18 ms·
Writer Liu Cixin on How His Visions of the Future Collide with Reality
- makeitrain 5y agoI can't read the article because paywall, but Cixin Liu's three body problem trilogy had had a big impact on me. A big theme of the books is how we collectively process information and make decisions. The world is threatened by an alien species and different people have different strategies for deference. They need to pick something that can't be predicted and defeated. Essentially earth needs a collective poker face while rapidly innovating a unique solution. There is an implied parallel between human behavior and quantum particles. Our decisions are influenced by the information we have and signals from people and our surroundings. Quantum particle movement is influenced by the dynamic combination of forces on it. Both have probable outcomes from an observable state, but that observation influences the behavior of both. I'm left thinking about the nature of reality. Some things are probable, and some seem random. When we see an option we like, we can nudge the situation towards it. When we don't like the options, we can take a walk or try something new and shake up the probability field we exist in to generate new options. We can't predict the future because it depends on a series of interactions that have unpredictable outcomes. The three body problem explains how this is difficult to compute linearly. The best we can do is identify probabilities based on the information we have and our understanding of the model. Quantum particles exist in a wave until they are observed in a specific point. When the wave function collapses, it goes from being probably here, to definitely there. I experience this in situations with dynamic outcomes. IE, I think this client is likely to sign today, but they may not. Sports plays are another good example. When we no longer have the ball in our frame of reference, it is probably somewhere in the direction we last saw it go. When it's in the goal, everyone sees it there. It leads me to think about free will. We can go with the flow and give in to our influences. Or we can be decisive and do something else. The effects of our actions influence others in expected and unpredictable ways. I can have a great time being passive, just watching a movie or having a drink. I also enjoy being creative and taking risks. I get to experience the things other people contribute and share what I've found. I don't know what's out there beyond our understanding, but I've come to really appreciate the system we exist in.
- alexitorg 5y agoI enjoyed the Three body Problem. It reminded me of post war US science fiction novel. Simplistic aliens who are clearly our foes, heroic male leads, paper thin female characters and a bit of the confident can do swagger that comes with a booming economy.
- kieckerjan 5y agoThat hardly sounds like a recommendation.
- muro 5y agoThe premise itself was good (especially in the second book) and I think the female characters were fine. I enjoyed the trilogy.
- nootropicat 5y agoI think literally all truly catastrophic events in the book were caused by females acting like immature children. They don't really suffer any consequences of their actions - nothing comparable to the magnitude of their sins - others do. It's an extremely antifeminist trilogy and clearly intended to be so. The alternative apt title would be 'How feminism destroys civilizations'. I don't think there's a spoiler tag on HN, so I wrote it as vaguely as it can be without spoiling the story. (please note I'm just describing how the book is, not making a statement about feminism)
- TremendousJudge 5y ago
- OneTimePetes 5y agoWe have seen over the last decades a great reduction in "exponential" dangerous technologie, that gets handed out to the people. We will not have flying cars with little fusion bombs at there hearts. We will not have road cars with plutonium rods. We will not have software centralization, after Amazon hosting gets its first machine jumping virus. It turns out that humanity can be limited by policy and moderated by social engineering technology. So im now careful optimistic about these things. We will not perish because we handed weapons of doom to one of the uncamped billions.
- Borrible 5y agoNot impressed by TBP, even though I enjoyed it with interest. The 'Chinese Gorilla in the room coming out of the closet' phenomenon, the 'rising super power, we have to read it' effect, ya know. 'Oh look, its Chinese and shiny!' Personally, I vastly prefer SF that collides with "reality", like Philip K. Dick's.
- esarbe 5y agoI didn't really enjoy the three body problem. While the science part was nice, the characters were just plain out boring and forgettable. In those aspects it's very similar to The Foundation trilogy. Didn't enjoy that one either. From the interview: > But now, many of the most famous male stars here embrace their feminine qualities. I guess that interview was done before the current cultural purge started.
