11 ms·
Stop Equating “Science” with Truth (2017)
- H8crilA 5y agoWhat's funny about p-values and effect sizes is that the "good science", like physics, would routinely score 10^-6 or lower p-values, with models that explain nearly or even exactly 100% of the variance. Having a p-value of 0.05 is incredibly weak, even if nobody is cheating. It's just a garbage process that's guaranteed to produce high % of falsehoods, where the exact % depends on the prior probability of starting with true hypotheses. Obligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/ I mean think about the Newtonian mechanics, there really isn't almost any room for error. And once the model was pushed into more and more extreme applications and errors were eventually spotted the theory was refined into new mechanics.
- clairity 5y agodespite the sophisticated math required, physics is also orders of magnitude simpler than biology, chemistry, or the social sciences, which is why physics models can reach that level of certainty and other sciences haven’t yet.
- _3u10 5y agoWe just expect different things from those sciences. Physical simulations go equally awry on the large scale, like predicting the weather a week out.
- dangle1 5y agoScience is an amazing but frustrating tool. Amazing in the sense that it is the only way to reliably learn more about what is happening around us. Frustrating because it is much slower than we'd like in providing reliable answers in many situations (pandemics, perhaps even climate change). And the gap between gathering observations and reaching agreed upon conclusions gets filled with normal but unhelpful human behaviors. It's especially frustrating in medicine, perhaps most in behavioral medicine, because there are so many degrees of freedom in human behavior and value judgments assigned to behaviors.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- avalys 5y agoIf you want the truth, talk to an engineer, not a scientist.
- lbriner 5y agoHow would that help? Engineering is probably even more polarised than general science because engineers are all about the black-and-white. The difficult part is that life is much more nuanced. Even if a woman's brain is objectively different than a man's, there might be a social or environmental reason, it might or might not have an effect on their abilities in different areas. Maybe if women and people of colour were given 500 years of time like white men, then maybe their brains would be the same as men. Who knows? The danger is probably not science per-se but the pressure to find nice summaries to difficult problems. You would get a PhD on "women aren't as clever as men" much more easily than "the differences between mens and womens brains are really complicated and hard to understand"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- avalys 5y agoThat's kind of my point. Engineers are about black and white because that's what's required to make decisions, to ship things, to actually make something work. Actionable truths are black and white. Anyone can say "Oh, it's nuanced, it's complicated, it's hard to say for sure." The challenge is in penetrating that nuance and identifying what it is possible to make definitive, black-and-white statements about (i.e., to find the truth). To the extent that any group in society does this for a living, it's engineers.
- rvense 5y agoActually, you should talk to a couple of them, because each will have their own version of the absolute, obvious truth (and a long list of reasons why everyone else is wrong and dumb) and then you can just pick the truth you like the most.
- SquibblesRedux 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jimmaswell 5y agoThis sounds like "some science has said things I don't like, so you shouldn't refer to science as a point in an argument."
- CoastalCoder 5y agoI understood the author to be making a different point. I don't think she was saying that the conclusions of science-like processes are worthless. Just that they shouldn't be treated as inscrutable fact, for the reasons stated in the article.
- exporectomy 5y agoConsidering the entire content is aligned with a popular political ideology, it's clear that she's just using it as an argument for her ideology. She even implied that a straw-man claim she attributed to science was wrong for no other reason that that it was the year 2017. The very first sentence is critical of the fact that people are trying to understand something scientific!
- jpeloquin 5y agoYeah. I think a key sentence is, "It is impossible to consider this field of science without grappling with the flaws of the institution—and of the deification—of science itself." The process of science, that is, actually checking to see if one's beliefs are consistent with reality, is essential to distinguish truth from falsity. Scientific institutions can and have done terrible things though. TFA references scientific racism; the eugenics movement is related to it and still-existing scientific institutions had a significant role in promoting eugenics. See [0] for a self-critical overview. That's the "flaws of the institution" part. The "deification of science" part refers to how the effectiveness of science as a problem-solving tool gives a sort of halo effect (truthiness) to anything that adopts the semblance of science. That's kind of unavoidable; if something works, it gets status, and people will try to have some of that status rub off on them. I sort of disagree with the article's statement that "pseudoscience has always been a core feature of post-Enlightenment scientific knowledge and it remains that way because scientists refuse to integrate contemporary science, technology, and society studies research into university curricula." Scientists are critical of themselves and their fields and teach and discuss the material covered in TFA. The author was trained as a scientist, and their critiques mirror those expressed within science; again, see [0] for an example. If you do human subjects research as a professional scientist, you receive an intensive education in the ways science (and medicine) has failed to treat people as people, and accept strong limitations and oversight on your own research activities. I also sort of agree with the author though because the same level of education is not generally provided with regards to science's role in sexism or racism, at least not to the same rigor as human subjects research. [0] U.S. Scientists' Role in the Eugenics Movement (1907–1939): A Contemporary Biologist's Perspective https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2757926/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2757926/
- agumonkey 5y agoReading the history of science is a good reminder too. The amount of mistakes and struck of luck. Science is a quest in models. With a somehow high degree of self consistency (poetically so). But that's it.
