4 ms·
The most enduring product of any nuclear power project is not radioactive waste, but corruption. Nuclear power construction projects, at least in the western wo
by ncmncm 5y ago
The most enduring product of any nuclear power project is not radioactive waste, but corruption. Nuclear power construction projects, at least in the western world, invariably become conduits for wholly legal, long-term corruption, making nukes about the most expensive kind of power (ignoring externalities from coal). This is a common feature of big-ticket public-works projects, particularly also including tunnel projects and military procurement.
Nukes take so long to build not because it is so hard to do -- it is mostly just concrete and plumbing -- but because nobody actually involved wants the construction money ever to stop flowing. No output is even promised for years, which is easily stretched out, often beyond a decade. Sunk-cost fallacy helps this process: once a few $B are burned, it is easy to unlock more against the prospect of admitting what was already spent bought nothing.
As bad as is the corruption around fission, fusion has been and must be much worse. A fission plant is expected to produce power eventually, or the plug will finally be pulled. One recent fission failure has cost $30B, so far, which seems like a lot, but fusion has burned more already without even breaking ground on a plant. ITER, even if 100% successful, will generate zero watts: no turbines are in the site plan. A plant built after it would cost, conservatively, >$50B and take decades to finish. (The most likely outcome would be that it is never finished.) Meanwhile, the costs of solar, wind, and storage are still plummeting, with no hint of a lower limit.
Thus far wind and solar have mostly avoided becoming conduits for corruption, probably because it is easy to see how the money is spent, and maybe because of the high fraction of idealists involved. (The exception is solar thermal.) Power can begin flowing almost immediately, after a small fraction of the whole installation is done, which can then fund further construction. Thus, the up-front capital needed is small, and costs are constrained by immediate revenue.
Thus, every penny diverted to fission and fusion (not to mention feeding and maintaining coal) from solar and wind brings climate catastrophe ever nearer.
- joe_the_user 5y agoThis is a key point. The US especially needs to solve the construction generates corruption problem before it can have sane nuclear power. It needs to do this for public transit as well. But the thing with solar is you can ramp it up and then worry about how to store the cyclical excess and this means you can make the storage mechanism competitive.
- danny_codes 5y agoThis seems pretty naive to me. Big public works projects are big so they take a lot of time and money. Of course there's political overhead and graft, etc. However, I'd argue that doesn't really matter. Let's say it costs $10 billion to build a nuclear plant producing ~2 GWatts (something about what has costed historically). This includes all the graft and corruption of which you speak. We need around 500 of them (need ~1 TWatt) to replace all existing electric power generation for a total cost of $5 trillion. Financed over 15 years that's $50 billion a year (~8% increase in federal spending). So really who cares if public works projects are inefficient? For a modest tax increase (or modest debt increase) we're done with primary energy-production related emissions. Added benefit is we can almost certainly export our now resurgent and world-leading fission power plants around the world. This would (a) solve a big part of the climate change problem (b) make America look good, particularly if we provide fission technology at-cost (c) position us as a technology leader in the sustainable/renewable energy sector. As a sidenote, it's also VERY likely that building 500 hopefully identical power plants would drive costs down significantly. Numbers given are worst-case.
- ncmncm 5y agoThat price is at least 5x solar+wind+storage. I estimate 3/4 the cost of a nuke plant (when it gets finished at all) is graft. Besides the waste, it enriches crooks who go on to poison public decision making. That is how we got where we are now. It costs more just to operate and maintain an existing nuke than to build out new solar. That is why they are being retired, and new projects are cancelled. Their power gets less competitive with every day that passes.
- danny_codes 5y ago> That price is at least 5x solar+wind+storage. Do you have a source? This seems.. unlikely to be true. As for your point on graft, you seem to have a very black/white view of government. I find, in general, that black/white views are usually wrong quite often, since very few things are black/white. While I'm sure we can point to many examples of big public works projects that were debacles, certainly there are many examples which have turned out quite well. An immediate assumption that any large public works project will turn out badly is, I think, naive.
- PostOnce 5y agoITER isn't a commercial project. It's a multinational research project. You're basically saying "research is corruption because it isn't guaranteed to produce a result", well, if it was, it wouldn't be research. The plan for fusion: First, prove it can work. Then, worry about commercialization and cost reduction after we know it works. You're also glossing over the fact that if fusion works, it solves a lot of problems other renewables don't: density, reliability (at night, on a still day, etc), possibly cost overall. Probably more, I'm no expert.
- ncmncm 5y agoITER is a research project that is costing more just to build, before any research happens, than a full-scale commercial production fission plant. (The scientists are not getting much of that. But somebody is.) There is much that nobody knows about getting fusion working. What we can be confident about is that if ever made to work, it will cost way more than a fission plant of equal capacity. Fission is itself not competitive today, and gets less so every day. A>B>C => A>C Is this logic hard to follow? Cost of fusion is unknown, but already very large. Cost of renewables is known, small, and reliably decreasing.
- PostOnce 5y ago50 years ago, you'd have told us to avoid developing weather satellites because we already have proven cheap anemometers. Obviously, that would have been a poor idea in hindsight, nevermind the tangential benefits of other space tech (satphones, GPS, etc). Who is to say that fusion plants are necessarily going to remain as expensive as you claim them to be in the midst of another industrial revolution? This isn't a Wikipedia article for no reason: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Industrial_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Industrial_Revolution You have to do research if you want the benefits thereof. Sure it can be expensive and time consuming... but investments have cost and risk. We're trying to get a big payoff, not save every possible cent in the now. Also, I would argue that the building of it (and design of it) is of course part of the research, not "something that happens before any research can happen" as you said.