6 ms·
The actual split is 54% to 46%, which is something that I would not qualified as significant. It is a difference, but hardly shows that men are disengaged mass
by watwut 5y ago
The actual split is 54% to 46%, which is something that I would not qualified as significant.
It is a difference, but hardly shows that men are disengaged masses.
- maxk42 5y agoThat's more than a 17% difference. Seems significant to me.
- whatshisface 5y agoSignificant for what? Understanding our society? For that, any statistically significant result is significant. For forecasting the life course of a person? Not as significant.
- marcellus23 5y ago> For forecasting the life course of a person Where did this come from? When did the discussion apparently become about this?
- whatshisface 5y agoThere have always been two closely related discussions going on whenever demographics come up. The first is a discussion about what course our society will take, and the second is a discussion about what an individual can expect to see as they make their way through life.
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoSignificance of numbers has little to do with the difference. 0.00000001% can be significant so long as the sample size be large enough. It simply means it's unlikely that the numbers are caused by a statistical fluke and expected to show up again in a reproductive attempt. Of course significant numbers are very often not reproduced, both due to that the publishing industry selects upon creating this result and because the mathematical principles that compute significance are simply abused, both willfully, and due to lack of understanding of the assumptions behind it.
- benchaney 5y agoYou are confusing statistical significance with practical significance. A difference of 0.00000001% can be statistically significant with enough data, but it will never be practically significant.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoExcept in physics where the charge of an electron couldn’t be different by even less than that or else there could be no life. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-structure_constant https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-structure_constant
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoAnd what exactly would be the meaning of the word “practical significance” then? what exactly would it signify? Because honestly; I feel this secondary meaning is a buzzword transferred from the first meaning which actually has meaning, but in the secondary case it's simply used to use an expensive word without understanding it.
- Jensson 5y agoSignificance was a word before statistics used it to define one of their concepts. Just because a field takes a word people used in everyday contexts and used it to define something doesn't mean that the everyday meaning disappears. Edit: Another example is significant digits. Significant digits is a much older concept than significance in statistics, and maps much better to the original meaning of significance. Basically significant things are things you can't ignore when you do your analysis.
- Blikkentrekker 5y ago> Significance was a word before statistics used it to define one of their concepts. Just because a field takes a word people used in everyday contexts and used it to define something doesn't mean that the everyday meaning disappears. That doesn't answer what I asked: what exactly is the meaning here because I remain unconvinced that it's not simply an empty buzzword inserted that transferred from it's usage of statistics, especially when used in conjunction with percentages. > Edit: Another example is significant digits. Significant digits is a much older concept than significance in statistics, and maps much better to the original meaning of significance. Basically significant things are things you can't ignore when you do your analysis. Indeed, and that has a meaning that I understand which is also morphologically transparent, but in this supposed meaning of the word which you've to elaborate upon it is neither morphologically transparent, nor do I actually see any meaning in it and I still feel it's used as a buzzword to simply make use of a fancy word for it's own sake.
- syshum 5y agoI seem to remember when with split was the other direction it was considered significant.... Seen as another example of Sexism in Higher Education Interesting how things change
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoNobody's clamoring to fix the under-representation of men in teaching and nursing either.
- Spivak 5y agoThe reason for this is complicated though. To say that it's just that political climate and that people don't care about men's issue is doing it such a disservice. The reason there's so much media attention on the issues of women and minorities is because generally speaking any issues faced by cisgender heterosexual white men are considered important by default. You usually don't have to fight for them because the people in power will just fix them. So it's fascinating that there are issues faced by this population that aren't moving despite everything being aligned to just make them go away and that you have to fight for them like they were minority issues. And what's crazy is that for these issues the population you need to convince that these issues are important are white men! Specifically for gender representation in nursing and teaching there's three main barriers to have to be broken down to get people to care about them. 1. That the factors that are keeping men out of teaching and nursing are internal -- lack of motivation or ability, rather than external factors like discrimination or access to education. 2. That nursing and teaching are "low status" careers so it doesn't matter if there's a gender gap because nobody is really clamoring to be one. 3. That nursing and teaching are "women's work," which is especially funny since teaching used to be male dominated.
- Jensson 5y ago> any issues faced by cisgender heterosexual white men are considered important by default Any evidence for this? To me it seems like people care much more about homeless women even though most homeless are men, they care more about womens suicides even though men kill themselves more, they care more about when women get murdered even though men get murdered more etc. People care more about white people than black people, yes. People care more about cis than trans, yes. But I have seen no evidence at all that people care more about men than women.
- Spivak 5y agoI do think it's really funny how the weather changes so much on the internet when discussing boys education vs the wage gap but I digress. The thing that makes it hard to write off is that over a large enough population and across time you would expect it to even out. That doesn't mean that year over year there won't natural swings one way or another but the fact that it's always more women says something interesting about higher education that almost surely we'd want to correct. We don't necessarily know what it says without looking but something is making it so that men aren't pursuing, getting excluded from, or having difficulty getting their doctorates.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoNote that there are more men than women in the population though.
- watwut 5y agoThere are more women in the population.
- Jensson 5y agoNot at the age people go to college. More men are born but they die quicker so you have more old women and more young men.
- elliekelly 5y agoMaybe women are just more interested in learning than men! It could just be a matter of “preferences” and that’s fine, right? Edit: For the sake of clarity, my comment was tongue-in-cheek as it's the justification I repeatedly see whenever gender imbalance/inequality is mentioned on HN. I think it's patently ridiculous to say that one gender is for some reason more interested in learning than another.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI think this is the case. Men preferring to work with their hands over books is observed over many cultures. The university system expanding mostly in the direction of brain-work leaves out these men. Ideally we would have a Germany-like system that better guides training for these populations and professions to help create a more robust working class.
- Jensson 5y ago> Men preferring to work with their hands over books is observed over many cultures If the books are about robots and the manual task is taking care of kids you'd draw the opposite conclusion.
- avs733 5y agothe size of the difference alone does not denote significance. It can only indicate scale.