- swayvil 5y agoMost of us prefer to live inside a game. The rules of the game are what we call "truth". Truth is nice because it's simple. No thinking about it required. No energy spent puzzling. It's just truth. No how, why, who or anything about it. It's just truth. The best truths are gotten from authorities. They're the best because the truth comes preformatted in statement form. Thus it's ez to consume. And the truth clicks nicely into your fantasy like a lego into a bunch of other legos.
- jes 5y ago> Most of us prefer to live inside a game. I am interested in hearing about how you escaped the game, should you wish to say more.
- _3u10 5y agoThe only way to win is not to play.
- JasonFruit 5y agoMicrodosing LSD, duh. This is HN.
- jes 5y agoI was thinking I might get a reply about non-duality or something else along those lines, as that topic interests me. That being said, I'm down with people exploring psychedelics if they wish to do so.
- jes 5y agoFor whatever reason, I always seem to hit a mental speed-bump when someone mentions "the truth." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (the SEP) has a long article [1] on the subject of Truth. There are multiple competing claims as to what is meant when we say that something is true. [1] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/truth https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/truth
- goatlover 5y agoOn a deflationary account of truth, scientific statements can be true if they meet the standard of empirical verification. It’s raining diamonds on Saturn is true if we can detect diamond rain on Saturn right now.
- bawolff 5y agoWas it also "true" in 1877 when Giovanni Schiaparelli detected canals on mars that there were canals on mars?
- SquibblesRedux 5y agoObservations and subsequent inferences should always come with probabilities. No matter how beautiful the math, the measurement is never perfect.
- mithr 5y agoI think this is kind of a reductive, attention-grabbing headline. The real intention is "stop equating 'the scientific process' with 'the entire body of knowledge that has ever been produced by people calling themselves scientists'". The body of knowledge produced by scientists includes real truths, but also a lot of work produced by people without good methodology, and a lot of things that were thought to be correct at the time but were later disproved. And as the author mentioned, none of this is exempt from whatever society-level base assumptions were thought to be indisputable at the time. For all that, the scientific process, while imperfect in many ways, is still the best way the human race has so far discovered to learn and advance. You could say that the pursuit of science is, by definition, the pursuit of truth.
- moonchrome 5y ago>is still the best way the human race has so far discovered to learn and advance The way I see it - it's really successful in some domains and is worse than useless in others - because it rides on credibility it acquired in the domains it is effective in, it creates false confidence in results it produces in domains it doesn't fit.
- hackbinary 5y agoThis article sets up a strawman argument and then attempts whataboutry to prove her thesis. She is neither an expert in the philosophy of science, philosophy, or any of the fields she is critiquing. She also fails represent what science actually is: a way to organise the best set of information we have collected thus far. Science has never claimed to be the absolute truth on anything, and that an implied assertion the author is attempting to make. In the end, the author is only able to prove that science, like all human endeavours, is imperfect. She let all of us down by failing to say what she would replace it with, or simply articulate reasonable boundaries through which science ought to be seen.
- exporectomy 5y agoShe makes a clear implication that she would replace it with her own cultural ideologies.
- rob74 5y agoWhile it is important to reaffirm that science != truth, it is even more important to reaffirm that (proper) science most of the time is considerably closer to the truth than "the stuff some random wacko posts on YouTube/Facebook/Twitter/whatever", even if that stuff offers easier explanations for the problems of the world...
- systemvoltage 5y agoTrue, and most of these wackos range from home-remedy moms to yogi babas. The worrying trend without a counter force is authorities like Big Tech and institutions masquerading imperfect science as truth. Just look at the Covid shit show we’ve seen. Makes you wonder if these people should hold any power whatsoever. We should strive to be transparent. Whether that’s debunking bad science or doubling down on good science.
