14 ms·
Vienna museums open adult-only OnlyFans account to display nudes
- imgabe 5y agoSo, they’re doing this because the images constantly get flagged and reported on other social media. It doesn’t seem that hard to let users set a NSFW flag that determines whether they’re ok with nsfw content in their feed. Doesn’t Reddit do this?
- grey413 5y agoReddit does that... but also scrubbed pretty much all nude and sexual subreddits off their "all" and "popular" feeds to appease advertisers.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd occasionally nuking them when they cross an unspecified line that must not be crossed.
- armchairhacker 5y agoI mean i actually get that…you don’t want random casual viewers accidentally seeing graphic images. Even an NSFW tag (which in reddit is often abused on definitely not-NSFW content) won’t deter them. IMO as long as reddit still has those images, even if they’re behind subreddits which proclaim “WARNING: SEE AT YOUR OWN RISK”, that’s good enough.
- ImaCake 5y agoIn certain countries having a specific flag come up on your reddit feed is dangerous. So NSFW applies to things like that too. I agree with your opinion on how reddit deals with NSFW issues.
- sp332 5y agoI think Twitter allows this, but Facebook does not.
- version_five 5y agoReddit uses the NSFW flag as bait to get you to sign up for the app. Any time you click on a link to such content, you are told have to install the app to see it.
- diogenesjunior 5y agoMaybe this is a mobile only thing? I can view NSFW content on desktop (both old + new reddit) while being logged out and logged in without a prompt to download anything.
- version_five 5y agoThanks I'll have to try that, I think I've only ever used it on my phone. I recently encountered that app-wall and had even googled how to get around it and couldn't find any information on it.
- diogenesjunior 5y agoYeah, they are very sneaky with their methods.
- uuddlrlr 5y agoReplace www.reddit.com with old.reddit.com or i.reddit.com. Not sure if it works with NSFW, but they've recently taken to app-blocking everything and it fixes at least that.
- pjc50 5y agoTwitter does. Facebook and therefore instagram have the "no female-presenting nipples" rule, and you're not allowed adult content even though they know you're an adult.
- _fat_santa 5y agoIt's probably that and it's great marketing TBH. They could have just posted them on their own site or another palace that allows NSFW images (Reddit, Twitter, etc). But they probably also knew that a story about an art museum opening an OnlyFans is going to be fantastic marketing.
- yosito 5y agoI find it a bit sad that we've become so Puritan that even art is considered "adult".
- mdoms 5y agoUnfortunately the tech platforms are controlled by American companies with American values.
- tisthetruth 5y agoHaha the end result of being conditioned to wear shorts to the beach. In the future people won't even look at each other anymore. It will be taboo.
- shadilay 5y agoContext is dead because AI content moderation is infinitely cheaper than human moderation. It's time to end the tyranny of centralized services.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 5y agoWell, they already can plug their website into the decentralized www. What they want is to tap into an existing large audience.
- shadilay 5y agoAre you saying that an institution has to market itself to potential customers in order to exist and has to follow them to where they are? The aim here is to develop interoperability so users have the option of thousands of networks without lock in.
- dymk 5y agoOther way around. Cultural changes have driven companies to build broad catch-all moderation because that’s what the loudest demand.
- 5y ago
- rapnie 5y ago> Vienna’s tourism board has started an account on OnlyFans – the only social network that permits depictions of nudity – in protest against platforms’ ongoing censorship of its art museums and galleries. The only social network? How about the Fediverse? Spin up their own PixelFed (and a Mastodon instance too), promote it widely, and donate some of their public money to these FOSS projects based on open standards, instead of just choosing a proprietary centralized platform.
- jstx1 5y agoFediverse is a niche thing for people who care more about decentralisation for the sake of decentralisation rather than the actual social media aspect.
- elsjaako 5y agoI'm on mastodon because it's a nice social network. It doesn't even need to grow, it's fine as-is.
- kradeelav 5y agoNot in my experience, personally. There's a fair few artists who have art accounts on mastodon.socal and the related mastodon servers - especially handy for NSFW artists of all stripes. two examples: https://mastodon.social/@kradeelav https://mastodon.social/@kradeelav https://mastodon.social/@chirart https://mastodon.social/@chirart
- rapnie 5y agoI don't know where you get this notion. Fediverse is small with only about 4 million accounts spread out on a couple 1,000 instances. Social aspects are taken very seriously though, and have created a unique atmosphere and culture. Netiquette is taken seriously, and devs take care to avoid building social features that are harmful.