- Fellshard 5y agoThat's a pretty current view of Chinese national policy, actually, so it doesn't come as a surprise at all. From what I recall, Liu takes a party line; I believe he defended their treatment of Uyghurs in recent interviews, for example.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoWell, at the risk of sounding like a coward, I would toe the party line also if I lived in China and had any public presence. The price of publicly opposing Xi Jinping's policies is disappearing for a year or so then making a scripted subdued apology on CCTV.
- esarbe 5y agoCoward here, too. The perfidious thing is that even emigrating doesn't put you out of Xi Jinping's grasp. It's well documented how pressure is applied to vocal opponents of the new Leaders policies by going after their families in China.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoYep, happens in New Zealand on the regular. It's well known that all the local Chinese language newspapers toe the party line, and Chinese community groups (especially Skykiwi) are infiltrated by the CCP to a rather large extent, and if you're overly critical, well, hopefully you managed to get residence visas for 奶奶 / nǎi nai and 姥姥 / lǎo lao beforehand. Also, expect to be ostracised by the emigrant Chinese community. Oh, and even if you're not Chinese, but you're critical of China, well... https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/the-curious-case-of-the-burgled-professor/LIFRYA3UBZNGCZPT45NB77KCY4/ https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/the-curious-case-of-the-burgle...
- baybal2 5y agoI was expecting the "where it collides with reality" to be at least somewhat touch the nuclear war topic with 3 players. Even the name of the trilogy is an allegory on the "three countries" — a historical novell any Chinese speaker will instantly recognise. Now, we have similarly 3 nuclear superpower countries: Russia, USA, and China. The question he wanted to ask was "How will the three will act when it will come to press the big red button?"
- smhost 5y agoA small price to pay for a country that isn't confused about its place in the world, where one half of the population wants to kill the other half, and so on. Pick your poison, I suppose.
- simonh 5y ago[flagged]
- Aunche 5y ago>Is the price the Uyghurs pay worth it? How exactly is defying the Party's wishes as a minor celebrity going to help the Uyghurs in any way? I feel like the Western view of morality these days is completely divorced from cause and effect. It's no surprise that they can spend trillions of dollars on developing a government that collapses within a week.
- smhost 5y agoWell, what's the alternative? You can either have a truly mulitcultural society like China, where the government spends a lot of effort elevating minority cultures, building cultural centers, and arabizing the infrastructure; or you can have a deeply racist society that leaves its minority population to rot in prisons and sewers, or to leave it to its worst vices, all in the name of so-called "freedom".
- schwartzworld 5y agoThe Three Body Problem should be retitled. Here are some ideas: - Nothin' But Plot Holes - Attack of the Flat, Interchangable Characters - the Four Body Problem (since the trilsolarans don't actually live in a 3-body system I'm convinced that the only way to like that book is to have never read real SF before. It's so hackneyed and tropey. People call it hard sf, but it's the opposite.
- typon 5y agoI wouldn't call TBP "hard sf", its more like hard fantasy sf. It delivers on that pretty well - better than anything other series I have read. As for hackneyed and tropey, I can't think of another sf series that has this many original ideas presented in a way that's this compelling.
- jmull 5y agoDon't get too hung up on the "hard sf" label. It effectively just means, "The science presented seemed plausible enough to me that it didn't distract or annoy me." It's entirely personal since we all have different levels of fluency in science, and different levels of tolerance for the dissonance we feel when we read something we know is wrong.
- dobladov 5y agoCan you recommend real sci-fi books?
- lazyweb 5y agoNot OP, but Greg Egan is mentioned somewhat often around here. Having read some of is books (Schild's Ladder, Permutation City, Diaspora) I can firmly recommend them, and would assign them the "hard sci-fi" tag. You can also never go wrong with Arthur C. Clarke. Another favourite of mine, "Tomorrow and Tomorrow" by Charles Sheffield.
- dnautics 5y agoGreg Egan's diaspora is fantastic. I can't stop thinking about that book.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.md/KrPuN https://archive.md/KrPuN
- AniseAbyss 5y agoCyberpunk from the 1980s is notoriously ridiculous. And the geniuses at CDPro made it even worse by shifting the timeline 50 years to 2077... Predicting the future is surprisingly hard.