- badRNG 5y ago> The worrying trend without a counter force is authorities like Big Tech and institutions masquerading imperfect science as truth. I think it's a matter of triaging problems. The situation we are in is that thousands of potentially preventable deaths are happening every week because a significant portion of the public trusts polemicists and Facebook memes for medical information more than their own doctors (this isn't intended to be hyperbolic or to strawman that position, I believe that to be a fair assessment of the situation.) Is so-called Big Tech really being too tough on misinformation? And even if it is, is that an issue we should prioritize ahead of other measurable harms caused by that same misinformation?
- ccn0p 5y agoBut should it really be big tech's responsibility to triage? If so, based on what information? The CDC? WHO? Then what happens if a doctor on the frontline wants to disagree with one particular aspect of the "authoritative source" information, posts their discoveries on Facebook/Youtube, and is censored because it was classified as misinformation? That would effectively mean the government is suppressing speech. Sounds fine and dandy as long as you, the consumer of information, is aligned with the authoritative sources, but history has shown time in and time out that regimes change and that power is intoxicating and that those that want suppressed speech can eventually become the suppressed. Nobody says this better IMO than Ira Glasser who led the ACLU from '78-2001 and defended the rights of Nazi's to march. Check out the documentary Mighty Ira.
- nicodjimenez 5y agoScience if: if X happens, then Y happens. The truth is asking what is X and is a mostly philosophical exercise, but the truth becomes pragmatic when belief in X lead to Y outcomes. Eg belief in God can lead to good outcomes even if God itself is unverifiable in a scientific sense. The truth can be a self fulfilling prophesy.
- paulpauper 5y ago"trust the science" used to be spoken unironically. I think the pro-science side during Covid shot themselves in the foot with zealotry and false sense of certainty. Science , unlike religion, should be amendable. It's supposed to be provisional. A major part of science is debate, the inquiry of knowledge, not just being told to shut-up for the sake of science.
- korla 5y agoI think you're equating the pro-mask side with some pro-science side. None of which has to do with the validity of science, or what truth is. You're talking about politics.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoThe "trust the science" people are using science to justify their political positions, which come with them the force of law backed up by government threats of violence.
- rootusrootus 5y agoMeanwhile, the 'do your own research' people are using Dr. Shiva as their counter-science argument. Yeah, that Dr. Shiva.
- bawolff 5y agoIsn't that the way its supposed to be? Scientists discover what they can (falliable as they may be). Politicians take scientist's best understanding at the time, balance the concerns of various groups, and make a decision. Politicians decisions are backed up with violence (always, not just for this) because states having a monoply on violence is just how states work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ccn0p 5y ago
- darepublic 5y agorails on science while throwing out social sciences theories left and right as undeniable truth, all unironically.
- molbioguy 5y agoWe should stop making Science a religion. Science is a powerful tool for generating and validating models of how things work. But it often works slowly and is certainly fallible (at least in the short run). Science as a methodology and persuit should be praised and supported, but shouldn't be followed blindly based on the views of a subset of scientists. Scientists often disagree about the details of models -- more than people outside the field would believe.
- agumonkey 5y agoProblem today is that rapid access to text made people think they could integrate and digest the whole thing.
- drewcoo 5y ago> rapid access to text made people think they could integrate and digest the whole thing Are you talking about the Internet or the bible?
- agumonkey 5y agomaybe both. Actually I'm talking about post web 2 era. I've seen increasing amount of people very "knowledgeable" about the "scientific method" but who never made derived one proof in their life or never made up a concept from zero. It's very painful to see sheeps throwing wikipedia paragraphs pavlov style. Talking about the bible, there was a talk about the printing press and the fact that it made debates a bit saner since people could avoid hearsay. The Bible might not be the most refutable piece but it seems it gave some kind of stable ground for discourse.. (according to the people at that conference)
- rvense 5y ago> We should stop making Science a religion. Unfortunately, we appear to be quite fundamentally, in the vaguest sense of the word, religious beings...