- teorema 5y agoI can remember when a lot of widespread network platforms were niche. Twitter and post Twitter started this VC instant popularity expectation. I don't mean to advocate for Mastodon or anything else in particular, but these things sometimes have a way of being niche until they're not. I also think part of the parent's argument was that in encountering obstacles like this, groups of nonprofit institutions such as art museums could leverage their position to promote decentralized systems, rather than simply throw up their hands and go with a sensationalized move. Then again we are here discussing it. But then again if they banded together to post on some decentralized platform we'd probably be talking too.
- Santosh83 5y agoMeanwhile we have hundreds of videos of a man being brutally chopped off his hand, hung upside down while he bleeds, then legs chopped off and finally dies gasping all over Twitter and Facebook, for anyone to see, even kids who stumble upon it. Apparently such content doesn't harm users as much as some Renaissance nudes.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoLinks
- Santosh83 5y agohttps://twitter.com/goyalsanjeev/status/1448953085770960899 https://twitter.com/goyalsanjeev/status/1448953085770960899 https://twitter.com/along_live/status/1448896904520077320 https://twitter.com/along_live/status/1448896904520077320 https://twitter.com/adolitics/status/1448906467558387713 https://twitter.com/adolitics/status/1448906467558387713 https://twitter.com/ColVKChauhan/status/1448894875118624769 https://twitter.com/ColVKChauhan/status/1448894875118624769 There are hundreds of them (just search by hashtags in the posts above). Of course same set of videos/pics repeated over & over, but my point is that such stuff is present all over Twitter & FB and anyone accessing those platforms can stumble upon them. Twitter doesn't even seem to put them behind a "Violent/NSFW" click-through. I don't see how nudity can be more damaging or pernicious than such content.
- wbl 5y agoAnd the papers printed a nude nine year old girl getting burned alive by napalm. Some events are worth depicting even if they are shocking or horrifying and political murder is one of them.
- riffraff 5y agoThere's probably a potential difference in intent, in the sense that a kid will not buy the new York times but they might be exposed to random things on Twitter. I'm not sure of the "kids will suffer because of violent images" idea tho, we were shown a crap ton of terrible imagery from WWI/WWII/Holocaust/Vietnam when I was in middle school, and if anything I thought it was a good thing.
- thinkingemote 5y agoWhen traditional cultural institutions openly back the pornography industry what does that say about the future of culture?
- version_five 5y agoThat eroticism has been and will be part of culture?
- sp332 5y agoExcluding a basic part of human experience (nude bodies, let alone sexuality) really puts a crimp on artistic expression. Facebook is a cultural dead end.
- seattle_spring 5y agoIt says that they're no longer going to cater exclusively to people who get their worldview from a multi-millenia old fictional book.
- jikbd 5y agoThey could also host these on their own website, but of course that doesn’t sound as flashy. We are subject to American Puritanism because Europe has failed time and time again to create competitive social networks because of regulations and scarce access to capital. Better complain about that.
- samus 5y agoSilicon Valley has the first-mover advantage in social networks and pretty much all other sectors in IT technology. Competitors in Europe only exist because of niches, sometimes created by regulation and mostly by cultural differences. However, the (mostly) laissez-faire approach to access to information makes it difficult to put constraints on social networks. China managed to do so thanks to their Great Firewall. The GDPR is too little, too late, and the public is too used now to scatter factoids about their private lives on the internet.
- inetsee 5y agoI knew very little about OnlyFans, and when I went looking for more information I found this line on Wikipedia: "The website [OnlyFans] has been criticized for hosting child sexual abuse material, though the National Center on Sexual Exploitation reports negligible numbers of incidents in comparison to Facebook."
- jamesmishra 5y agoIf you want to post on OnlyFans, you have to verify your account with a government-issued photo ID. I imagine this requirement makes OnlyFans a very unattractive website for child pornographers and other people guilty of federal crimes.
- cblconfederate 5y agoAll public services need to get out of facebook and all social media, otherwise they re not respecting the privacy of their citizens.
- Bayart 5y agoI see a lot about China trying to export its censorship, but little about how America is already doing it at scale throughout much of the world.
- cblconfederate 5y agoIt's not america's fault, but the rest of the world's. Unfortunately europe has rendered itself completely dependent on US media to the point where i don't know any sites where i could discuss matters from european perspective. There are only local language sites.
- watwut 5y agoWhy the local language sites don't count? It is not like Americans discussed American issues in Italian, Americans talk about it in their own local language.
- cblconfederate 5y agobecause europeans talk different languages. You re more likely to talk to european entrepreneurs from other countries here than in any other forum.
- Bayart 5y agoMight isn't right.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoWell there's always Hacker News! I'm European, ask me anything.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- matt_morgan 5y agoLaws in Europe are different in the US. I used to work at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where I published the entire collection online. I got calls from colleagues in Europe amazed that we didn't worry about kids seeing stuff they shouldn't. We think the US is puritan but the decision that anything with merit can't be judged obscene actually protects us.
