4 ms·
One of the interesting documented effects of removing anonymity is that is lowers the input of moderate voices. People with extreme views don’t care if their v
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
One of the interesting documented effects of removing anonymity is that is lowers the input of moderate voices.
People with extreme views don’t care if their voice is public.
- floatingatoll 5y agoI would not describe today’s internet as promoting the sharing and reasoned consideration of moderate viewpoints. It turns out that anonymous sock puppets prevent communities from moderating extremism. We’ve invested two decades or more by now into the theory that anonymity will prevent the suppression of moderate voices, and we’ve failed. Time to try something else.
- im3w1l 5y ago> we’ve failed Extremism seems lower than ever to me.
- Pyramus 5y agoNot sure if you are being satirical or not. Political extremism is at an all-time high in Western democracies: The US has seen a president that doesn't respect elections, an attack on the capitol, an ever widening gap between the left/right 'tribes', and poor and rich. Far-right extremism has overtaken Islamist fundamentalism. A decline of newspapers, 'the media' and journalism in general and the rise of Fox News and the like. That's not a US exclusive: UK, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, Poland paint a similar, slightly less pronounced, picture. We live in a period of unprecedented peace in Western democracies and all signs are pointing towards increased nationalism and instability.
- mdp2021 5y agoI am not sure where you see a rise of nationalism. Particularism for distrust of a broader subjection, for example, is more of a regionalism.
- Pyramus 5y agoUS / China trade war, US / EU tariffs, Brexit, "America First", the rise of nationalist parties all over Europe, some even in government. Border controls in Europe. It's concerning.
- pjc50 5y agoMuch of the worst incitement is done by people in newspaper columns under their own names with blue ticks on twitter. (Pop quiz: which newspaper columnist has been cited approvingly in more than one mass shooter manifesto?)
- adventured 5y agoPoliticians are also popular inciters these days and pretty much universally shielded from responsibility for it (Trump's social media ban is one of the few cases where I'm aware of any of them being punished at all for acts of incitement). Rather comically, the morons in control of the social media companies have done Trump an extraordinary favor. They've made him look better than he otherwise would by denying him access to the megaphone. They're considerably helping him in the lead up to 2024 by keeping him off the social media platforms where he'd otherwise be constantly putting his foot in his mouth and reminding center voters why they elected Biden. The best thing social media companies could do if they wanted to stop the inbound 2024 Trump campaign, would be to let him actively Tweet.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI agree per Trump. They are almost trying to create an underdog situation again. Sigh