- 5y ago
- darth_avocado 5y agoFrom Wikipedia: Science (from Latin scientia 'knowledge')[1] is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the world. Science can be equated with Truth, but not what passes as science these days. All the author talks about are papers, peer reviews and academia, which at this point everyone is aware, is full of fabrication. Countless peer reviewed papers don't have findings that can be reproduced, a lot of them are just summaries of other questionable studies. I think it's important to define what is considered science and what is not science before we get into the discussion of whether science is the Truth or not.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI believe that "Science" is not a monolith and our language/culture currently lacks the model necessary to distinguish between "significant and unlikely to change" versus "specific, moment in time" science. I'm actually struggling to articulate this concept myself because I'm having trouble picking two existing words to describe it. When I say "significant and unlikely to change" I'm referring to thinks like physical laws, kinematics, chemistry, that sort of thing. The "science" of these fields is essentially "settled" and there is not a reproducibility crisis in this domain. There is a high level of trust in this kind of scientific knowledge. Contrast this to "specific, moment in time" studies, with things like nutrition, social sciences, economics, policy, etc. You could call these soft sciences, but I don't think that concept does it justice. We deal with this domain constantly when arguing via back-and-forth citations online. You can find dozens of studies that assert X is true and dozens of others that assert X is false. A paper might have been published in a reputable journal but that does not mean it is now the "Truth" in the same way that we ascribe studies in the first category. For instance, a paper published about evolutionary psychology is not as true as evolution itself. Yet, we bucket both into the same category of "Science". There is a massive reproducibility crisis in this domain and it really does seem like many studies are only "true" in the confines of that study when it happened. When people cite this kind of science they piggyback off of the reputation of the first kind. I think that is the crux of the issue mentioned in the article.
- mikkergp 5y agoPart of the problem is that medicine, with its life and death implications, is more like the second than the first.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoAbsolutely, and some really weird effects show up because of human behavior and expectations during treatment. Did you know that patients think older drugs are less effective than newer ones? This is almost like a placebo effect, but people will literally not respond as well if they are being told they're getting an older drug than a newer one. How bizarre is that? You would think the efficacy would be objective since the molecules haven't changed. But I doubt any study could control for the introduction of some new treatment decades later.
- b0rsuk 5y ago[dead]
- scoofy 5y agoI read articles like this and once again realize that there are many trained scientists that have never read a bit of philosophy. The underlying theory of why the scientific method is so successful is there, and it's often ignored. There is a reason why we use the scientific method, and why we know that our knowledge is inherently limited, and presents itself as a dance between inductive model-building, and deductive model extrapolation. Science-as-truth should generally be always thought of as nonsense. Well done, falsifiable, repeatable, science-as-really-good-prediction is a much better model. It's important to remember that even in the standard model of physics, behemoth of human achievement, is both incomplete and limited in scope.
- trutannus 5y ago> there are many trained scientists that have never read a bit of philosophy Not only not read a bit of philosophy, but it's almost as common to find trained scientists who scoff at the field as a whole. Of the trained scientists I've met, only two didn't immediately respond with condescension when I brought up philosophy as a subject worth paying attention to. Several have actually tried to tell me that science and philosophy are "opposites", or went with the the tired line of "philosophy is just science that does not have any proof for it". That last one there fundamentally misunderstands the point of it all. An ignorance philosophy in general I think is a problem right now.
- logicalmonster 5y agoScience qua science can provide humans with (close to) objectively accurate information, obviously constrained by the limits of human understanding of the natural world and the technology we have to measure phenomena. What science can't do is the following: * Science cannot make risk-management decisions for people. Weighing the known and unknown rewards and risks of some human decision and choosing what human action to take based on objective information is outside of the realm of science. No, the science cannot make choices for humans. Rational and smart people, when presented with the same scientific evidence, can make different choices. For instance, there have been many times in the past when the European Medicines Agency and the US Food and Drug Administration have had differing opinions on whether or not some drug ought to be approved. Risk management is a different topic than science, yet they get wrongly conflated every day on TV these days. * Science cannot make value judgements or ethical decisions for humans. There are some hills that humans find to be important enough to be worth taking some risk for. Science cannot decide whether "freedom" is important enough to risk dying for, yet rational humans have made and will continue to choose freedom as long as free will exists.
- didibus 5y agoI agree on the second part, science cannot decide what we humans want for ourselves and value and prioritize. Science is a means to an end, the end is what we have to decide for ourselves. But when it comes to risk-management, I think science plays a big role, it can allow you to assess risk and predict probability of outcomes. That's super important in risk-management. What science cannot do is decide your risk appetite, risk tolerance as well as risk preferences. You also need to choose which scientific model you also believe in the most, and when limited experimentation has occurred, science cannot help you choose, though more scientific research could give you comparative data between two scientific models that can help you choose. But all this takes time. And when time is limited, science can't take its normal course, that's where human judgement is necessary.