- ivanstojic 5y agoRemember. Liu Cixin said the following about Chinese internment camps for Uighur: “Would you rather that they be hacking away at bodies at train stations and schools in terrorist attacks? If anything, the government is helping their economy and trying to lift them out of poverty,” Liu said, adding: “If you were to loosen up the country a bit, the consequences would be terrifying.” I wonder if that’s also something where his vision collides with reality.
- herendin 5y agoThe source of that quote, which adds a little explanation of his reasoning and thought process: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/06/24/liu-cixins-war-of-the-worlds https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/06/24/liu-cixins-war...
- beebmam 5y agoThis source makes that quote even more damning. The same logic Liu uses here is the same argument slave societies used to justify themselves; that: "If China were to transform into a democracy, it would be hell on earth," is exactly the same logic that Slave Owners used to justify the permanent enslavement of millions of people. These are some profoundly shameful words. I'm genuinely shocked that anyone on Hacker News would consider Liu a decent human being.
- istorical 5y agoI would suggest examining this question of 'what level of state intervention to create public safety and public order is just' without framing one's own perspective or the cultural norm of one's own place and time as the obvious 'correct' answer. One from the future or some utopian free-love society could argue that 21st century western neoliberal capitalist states with police and criminal justice systems as they are and economic systems as they are are themselves permanent enslavement of millions of people. And if you'd argue 'well, I believe in abolishing the police, ending the drug war, and UBI for all' I'm sure they could still find parts of your worldview that would be pretty much just enslavement. Maybe the idea of pet ownership, of forced education of what we currently call 'children', maybe some taboo around sex or love. In which case, that future person could say that they're genuinely shocked that anyone on Hacker News could consider _you_ a decent human being. My point is simply, there's no simple 'obvious' answer when it comes an ethical / moral / economic question as large as this. It's a question of trade-offs and optimizing for different goals / values / metrics.
- chaostheory 5y agoI'm not sure why so few people are aware of this, but The Three Body Problem is just thinly veiled nationalist propaganda. All you have to do to see it is switch the alien antagonists with Western colonial powers.
- yongjik 5y ago> All you have to do to see it is switch the alien antagonists with Western colonial powers. Isn't this basically saying "If you read the bad guys as the West, then the novel portrays the West as the bad guys"?
- mdoms 5y agoYes every Chinese person is out to get you.
- chaostheory 5y ago1. Do you know what I'm referring to? 2. I have only mentioned one sci-fi author, and not an entire ethnic group. 3. I am also Chinese myself.
- SkyMarshal 5y agoI think that part is obvious, at least to anyone who can read between the lines, so maybe not to young children. Also in a world still trying to make nice with the CCP, nobody was going to talk much about that aspect anyway. But the interesting thing that Liu accomplished with these books, is communicating how it feels to be faced with a technologically superior adversary intent on colonizing you. That’s not something most modern Americans and many others have ever experienced, but Liu made it universally relatable. Worse, you have a means of leveling the playing field, rapidly catching up, but your leaders and society keep making poor decisions, preventing you from doing so - trusting the Trisolarians after Luo Ji became Swordholder, Luo Ji’s successor, banning light speed research, strategy for defending against a Dark Forest strike, etc. That is probably what it felt like living under the CCP for a long time - Great Leap Forward (famine), Cultural Revolution (destruction of knowledge and science), etc. all unnecessary setbacks to China's advancement. I suspect that’s partly why the books have captured so many people’s imaginations, it's an exploration of cultural systems and psychology as much of scifi.
- justicezyx 5y agoMr. Liu is like any accomplished writer, they are more often misread than correctly appreciated. Even himself cannot see how vastly different between his own ideal and the reality in his writing. For example, LIU proclaimed Arthur Clark as his role model. But his writing just has little resemblance of Clark's detailed subtle and mind grabbing magic. Liu's works always are presenting a grand idea, but presenting details from normal guys perspective. That makes it more of a Asimov writter. But his ideas are often more abstract than Asimov's, and make them closer to what Frank Herbert did in dune, but again, Herbert's work had much better dialogue and subtlety than LIU's. And of course, because of the vastly different cultural background, most of the details are lost to western readers, making them, although still fluent thanks to the nice translation, througly bland in all aspects other than the high ideas.