6 ms·
An option to hide all podcasts would significantly improve spotify's recommendations. I don't listen to podcasts (though I have accidentally clicked on one, wh
by klyrs 5y ago
An option to hide all podcasts would significantly improve spotify's recommendations. I don't listen to podcasts (though I have accidentally clicked on one, when a podcast interviewed a musician I like... blech). Why is my screen filled with podcasts multiple times per day? I like the music recommendations, "so and so artist radio," etc., but they make me hunt for them.
Also, while I like a broad variety of genres, I only like listening to one at a time. I don't want a rap mix to be invaded by a Bach sonata. And yet...
- gundmc 5y agoI listened to one episode of "Call Her Daddy" because I saw it ranked as one of the most-listened podcasts out there and Spotify will not let go putting it front and center on my home screen every day.
- jonathankoren 5y agoI was using Spotify for podcasts because they were there, but then my home feed got dominated by them, and they occasionally get queued up and giving me a mix of podcasts and music, which I don’t want. I started migrating to Apple Podcasts so I can context switch more easily.
- bkraz 5y agoI agree. Spotify acknowledged the request to remove podcasts from the home screen in June of this year: https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/All-Platforms-Podcasts-Option-to-disable-or-hide-podcasts/idi-p/4812243 https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/All-Platforms-Po... Keep adding votes and pressuring them.
- fpgaminer 5y agoSeriously. I listen to podcasts, but I'm not going to do it through Spotify, who's working to build a walled garden around a traditionally open media. I'm also not interested in Joe Rogan, which they _constantly_ plaster my front page with. I did try a Spotify podcast once. It was on my recommended list and was called daily dad jokes or something. Figured it was worth a quick laugh. Well it turned out to be a bot podcast. They set up a bot to rip jokes from Reddit, push them through TTS, and dump it into a Spotify podcast. No thanks. Meanwhile, Apple Podcasts, my go to, works great, doesn't spam me, and even added a feature where you can pay for a no-ads version of a podcast. Worked seemlessly.
- rsyring 5y agoI rarely listen to podcasts but was going to try and listen to a specific one Joe Rogan did recently. After listening for a few minutes, an ad came on. I pay for spotify, why am I listening to an ad? Anyway, I waited like 90 seconds and he came back on. Withing about 15 minutes, I had two more ads come on and they were 90 & 120 seconds each. After the second ad played, the podcast didn't start. Fiddling with it caused the podcast to start over from the beginning. When I tried to seek to the last place I was, it played an ad immediately. Seriously unbelievable. I gave up and will never attempt to listen to an ad supported podcast on Spotify again.
- hutattedonmyarm 5y ago> I pay for spotify, why am I listening to an ad? Because Spotify doesn’t pay anything to the podcast producers. So podcasts run their own ads. (Well, some do. Others live off donations or offer a way to pay them)
- design-material 5y agoSpotify didn't pay Rogan to be exclusive to them?
- oriolid 5y agoI have never listened to a podcast on Spotify and I still have them on my home screen, so I think that it's hardcoded, not a generated recommendation. The probably autogenerated daily mixes have been surprisingly non-bad for me. Nothing like rap mix invaded by Bach, but the "classic rock" mix sometimes has Ghost that doesn't really sound that out of place.
- slig 5y agoMy guess is that they don't have to pay rights for the podcasts, so for them it's a win/win if you spend your attention on their app listening to free content.
- klyrs 5y agoI mean, I have a paid account... the biggest win for them is when I forget to turn the tunes on when I sit down to my desk.
- underwater 5y agoIt's probably that they can get exclusive podcasts, but not exclusive music. They want podcasts to be something that locks you into Spotify.
- slig 5y agoVery good point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 5y agoAn option to hide all podcasts would significantly... An option have a personal search expression with a variety of tags include and excluded and other stuff neutral is what I want for everything. It's twenty years since Alt-Vista allowed search with logic expressions and "recommendation" has gotten more and more railroad-y since then. The "don't give options, make it moron proof" paradigm literally forces us all to be morons.
- hugocbp 5y agoAgreed. I love podcasts, on my podcast app. I'm really disappointed how Spotify is buying several big podcasts and moving to their platform exclusively. I tried to listen to a Science Vs episode the other day, and now my Spotify is almost completely filled with podcasts recommendation. Plus, the experience is still far from specialized podcast apps. The result: I'll probably stop following Science Vs (and any other podcast that moves exclusively to Spotify). They could, at least, have a separate Spotify Podcast app so things wouldn't be mixed (kind of like Wealthsimple has separate apps for Investing and Trading). I'm still sad Spotify bought Gimlet and apparently will do (if not already) this to all their podcasts.
