3 ms·
Wow, I think my group should pay its fair share (paraphrasing) OK, lets do little example. Suppose a large group of your friends a pizza and half the people
by joe_the_user 15y ago
Wow,
I think my group should pay its fair share (paraphrasing)
OK, lets do little example.
Suppose a large group of your friends a pizza and half the people just hadn't paid. Would you say "hey, I'll pay for all these people" or "hey, we all need to pay our fair share".
How hard is that to understand?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sophacles 15y agoSuppose a large group of your friends a pizza and half the people just hadn't paid. You forgot a verb in there. Presuming a) the intended verb was bought or ordered and b) this isn't an indicator of you being complete moron: Assume we all paid our 1/n of the price. Then assume I eat 1/n + m (where m >= 1) pieces of pizza. My friends suggest I pay more. Do I accuse them of being communist scum? Should I pay more because I got more? Or do I do what you seem to be suggesting and try to pay less and argue it is because I got more?
- mikeash 15y agoIf I'm out with my friends, you're damn right I'd want to pay for the ones struggling with a minimum-wage job and consider that to be my fair share.
- jackpirate 15y agoYou missed the point. That's exactly what Buffet wants. In the pizza example, the people who are not paying their fair share are not the minimum-wagers, but rather the mega-rich who pay only 15% capital gains.
- mikeash 15y agoThe post I'm replying to placed "pay my fair share" in opposition to paying for the pizza eaten by the people who didn't pay for themselves. I'm pretty sure that the point you're making is not the point he was making, which to me sounded like the standard argument against progressive taxation.
- joe_the_user 15y agoNo, you're misinterpreting my original post. jackpirate is correct.
- mikeash 15y agoThanks for clearing that up. Sorry I got it wrong. At least we all agree!