- jjmorrison 5y agoThis person either did not read that memo or read what they wanted from it. It makes no claim of individual inferiority or superiority.
- dekhn 5y agoLarge areas of psychology research are nonscientific. They simply don't qualify as producing testable models that, when tested repeatedly, hold up. This is one of the mistakes that the Damore memo made: the author attempted to justify his claims based on shaky science, which didn't help his argument. Now, let's talk about another area of science. The structure of DNA, or whether electron spin exists or what the shape of the earth is. There are no questions in my mind (beyond the normal ones I have about Descartes' Great Deceiver) that the structure of DNA in aqueous solution at room temperature with 15mM Mg is B-form, very close to what was described by Watson and Crick, or that electron spin exists and that we can use it to do NMR to determine molecular structures. And the planet Earth is an oblate spheroid. All three of those are so true that if you were able to disprove either, massive areas of science would fall. I cannot imagine any set of data which could falsify any of those three hypotheses in a way that didn't completely tank science.
- bloaf 5y agoStereotypes are often better predictors of human behavior than actual psychological research. [0] Would Damore been more justified in his memo if he simply cited common stereotypes rather than psychology research? Throwing out psychology, as the author of the original piece wants to do, is a double edged sword. You may knock the legs out from under Damore's stool, but you have no evidence left to use to argue against him. Indeed, quite a few people's "gut feelings" are going to be aligned with his argument. [0] https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2016-jussim.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2016-jussim.pdf
- dekhn 5y agoI don't see the need to use evidence to argue against (or for Damore). Everything he said is just opinion, not an actual argument. If instead you want to have an interesting argument, people shoudl start with Larry Summers, who articulated the same question but in a much more intelligent way (and was still cancelled because of it!): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Summers#Differences_between_the_sexes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Summers#Differences_b... https://web.archive.org/web/20080130023006/http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html https://web.archive.org/web/20080130023006/http://www.presid... Anybody who cares about Damore's message one way or the other should go back and read what Larry said, and internalize it. A brilliant leader was cancelled because he spoke what is the most likely hypothesis to explain the observed data.
- meroes 5y agoSellars, "Sellars thinks that science’s aperspectival description of the empirical world is the measure of reality", and Carnap, "Since science in principle can say all that can be said, there is no unanswerable question left", would disagree. Or at least we'd have to distinguish what we call science. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sellars/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sellars/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spacetime-bebecome/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spacetime-bebecome/
- bawolff 5y agoI feel like truth is the limit (in a calculus sense) of science. We can never get there. Sometimes we're close, and sometimes we're far away. Science allows us to approximate "truth" better and better, putting bounds on it. To take it a religious way, science is the lantern in this story from babylon 5 https://youtu.be/JjnpTcvGvts https://youtu.be/JjnpTcvGvts .
- AdrianB1 5y agoI think the article is misguided; there are, at least in my languages, 2 very clear definitions for science: "exact sciences" and the others. They all have in common the use of scientific methods, but that's it: one set is precise, the likes on "1+1=2" math or engineering and the others that are very imprecise like phycology, for example. Anyone using non-precise sciences to make a point against all "science" is malevolent, in my opinion.
- dragonwriter 5y agoThere are no such things as “exact sciences”; if it is exact, its pure logic, not empirical science. If it deals with the real world rather than pure abstractions, it is inexact and science is a continuous effort of refinement of approximation. Some fields of science offer easier opportunity for controls and more clarity of results, but even the clearest is not exact.
- AdrianB1 5y agoIt is not a term I invented, just told about it; in the universities in my country the use of the term is the norm, so don't shoot the messenger. A quick check shows me we have several universities with this name, one example is here: https://stiinteexacte.uav.ro/prezentare/prezentare https://stiinteexacte.uav.ro/prezentare/prezentare
- dragonwriter 5y agoSure, I know the name is a thing; I’m just pointing out that the name is misleading.
- scoofy 5y agoI mean, I feel that this take is by far the most misguided. There are no "exact sciences." Even suggesting as much shows a deep misunderstanding of what science is. Mathematics is not a science, it is a deductive framework based on axioms that are effectively arbitrary. Engineering is a exercise in applied use of physics, chemistry, and other sciences. Wide of margins for error are employed in most engineering exactly because most engineers know what variables they don't know, and even still there are engineering failures that regularly occur.
