always thought I was too quick to jump to conclusions. After reading this, I'm not so sure I am any more. I guess the true conclusion-jumpers don't think they are. David Dunning strikes again!
- dsizzle 5y agoHaha. (I had just come here to note one of the authors is the Dunning from the Dunning-Krueger effect -- I honestly didn't know anything about him, such as whether he was still alive!)
- motohagiography 5y ago"Jumpers," as described mostly just lacked a fear of consequences of being wrong and were presented with an incentive to guess. Not to be conspiratorial, but one can't help but notice a recent preoccupation in mainstream outlets with pathologizing conspiracy theorists, dissenters, and now, "jumpers." Referencing Khaneman and Tversky's "system 1 and system 2" from their bestseller Thinking Fast and Slow without crediting it seems to be more about avoiding the scrutiny that would draw, and instead, appearing authoritative with statements about how ancient psychological researchers commonly distinguish between these types of thought. We should even be concerned someone who could be a "jumper," may also have schizophrenia, as our thinking may have applications to that. Maybe it's interesting, or maybe on closer inspection and thoughtful consideration it resembles propaganda to ignore your instincts, trust the narrative, and provides blunt tools for being suspicious of others who don't. If only most people were smart and comfortable enough to jump to conclusions and then course correct as needed, we could avoid the consequences of groupthink by those who fear criticism above all.
- helen___keller 5y ago> Not to be conspiratorial, but one can't help but notice a recent preoccupation in mainstream outlets with pathologizing conspiracy theorists, dissenters, and now, "jumpers." No conspiracies needed. QAnon type conspiracies are more visible than ever (as they get blown up on social media) and personally I've seemed to notice a pretty big uptick in 'uncle so and so went off the deep end so we had to cut off communication' type stories. This increase in attention feeds news stories about conspiracy adherents (and anybody that can be lumped in with them, even if it's not warranted). > maybe on closer inspection and thoughtful consideration it resembles propaganda to ignore your instincts, trust the narrative, and provides blunt tools for being suspicious of others who don't This is almost all "news" nowadays. Antifa is running the left, QAnon is running the right, somebody is out to get you and ruin the American way of life and we're going to tell you who the bad people are if you just tune in for our next segment.
- notreallyserio 5y ago> I've seemed to notice a pretty big uptick in 'uncle so and so went off the deep end so we had to cut off communication' type stories. I wonder how long that sort of cutting off has been happening in the past. I know there are members of my extended family I don’t associate with due to their crazy beliefs, but I haven’t talked about it.
- wombatmobile 5y agoThe article lacked a single counter-example to show when jumping to a conclusion might be advantageous. And yet much of life is dominated by such cases. Great ball players jump all the time. Hunters jump or go hungry. Soldiers jump or get jumped. Financial traders jump all day long. It doesn't mean they don't study at night, but during they day, they don't spend time pondering trades that disappear as fast as a gap in traffic. Maitre d's jump. Taxi drivers jump. Fork lift drivers jump. Customs inspectors jump. Politicians jump. Not everyone jumps. Engineers work things out. But they still have to jump sometimes before the factory explodes or the heat shield disintegrates or the oxygen runs out.
- gilmore606 5y agoFortune favors the bold. People telling you to never be bold want all the fortune.
- anovikov 5y agoHaha i am a person who jumps to conclusions, and i actually bought my most recent car after 1.5 visits to dealerships (i tried BMW but the dealer was rude to me so i left before i actually found out anything, and went straight to Volvo and i am super happy with my new S60). So i think i am qualified for an opinion :D One thing that hits me is conspiracy theories. Although i am not buying into any of the currently circulating ones (covid deliberately invented by Chinese, mind control chips and 5G, faked Moon landings), i understand people who do. Actually, hiding link between cell phones and cancer was a very viable idea through ~mid-2000s when cell phones became just way too numerous so if the link was true, it would become impossible to hide (and this is about the time when i heard of this theory a lot, then it gradually subsided, i haven't really heard of it in any serious manner in the last 10 years). After all, we know that they quite deliberately denied addictiveness of tobacco? They denied harm from leaded gasoline and lead water pipes? There is so much nasty crap authorities concealed or actively denied because they made money on it. They still deny how dangerous and addictive sugar is. Many of them still deny global warming.
- kbelder 5y agoAbiogenic origin of oil in the Earth's crust. There's no strong scientific evidence for it, so I can't bring myself to believe it; but I can't bring myself to dismiss it, either. It somehow strikes a cord in me as a reasonable thing. I have to keep telling myself "It's probably not true," but if it ever turns out to be proven, I'd be shouting "I KNEW IT!"
- djmips 5y agoIt's related to the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect where you read something you are well studied in and you find it riddled with errors then you read something else you know nothing about, like say the origin of oil and you are more open to terrible mistakes. But then again I do think about how past generations had their own established theories, like 'the ether', or a geocentric universe only to have those be laughed at by our current understanding. But all that is more of romantic notion that I might be on to something that science has totally missed a romantic version of the Gell Man amnesia effect. Basically we can't know everything and have to trust something.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoConspiracy theories are a manifestation of skepticism. One insight recently in the political theater is to determine what your audience is skeptical of. Everyone is skeptical of something, and these biases, when pinpointed, can be illuminating. On any topic you can split skepticism into groups. Are you more skeptical of government? The pharmaceutical industry? Corporations? Which?
- tgflynn 5y ago> Conspiracy theories are a manifestation of skepticism. They're a manifestation of biased skepticism. Conspiracy theorists tend to be skeptical of everything except their own favorite conspiracy theories.
- tgv 5y agoIMO, they are born from distrust rather than skepticism, even though they are clearly related.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAll skepticism is biased by one’s background. The ‘quid est veritas’ of our age will become more difficult with all the noise, deep fakes, powerful interests, etc.
- scandox 5y agoLots of people hum and haw and get things totally wrong. The question is not how fast you jump but how well prepared the ground of your thought was for the situation.
- rmorey 5y agoIt's a "Jump to Conclusions Mat". You see, it is a mat that you put on the floor, and it has different CONCLUSIONS written on it that you could JUMP TO.
- tomlue 5y agopeople underestimate the cost of dwelling on problems. There is great value to coming to conclusions quickly.
- ARandomerDude 5y agoThis headline and article are essentially, "Foolish people are often foolish."
- xyzzy21 5y agoIt's about impulse control. Most criminals do not have it either.
- greenail 5y agoI think most people on this thread have jumped to apply this generally when I think it is intended to be focused on schizophrenia. I also think the research shows that bias intervention training doesn't really take over the long run and I question how useful this is for the average joe.
- desktopninja 5y agoWonder if this outcome can be reproduced if asked in other spoken human languages and "AI"
- iammisc 5y agoThis thread is basically chock full of people jumping to conclusions, including myself. It seems to me that jumping to conclusions is part of the human condition, and I find it difficult to blame them for that.