3 ms·
I can believe in my theory until it is disproven. It has yet to be disproven, and given how the gender balance in these fields has similar bias in all developed
by Jensson 5y ago
I can believe in my theory until it is disproven. It has yet to be disproven, and given how the gender balance in these fields has similar bias in all developed nations I'll likely never get disproven.
Your theory that women are held back by bias would require that every developed country coordinated their biases so they map the same by field. That doesn't make sense, there is no way I'll believe that is true unless some really extreme evidence is provided. How else would you explain that the gender ratio for these subjects in Russia is very close to the same as in USA? It isn't like they share culture etc. There are so many fields, why would biology have the most women, then chemistry, then civil, then mechanical etc? It is too much of a coincidence.
- tptacek 5y agoIt's almost like you'd have to believe that more than one western culture is historically patriarchal.
- Jensson 5y agoI do, but that doesn't explain how everyone of those patriarchal societies developed the same with the same fields getting dominated by women when they opened up to women. All fields were dominated by men 80 years ago and were extremely hostile to women. Since some fields attracted women and others didn't, if that was just random chance then you'd expect different cultures to see women take interest in different fields, but that didn't happen. Instead this evolved similarly all over the world.
- tptacek 5y agoI do not have the same faith in the decorrelation of academia in different countries that you do.
- Jensson 5y agoThat is a really weak argument though, Soviet and USA didn't share much culture during the cold war. Professors talking a bit to each other shouldn't affect the student bodies that much, and at the time most American influences were banned in Soviet. So to me your explanation looks extremely weak. You can believe in that, but you wont convince me on this, there is just too much data in my favor. Of course the future could prove me wrong and I am open to that, but I'd argue that the data we have today strongly supports my stance. Note, I am not saying that we should discourage women who want to enter these fields. That serves absolutely no purpose.
- pvg 5y agoSoviet and USA didn't share much culture during the cold war They certainly shared patriarchy which has been around a lot longer than the cold war. You haven't provided much in the way of numbers being 'the same' but the comparison would also be skewed by these countries' significantly different gender ratios, on top of many other factors.
- Manuel_D 5y agoInterestingly the more patriarchal a country is, the more women go into STEM [1]. The societies with the most egalitarian gender roles have the lowest rates of women in STEM, while highly unequal countries have the highest. 1. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/02/the-more-gender-equality-the-fewer-women-in-stem/553592/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/02/the-more...
- tptacek 5y agoNo, I'm not talking about the absolute rate of participation in STEM overall, but the relative participation in different subfields.
- Manuel_D 5y agoThe correlations hold true even if we exclusively examine computer science participation exclusively. Patriarchal societies have greater representation than egalitarian countries. The correlation between patriarchy and lack of representation of women in engineering subfields is not just untrue, but the opposite of what we do observe.
- tptacek 5y agoOnce again: I am interested in the difference between participation math, earth sciences, and chemistry subfields and computer science. If you have those numbers for other countries, I'm interested. I'm not so interested in your extrapolation from overall STEM numbers.
- Manuel_D 5y agoYup here's technology graduates specifically, apart from STEM as a whole: https://honeypotio.github.io/women-in-tech/ https://honeypotio.github.io/women-in-tech/ If anything, the gender equality paradox is even stronger. At the highest we have a lot of more conservative ex-soviet countries like Bulgaria, Romania, Latvia, and Lithuania. The United States has considerably more women in tech (25%) than more progressive countries like Sweden (21%), Norway (19%), Austria (17%), Germany (17%), Netherland (16%), Belgium(14%).