4 ms·
>In his words, even if there is ‘a mere 1 per cent chance’ of 1054 people existing in the future, then ‘the expected value of reducing existential risk by a mer
by imtringued 5y ago
>In his words, even if there is ‘a mere 1 per cent chance’ of 1054 people existing in the future, then ‘the expected value of reducing existential risk by a mere one billionth of one billionth of one percentage point is worth 100 billion times as much as a billion human lives.
I can already imagine longtermists talk about how it would be bad if they were among the billion dead because it would go against their mission statement. After all if the extinction of humanity is the death of an unimaginable number of potential human lives then avoiding the extinction of longtermism becomes equally important. How convenient...
Edit:
>Beckstead argued that we should prioritise the lives of people in rich countries over those in poor countries
This irritated me enough to edit my comment. These globally rich people have the least amount of potential because they already exceed what a single human can do by a wide margin, they are dependent on a huge amount of "supporters" to reach their current potential. Inequality by itself is causing the decline of population and economic growth.
What humanity and the economy truly needs to do is balance the demand and supply for labor on an individual level. The idea that the already rich deserve even more support results in a situation in which they supply more labor than they demand in labor, meaning they produce more than they consume or invest. The surplus which was basically earned by inefficiently allocating work to those who do not need to work then has to be distributed voluntarily through charity or involuntarily through taxation. If they do neither they save the money which is just deferred spending. The end result is that they "delay" the economy forcing governments to step in by borrowing money and spending the shortfall back into the economy or by letting the central bank adjust interest rates (no longer possible with the zero lower bound).
If you were to allocate work based on how much people intend to consume or invest then work would be allocated to poor people because they demand more labor than they currently supply. The result is that they start consuming and investing more which results in economic growth. By prioritizing the rich Beckstead is just doubling down on a prisoners dilemma that is holding our economies back. If such a person declares himself a longtermist then I honestly don't see anything long term about this movement, just more short term thinking.
- Hermitian909 5y ago> These globally rich people have the least amount of potential because they already exceed what a single human can do by a wide margin, they are dependent on a huge amount of "supporters" to reach their current potential. I don't think Beckstead would disagree, but that he's making a different point. Being able to reach your potential requires support networks and opportunities. Someone from a third world nation like Liberia will not. All things being equal, a random child born in the US will have more impact on the world than a random child from Liberia. While that could be made different, and people from those poorer countries have as great a potential as any American, it's unlikely anything will change in the near future to allow a greater proportion of them to achieve that potential. I don't want to endorse any of his ideas on whether that means American lives should take priority, but I don't think his overall point about Americans currently having a higher expected value vis a vis long term impact on humanity is wrong.