- antisthenes 5y agoFar worse than equating science with truth is equating expert opinions with layman opinions. The latter is toxic to the very fabric of society and erodes the value of expertise in all fields and stifles useful and informed public discourse.
- bloaf 5y agoThis is dangerous reasoning; the google memo incident shows science walks a narrow path, and there are pitfalls all around. Science is the best sword we have to separate truth from falsehood; to say that science is wrong and biased whenever it doesn't say what we like is to commit the exact same sin against scholarship as Damore. Damore didn't like what he was hearing from the diversity experts so he went and cherry picked the studies that supported his gut feeling. Cherry picking is still cherry picking even when you're doing it in defense of diversity. I think one of the under-discussed aspects of the whole debacle was the is-ought problem [0], i.e. the gap between statements about "what is" and statements about what "ought to be." Science works very well on "what is" questions. It can tell us that the earth is warming. It can tell us all the things that will happen as the earth warms, and all the things we could do that that would stop the earth from warming. But when it comes time to decide what temperature the earth "ought" to be, we can't ask science; we have to first decide what our goals are. If our goal is to maximize short term profit, we will get a different answer than if we want to maximize long term sustainability. In the same way, science can't tell us what the gender ratio "should" be. Its on us to decide what our priorities are. If our goal is short term profit, we will undoubtedly prefer a different ratio than if we are trying to achieve a more egalitarian society in the long term. So that is why the author's assertion "In fact, science has often made its living from encoding and justifying bias, and refusing to do anything about the fact that the data says something’s wrong." is a misrepresentation of science. Science tells us "the earth is warming", we are the ones who have to add "and that is wrong." Science tells us "there is bias", we are the ones who have to add "and that is wrong." That scientists in the past have failed to add that last bit (or even added "and that is good!") is not adequate justification for the author to simply dismiss science. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem
- sudorook 5y agoI hadn't thought of the Damore fiasco in a while. I'm not particularly pleased to revisit it. To me, it was a strong indicator to those in industry that a good-faith attempt at discussion on potentially controversial topics can blow up _badly_. One is better off to keep silent and not stick one's neck out. Since then, I've seen worrying trends in academia that suggest it will follow suit... In the years since 2017, there has been a strong push for scientists to take upon themselves the responsibility for not just conducting research but also for the way the public discussion unfolds. To so do, they collaborate to create uniform messaging so that bad actors cannot find disagreements over details and implications and use them to sow divisions among the general public or, at worst, inflict harm on populations deemed vulnerable. This creates problems in that scientists are pressured to be silent with their own disagreements. (e.g. One should not value one's individuality over solidarity.) This is particularly acute if one is in the minority of opinion. My concern is that over time, this pressure will diminish variance in opinion on any given topic. Variance will become invariance, and that invariance will then be misinterpreted as proof of Truth. Any research or even opinion at odds with it become outrageous. As this unfolds, more and more people will fall into the same trap as the author --- dismissing unpalatable albeit tendentiously backed arguments as unscientific and reflective of deep, un-measurable cultural evils while accepting extrapolations from similarly tendentious research that backs a more acceptable narrative, e.g. "because the authors of the paper are women, ... we can expect 10 percent fewer citations." I find all of this deeply dispiriting. The capacity for science to produce models that reflect the natural world depends on the free dissemination and interrogation of all ideas. Though John Stuart Mill wrote on free speech, his works are even more important in science. If people cannot freely question broadly and deeply held beliefs, they risk losing the knowledge of _why_ they are so deeply held by so many. If that ever happens, we will have lost something truly precious.
- ccn0p 5y agoVery well said. I don't have any insider knowledge on the way "Science" happens, but I can say from personal experience that this is exactly how politics in the US seems to be trending. You're allowed a certain range of thought, and if you go outside that range, there's some level of social/communal ostracizing that happens. Dispiriting is a great description. I feel like this leads to further separation of actual physical communities as well with subsequent separation of governance styles, further polarizing the country in a fly-wheel effect.
- pcvarmint 5y agoSee "Scientism and Values", by Helmut Schoeck and James Wiggins [1]. [1] https://mises.org/library/scientism-and-values https://mises.org/library/scientism-and-values