5 ms·
Before you can make this claim, you'll need to put your definition of merit out there, and additionally defend that the 10% we're talking about here truly has t
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
Before you can make this claim, you'll need to put your definition of merit out there, and additionally defend that the 10% we're talking about here truly has this meritorious status.
- twoquestions 5y agoIn addition to this, OP should also prove that these people have others' best interest in mind. Without some sort of accountability, increasing most people's standard of living is irrational. I've read enough early US industrial history and the history of the East India Company to see how this can get horrifying with a quickness.
- TameAntelope 5y agoHonestly? I don't know, and if pressed I'd have a hard time coming up with a usefully specific answer, but I still believe what I do; that not everyone should be forcibly allowed to participate. Maybe that's helpful? I do think there are marginalized groups and that should be accounted for (ideally, in my limited understanding of the problem, by raising those groups up), but I don't think "baseline" should be, "Everyone is equally involved in steering the US economy."
- avgcorrection 5y ago> > Okay, I'll say it; good. Democracy is fine as a method to run a government, ... > [...] > Honestly? I don't know, and if pressed I'd have a hard time coming up with a usefully specific answer, but I still believe what I do; Strong words spoken from atop the pile of sand.
- TameAntelope 5y agoYes, I believe something with low certainty, at least partially because I can't fully articulate it. That doesn't mean I don't believe it, however, and I can't think of a better way to grow my understanding of something than to take a position on it on the Internet! Almost all of my beliefs/opinions are built on some form or another of sand. Certainty is the real mind killer, IMO.
- fighterpilot 5y agoIn a free-market system, merit is defined by your peers. If you can add unique subjective value to them, they will give you money in return for that unique subjective value add. That's by and large a great thing, because it means that the people getting the richest are largely the same people who are providing the most value to others, and so it aligns incentives with useful production and useful work in a decentralized way. We can zoom into examples to understand better. Why is George Clooney so rich? Because he added a little bit of value (say, $3 worth) to the lives of millions via his acting skills, and he got a slice of all that value add. This is not to say it's perfect, and I could go on about why it's not, but the central point is that "merit" (i.e. income/profits) is defined by one's peers opinions about your unique value add to them.
- Klinky 5y agoMore money might also mean you're just really good at colluding, anti-competing, price fixing/gouging, arbitraging, exploiting, socializing expenses and negative outcomes, or monopolizing. It's extremely flawed and naive to think a positive balance sheet means a positive outcome for society occurred in the process of obtaining it.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThat's why I said I could go on about why it's not perfect. I admit there's downsides, but I still view it as a great thing on net, due to the general tendency to align incentives with value provision.
- colordrops 5y agoThe system is heavily corrupt. The premise that it is mostly working with some flaws itself is heavily flawed.
- Klinky 5y agoIt's not just "not perfect", it's extremely flawed. You didn't "go on" at all about its flaws or failures at measuring merit, and only provided a toy example of a superfluous mega-rich celebrity deserving his wealth while ignoring Hollywood's underhanded exploitation and accounting issues.