6 ms·
> That is why the increasing cost of craftsmanship, while real, cannot account for the decline of neighborhood beauty. It's not the cost, it's the availability
by jedberg 5y ago
> That is why the increasing cost of craftsmanship, while real, cannot account for the decline of neighborhood beauty.
It's not the cost, it's the availability. I'm currently in the process of a home renovation. If you want a master craftsman to build you say, kitchen cabinets, you may have to wait years for them to be available.
Or you can go to the store and buy custom built cabinets from a factory and have them in a few weeks.
It's the same with the outside of the house. You can build a generic outside with supplies from Home Depot, or if you're really fancy the contractor's supply depot, or wait years for a master to do a custom job for you.
- harryh 5y agoIf demand so significantly exceeds supply, why aren't folks with these skills raising prices?
- jedberg 5y agoThey already charge a significant amount. But that doesn't increase the supply of master craftsmen. You can't just make more masters. :) Also, there is still a price ceiling. If they charge too much, people will choose the cheaper alternatives even if they aren't as good.
- Gigachad 5y ago> You can't just make more masters. You can given enough time. Your second point is more likely the real reason. These jobs might seem to pay lots from the outside but if you dedicated the same time to a more boring job like management you very quickly make a lot more money with almost unlimited room to bump your prices.
- Sebb767 5y ago> These jobs might seem to pay lots from the outside but if you dedicated the same time to a more boring job like management you very quickly make a lot more money with almost unlimited room to bump your prices. This is from a German perspective, but here this is absolutely untrue. Masters earn a hell of a lot of money and business is basically limitless, even for masters. Being charged 120€-150€ per hour plus drive for a master and an apprentice is not unusual. Add to that that they start earning 5-9 years earlier. Sure, they start lower, but they have a lot of time to catch up as well as save money. In my circles, these guys drove awesome cars while us students survived still survived on ramen (or parents). Lastly, you can absolutely scale your business. If you go on to be a freelancer or even make your own company and hire people, you can get very far, if you intend to do so. Sure, the absolute top of white collar workers might earn more; eight digits is probably not going to happen. That being said, that's the 1% of the 1%. Here in Germany, 100k€ per year is already a really high salary and to get there in white collar work, you'll need to make quite some career jumps. For masters, on the other hand, this is absolutely doable if you don't suck at your job.
- chaircher 5y agoA lot of these people prefer the stability of knowing their income over a long period of time, rather than focusing on maximising profitability and therefore losing time working on their craft and also introducing instability longer term. My job is similar to this sort of thing and I have gone down the maximising profit route, and even though I've not pushed it to an extreme it can be difficult to stay disciplined about it. You lose a lot of time to it, as well as intelectual bandwidth - you're bouncing back and forth between business brain and craft brain a lot more. Crafts people also tend to be more community orientated which likely reflects in their pricing.
- harryh 5y agoSuper interesting answer. Thanks!
- OJFord 5y agoNot to discount the answer you've had, but to offer another factor: 100 * £10 > 50 * £19 It plays into the other really: you have to multiply your fee by more than the reduction in volume to make more money; if you break even on the trade, in a way that's great, less work same money, but now you're not practicing. So there's a trade-off there, and for it to be obviously worth it, there really has to be a significantly outsized boost to fee compared to reduction in number of people prepared to pay it, that just isn't going to happen unless you had it really wrong to begin with. (Maybe if you're already on the very high designer end you can suddenly go 10x or more as a result of being 'discovered' or going 'viral'? But not lower on the ladder, like the difference between DIY shop 'it works' vs. bespoke; carpenter vs. joiner; as discussed above.)
- rdtwo 5y agoBecause people don’t actually want to pay 5x-10x for craft items and that’s how much it costs. Craftsmen are in competition with labor in the 3rd world that gets paid 2-10$ a day instead of 50$ an hour
- saila 5y agoThat's the current situation, but what about the past several decades? The article claims that very few attractive neighborhoods were built in the US post WWII.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoThe cheap box aesthetic peaked in the sixties.
- mips_avatar 5y agoThat's where I think there's hope for a third option. Where I grew up there were a lot of Sears catalog homes, and they were really nice. Those were all manufactured and are a whole lot more beautiful than a builder grade home today.
- smileysteve 5y agoOr you can buy Ikea cabinets and have whatever quality you build (+ better hinges than prebuilt) Plus
- UncleOxidant 5y agoCabinet making is a lost art. It used to be very common, but now most cabinetry is mass produced in factories so there aren't many people around who are skilled in the art.
- rdtwo 5y agoIt’s slow and inefficient without scale and tooling. Just like how most people don’t have custom cars because it’s too expensive
- a2tech 5y agoCabinets are not almost exclusively made to order in factories. At least the ones that aren't picked up in a box at Lowes. We just had a new bathroom installed and each cabinet was hand made--in a factory settings of course, to our specifications.
- conductr 5y ago> hand made It was most likely CNC made and hand assembled. The guy doing the assembly would have no clue what to do without the CNC’d parts. The guy designing the CAD files would have no clue how to assemble the CNC’d parts. Neither of them know how to install the cabinets in your bathroom. This used to all be done by the same guy.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoA lot of them are picked up in a box at Lowes (or Depot or Ikea). Sure you can have custom ones made in a factory, but 60+ years ago most every carpenter worth his (well, they mostly were male then) salt knew how to make decent cabinets. I went to an estate sale a few years back where the deceased had been a cabinet maker - the cabinets and homemade furniture were amazing.
- lapsed_pacifist 5y agoBaumels' Cost Disease.
- hammock 5y ago>It's not the cost, it's the availability. I'm currently in the process of a home renovation. If you want a master craftsman to build you say, kitchen cabinets, you may have to wait years for them to be available. Crown molding and things went out WAY before any of these supply chain issues you've brought up from the last 1-2 years. The cost of trim wood is exponentially more than it was 50 years ago, and on top of that you cant find anyone who knows how to make custom ornamented trim.
- yeetaccount 5y agoSame reason we don’t have stone masons in every town nowadays. Too much time, too much material, not enough customer volume. Can’t operate with today’s (lack of) disposable income and material availability being diluted by an increasing population. The standard of living has gone up IMHO bc of increased efficiency in the face of dwindling resources. We don’t all live in stone mansions with servants, but a nice apartment built to code as cheaply as possible with electricity, AC and a roomba is by some measures a better life than anyone on the planet had 100 years ago. As a builder, you make more money too.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoThere's actually way more disposable income today than even 100 years ago. We just spend it on things that didn't exist before like car insurance and iPhones.
- advael 5y agoWhat do you consider "disposable income"? Car insurance is legally mandatory if you drive a car. If your income is predicated on being able to commute by car (as it is for many Americans, though hopefully a trend toward remote work will ameliorate this somewhat) then your insurance is no more optional than your gas. People also talk about smartphones as though they're a luxury item, but for most intents and purposes owning one can be viewed as required. Tons of services, including your bank, require a cell phone for authentication, if not to use their services at all. Everyone from your boss to your spouse has an expectation that you can be reached most if not all of the time. I try to avoid being reachable at all times, but this is a luxury I can afford because I'm relatively well-off and technologically adept, and I still can't get around 2FA requirements for everything. So like, if that stuff is bought with "disposable income", is rent?
- rsj_hn 5y ago"Disposable income" is not some vague philosophical term that we have to haggle over. It simply means income minus taxes paid to government. Please please don't redefine economic terms to suit your intuitive belief about what a word "should" mean because you are wading into an area where you don't know the agreed upon terminology. That impedes communication. If you want to refer to income after paying necessities, then this is "discretionary income".