- elamje 5y agoWhy Spotify plasters your home page with Podcasts: Short answer is $$$$. Longer answer is: Spotify must pay royalties for each song played. Imagine if there was a completely free (for Spotify) form of content that filled users ears for hours, thus removing the need for Spotify to pay royalties. Ahem podcasts. Now imagine if Spotify started injecting ads into said media form to grow their revenue beyond subscriptions. Again, podcasts. So now, you have a very long-form content that both saves you royalty $ and drives new revenue. QED. Podcasts will continue to be plastered all over your recommendations, be top search results, etc, until the above stops being true. Wrote about this in detail recently: https://www.towardssoftware.com/spotify.txt https://www.towardssoftware.com/spotify.txt
- Gigachad 5y agoI think the more likely answer is that podcasts can be produced with exclusivity deals while songs can not. Spotify is large because they were first and because apple/google music suck. But eventually apple and google will stop sucking and users will drain from Spotify rapidly unless Spotify can create content to keep users in. Spotify is in the position of Firefox 15 years ago right now. Eventually the built in apps will take over.
- bombcar 5y agoWelcome to McDonalds, home of the Mcadoyble. Now given that burgers cost us money to produce, wouldn’t you rather have a podcast? Does this whole thing not seem insane to anyone else?
- the_pwner224 5y agoSelling a burger is inhernelty profitable for McD, they sell it for more than they spend on manufacturing and shipping and serving it. Each new burger sold adds more profit. Serving music is unprofitable for Spotify. They collect your monthly subscription fee, then every additional song play makes Spotify lose money. They don't want to have zero song plays since then nobody would subscribe, but their goal is sell the profitable thing (subscriptions) while minimizing the unprofitable thing (song plays).
- a5aAqU 5y agoPandora's music recommendations are amazing, and the stations stay within their genre. I've discovered a huge amount of new music that way. I've never used Spotify, so I can't compare. I don't like podcasts either. I get more out of audiobooks.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoIt has been years since I've tried Pandora: Back when I tried it, they only let you skip a number of songs in a short time and often played things I didn't care for. Lots of slightly obscure songs weren't available. It might be better for more popular music or have improved in the last decade, I don't know. I started using Spotify. And still now as then: It is only available in the US. I no longer live in the US.
- a5aAqU 5y ago> they only let you skip a number of songs in a short time and often played things I didn't care for. If you aren't in the US, then it won't work, but I create multiple stations and can switch station if the music isn't good. I can't remember it ever not being good though. I use the like button to train it. > Lots of slightly obscure songs weren't available. If I'm looking for a specific song, I usually go to YouTube. Most of what I listen to is pretty obscure, but it might depend on the genres.
- hn_go_brrrrr 5y agoIf only the audio quality weren't crap. I switched away from them to get better audio, and would gladly switch back if they provided better than 192.
- 015a 5y agoI don't usually overreact too strongly to big tech making dumb decisions like these, but Spotify's podcast pushing actually did drive me away from the platform. I beg Spotify to think Logically about it. There is a limited amount of screen real estate available on any display, but especially phones. Q.e.d: pushing podcast-related content actually hurts the music listening experience. Conversely, pushing music content hurts the podcast listening experience. This is (mostly) inarguable; any pixel dedicated to an interface element related to podcast content is a pixel which cannot display music content; its a zero sum game. I say "mostly" because; there are people who I'm sure love Spotify Podcasts, and having both avenues within one app is a net win. I'd be willing to accept a toggle in settings which could "focus" the app Between Music <> Music + Podcasts <> Podcasts. I don't think that's unreasonable, and I also don't feel it would be unreasonable for it to default to Music + Podcasts. Though it brings up an interesting point: Imagine the experience of someone who does primarily come to Spotify for podcasts. Its among the worst podcast apps in the history of podcast apps! Its littered with music! That's a horrible experience! The ironic part is, Spotify is probably happy to lose me as a customer. I'm a "Music power user" if there were such a thing. They may end up paying more in royalties for the music I listen to than I pay them, and I can't say I've listened to more than a half-dozen podcasts. "Show me the incentives, and I'll show you the outcomes": Spotify is not incentivized to build an app that benefits people who listen to a lot of music. Their bread and butter is people who listen to a bit of music and podcasts; just enough to keep them paying each month. So, I don't lose too much sleep over their slow decent into mediocrity; I'm far more concerned about the unfortunate reality that there are no longer any great options in this space, for people like me.
- zippergz 5y agoYou’re probably right but I have yet to meet anyone who loves podcasts in Spotify. The two groups I have encountered who use it are those who never listened to podcasts at all before so don’t know any other way, and people who begrudgingly use it because some podcast they like went exclusive there. Which I guess are both good for Spotify but it puts them in a weaker position than if people actually did truly like the experience.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]