- vmception 5y agoprotip: nothing gets judged as legally obscene in the US as nobody wants the actual decisive court case. Supreme Court has left a carveout that things can distinctly be considered obscene, but nobody has gone that far. they made new carveouts for child sexual depictions even it not passing the obscenity test. More recently, a man was sued under copyright laws for pirating pornography and their defense was that because the work was obscene it could not be have any copyright restrictions, of course since the law firms suing over piracy are just spraying and praying, they don't want an actual trial. This area is not resolved and likely won't ever be.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> nothing gets judged as legally obscene in the US as nobody wants the actual decisive court case There are a lot of court cases on obscenity, some of which hold decisively [1]. > a man was sued under copyright laws for pirating pornography and their defense was that because the work was obscene it could not be have any copyright restrictions…since the law firms suing over piracy are just spraying and praying, they don't want an actual trial Nonsense. Porn companies regularly go to court to protect their IP [2]. (To your example, in which venue was your defendant defending himself if not in a court?) [1] https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/porn/prosecuting/overview.html https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/porn/prosecut... [2] https://abovethelaw.com/2017/12/porn-piracy-forbidden-to-settle/?amp=1 https://abovethelaw.com/2017/12/porn-piracy-forbidden-to-set...
- vmception 5y agoEverything in your [1] source says obscenity itself gets further and further diluted, and that the judges decisively say "obscenity exists" but are not trying cases themselves on obscenity grounds. and then stops before the year 2002. that is a laughable source as it doesn't even know what happened in the final court case mentioned and then lacks 20 years of data. this is a chronology, on this topic the relevant cases being the later ones, even in your article. I mentioned one specific court case where one specific defendant was sued over one specific piece of content, where one specific plaintiff didn't move forward with the case after being presented with a defense, because they are serial plaintiffs that only want settlements. Your own source [2] says serial plaintiffs is what is happening! Not even sure where to start with you. The only point being about why there is not a decisive case on that particular defense because it never reached a judge. More specifically, Liuxia Wong v Hard Drive Productions is a countercase, referring to Hard Drive Productions demanding a settlement from Liuxia for infringing on their copyright of a porn movie. Liuxia sued them back saying it wasn't copyrightable. What you will find online are motions to dismiss, which were denied. Then you'll find there was a settlement https://casetext.com/case/liuxia-wong-v-hard-drive-prods-1 https://casetext.com/case/liuxia-wong-v-hard-drive-prods-1 short discussion (about why its largely unsatisfactory in establishing any precedent and reinforces how there likely won't be any precendent on this matter as nobody is interested in taking it above trial courts): https://dietrolldie.wordpress.com/2012/06/05/case-closed-wong-v-hard-drive-productions-412-cv-00469-judgment-against-hdp/ https://dietrolldie.wordpress.com/2012/06/05/case-closed-won...
- elmicha 5y ago> There are 2527 videos about “nudity” on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them. https://vimeo.com/tag:nudity https://vimeo.com/tag:nudity
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- qualudeheart 5y agoThey could also have self hosted a website and accepted payments through Monero or Bitcoin. Why rely on Onlyfans as another third party site?
- jackson1442 5y agoThey could have “just” made their own payment processor too. It’s not feasible to build an entire platform for every project.
- dwighttk 5y agoUh… I follow a lot of artbots on Twitter that display nudes with no problems
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoIt is common but I know some creators who censor their posts as nudes are actually against the rules and people can get their accounts banned for this. For some that work hard to build a following getting banned can be catastrophic.
- dwighttk 5y agoThe guy that runs these accounts was having a few blocked about 6 months ago but seems to have straightened it out. They’re bots though so it isn’t gonna kill him if they shut one down.
- _fat_santa 5y agoEveryone is saying they could have gone to X, Y or Z instead of going to OnlyFans. IMO this decision to host on OF was very deliberate. Had they gone to any other platform no one would have raised an eyebrow. But because they went to OF everyone is doing a double take because of OF's reputation. They knew (rightly so) that if they opened an OF account, they would get a bunch of free press and bring more eyeballs to their artwork.
- jrochkind1 5y agoThey are quoted saying as much in the NYT coverage of this story: > Mr. Kettner said that the OnlyFans account is not a permanent solution, but rather a protest against censorship and a call for conversation. “We want to draw attention to a certain thing,” he said. “We want to put it out there, to talk about the role of artificial intelligence, of algorithms.” https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/21/style/onlyfans-nude-art-vienna.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/21/style/onlyfans-nude-art-v...