3 ms·
"An asset swap of newly printed cash for bonds." What the hell is printed cash? QE just means banks get bank reserves which a have become a claim against the t
by imtringued 5y ago
"An asset swap of newly printed cash for bonds."
What the hell is printed cash? QE just means banks get bank reserves which a have become a claim against the treasury bonds. Whether you own the bonds directly or indirectly via central bank reserves doesn't matter at all. Imagine the fed issues a new currency called the treasury dollars. All you can do with treasury dollars is buy treasury bonds from the fed. That's what QE does except with bank reserves which can also be used to lend out money to businesses and consumers.
Really, QE is a nothing burger. It doesn't make consumers, businesses or governments more likely to borrow. It should be stopped because it is completely ineffective. All it really does is tighten the treasury bond market which means technical buyers (money market, insurance and pension funds) who really need the bonds will bid for increasingly lower yields on the bonds. You know that is a huge surprise, the idea behind QE was that people start selling their government bonds and buy higher yielding bonds from corporations. That didn't happen as much as the Fed wanted.
- sokoloff 5y agoLower risk-free rates lower mortgage rates which would increase mortgage affordability and amounts borrowed. That makes me, an existing home “owner” more likely to refinance, possibly with cash-out and makes many new borrowers willing/able to borrow more money than if the risk-free rate was 5% higher. I think QE does increase borrowing; it’s not clear to me that it does it for a net good.
- adam_arthur 5y agoRead my reply to the other poster, as it basically addresses this directly. But the TLDR is that it distorts the activity in the treasury markets, reducing treasury yields, and encourages risk taking/juices asset valuations. And they buy 30y treasuries, so you really think in the span of 30 years this money won't get lent out? The Fed played no small part in housing rallying 30-40% nationally in the span of 18 months. Does this seem normal or natural to you? What about the youth that want to own some day? We are multiple standard deviations above the 100yr inflation adjusted mean for housing, well above the 2008 bubble peak now. This is called pulling forward 10 years worth of gains/value to the present, IE a generational transfer of wealth from the young (non-asset owners) to the old (asset owners). For this reason alone, the policy is a total disaster. People claim to care about wealth inequality, but cheer excessively easy money policies on at every turn. The obvious other reason it's a disaster is because of moral hazard and risk taking that can lead to more epic declines than a smoothed business cycle. The Fed played a big part in the psychology around the dotcom and 2008 bubble, for example. Read up on the Greenspan Put. Earlier action from them could have prevented these. The Fed buys 60% of all newly issued treasuries. This is almost banana republic levels of monetization of the debt. Yes, the government pays interest on this debt just the same, but they have a buyer willing to pay any price without concern to fair value.